Contents of this source
Abstract
This record continues the arbitrary-background bounded Bedford–Taylor calculus and actual bounded-classical potential quotient proved in R4–R5. Its main further result identifies the positive cone of the actual bounded classical difference class: if , then in the original CLD cone if and only if is itself classical psh. The proof establishes order transfer on every complete extension and analytic test map, retains actual curve endpoint values, and recovers ambient upper semicontinuity through proper-fiber maxima of finite Shilov interpolants. Curvature order and continuous coefficient relations therefore transfer to every fixed allowed positive closed background, including discontinuous potential slots. The resulting mixed order estimates give qualified total-variation stability. Arbitrary assigned bounded Borel representatives remain outside these assertions.
In the actual delta-test category, every total-degree delta-form acts over every allowed background with ordinary locality. Constant real cycle relations act in all degrees, and every real delta-form has an exact finite local generation by piecewise smooth coefficients and constant cycles. Full actual analytic delta-testing is constructed for the local weak closure of positive closed delta-form backgrounds, including all their bounded BT tails, smooth regular flags, singular effective Cartier divisors, integrable extended classical potential curvatures, and integrable diffuse barycenters. The higher-degree analytic-relation kernel for an arbitrary background remains open.
An actual bounded classical potential below the curvature of a continuous potential is automatically continuous. Normalized families with a compact continuous family of upper potentials are compact in local uniform topology. Their actual mixed images are weakly closed on the same domain, and their represented curvature quotients have joint weak stability even with a varying positive closed background. A local finite Shilov normalization also gives weighted stability for the specified representatives; it does not identify arbitrary weights by curvature alone.
In remaining degree one, sharp Hardy and strong capacitary constants are respectively one and four. The universal finite-energy threshold for concave capacity-growth moduli is determined. A compact Gauss set has zero relative BT capacity but positive energy capacity; a measure on it has a bounded continuous energy solution but no local bounded classical difference potential. Exact convex-envelope and diffuse carrier capacities give further qualified Borel regularity results. Exact continuous classical interpolation on a fast polar Cantor set gives explicit capacities for arbitrary bounded Borel radial graphs and filled tubes over that diffuse parameter set.
For Dirichlet theory, completed degree-one feasibility has an exact energy-dual criterion, while higher-degree variation criteria retain explicit feasibility hypotheses. Counterexamples rule out unrestricted relative Hessian root concavity and show that the actual zero-boundary classical Monge–Ampere image can be nonconvex in every remaining degree at least two, even for sums of smooth analytic-subspace integration currents. All new proofs, direct consequences, failed routes and unresolved gates have separate status labels.
Reading guide
Section “Scope, conventions, and dependencies” fixes the hypotheses and frozen dependencies. The main ordered-quotient advance is in Sections “Functoriality of curvature order for actual bounded potentials”–“Positive curvature in the actual bounded classical difference class”; its module and stability consequences follow immediately afterward. The delta-extension conclusions are in Sections “Every real delta-form is locally generated over piecewise smooth forms”–“Barycenters of backgrounds in the approximation cone”. The sharp arbitrary-background estimates are in Sections “A sharp Hardy estimate for every normalized relative tester”–“A sharp strong-capacity inequality and energy traces”. The precise changes from R5 and the next proof gates are recorded at the end. This is a continuation with complete new proofs, rather than a replacement for the frozen primary-literature comparison or the authorized internal manuscripts. References marked R4 or R5 refer to the exact numbered results retained in the complete continuation archive.
Scope, conventions, and dependencies
Fix a finite extension with its original absolute value. An allowed space is a good Hausdorff boundaryless quasi-smooth -analytic space of pure dimension . All opens are ordinary topological opens. Put . A background of degree is symmetric, positive in the original middle CLD cone specified by R, and separately - and -closed. It acts on all original compact smooth CLD forms of complementary degree. The words positive, strongly positive, and weakly positive are not interchanged.
The class consists of actual locally bounded classical psh functions as defined in B. Values on ambient polar sets are retained. Products with coefficient-Radon currents use actual Borel multiplication. Local assertions are checked on all original moments and refinements, not just on one chosen skeleton. Signed bounded classical differences are expanded into finite signed combinations of positive mixed currents whenever coefficient estimates are used.
Authorized and frozen inputs
The internal manuscripts R and B are used as authorized inputs. R supplies continuous local regularization, the original middle-cone coefficient-Radon estimates, and fixed-continuous-multiplier weak continuity. B supplies the prescribed local decreasing continuous semipositive PL rows and their original smooth positive refinements, the class definition, and the original mixed calculus. Their statements are not reproved or globally audited in this record. A2 remains the completed geometric adelic nefness input under its stated number-field, integrable adelic-line, and boundary assumptions. No part of A2 is treated as a new open problem.
The following results of the preceding records are frozen inputs.
The complete bounded BT calculus for every fixed allowed arbitrary background: existence, positivity, separate closedness, recursive and regularization independence, differentiated-slot symmetry, multilinearity, ordinary locality and gluing, and weighted joint decreasing convergence on all original tests.
Relative CLN estimates with finitely many original positive control forms, bounded-classical energy measures and Green identities, and their weighted convergence. R4, Lemmas 71.1 and 71.2 and Theorem 71.4 supply normal-factor variation control and uniform piecewise smooth test approximation.
R5, Theorems 10.1–10.2, identify the actual bounded classical curvature kernel with continuous classical pluriharmonic functions. In particular for every allowed fixed . Its signed differentiated-potential calculus is also retained. This arbitrary-background potential quotient is already
PROVED; it is not an open gate of this round.The qualified comparison, maximum-locality, quasicontinuity, completed bounded calculus, and faithful relative energy-form results retain the domains and hypotheses of R4. In particular an energy solution or a completed relative potential is not automatically an actual ambient classical psh function.
