Conjecture Atlas

Proof source

Polar witnesses and capacitability from ambient extremals

Complete proof text in the unsigned reading edition.

Download sourceBrowse research records

Reading edition of the complete source note. Original labels and explicit equation tags are retained; references use source titles where compiled numbering is unavailable. Current result status is recorded separately in the project register.

Contents of this source
  1. Polar witnesses and capacitability from ambient extremals

Polar witnesses and capacitability from ambient extremals

Status: NEW_PROVED, relative to the adopted inputs and the preceding reviewed R2 theorems. The witness construction, arbitrary-set extremal mass formula, and ordinary-open proof of increasing continuity are supplied below. The Choquet and patching consequences are DIRECT_COROLLARY. The two theorem groups (N) and (E) are separated to display dependencies; both have been proved in the preceding sections. Neither a general Josefson theorem nor Borel outer regularity is an input.

Domain and the two theorem inputs

Let VV be a connected ordinary open with compact closure in a smooth affine algebraic chart over the fixed finite extension K/QpK/\mathbf Q_p. Assume that its ordinary boundary is nonempty and that there is ρ∈Cb(V)∩C(V‾),ρ<0 on V,ρ=0 on ∂V.\rho\in\mathcal C_b(V)\cap C(\overline V),\qquad \rho<0\text{ on }V,\qquad \rho=0\text{ on }\partial V. Thus each negative sublevel of ρ\rho has compact closure in VV. All capacities in this section use the ambient background [1][1] and the fixed admissibility domain VV. Write C(E)=Cap⁡[1](E;V),C∗(E)=inf⁡G⊃EG ordinary open in VC(G).C(E)=\operatorname{Cap}_{[1]}(E;V),\qquad C^*(E)=\inf_{\substack{G\supset E\\G\text{ ordinary open in }V}}C(G). The first notation is initially for Borel sets; the second is defined for arbitrary subsets. All Monge–Ampère measures and their weak limits use the original CLD scalar test functions.

For any subset A⊂VA\subset V, define FA={v∈Cb(V):−1≤v≤0, v=−1 on A},hA=sup⁡v∈FAv,UA=hA∗.\mathcal F_A=\{v\in\mathcal C_b(V):-1\leq v\leq0,\ v=-1\text{ on }A\}, \qquad h_A=\sup_{v\in\mathcal F_A}v,\qquad U_A=h_A^*. The ordinary upper regularization UAU_A is bounded classical by Theorem “Local bounded upper-envelope theorem”. The conditions v=−1v=-1 and v≤−1v\leq-1 are identical for this normalized family. The raw supremum is never substituted for its regularization without a stated argument.

The two theorem groups are recorded separately to make the dependency order explicit:

  1. For every locally uniformly upper-bounded family of bounded classical psh functions, the difference between its actual supremum and its ordinary usc regularization is contained locally in a Borel set of ambient outer capacity zero. In particular a locally uniformly bounded increasing sequence has its actual supremum equal to its regularization outside such a set, and their values agree at every ambient divisorial point. Local and fixed-domain null classes are identified only through Corollary “Equivalence of local null classes”. These are Theorem “Negligible upper-envelope sets have ambient outer capacity zero”, Theorem “Increasing envelopes have no ambient capacity jump”, and Corollary “Upper regularization preserves divisorial values”.

  2. If G⋐VG\Subset V is ordinary open, then UG=−1U_G=-1 at every point of GG, UGU_G has ordinary boundary limit zero, supp⁡(DUG)n⊂G‾\operatorname{supp}(DU_G)^n\subset\overline G, and ∫V(DUG)n=C(G).\int_V(DU_G)^n=C(G). For a compact K⋐VK\Subset V, the corresponding compact extremal identity is ∫V(DUK)n=C(K).\int_V(DU_K)^n=C(K). The open-set identity concerns total mass. It does not assert ∫G(DUG)n=C(G)\int_G(DU_G)^n=C(G): the function is constant on GG. These are Theorems “Open-set extremals and their total mass” and “The compact extremal and its equilibrium mass”, with the domain and boundary properties of Lemma “Basic extremal properties and a countable selection”.

For every fixed A⊂W⋐VA\subset W\Subset V, choose a>0a>0 sufficiently large that aρ≤−1a\rho\leq-1 on W‾\overline W. Then b=max⁡(−1,aρ)∈FA,b≤UA≤0.b=\max(-1,a\rho)\in\mathcal F_A, \qquad b\leq U_A\leq0. This gives the ordinary boundary limit zero of UAU_A, uniformly for all such AA. In particular {UA<−1+η}⋐V\{U_A<-1+\eta\}\Subset V for every 0<η<10<\eta<1, with a common compact bound for fixed WW and η\eta. The capacity of WW is finite by relative CLN on a slightly larger compact stage.

We also use the total-mass order of Lemma “Order of total Monge–Ampère masses”: if u≤v≤0u\leq v\leq0 are bounded classical functions with ordinary boundary limits zero, then ∫V(Dv)n≤∫V(Du)n\int_V(Dv)^n\leq\int_V(Du)^n, including infinite masses.

A nontrivial pole witness for an outer-capacity-zero set

Theorem (A witness on the specified exhaustion domain). Let E⊂W⋐VE\subset W\Subset V be an arbitrary subset with C∗(E)=0C^*(E)=0. For every fixed ambient divisorial point z∈Vz\in V there is a nonpositive extended classical psh function ϕ\phi on VV such that E⊂{ϕ=−∞},−1≤ϕ(z)≤0.E\subset\{\phi=-\infty\},\qquad -1\leq\phi(z)\leq0. In particular the witness is not identically −∞-\infty.