The full eleven-direction classical-to-non-Archimedean comparison, with primary theorem locations, is retained in R4, Section 13, pp. 41–50. The present record gives a precise update at the gates it actually changes. A result marked NEW_PROVED has a proof here relative to the stated inputs; the label makes no claim of priority over every published result. DIRECT_COROLLARY is used conservatively for deductions already supplied by the frozen calculus. External facts and conditional hypotheses are identified where used.
Two distinct extension questions
Ordinary potential independence, preservation of represented curvature order, and testing on every delta-form are different assertions. R5 settled independence. The new bounded-difference positivity criterion settles order, and its proof uses no higher-degree delta extension. The latter extension question retains the separate scopes below. This round uses Mihatsch’s actual analytic delta-form sheaf , as defined by compatible data on all skeletons and all refinements. Its total bidegree is used unless a tridegree is displayed. The external map is faithful, but faithfulness of that map does not by itself extend an arbitrary ordinary current to the larger test sheaf.
We prove the following sufficient mechanism. Let be the ordinary weak closure, on one fixed ordinary domain , of positive separately closed actual delta-form backgrounds. Full actual delta-testing is constructed for . All bounded classical BT tails of such backgrounds stay in that class. Smooth regular flags and their integrable diffuse barycenters give additional examples. The equality of this class with all allowed backgrounds is not assumed.
The all-background ambient cycle action is stronger in a different direction: constant real tropical cycles and all their ambient relations act over every fixed allowed . Actual analytic zero-presentations introduce an additional kernel. Explicit saturated torus and matroidal chart hypotheses remove that kernel in their fixed-chart scope. Their locality must not be upgraded to arbitrary ordinary subopens without another argument.
Capacity and Dirichlet notation
On a fixed capacity domain , normalized testers are actual classical functions defined on all of with . Raw capacity is their supremum of masses, and the star denotes the infimum over ordinary open neighborhoods in the same domain. C1 denotes sharp compact no-gain under the relevant weak closure; C2 denotes raw Borel equality with that ordinary-open outer capacity. Both remain open in general unless a theorem below supplies an explicit additional hypothesis.
When has degree , the remaining degree is one and for real original compact smooth . The sharp Hardy and strong-capacity estimates below hold for every such allowed , in every ambient dimension. Faithful closed form and Dirichlet conclusions invoke the additional frozen form setup where stated. For a background of smaller degree one may fix the other bounded BT slots to obtain a degree-one tail; this does not freeze a nonlinear family in which all slots vary.
Ordinary currents and actual delta-tests
What ordinary equality determines in the actual delta-form category
Throughout this section, is the original finite extension of , with its original absolute value. The analytic space is good, Hausdorff, boundaryless, and purely -dimensional. When the relative bounded-potential calculus is used, is also quasi-smooth and has the local hypotheses of that calculus. Write Here is the sheaf of actual delta-forms of [Mih24, Definition 4.2]. Its total bidegree is used: a tridegree has total bidegree . We do not identify with the algebraic sheaf without the hypotheses of the comparison between those two sheaves.
The external faithfulness statement
Proposition (Faithfulness on actual delta-forms). EXTERNAL_KNOWN. For every ordinary open , integration defines an injective map It commutes with and . The source is defined using all original toric refinements; it is not the quotient obtained from one chosen tropicalization alone.
The precise input is [Mih24, Proposition 4.11, printed pp. 70–71]. The standing field and analytic-space assumptions are given at the start of its Section 3, printed p. 42; in particular its field is any complete non-Archimedean field, and its analytic spaces are good and Hausdorff. Section 4 assumes pure dimension and empty analytic boundary. Thus no algebraic closure of the fixed is needed here. The original smooth-test topology is recalled in the proof of that proposition. Definition 4.2 and Lemma 4.4, printed pp. 61–62, are the relevant all-refinement definitions and vanishing criterion.
Corollary (Ordinary equality for two actual delta-forms). DIRECT_COROLLARY. If and on all original smooth tests, then as actual delta-forms. Consequently, for every , The same conclusion holds after multiplication by any further actual delta-form for which the total degree and support make the integral meaningful.
Proof. Injectivity gives in the sheaf . Its wedge product and integration are operations on sections of that sheaf. Applying them to this equality proves the assertions. No density of smooth tests in a delta-test topology is asserted or needed. ◻
The precise BT comparison for delta-form backgrounds
Lemma (Multiplication by a piecewise smooth function). DIRECT_COROLLARY. Let and . Then is a continuous actual function, is an actual delta-form, and as coefficient-Radon currents. The right side is the ordinary Borel multiplier, with its actual point values.
Proof. By [Mih24, Proposition 4.7, printed p. 66], . On a common finite skeletal presentation over the support of a test, multiplication by multiplies each smooth coefficient of the polyhedral current by the restriction of the continuous function ; this is the product described in [Mih24, Remark 4.3(1), printed p. 61]. The coefficient measures of the resulting ordinary current are therefore times the coefficient measures of . A finite partition of unity and the refinement compatibility in the definition of identify the local statements. Equality holds for every original smooth test, including tests requiring a further moment refinement. ◻
Theorem (Comparison on an actual delta-form background). DIRECT_COROLLARY. Let and suppose that is symmetric, positive in the project’s original middle CLD cone, and separately - and -closed. Let , with . Put in . Then
In particular the delta-form on the right represents a positive, separately closed ordinary current. This includes semipositive PL potentials, whenever those potentials are actual piecewise smooth functions in the indicated original moment category.