Proof. Choose an ordinary W′W' with W‾⊂W′⋐V\overline W\subset W'\Subset V. From C∗(E)=0C^*(E)=0 choose ordinary opens Oj⊃EO_j\supset E with C(Oj)<2−jC(O_j)<2^{-j} and set Gj=W′∩⋂i=1jOi,uj=UGj.G_j=W'\cap\bigcap_{i=1}^jO_i,\qquad u_j=U_{G_j}. The GjG_j decrease, while −1≤uj↑h≤0-1\leq u_j\uparrow h\leq0. They share a lower barrier b=max⁡(−1,aρ)b=\max(-1,a\rho) as above. Their measures are supported in the one compact set W‾′\overline W', and their total masses tend to zero by (E).

Put U=h∗∈Cb(V)U=h^*\in\mathcal C_b(V). By (N), h=Uh=U locally outside sets of outer capacity zero. The actual increasing-limit theorem “Local increasing convergence without a prescribed collar”, the completed calculus “BT calculus on the bounded capacitary closure”, and independence under such changes of representatives give (Duj)n⟶(DU)n(Du_j)^n\longrightarrow(DU)^n on all original compact scalar tests. Their vanishing total masses imply (DU)n=0(DU)^n=0. Also b≤U≤0b\leq U\leq0, so UU has ordinary boundary limit zero. Pointwise ambient domination “Pointwise ambient domination and uniqueness”, applied to UU and 00, now gives U=0U=0 on VV. Indeed all sets {U<−ϵ}\{U<-\epsilon\} are relatively compact by the lower barrier, and (DU)n(DU)^n vanishes on the whole strict gap.

By the divisorial part of (N), uj(z)↑0u_j(z)\uparrow0. Choose a strictly increasing sequence jlj_l such that ujl(z)>−2−lu_{j_l}(z)>-2^{-l}. The finite sums ϕm=∑l=1mujl\phi_m=\sum_{l=1}^m u_{j_l} are nonpositive classical psh and decrease with mm. Their pointwise limit ϕ\phi is extended classical psh by the classical decreasing closure, and ϕ(z)≥−∑l2−l=−1\phi(z)\geq-\sum_l2^{-l}=-1. For x∈Ex\in E, every GjG_j contains xx and the open-set extremal satisfies uj(x)=−1u_j(x)=-1 exactly. Thus ϕm(x)=−m\phi_m(x)=-m and ϕ(x)=−∞\phi(x)=-\infty. No integrability of the original set or a global pole-patching theorem has been used. ◻

Corollary (The local zero-set equivalence on this domain). On the same exhaustion domain, for every arbitrary E⊂W⋐VE\subset W\Subset V, C∗(E)=0⟺E⊂{ϕ=−∞} for some nonpositive classical ϕ on V, ϕ≢−∞.C^*(E)=0 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad E\subset\{\phi=-\infty\} \text{ for some nonpositive classical }\phi\text{ on }V, \ \phi\not\equiv-\infty. The implication from right to left is the already proved ambient polar theorem, not a new nonconcentration hypothesis.

Proof. The forward implication is the theorem. For the reverse implication, Corollary “Local outer-capacity zero of ambient pluripolar sets” gives local outer capacity zero on every compact/domain pair. The fixed-domain comparison “Equivalence of local null classes” gives C∗(E)=0C^*(E)=0. ◻

Definition (Local negligibility in the ordinary topology). Let EE be an arbitrary subset of an allowed ordinary open UU. It is locally negligible if every x∈Ux\in U has an ordinary neighborhood O⊂UO\subset U and a nonempty locally uniformly upper-bounded family F⊂Cb(O)\mathcal F\subset\mathcal C_b(O) such that E∩O⊂{sup⁡v∈Fv<(sup⁡v∈Fv)∗}.E\cap O\subset \left\{\sup_{v\in\mathcal F}v< \left(\sup_{v\in\mathcal F}v\right)^*\right\}. It is locally increasing-negligible if the family can be chosen as one increasing locally uniformly bounded sequence in Cb(O)\mathcal C_b(O). Local pluripolarity means that every x∈Ux\in U has a connected ordinary neighborhood O⊂UO\subset U and an extended classical psh function ϕ\phi on OO, not identically −∞-\infty there, with E∩O⊂{ϕ=−∞}E\cap O\subset\{\phi=-\infty\}. Local outer-capacity zero means that Cap⁡[1]∗(E∩H;Ω)=0\operatorname{Cap}_{[1]}^*(E\cap H;\Omega)=0 for every permitted ordinary norm-box domain Ω⊂U\Omega\subset U and every compact H⋐ΩH\Subset\Omega.

Corollary (Local polar, negligible, and outer-zero sets). On every allowed ordinary open UU, the following properties of an arbitrary subset E⊂UE\subset U are equivalent:

  1. EE is locally pluripolar;

  2. EE has local ambient outer-capacity zero;

  3. EE is locally increasing-negligible;

  4. EE is locally negligible.

These are local witness assertions. A single global psh witness on UU is not asserted.

Proof. The implication (i)⇒\Rightarrow(ii) is Corollary “Local outer-capacity zero of ambient pluripolar sets”. For (ii)⇒\Rightarrow(i), fix x∈Ux\in U and use Lemma “Local supply of exhaustion domains” in an ordinary algebraic neighborhood to choose an exhaustion domain VV containing xx. Choose a connected ordinary WW with x∈W⋐Vx\in W\Subset V and an ambient divisorial point z∈Wz\in W. The local null-class comparison gives Cap⁡[1]∗(E∩W;V)=0\operatorname{Cap}_{[1]}^*(E\cap W;V)=0. Theorem “A witness on the specified exhaustion domain” supplies a nonpositive classical witness ϕ\phi on VV, finite at zz, whose pole set contains E∩WE\cap W. Its restriction to WW is a nontrivial classical witness, as required.

For (i)⇒\Rightarrow(iii), shrink a connected witness neighborhood if necessary and subtract a finite upper bound so that ϕ≤0\phi\leq0. The pole set P={ϕ=−∞}P=\{\phi=-\infty\} has empty ordinary interior by Proposition “A nontrivial pole set has empty ordinary interior”; hence the witness remains nontrivial on every smaller connected ordinary neighborhood. The actual bounded classical functions wN=1+max⁡(ϕ,−N)Nw_N=1+\frac{\max(\phi,-N)}{N} increase to 1Pc\mathbf1_{P^c}. Because PP has empty ordinary interior, the ordinary usc regularization of this actual limit is the constant one. Its discrepancy set is exactly PP, which contains the specified part of EE. This proves increasing negligibility. The implication (iii)⇒\Rightarrow(iv) is immediate.

Finally (iv)⇒\Rightarrow(ii) follows from Theorem “Negligible upper-envelope sets have ambient outer capacity zero”. To express it on a prescribed compact/domain pair (H,Ω)(H,\Omega), restrict the local witness families to smaller permitted domains contained in Ω\Omega. Choose countably many ordinary cores covering E∩HE\cap H; such a choice exists in the locally second-countable finite pp-adic setting. Each core intersection has outer capacity zero on its own domain and therefore on Ω\Omega by domain monotonicity. Countable subadditivity gives the required zero capacity on HH. No uncountable union of exceptional sets is taken. ◻

Corollary (Pole patching on one exhaustion domain). On the same connected exhaustion domain VV, let E⊂VE\subset V have local ambient outer-capacity zero. In particular this applies to a locally pluripolar EE. Then there is one nonpositive extended classical psh function ϕ\phi on VV, not identically −∞-\infty, such that E⊂{ϕ=−∞}E\subset\{\phi=-\infty\}. No relative compactness of EE itself is required for this conclusion.

Provenance: DIRECT_COROLLARY. The domain VV and its exhaustion hypothesis are retained.

Proof. Choose ordinary Wm⋐VW_m\Subset V increasing to VV and fix one ambient divisorial point z∈Vz\in V. Put Em=E∩WmE_m=E\cap W_m. The fixed-domain null-class comparison gives C∗(Em)=0C^*(E_m)=0. The witness theorem gives nonpositive classical ϕm\phi_m on VV with Em⊂{ϕm=−∞}E_m\subset\{\phi_m=-\infty\} and ϕm(z)≥−1\phi_m(z)\geq-1. The series ϕ=∑m≥12−mϕm\phi=\sum_{m\geq1}2^{-m}\phi_m is a decreasing limit of nonpositive classical partial sums and is therefore extended classical. It satisfies ϕ(z)≥−1\phi(z)\geq-1, so it is nontrivial. Every point of EE belongs to some EmE_m, and the corresponding positive summand forces ϕ=−∞\phi=-\infty there. ◻

Remark (Why the domain qualification is essential). Untwisted pole globalization on every analytic space is FALSE. For example, the rational point 00 of PK1,an\mathbf P^{1,\mathrm{an}}_K is locally pluripolar, with local witness log⁡∣t∣\log|t|. A nontrivial global extended classical psh function on this proper connected space attains a finite maximum and is constant by the strong maximum principle [GR25, Theorem 6.1]. It therefore has no pole. The preceding corollary is globalization on the one specified exhaustion domain; it is not that false unrestricted assertion, nor a theorem about globally twisted psh functions.

An outer-capacity formula for arbitrary relatively compact sets

Theorem (The extremal total-mass formula). For every arbitrary A⊂W⋐VA\subset W\Subset V, C∗(A)=∫V(DUA)n<∞.C^*(A)=\int_V(DU_A)^n<\infty. This assertion neither assumes Borel measurability of AA nor identifies the raw capacity with its outer regularization beforehand.

Proof. If G⋐VG\Subset V is ordinary open and contains AA, then FG⊂FA\mathcal F_G\subset\mathcal F_A, hence UG≤UA≤0U_G\leq U_A\leq0. Both functions have boundary limit zero. The mass-order lemma and (E) imply ∫V(DUA)n≤∫V(DUG)n=C(G).\int_V(DU_A)^n\leq\int_V(DU_G)^n=C(G). Taking the infimum over such GG gives ∫V(DUA)n≤C∗(A)\int_V(DU_A)^n\leq C^*(A). Relatively compact opens suffice here: intersect any open cover with a fixed relatively compact open neighborhood of W‾\overline W. This also proves finiteness.

Since hA=−1h_A=-1 on AA, input (N) shows that A∩{UA>−1}⊂NA\cap\{U_A>-1\}\subset N for some set N⊂WN\subset W with C∗(N)=0C^*(N)=0. We may use a Borel outer-zero cover of this defect if AA itself is not Borel. Fix 0<η<10<\eta<1 and put Gη={UA<−1+η},vη=max⁡(−1,UA1−η).G_\eta=\{U_A<-1+\eta\},\qquad v_\eta=\max\left(-1,\frac{U_A}{1-\eta}\right). The set GηG_\eta is ordinary open and relatively compact, because UAU_A is usc and bounded below by the common exhaustion barrier. The function vηv_\eta is classical, has boundary value zero, belongs to [−1,0][-1,0], and equals −1-1 on GηG_\eta. Consequently UA1−η≤vη≤UGη.\frac{U_A}{1-\eta}\leq v_\eta\leq U_{G_\eta}. Twice applying the mass-order lemma gives C(Gη)=∫V(DUGη)n≤∫V(Dvη)n≤(1−η)−n∫V(DUA)n.C(G_\eta)=\int_V(DU_{G_\eta})^n \leq\int_V(Dv_\eta)^n \leq(1-\eta)^{-n}\int_V(DU_A)^n. Finally A⊂Gη∪NA\subset G_\eta\cup N. Monotonicity and subadditivity of outer capacity, and its equality with raw capacity on ordinary open sets, imply C∗(A)≤C(Gη)≤(1−η)−n∫V(DUA)n.C^*(A)\leq C(G_\eta) \leq(1-\eta)^{-n}\int_V(DU_A)^n. Let η\eta decrease to zero. The two inequalities prove the formula. ◻