If two such delta-form expressions represent the same ordinary BT current, then they agree as actual delta-forms and on every complementary compact delta-test. If , the weighted current is also represented by the delta-form .
Proof. The separate closedness of and Proposition “Faithfulness on actual delta-forms” imply in . Suppose inductively that the product with is represented by the separately closed delta-form The ordinary recursive definition and Lemma “Multiplication by a piecewise smooth function” give The last equality is the Leibniz rule with both derivatives of zero. This proves the induction, starting with . Positivity and closedness are supplied by the already established ordinary BT theorem, not by an unidentified positivity convention for arbitrary delta-forms. The full delta-test equality follows from Corollary “Ordinary equality for two actual delta-forms”; the weighted assertion follows from the multiplier lemma. ◻
Remark (What this does and does not say for arbitrary backgrounds). For every allowed fixed positive closed , even when is not an actual delta-form, the currents and above exist by the ordinary BT theory. Their individual differentiated slots depend only on , by the R5 potential quotient theorem. This does not by itself construct a functional on all delta-tests.
For example, a formal expression , with admissible slots and compactly supported original smooth coefficients of complementary degree, can be paired with by the corresponding finite sum of ordinary BT pairings. To call this an action on the delta-form represented by that expression, one must additionally prove that every zero relation between such expressions annihilates . Independence of one potential in one slot is only the linear part of this relation problem. Proposition “Faithfulness on actual delta-forms” does not supply a product of an arbitrary current with a delta-form.
An arbitrary ordinary current is, by definition, a functional on , not on . A full delta-test identity involving it is therefore not a statement until the enlarged action has been defined and shown independent of all presentations and refinements. This is distinct from the already settled comparison for two actual delta-forms.
The algebraic GK category is a separate input
In [GK17], the standing base field is algebraically closed, complete, and nontrivially valued, and the space is the analytification of an algebraic variety; see its Notations and Terminology, printed p. 8 of arXiv:1406.7637v3. Definition 4.4 imposes vanishing after all algebraic morphisms, and Definition 4.13 sheafifies the corresponding algebras. Remark 6.7 explicitly does not assume faithfulness of the ordinary-current map; Proposition 6.8 gives a criterion using all algebraic pullbacks for its generalized delta-forms .
Mihatsch states the embedding in [Mih24, Section 4.2, printed p. 67], under those GK hypotheses, and explains its basis in Lemma 4.4 and Theorem 4.5. He labels that comparison as given without formal proof. Once this embedding is available for the actual datum, Corollary “Ordinary equality for two actual delta-forms” applies to its image, and equality there implies equality on GK delta-tests as well. None of these sentences replaces the original finite by its completed algebraic closure or transfers an arbitrary current across that extension.
The theorem above accordingly uses Mihatsch’s actual sheaf directly over the original . It neither asserts that embeds into it nor that arbitrary CLD currents acquire all the nonclosed, nonpositive, and off-diagonal operations of the delta calculus.
The local divisor generation that is actually available
This section separates three algebras: constant-weight rational tropical cycles, smooth-coefficient expressions in those cycles, and all actual Mihatsch delta-forms. The distinction matters before one asks whether a formula involving an arbitrary background current descends through relations.
Proposition (The fan generation input). EXTERNAL_KNOWN. The graded ring of rational tropical cycle fans in , with rational weights and stable intersection, is isomorphic to the rational polytope algebra. Every codimension- such cycle is a finite rational linear combination of th powers of tropical hypersurfaces of rational polytopes.
The precise source is [JY16, Theorem 5.1 and Corollary 5.2], printed pp. 19–20 of arXiv:1309.7064v3. Its convention on printed p. 3 explicitly restricts Sections 3–6 to fans. Its Section 5 works over , not with arbitrary non-rational polyhedral directions. The constructive paragraph after Corollary 5.2 uses a subdivision into a simple polytopal fan and products of nonnegatively weighted divisor fans. These are equality statements for cycles, not only equality of their supports or rational-equivalence classes.
Corollary (Constant real weights and local affine cycle germs). DIRECT_COROLLARY. Let be a constant-weight rational polyhedral tropical cycle of codimension on a neighborhood of . Real constant weights are allowed, and the affine offsets of its polyhedra may be real. After shrinking to a neighborhood of , there are finitely many real numbers and convex piecewise affine functions whose gradients are integral such that
The functions have real additive constants; no extension of the valued base field is required when their pullbacks are used later.
Proof. Choose a finite subordinate polyhedral complex near . On a sufficiently small neighborhood, this cycle is the restriction of the translate by of its local cone fan. The directions of that fan are rational. For a fixed finite rational fan, its constant real weight vectors satisfying balancing form the real kernel of a matrix with rational entries: choose rational bases in the finitely many normal quotient spaces and write the balancing equations. This kernel has a rational basis. Consequently the real-weight fan is a finite real linear combination of rational-weight fans on the same complex.
Apply Proposition “The fan generation input” to each of these finitely many rational-weight fans. If is a resulting rational polytope, its support function is convex piecewise linear, and is its tropical divisor. Translate the argument to . Choose an integer clearing the denominators of the vertices of and set . Then has integral gradients, and the factor is absorbed into . The divisor product agrees with stable intersection by [Mih23, Theorem 4.1(4)], proving (eq:r6-local-cycle-generation). ◻
Corollary (Original moment pullbacks). DIRECT_COROLLARY. Let be an original toric moment map over the fixed . On a neighborhood on which a delta-form is represented by a finite sum where the are smooth superforms and the have constant weights and rational directions, it is locally a finite real linear combination of expressions with continuous piecewise affine classical psh functions . The identities hold in the actual delta-form sheaf and hence after every further original moment refinement.