The missing continuity axiom and the Choquet conclusion

Theorem (Continuity from below on arbitrary subsets of a core). If Aj⊂Aj+1⊂W⋐VA_j\subset A_{j+1}\subset W\Subset V are arbitrary subsets and A=⋃jAjA=\bigcup_jA_j, then C∗(A)=lim⁡jC∗(Aj).C^*(A)=\lim_j C^*(A_j).

Proof. Write Uj=UAjU_j=U_{A_j}; these bounded classical functions decrease with jj. By (N), each defect Aj∩{Uj>−1}A_j\cap\{U_j>-1\} is contained in an outer-zero set NjN_j. The countable union of the NjN_j has outer capacity zero. For ϵ>0\epsilon>0, choose one ordinary open set GG containing that union with C(G)<ϵC(G)<\epsilon.

Fix 0<η<10<\eta<1 and put Oj=G∪{Uj<−1+η}.O_j=G\cup\{U_j<-1+\eta\}. These are increasing ordinary open sets, since the UjU_j decrease. Each OjO_j contains AjA_j. The truncation estimate in the preceding proof and its mass formula give C(Oj)≤ϵ+(1−η)−nC∗(Aj).C(O_j)\leq\epsilon+ (1-\eta)^{-n}C^*(A_j). The raw capacity is continuous from below on Borel sets, directly from its definition as a supremum of Radon measures. Applying this only to the increasing open sets OjO_j yields C∗(A)≤C(⋃jOj)=lim⁡jC(Oj)≤ϵ+(1−η)−nlim⁡jC∗(Aj).C^*(A)\leq C\Bigl(\bigcup_jO_j\Bigr) =\lim_j C(O_j) \leq\epsilon+(1-\eta)^{-n}\lim_j C^*(A_j). Let ϵ\epsilon and then η\eta decrease to zero. Monotonicity supplies the reverse inequality.

This is the ordinary-open argument of the classical capacitability proof, [BT82, §8, Theorem 8.2], with its analytic hypotheses proved separately here. An infinite intersection of open covers is not declared open, and no infimum/supremum interchange is made. ◻

Corollary (Local Choquet capacitability and Borel outer regularity). Fix an ordinary core W⋐VW\Subset V. The set function A⟼C∗(A),A⊂W,A\longmapsto C^*(A),\qquad A\subset W, is a finite monotone countably subadditive Choquet capacity: it is continuous from below on arbitrary increasing sets and from above on decreasing compact sets. Every Suslin subset A⊂WA\subset W (analytic in the descriptive-set-theoretic sense) is capacitable: C∗(A)=sup⁡K⊂AK compactC(K).C^*(A)=\sup_{\substack{K\subset A\\K\text{ compact}}}C(K). In particular every Borel A⊂WA\subset W satisfies C(A)=C∗(A).C(A)=C^*(A).

Proof. Monotonicity and countable subadditivity are already proved for outer capacity. Compact continuity from above is Lemma “Elementary outer-capacity facts”; increasing continuity is the preceding theorem. Finiteness follows by covering W‾\overline W with one relatively compact ordinary open and applying CLN to its closure. The core WW is a locally compact second-countable metrizable space in the fixed finite pp-adic algebraic setting. The Choquet capacitability theorem, in the form recalled in [BT82, §8, following Theorem 8.2], therefore gives C∗(A)=sup⁡K⊂A compactC∗(K)C^*(A)=\sup_{K\subset A\text{ compact}}C^*(K) for such Suslin AA. This terminology concerns analytic sets of the Polish space WW, not analytic subspaces over the base field KK. For compact KK, the mass formula of the preceding theorem and the compact part of (E) give C∗(K)=C(K)C^*(K)=C(K).

For Borel AA, raw inner regularity is elementary: C(A)=sup⁡vsup⁡K⊂A compact∫K(Dv)n=sup⁡K⊂A compactC(K).C(A)=\sup_{v}\sup_{K\subset A\text{ compact}} \int_K(Dv)^n =\sup_{K\subset A\text{ compact}}C(K). Only two suprema are interchanged in this equality. Combining it with capacitability gives C(A)=C∗(A)C(A)=C^*(A). ◻

Scope and dependency order.

The capacity-zero witness uses only the open extremal identity, ambient no-jump, the proved increasing calculus, and pointwise ambient domination. The arbitrary-set mass formula and Choquet continuity do not use that witness theorem: their only null-set input is (N). Thus the argument does not prove negligible sets polar by first assuming that conclusion. The capacitability statement is on each fixed relatively compact core of this explicitly qualified domain. It does not assert a global Josefson theorem on an arbitrary analytic space, or discard the negative-exhaustion-domain hypothesis.

A distinction in abstract capacity theory.

For a Borel capacity cc, its Borel-envelope extension inf⁡{c(B):A⊂B, B Borel}\inf\{c(B): A\subset B,\ B\text{ Borel}\} is different from the ordinary-open extension used here. The familiar increasing-set argument using ⋂k≥jGk\bigcap_{k\geq j}G_k yields Borel sets, not open ones. Raw Borel inner regularity and raw Borel continuity from below therefore do not, by that argument, supply the missing continuity axiom for the ordinary-open extension. Theorem “Continuity from below on arbitrary subsets of a core” supplies the required axiom by actual ordinary sublevel sets of extremal functions.

References requiring source context

Some references in this note depend on its original surrounding manuscript. Their source labels are retained in the reading edition; its TeX is available above.

Source text and edition identity

This reading copy omits personal attribution and places existing mathematical question marks over their relation symbols. The mathematical content and source status are retained.

Reading-copy SHA-256 ba0544927cadf70f4ebe58e8a1a67c6fe43b9fd5ebff325a0d3a96c49bd7a3af

Frozen-original SHA-256 ba0544927cadf70f4ebe58e8a1a67c6fe43b9fd5ebff325a0d3a96c49bd7a3af

\section{Polar witnesses and capacitability from ambient extremals}
\label{sec:r2-polar-converse-choquet}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{NEW\_PROVED}, relative to the adopted
inputs and the preceding reviewed R2 theorems.}
The witness construction, arbitrary-set extremal mass formula, and
ordinary-open proof of increasing continuity are supplied below.
The Choquet and patching consequences are
\texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}. The two theorem groups
\textup{(N)} and \textup{(E)} are separated to display dependencies;
both have been proved in the preceding sections. Neither a general
Josefson theorem nor Borel outer regularity is an input.

\subsection{Domain and the two theorem inputs}

Let $V$ be a connected ordinary open with compact closure in a smooth
affine algebraic chart over the fixed finite extension $K/\mathbf Q_p$.
Assume that its ordinary boundary is nonempty and that there is
\[
 \rho\in\Cb(V)\cap C(\overline V),\qquad
 \rho<0\text{ on }V,\qquad \rho=0\text{ on }\partial V.
\]
Thus each negative sublevel of $\rho$ has compact closure in $V$.
All capacities in this section use the ambient background $[1]$ and
the \emph{fixed admissibility domain $V$}. Write
\[
 C(E)=\operatorname{Cap}_{[1]}(E;V),\qquad
 C^*(E)=\inf_{\substack{G\supset E\\G\text{ ordinary open in }V}}C(G).
\]
The first notation is initially for Borel sets; the second is defined
for arbitrary subsets. All Monge--Amp\`ere measures and their weak
limits use the original CLD scalar test functions.

For any subset $A\subset V$, define
\[
 \mathcal F_A=\{v\in\Cb(V):-1\leq v\leq0,\ v=-1\text{ on }A\},
 \qquad h_A=\sup_{v\in\mathcal F_A}v,\qquad U_A=h_A^*.
\]
The ordinary upper regularization $U_A$ is bounded classical by
Theorem~\ref{thm:r2-local-upper-envelope}. The conditions $v=-1$
and $v\leq-1$ are identical for this normalized family. The raw
supremum is never substituted for its regularization without a
stated argument.

The two theorem groups are recorded separately to make the dependency
order explicit:
\begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\Alph*)}]
\item[\textup{(N)}] For every locally uniformly upper-bounded family
of bounded classical psh functions, the difference between its actual
supremum and its ordinary usc regularization is contained locally in
a Borel set of ambient outer capacity zero. In particular a locally
uniformly bounded increasing sequence has its actual supremum equal
to its regularization outside such a set, and their values agree at
every ambient divisorial point. Local and fixed-domain null classes
are identified only through
Corollary~\ref{cor:r2-fixed-domain-null-classes}.
These are Theorem~\ref{thm:r2-negligible-outer-zero},
Theorem~\ref{thm:r2-increasing-no-jump}, and
Corollary~\ref{cor:r2-divisorial-no-jump}.

\item[\textup{(E)}] If $G\Subset V$ is ordinary open, then $U_G=-1$
at every point of $G$, $U_G$ has ordinary boundary limit zero,
$\operatorname{supp}(DU_G)^n\subset\overline G$, and
\[
 \int_V(DU_G)^n=C(G).
\]
For a compact $K\Subset V$, the corresponding compact extremal
identity is
\[
 \int_V(DU_K)^n=C(K).
\]
The open-set identity concerns \emph{total mass}. It does not assert
$\int_G(DU_G)^n=C(G)$: the function is constant on $G$.
These are Theorems~\ref{thm:r2-open-extremal} and
\ref{thm:r2-compact-extremal}, with the domain and boundary
properties of Lemma~\ref{lem:r2-extremal-basics}.
\end{enumerate}

For every fixed $A\subset W\Subset V$, choose $a>0$ sufficiently
large that $a\rho\leq-1$ on $\overline W$. Then
\[
 b=\max(-1,a\rho)\in\mathcal F_A,
 \qquad b\leq U_A\leq0.
\]
This gives the ordinary boundary limit zero of $U_A$, uniformly for
all such $A$. In particular $\{U_A<-1+\eta\}\Subset V$ for every
$0<\eta<1$, with a common compact bound for fixed $W$ and $\eta$.
The capacity of $W$ is finite by relative CLN on a slightly larger
compact stage.

We also use the total-mass order of
Lemma~\ref{lem:r2-total-mass-order}: if $u\leq v\leq0$ are bounded
classical functions with ordinary boundary limits zero, then
$\int_V(Dv)^n\leq\int_V(Du)^n$, including infinite masses.