Proof. Apply Corollary “Constant real weights and local affine cycle germs” in a neighborhood of and shrink accordingly. A convex piecewise affine function is a finite maximum of affine functions. Each affine pullback is a real linear combination of logarithms of analytic units plus a real constant. Such affine pullbacks are pluriharmonic under all complete extensions, and their finite maxima are classical psh. The delta pullback commutes with and wedge products by [Mih24, Definition 4.2(3)]; this proves the displayed identity. Refinement compatibility is part of the same definition, not a separate assertion made on only the original chart. ◻
Remark (Generation is not the relation theorem). The preceding corollary constructs representatives. It does not prove that the ordinary BT pairing of such a representative with an arbitrary fixed is independent of the representative. The remaining relation problem is exactly that a zero delta-form expression must have zero relative BT action. The R5 potential quotient settles individual degree-one potential changes, not automatically all polynomial relations between several factors.
Example (A false generation statement for the full Mihatsch algebra). FALSE; direct degree check. The full algebra is not generated by smooth forms and the curvature factors alone. Its degree-zero part contains the continuous piecewise linear function , by [Mih23, Lemma 3.7]. The degree-zero part of the algebra generated by smooth forms and factors of positive bidegree consists only of smooth functions. Thus this function is absent from that proposed generated algebra. The same example occurs over the original on an annulus whose skeleton contains : the function has , where is the unit Gauss point, by the original torus calibration. If were original smooth near , its curvature would be a smooth top-degree form there. Such a form has Lebesgue densities on finitely many local calibrated one-dimensional skeletal cells, and hence has no atom at . This contradiction proves the claimed non-smoothness. A corner seen only on one fixed skeleton would not by itself prove non-smoothness after all moment refinements.
This disproves the literal generation assertion; it does not disprove a generation statement allowing piecewise smooth coefficients, first derivatives, or further operations.
Scope of the two published definitions.
The generalized delta-preforms of [GK17, Definition 2.9] allow tropical cycles with smooth weights. Their differential subalgebra is defined through the closed subspace and the algebra in §4.6 and Definitions 4.9 and 4.13. Consequently the constant-weight hypothesis of Corollary “Original moment pullbacks” must be retained; it is not a verified description of every section of .
Mihatsch’s real delta-forms are all balanced polyhedral currents, equivalently those polyhedral currents whose and derivatives remain polyhedral; see [Mih23, Definitions 3.1–3.2 and Theorem 3.3]. His theory also permits non-rational polyhedra. Neither this class of variable coefficients nor non-rational direction data is covered by the rational fan generation theorem quoted above. Their treatment cannot be replaced by an invocation of the polytope algebra without an additional proof.
A useful external structural formula, not a missing generation theorem.
For real delta-forms, [Mih23, Theorem 4.1 and its uniqueness proof, printed pp. 13–14] characterizes the product by the Leibniz rules, multiplication by piecewise smooth forms, and Divisor intersection satisfies and reduces to for a separately closed ; see Definition 4.6 and Remark 4.7, printed p. 15. These formulas may guide an extension to a new class of currents. They are proved in the delta-form category, however, and do not assert that the required diagonal intersections, exterior products, or presentation-independent piecewise operations exist for every ordinary CLD current.
What the additional proofs in this round now supply.
Theorem “Constant real tropical cycles act over every fixed background” treats constant cycles with arbitrary real directions. The exact finite construction in Theorem “Local piecewise smooth module generation” treats all smooth coefficient arrays, including flat ones, and proves that every real Mihatsch delta-form is locally a finite sum of piecewise smooth forms times constant real cycles. Thus the two omissions from the quoted rational fan theorem have been addressed by separate proofs in this round. These proofs do not turn the quoted JY theorem into a stronger external input. The further actual analytic relation problem is settled for the weak-approximation class in Theorem “A full actual delta-test extension”; its all-background version remains a distinct open question.
Closed Radon currents and piecewise smooth tests
Throughout this section is the original finite extension of , and is a good Hausdorff boundaryless quasi-smooth -analytic space of pure dimension . All smooth forms are the original CLD forms. The coefficient-Radon property and Borel multiplication are understood on the actual Berkovich space, as in R and B. No pushforward to one selected skeleton is used.
Write for the sheaf of piecewise smooth forms defined using original toric moment presentations and their full tropical images. Its equivalence relation is the one in Mihatsch, §4.2, equation (4.9), printed page 65. On a polyhedral complex, the smooth pieces agree after restriction to the affine tangent space of every common face; see §2.1(16), printed pages 13–14. By his Proposition 4.7, this is precisely the codimension-zero part of his sheaf of actual delta-forms. It is not the entire sheaf .
Provenance before the new argument.
R4, Theorem 71.4 (printed p. 240), already proves the piecewise-test action and uniform smooth approximation for arbitrary original-positive separately closed currents. Its wall estimates even give an bound uniform under fixed finite mass controls. That positive case is a DIRECT_COROLLARY here, including its identification with the codimension-zero delta-test class. The additional assertions below concern closed coefficient-Radon currents without a positivity assumption, all smooth level sets rather than only affine moment walls, and the resulting piecewise smooth module structure. They do not replace the stronger quantitative R4 estimate.
Lemma (Tangency of the mass on a smooth level set). Let be a coefficient-Radon current on . If , then for every real original smooth function and every , If , the corresponding identity with holds. These are identities on all original complementary compact smooth tests, including arbitrary further moment refinements. No positivity hypothesis is needed.
Status: NEW_PROVED for the stated nonpositive closed-current extension. The positive affine-wall case is already part of R4.