\subsection{A nontrivial pole witness for an outer-capacity-zero set}

\begin{theorem}[A witness on the specified exhaustion domain]
\label{thm:r2-capacity-zero-polar-witness}
Let $E\subset W\Subset V$ be an arbitrary subset with $C^*(E)=0$.
For every fixed ambient divisorial point $z\in V$ there is a nonpositive
extended classical psh function $\phi$ on $V$ such that
\[
 E\subset\{\phi=-\infty\},\qquad -1\leq\phi(z)\leq0.
\]
In particular the witness is not identically $-\infty$.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Choose an ordinary $W'$ with
$\overline W\subset W'\Subset V$. From $C^*(E)=0$ choose ordinary
opens $O_j\supset E$ with $C(O_j)<2^{-j}$ and set
\[
 G_j=W'\cap\bigcap_{i=1}^jO_i,\qquad u_j=U_{G_j}.
\]
The $G_j$ decrease, while $-1\leq u_j\uparrow h\leq0$.
They share a lower barrier $b=\max(-1,a\rho)$ as above.
Their measures are supported in the one compact set
$\overline W'$, and their total masses tend to zero by \textup{(E)}.

Put $U=h^*\in\Cb(V)$. By \textup{(N)}, $h=U$ locally outside
sets of outer capacity zero. The actual increasing-limit theorem
\ref{cor:r2-local-increasing}, the completed calculus
\ref{thm:r2-completed-calculus}, and independence under such changes
of representatives give
\[
 (Du_j)^n\longrightarrow(DU)^n
\]
on all original compact scalar tests. Their vanishing total masses
imply $(DU)^n=0$. Also $b\leq U\leq0$, so $U$ has ordinary
boundary limit zero. Pointwise ambient domination
\ref{cor:r2-pointwise-ambient}, applied to $U$ and $0$, now gives
$U=0$ on $V$. Indeed all sets $\{U<-\epsilon\}$ are relatively
compact by the lower barrier, and $(DU)^n$ vanishes on the whole
strict gap.

By the divisorial part of \textup{(N)}, $u_j(z)\uparrow0$.
Choose a strictly increasing sequence $j_l$ such that
$u_{j_l}(z)>-2^{-l}$. The finite sums
\[
 \phi_m=\sum_{l=1}^m u_{j_l}
\]
are nonpositive classical psh and decrease with $m$. Their pointwise
limit $\phi$ is extended classical psh by the classical decreasing
closure, and $\phi(z)\geq-\sum_l2^{-l}=-1$.
For $x\in E$, every $G_j$ contains $x$ and the open-set extremal
satisfies $u_j(x)=-1$ exactly. Thus $\phi_m(x)=-m$ and
$\phi(x)=-\infty$. No integrability of the original set or a
global pole-patching theorem has been used.
\end{proof}

\begin{corollary}[The local zero-set equivalence on this domain]
\label{cor:r2-local-polar-equivalence}
On the same exhaustion domain, for every arbitrary $E\subset W\Subset V$,
\[
 C^*(E)=0
 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad
 E\subset\{\phi=-\infty\}
 \text{ for some nonpositive classical }\phi\text{ on }V,
 \ \phi\not\equiv-\infty.
\]
The implication from right to left is the already proved ambient
polar theorem, not a new nonconcentration hypothesis.
\end{corollary}

\begin{proof}
The forward implication is the theorem. For the reverse implication,
Corollary~\ref{cor:r2-ambient-polar-outer-zero} gives local outer
capacity zero on every compact/domain pair. The fixed-domain
comparison \ref{cor:r2-fixed-domain-null-classes} gives $C^*(E)=0$.
\end{proof}

\begin{definition}[Local negligibility in the ordinary topology]
\label{def:r2-local-negligibility}
Let $E$ be an arbitrary subset of an allowed ordinary open $U$.
It is locally negligible if every $x\in U$ has an ordinary
neighborhood $O\subset U$ and a nonempty locally uniformly
upper-bounded family $\mathcal F\subset\Cb(O)$ such that
\[
 E\cap O\subset
 \left\{\sup_{v\in\mathcal F}v<
                    \left(\sup_{v\in\mathcal F}v\right)^*\right\}.
\]
It is locally increasing-negligible if the family can be chosen as
one increasing locally uniformly bounded sequence in $\Cb(O)$.
Local pluripolarity means that every $x\in U$ has a connected ordinary
neighborhood $O\subset U$ and an extended classical psh function
$\phi$ on $O$, not identically $-\infty$ there, with
$E\cap O\subset\{\phi=-\infty\}$.
Local outer-capacity zero means that
\[
 \operatorname{Cap}_{[1]}^*(E\cap H;\Omega)=0
\]
for every permitted ordinary norm-box domain $\Omega\subset U$
and every compact $H\Subset\Omega$.
\end{definition}

\begin{corollary}[Local polar, negligible, and outer-zero sets]
\label{cor:r2-polar-negligible-equivalence}
On every allowed ordinary open $U$, the following properties of an arbitrary subset
$E\subset U$ are equivalent:
\begin{enumerate}[label=\textup{(\roman*)}]
\item $E$ is locally pluripolar;
\item $E$ has local ambient outer-capacity zero;
\item $E$ is locally increasing-negligible;
\item $E$ is locally negligible.
\end{enumerate}
These are local witness assertions. A single global psh witness on
$U$ is not asserted.
\end{corollary}

\begin{proof}
The implication (i)$\Rightarrow$(ii) is
Corollary~\ref{cor:r2-ambient-polar-outer-zero}.
For (ii)$\Rightarrow$(i), fix $x\in U$ and use
Lemma~\ref{lem:r2-local-exhaustion-domains} in an ordinary algebraic
neighborhood to choose an exhaustion domain $V$ containing $x$.
Choose a connected ordinary $W$ with $x\in W\Subset V$ and an
ambient divisorial point $z\in W$. The local null-class comparison
gives $\operatorname{Cap}_{[1]}^*(E\cap W;V)=0$.
Theorem~\ref{thm:r2-capacity-zero-polar-witness} supplies a
nonpositive classical witness $\phi$ on $V$, finite at $z$, whose
pole set contains $E\cap W$. Its restriction to $W$ is a
nontrivial classical witness, as required.

For (i)$\Rightarrow$(iii), shrink a connected witness neighborhood
if necessary and subtract a finite upper bound so that $\phi\leq0$.
The pole set $P=\{\phi=-\infty\}$ has empty ordinary interior by
Proposition~\ref{prop:r2-no-interior-poles}; hence the witness remains
nontrivial on every smaller connected ordinary neighborhood.
The actual bounded classical functions
\[
 w_N=1+\frac{\max(\phi,-N)}{N}
\]
increase to $\mathbf1_{P^c}$. Because $P$ has empty ordinary
interior, the ordinary usc regularization of this actual limit is
the constant one. Its discrepancy set is exactly $P$, which
contains the specified part of $E$. This proves increasing
negligibility. The implication (iii)$\Rightarrow$(iv) is immediate.

Finally (iv)$\Rightarrow$(ii) follows from
Theorem~\ref{thm:r2-negligible-outer-zero}. To express it on a
prescribed compact/domain pair $(H,\Omega)$, restrict the local
witness families to smaller permitted domains contained in $\Omega$.
Choose countably many ordinary cores covering $E\cap H$; such a
choice exists in the locally second-countable finite $p$-adic
setting. Each core intersection has outer capacity zero on its
own domain and therefore on $\Omega$ by domain monotonicity.
Countable subadditivity gives the required zero capacity on $H$.
No uncountable union of exceptional sets is taken.
\end{proof}

\begin{corollary}[Pole patching on one exhaustion domain]
\label{cor:r2-exhaustion-domain-pole-patching}
On the same connected exhaustion domain $V$, let $E\subset V$
have local ambient outer-capacity zero. In particular this applies
to a locally pluripolar $E$. Then there is one nonpositive extended
classical psh function $\phi$ on $V$, not identically $-\infty$,
such that $E\subset\{\phi=-\infty\}$. No relative compactness
of $E$ itself is required for this conclusion.
\end{corollary}

\noindent\textbf{Provenance: \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}.}
The domain $V$ and its exhaustion hypothesis are retained.

\begin{proof}
Choose ordinary $W_m\Subset V$ increasing to $V$ and fix one
ambient divisorial point $z\in V$. Put $E_m=E\cap W_m$.
The fixed-domain null-class comparison gives $C^*(E_m)=0$.
The witness theorem gives nonpositive classical $\phi_m$ on $V$
with $E_m\subset\{\phi_m=-\infty\}$ and $\phi_m(z)\geq-1$.
The series
\[
 \phi=\sum_{m\geq1}2^{-m}\phi_m
\]
is a decreasing limit of nonpositive classical partial sums and
is therefore extended classical. It satisfies $\phi(z)\geq-1$,
so it is nontrivial. Every point of $E$ belongs to some $E_m$,
and the corresponding positive summand forces $\phi=-\infty$
there.
\end{proof}

\begin{remark}[Why the domain qualification is essential]
Untwisted pole globalization on every analytic space is
\texttt{FALSE}. For example, the rational point $0$ of
$\mathbf P^{1,\an}_K$ is locally pluripolar, with local witness
$\log|t|$. A nontrivial global extended classical psh function
on this proper connected space attains a finite maximum and is
constant by the strong maximum principle
\cite[Theorem 6.1]{GR25}. It therefore has no
pole. The preceding corollary is globalization on the one
specified exhaustion domain; it is not that false unrestricted
assertion, nor a theorem about globally twisted psh functions.
\end{remark}

\subsection{An outer-capacity formula for arbitrary relatively compact sets}

\begin{theorem}[The extremal total-mass formula]
\label{thm:r2-arbitrary-extremal-mass}
For every arbitrary $A\subset W\Subset V$,
\[
 C^*(A)=\int_V(DU_A)^n<\infty.
\]
This assertion neither assumes Borel measurability of $A$ nor
identifies the raw capacity with its outer regularization beforehand.
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
If $G\Subset V$ is ordinary open and contains $A$, then
$\mathcal F_G\subset\mathcal F_A$, hence $U_G\leq U_A\leq0$.
Both functions have boundary limit zero. The mass-order lemma and
\textup{(E)} imply
\[
 \int_V(DU_A)^n\leq\int_V(DU_G)^n=C(G).
\]
Taking the infimum over such $G$ gives
$\int_V(DU_A)^n\leq C^*(A)$. Relatively compact opens suffice here:
intersect any open cover with a fixed relatively compact open
neighborhood of $\overline W$. This also proves finiteness.

Since $h_A=-1$ on $A$, input \textup{(N)} shows that
\[
 A\cap\{U_A>-1\}\subset N
\]
for some set $N\subset W$ with $C^*(N)=0$. We may use a Borel
outer-zero cover of this defect if $A$ itself is not Borel.
Fix $0<\eta<1$ and put
\[
 G_\eta=\{U_A<-1+\eta\},\qquad
 v_\eta=\max\left(-1,\frac{U_A}{1-\eta}\right).
\]
The set $G_\eta$ is ordinary open and relatively compact, because
$U_A$ is usc and bounded below by the common exhaustion barrier.
The function $v_\eta$ is classical, has boundary value zero,
belongs to $[-1,0]$, and equals $-1$ on $G_\eta$. Consequently
\[
 \frac{U_A}{1-\eta}\leq v_\eta\leq U_{G_\eta}.
\]
Twice applying the mass-order lemma gives
\[
 C(G_\eta)=\int_V(DU_{G_\eta})^n
 \leq\int_V(Dv_\eta)^n
 \leq(1-\eta)^{-n}\int_V(DU_A)^n.
\]
Finally $A\subset G_\eta\cup N$. Monotonicity and subadditivity
of outer capacity, and its equality with raw capacity on ordinary
open sets, imply
\[
 C^*(A)\leq C(G_\eta)
 \leq(1-\eta)^{-n}\int_V(DU_A)^n.
\]
Let $\eta$ decrease to zero. The two inequalities prove the formula.
\end{proof}