Proof. Put . Its absolute value is at most , while Uniform convergence and the local finite coefficient variations give as a current. Thus its tends to zero. The smooth product rule and identify that derivative with . On any fixed original test, coefficientwise bounded convergence identifies its limit with . This proves the first identity. The same proof gives the second. Every argument is made after the chosen test has been presented on a common refinement; hence no restriction of the test class has occurred. ◻
Definition. Let be the sheaf of coefficient-Radon currents such that, for every local real original smooth and every , both identities in Lemma “Tangency of the mass on a smooth level set” hold. Thus separately closed coefficient-Radon currents belong to . This auxiliary sheaf records exactly the tangency needed to multiply by piecewise smooth forms; its elements need not be closed.
Theorem (Canonical piecewise smooth multiplication). There is a unique local multiplication obtained from tangential restriction of the smooth pieces, It extends multiplication by original smooth forms and by actual continuous piecewise smooth functions. It is real bilinear, associative with the wedge product of piecewise smooth forms, and compatible with restriction and gluing on ordinary opens. It is independent of subdivisions, smooth extensions from faces, toric moment presentations, and further refinements. The resulting objects are ordinary coefficient-Radon currents. In particular every allowed arbitrary positive separately closed background , and every frozen bounded BT product over , acts canonically on all compact piecewise smooth complementary tests.
Status: NEW_PROVED for the general module formulation; DIRECT_COROLLARY for the asserted action on the project’s positive closed backgrounds and BT products, by R4 and the displayed external identification of the piecewise smooth sheaf.
Proof. Work first in one moment presentation and on a compact stage. Choose a finite polyhedral subdivision adapted to the piecewise smooth representative of . Use all relatively open faces, so their inverse images are disjoint Borel sets. Locally near the compact stage, choose a smooth ambient extension of the smooth form on each closed face. Define
There are only finitely many terms on the stage. Smooth extensions have bounded coefficients there, so this is a coefficient-Radon current. If several extension neighborhoods are needed, use a finite smooth partition on the ambient face; the same argument below proves independence of it.
Let be the affine span of , written as the common zero set of affine functions . Tangency gives Indeed , and restriction of a zero coefficient-Radon current to a Borel set remains zero. If two smooth extensions have the same tangential restriction on , their pointwise difference there belongs to the exterior ideal generated by the conormals . This follows by completing a basis of to an ambient dual basis. The coefficients of that decomposition are Borel and bounded on the compact stage. The preceding identities annihilate this difference in (eq:r6-pws-stratum-formula). Thus the formula does not depend on extension choices.
Subdivision does not change the formula. On each smaller face the old and new smooth pieces have identical tangential restrictions, and the same conormal argument applies. Any two finite subdivisions have a common subdivision.
It remains to check the quotient defining the analytic sheaf, not just a fixed polyhedral presentation. Suppose a presented piecewise smooth form is zero in that quotient. After passing to a common moment presentation, its restriction to the full tropical image is zero for every affinoid domain in the presentation. Cover the support of a given original test by finitely many interiors of such affinoids, and use an original smooth partition subordinate to those interiors. On one member subdivide and the piecewise smooth presentation simultaneously. For each resulting face, the representative has zero tangential restriction. The conormal argument therefore makes its product with the corresponding Borel part of zero. Summing proves zero on the chosen original test. This also proves invariance under the equivalence of two moment presentations, by taking their joint moments and subtracting the two representatives. The argument uses the full and works for every affinoid ; it does not replace the defining quotient by a selected skeleton.
If is any further original smooth function, apply the same formula to . Each summand is a smooth multiplier times a Borel restriction of , hence zero. The identity is identical. Thus the product belongs to . Using one common subdivision for two piecewise smooth forms proves associativity directly in (eq:r6-pws-stratum-formula). Bilinearity follows in the same way. Restriction is manifest, and the independence already proved glues the local constructions uniquely. For a continuous piecewise smooth function the face values are its actual values, so the formula is ordinary continuous coefficient multiplication. ◻
Proposition (Coefficient control and fixed-current smoothing). Fix and one compact stage with a finite original moment presentation. Let be a piecewise smooth form there. There exist smooth forms on a slightly smaller stage such that, for every fixed original smooth test on that stage, for each compact in the smaller stage. All these coefficient variations admit a common finite bound by the variations of finitely many coefficients of times a fixed bound for the piecewise smooth coefficients and . The assertion is for fixed ; it does not assert uniformity over an arbitrary varying family of currents.
Proof. Use a piecewise smooth representative on an open subset of containing the relevant tropical image. In each full-dimensional polyhedron choose its smooth coefficient array. Assign arbitrary bounded values to the array on lower-dimensional faces and convolve locally with a nonnegative compactly supported smooth mollifier of radius . Work on a relatively compact smaller real open, so no boundary extension issue occurs. The arrays remain uniformly bounded there and define .
For a fixed point in the relative interior of a face , all adjacent pieces have the same restriction to the tangent space of . Consequently, after restricting all covectors to that tangent space, the mollified array at tends to the common tangential array at . To verify this, discard the finitely many polyhedra whose closures do not contain , then use continuity of the smooth arrays on each remaining closed polyhedron. The mollifier averages only these finitely many arrays for sufficiently small . Their common tangential limits agree.
On , all components in the conormal exterior ideal are annihilated by , as in the preceding theorem. Thus the coefficients of on that set converge pointwise, after contraction, to zero, with a uniform bound by finitely many fixed coefficient variations of . Bounded convergence gives convergence in total variation on . Sum the finitely many faces. For an additional original test, make a common refinement first; the argument and the finite coefficient domination are unchanged. This proves the assertion on all original tests. A partition of unity gives the same statement for finitely many local presentations. ◻
Corollary (First derivatives of continuous piecewise smooth potentials). Let be separately closed and coefficient-Radon. For every real continuous piecewise smooth function , In particular both first derivatives are coefficient-Radon. These statements do not assert that for an arbitrary piecewise smooth form of positive degree; corner terms can occur in that situation.