\subsection{The missing continuity axiom and the Choquet conclusion}

\begin{theorem}[Continuity from below on arbitrary subsets of a core]
\label{thm:r2-outer-capacity-increasing-sets}
If $A_j\subset A_{j+1}\subset W\Subset V$ are arbitrary subsets
and $A=\bigcup_jA_j$, then
\[
 C^*(A)=\lim_j C^*(A_j).
\]
\end{theorem}

\begin{proof}
Write $U_j=U_{A_j}$; these bounded classical functions decrease
with $j$. By \textup{(N)}, each defect
$A_j\cap\{U_j>-1\}$ is contained in an outer-zero set $N_j$.
The countable union of the $N_j$ has outer capacity zero.
For $\epsilon>0$, choose one ordinary open set $G$ containing
that union with $C(G)<\epsilon$.

Fix $0<\eta<1$ and put
\[
 O_j=G\cup\{U_j<-1+\eta\}.
\]
These are \emph{increasing ordinary open sets}, since the $U_j$
decrease. Each $O_j$ contains $A_j$. The truncation estimate in
the preceding proof and its mass formula give
\[
 C(O_j)\leq\epsilon+
      (1-\eta)^{-n}C^*(A_j).
\]
The raw capacity is continuous from below on Borel sets, directly
from its definition as a supremum of Radon measures. Applying
this only to the increasing \emph{open} sets $O_j$ yields
\[
 C^*(A)\leq C\Bigl(\bigcup_jO_j\Bigr)
       =\lim_j C(O_j)
       \leq\epsilon+(1-\eta)^{-n}\lim_j C^*(A_j).
\]
Let $\epsilon$ and then $\eta$ decrease to zero. Monotonicity
supplies the reverse inequality.

This is the ordinary-open argument of the classical capacitability
proof, \cite[\S8, Theorem 8.2]{BT82}, with its analytic hypotheses
proved separately here. An infinite intersection of open covers is
not declared open, and no infimum/supremum interchange is made.
\end{proof}

\begin{corollary}[Local Choquet capacitability and Borel outer regularity]
\label{cor:r2-local-choquet}
Fix an ordinary core $W\Subset V$. The set function
\[
 A\longmapsto C^*(A),\qquad A\subset W,
\]
is a finite monotone countably subadditive Choquet capacity: it is
continuous from below on arbitrary increasing sets and from above
on decreasing compact sets. Every Suslin subset $A\subset W$
(analytic in the descriptive-set-theoretic sense) is capacitable:
\[
 C^*(A)=\sup_{\substack{K\subset A\\K\text{ compact}}}C(K).
\]
In particular every Borel $A\subset W$ satisfies
\[
 C(A)=C^*(A).
\]
\end{corollary}

\begin{proof}
Monotonicity and countable subadditivity are already proved for
outer capacity. Compact continuity from above is
Lemma~\ref{lem:r2-outer-facts}; increasing continuity is the preceding
theorem. Finiteness follows by covering $\overline W$ with one
relatively compact ordinary open and applying CLN to its closure.
The core $W$ is a locally compact second-countable metrizable space
in the fixed finite $p$-adic algebraic setting. The Choquet
capacitability theorem, in the form recalled in
\cite[\S8, following Theorem 8.2]{BT82}, therefore gives
\[
 C^*(A)=\sup_{K\subset A\text{ compact}}C^*(K)
\]
for such Suslin $A$. This terminology concerns analytic sets of the
Polish space $W$, not analytic subspaces over the base field $K$.
For compact $K$, the mass formula of the
preceding theorem and the compact part of \textup{(E)} give
$C^*(K)=C(K)$.

For Borel $A$, raw inner regularity is elementary:
\[
 C(A)=\sup_{v}\sup_{K\subset A\text{ compact}}
       \int_K(Dv)^n
     =\sup_{K\subset A\text{ compact}}C(K).
\]
Only two suprema are interchanged in this equality. Combining it
with capacitability gives $C(A)=C^*(A)$.
\end{proof}

\paragraph{Scope and dependency order.}
The capacity-zero witness uses only the open extremal identity,
ambient no-jump, the proved increasing calculus, and pointwise
ambient domination. The arbitrary-set mass formula and Choquet
continuity do not use that witness theorem: their only null-set
input is \textup{(N)}. Thus the argument does not prove negligible
sets polar by first assuming that conclusion. The capacitability
statement is on each fixed relatively compact core of this explicitly
qualified domain. It does not assert a global Josefson theorem on an
arbitrary analytic space, or discard the negative-exhaustion-domain
hypothesis.

\paragraph{A distinction in abstract capacity theory.}
For a Borel capacity $c$, its Borel-envelope extension
$\inf\{c(B): A\subset B,\ B\text{ Borel}\}$ is different from
the ordinary-open extension used here. The familiar increasing-set
argument using $\bigcap_{k\geq j}G_k$ yields Borel sets, not open
ones. Raw Borel inner regularity and raw Borel continuity from below
therefore do not, by that argument, supply the missing continuity
axiom for the ordinary-open extension. Theorem
\ref{thm:r2-outer-capacity-increasing-sets} supplies the required
axiom by actual ordinary sublevel sets of extremal functions.