Proof. The local ambient representative of is continuous and piecewise smooth on a finite polyhedral subdivision. It is locally Lipschitz: the gradients on each smooth piece are bounded on compact subsets and the pieces agree on common faces. Its mollifications converge locally uniformly to . Their first derivatives are the mollifications of its almost-everywhere piecewise derivatives, because continuity eliminates a distributional jump term in the first derivative. The tangential convergence proof of Proposition “Coefficient control and fixed-current smoothing” therefore applies to these derivatives. The smooth closed product rule gives . The left side converges distributionally to by local uniform convergence; the right side converges as a coefficient-Radon current to . Repeat for . Local identities glue by the preceding theorem. ◻
Exact scope.
The construction solves the codimension-zero delta-test extension for every fixed allowed background and its BT products. A positive-codimension delta-form is not merely a piecewise smooth coefficient array. Pairing with such a form can require an additional intersection. No arbitrary delta-test extension, no product of two arbitrary currents, and no varying-background monotone theorem is asserted here.
A lattice valuation identity over an arbitrary background
Fix the original , an allowed ordinary open , and one arbitrary symmetric original-positive separately closed -current . Put . The signed differentiated calculus of R5 is a frozen input: locally bounded differences of actual classical psh functions give coefficient-Radon mixed currents by finite polarization, with symmetry, recursion, and dependence only on their differentiated currents. All equalities below are ordinary current equalities on every original compact complementary smooth test and every further refinement.
Let denote the continuous actual functions which are locally differences of two members of . No continuity of those two individual presentations is required. Their pointwise maximum is again classical psh. Consequently is a real vector lattice: if , then and the maximum and minimum of two local differences can be reduced to this identity. These formulas are only used on a common local presentation; the resulting functions are their actual pointwise positive and negative parts.
Lemma (Orthogonality of positive and negative parts). Let and suppose . Then
The same conclusion holds with replaced by any signed mixed tail generated from by the frozen bounded classical-difference calculus, provided the total degree is allowed.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen signed calculus and ordinary locality. Its proof is recorded because it supplies the contact-set identity needed for the new cycle-relation argument below.
Proof. First let be any one positive separately closed mixed tail over , including . The signed current is coefficient-Radon by finite polarization. The set is an ordinary open because is continuous. On the actual function is zero, so the recursive definition, or ordinary restriction of , gives . Every coefficient Radon measure of therefore vanishes on . On the actual multiplier is zero. The two assertions imply as a coefficient-Radon current on all of . Applying and using the signed recursive calculus proves (eq:r6-disjoint-parts-orthogonality) with in place of . A signed mixed tail is a finite linear combination of such positive tails on each local presentation. Apply the preceding argument to its terms and use ordinary restriction and gluing. No assertion about the ordinary openness of a gap set between discontinuous psh functions is involved, and no simultaneous limit of two singular measures has been exchanged. ◻
Theorem (Max–min valuation for every mixed power). Let and set , . For every ,
The degree-zero convention is . A further fixed signed mixed tail may be inserted in every term whenever the degree permits it. The functions and are continuous classical differences; need not be psh. Thus the formula uses the signed calculus in its stated scope rather than asserting positivity of every term.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the preceding orthogonality identity and finite polynomial algebra. The ensuing application to ambient cycle relations is a separate theorem, rather than a new regularization theorem.
Proof. On the module of signed mixed tails over , write , , , and for their commuting differentiated-slot operators. This notation means composition of the defined recursive operations; it does not multiply two arbitrary currents. Linearity gives . With one has and . Lemma “Orthogonality of positive and negative parts” gives on every allowed tail. It follows that .
For two commuting symbols , their power sums obey This is checked by expanding the right side and cancelling the two cross terms. The pairs and have the same sum and product, hence have the same power sums by induction. Apply that polynomial identity to or the fixed tail. All operators commute by the frozen signed BT symmetry, and all intermediate terms have the specified degree. Local potential presentations give the identity locally; the original current sheaf glues it. ◻
Corollary (A finite exponential valuation). For let act on the module of signed mixed tails generated over by . The exponential is finite, with terms beyond the available degree zero. It satisfies If is actual pluriharmonic, then and .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Max–min valuation for every mixed power” and the frozen R5 quotient.
Proof. The product and its derivative depend on the actual current , so the operator is independent of a chosen signed-tail presentation. Expanding that presentation shows that it stays within the stated module and agrees with insertion of the differentiated slot. Those operators commute and satisfy . The ordinary finite binomial formula gives the first assertion. The valuation identity follows by summing the power identities with coefficients . For a pluriharmonic , R5 makes its slot zero on every positive tail; finite polarization gives the same conclusion on the entire module. ◻
Continuity is used at one precise place.
The proof uses that is an ordinary open. For a general discontinuous classical difference this need not hold. The preceding argument therefore supplies no new fine locality theorem for that larger class. Continuous PL support functions, which are the application below, satisfy the hypothesis exactly.
Descent through ambient tropical cycle relations
Fix the same original field and allowed space as above, one arbitrary allowed background , and original toric moments on an ordinary open . Changing all signs to additive valuations merely changes the chosen moment convention. We use the maximum convention for support functions and tropical divisors, consistently with [JY16, Notations and conventions, p. 3].
Let be the graded real module of ordinary currents obtained locally as finite linear combinations of the signed bounded-potential mixed tails over . Its grading records the number of differentiated slots. An operator of degree larger than the remaining dimension acts as zero. A continuous local classical difference defines on this module. This is a well-defined operator on actual currents: Borel multiplication and do not depend on a presentation of , while the frozen signed calculus shows that its value is another allowed mixed tail. The operators commute.
Lemma (Support functions under a convex union). Let be nonempty compact convex polytopes such that is convex. Then In particular is nonempty.
Proof. The maximum formula is immediate from taking the supremum over a union. Fix a linear functional . If , choose maximizers , . For every , the point has -value strictly greater than . The whole segment lies in , so all these points belong to . By closedness , and the maximum on is at least . The reverse inequality is automatic. The case of the opposite strict inequality is symmetric. If the two support values agree, the segment of maximizers lies in that common supporting hyperplane. Its intersections with the closed sets and cover the segment and contain its respective endpoints. Connectedness forces them to intersect. The intersection point has the common support value. This proves the second formula and nonemptiness. ◻
Theorem (Action of the rational fan cycle ring). Let be the graded ring of constant-weight rational tropical cycle fans in , allowing real weights. There is a canonical graded real algebra homomorphism characterized by
for every rational polytope . Thus every polynomial relation between constant rational tropical cycle fans annihilates every allowed mixed tail over the arbitrary . The output for a homogeneous cycle of codimension is a separately closed coefficient-Radon current of degree above that tail. No positivity claim is made for a general positive tropical cycle presented as a signed combination of hypersurface products.
Status: NEW_PROVED: the relation descent uses the elementary frozen-calculus consequence proved above and the external polytope algebra isomorphism. It is not a new construction of the ordinary BT product.
Proof. First work over . The rational polytope algebra is generated additively by symbols , with translation invariance and the relation when is convex. Its multiplication is Minkowski sum, , with and the point class as unit; see [JY16, Section 5, p. 19].
For assign The support function pulled back by is a finite maximum of original pluriharmonic functions, hence a continuous classical psh function. All its operators are therefore defined. Translating adds an affine function of . That function is original smooth pluriharmonic, so its operator is zero. Thus translation invariance holds. The support function of a Minkowski sum is the sum of the support functions. The finite exponential identity in Corollary “A finite exponential valuation” proves multiplicativity. The preceding lemma and the max–min exponential valuation prove the additive polytope relation. If one polytope is empty the relation is immediate. All defining relations are consequently respected, and the assignment gives a unital algebra homomorphism .
By [JY16, Theorem 5.1, pp. 19–20], the map is an isomorphism . Its logarithm sends to . In the nilpotent operator algebra, . Therefore has property (eq:r6-cycle-action-divisor). The graded component of degree of the polytope algebra is spanned by , so this action is graded and its homogeneous values are finite linear combinations of the signed BT currents asserted in the theorem. Separate closedness and coefficient-Radon type follow term by term.
For real weights, use scalar extension. On any fixed finite rational fan, the real balanced weight space is the real scalar extension of its rational balanced weight space, because balancing is the kernel of a rational matrix. Every finite collection of cycles has a common finite rational subdivision. Hence , with its products preserved, and the action extends uniquely by real linearity. Hypersurface generation gives the claimed characterization. This proof never changes the valued field and never replaces by a geometric or smooth background. ◻
Corollary (Local affine cycles, support, and ambient refinements). Let be a constant-weight rational polyhedral tropical cycle on a real open , with real affine offsets and real weights. There is a local action on . It is linear in , separately closed, and coefficient-Radon, and it has support contained in . It is independent of local fan representations and compatible with restriction, gluing, and affine rational refinements of ambient moment maps. Every equality of such ambient cycle germs gives an equality of their actions on all original compact smooth tests, including tests with additional moment coordinates.
Proof. We first verify locality of the fan action, rather than assuming it from its global algebraic definition. Near , a polytope support function satisfies where is the exposed maximizing face. Indeed the finitely many other vertices have a strict support gap at , which persists in a sufficiently small neighborhood. The equality is exact on that neighborhood. It remains exact after moment pullback, so its differentiated operators agree there. A finite expression for a cycle as powers of hypersurfaces therefore localizes to the corresponding expression for its translated local fan. If the cycle germ is zero, that fan relation is zero, and Theorem “Action of the rational fan cycle ring” annihilates it. This proves locality and the support assertion.
Every affine polyhedral cycle is, near a given point, the translate of its local fan. Apply the fan theorem to that translate, using in place of . On the overlap of two such neighborhoods their cycle germs agree; localizing both expressions once more at any point of the overlap reduces their equality to the same fan relation. Hence the currents agree on the overlap and glue uniquely. The same argument proves linearity and compatibility with restriction.
For an affine rational map of real moment spaces, pullback of a hypersurface potential is literal composition with . On a sufficiently small neighborhood it is again a convex piecewise affine function with rational gradients, with real constants allowed. The delta pullback is compatible with and products. Hypersurface generation and the identity of the actual composed potentials prove compatibility of the actions. Refinement never restricts the final test class: the current identity can be paired with any original test after its own common refinement. ◻
The remaining analytic kernel is separate.
The preceding results kill relations in the ambient real cycle algebra and its germs. They do not yet prove for an arbitrary original moment map on an arbitrary analytic space. A nonzero ambient cycle may have zero actual pullback. Annihilation of that additional kernel is required before the construction descends to all actual analytic delta-tests. The R5 quotient settles the corresponding differentiated potential relation in degree one; it does not automatically settle this higher-degree analytic relation. The fixed-coordinate torus case below has an independent faithfulness check.
Real cycle relations and pointwise polyhedral relations
The preceding rational construction has a stronger real version. The additional argument uses the presentation of piecewise polynomial functions on a simplicial fan. It also identifies a class of analytic relations that can be annihilated without approximating the background.
Lemma (A vanishing product of continuous potentials). Let be continuous local bounded classical differences on an ordinary open and suppose at every point. Then, over every allowed positive separately closed background , whenever the degree is allowed. The conclusion also holds on every signed mixed tail over a fixed allowed background.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen signed recursion and ordinary locality.
Proof. Induct on . The case is immediate. For let . It is a coefficient-Radon current. On the ordinary open the remaining product of actual functions is zero. Induction on that open gives . On its complement the multiplier is zero. Thus as an actual coefficient-Radon current, and its is zero. Signed tails are handled by their finite positive-tail expansions. All of these arguments are local on ordinary opens. ◻
Lemma (Finite piecewise linear functions give allowed signed slots). Every continuous piecewise linear function on a finite complete real fan is a difference of two finite convex piecewise linear functions. After composition with original unit moments it is therefore a continuous local bounded classical difference, over the original field.
Proof. Refine the fan by the finite arrangement of all hyperplanes containing its facets. Write their linear equations as and set . Continuity of the given function implies that, across each adjacent pair of full-dimensional chambers, its gradient jump is a scalar multiple of the corresponding normal. There are finitely many such jumps. For sufficiently large , every oriented normal jump of is nonnegative. Along a generic line, its successive slopes are then nondecreasing. By continuity, the same convexity inequality holds on every line, including lines in walls. Thus and are convex piecewise linear functions. Each is a finite maximum of linear functions. Their moment pullbacks are finite maxima of original pluriharmonic functions, hence classical psh under the full complete-extension curve definition. The actual difference is the required function. ◻
Lemma (The piecewise polynomial presentation). Let be a finite complete simplicial fan in . Choose one nonzero generator of each ray and let be its Courant function: it is linear on each cone and takes value at . Then where is generated by the squarefree monomials whose rays are not all in one cone. Here consists of continuous functions polynomial on every cone, with the homogeneous grading.
If is a subfan, the kernel of restriction is generated by the monomials whose ray supports lie in no cone of .
Proof. A nonface monomial vanishes pointwise, since on any cone only its own ray variables can be nonzero. Thus the displayed map factors through the stated quotient. In that quotient every polynomial is a linear combination of monomials whose support is a face. If it restricts to zero on a maximal cone , all monomials supported in have zero coefficients: the corresponding are independent linear coordinates and a polynomial vanishing on the relative interior is the zero polynomial. Every allowed monomial occurs in such a cone. This proves injectivity, and the same argument on maximal cones of a subfan proves the asserted description of the restriction kernel.
For surjectivity take a homogeneous piecewise polynomial and construct its expression in increasing order of face dimension. After matching all proper faces of a cone , its residual polynomial on vanishes on every facet. In its independent ray coordinates it is therefore divisible by . Write the quotient as a polynomial in those coordinates and use the identical polynomial in the global Courant functions, multiplied by that product. This corrects the residual on and vanishes on every other face of dimension at most . Processing all faces of that dimension consequently preserves earlier corrections. At the maximal cones the residual is zero everywhere. The initial constant on the zero cone is handled by a constant polynomial. This finite induction gives surjectivity degree by degree. ◻
Theorem (Piecewise polynomial functional calculus). For original moments and an arbitrary allowed background , there is a canonical graded algebra homomorphism which sends a degree-one piecewise linear function to . The source is the direct limit over finite complete real fans and their refinements. Every global linear function lies in its kernel, and hence so does the ideal generated by such functions.
More strongly, if is a subfan of a finite complete simplicial fan , if , and if vanishes on , then .
Status: NEW_PROVED for the operator descent and the stated pointwise-image ideal.
Proof. On one simplicial fan assign . The operators are defined by Lemma “Finite piecewise linear functions give allowed signed slots” and commute by signed BT symmetry. A nonface monomial has zero product of the actual Courant functions. Lemma “A vanishing product of continuous potentials” therefore annihilates its operator. Lemma “The piecewise polynomial presentation” gives a homomorphism from .
On a simplicial refinement, a coarse Courant function is the linear combination of the fine Courant functions given by its values at the fine ray generators. Linearity of shows that the two homomorphisms agree. Every two finite complete real fans have a common finite simplicial refinement, obtained by common subdivision and compatible triangulation of the cones. Thus these homomorphisms give the asserted direct-limit map, with no dependence on the ray normalizations. A global linear function pulled back by unit moments is original smooth pluriharmonic. Its operator on a separately closed tail is zero, so its generated ideal is killed.
Finally the kernel of restriction to is generated by its nonface monomials, by the preceding lemma. Their actual products vanish on because . The same zero-product lemma annihilates them. This proves the stronger assertion. Notice that it uses actual pointwise vanishing, not vanishing almost everywhere for the ambient integration current. ◻
Theorem (Constant real tropical cycles act over every fixed background). The ambient cycle action and its local affine version extend from rational directions to all constant-weight real tropical cycle fans and germs. It remains linear, graded, local in the real moment domain, and compatible with real affine changes of moments. It agrees with the previous action on rational cycles. Every output is an ordinary separately closed coefficient-Radon current, and all equalities hold on all original tests.
Status: NEW_PROVED using Theorem “Piecewise polynomial functional calculus” and the following external isomorphism.
Proof. Esterov’s Theorem 3.1 identifies the graded ring of continuous conewise-polynomial functions modulo the ideal generated by global linear functions with the ring of constant-weight real tropical cycle fans; see [Est12, Section 3, printed p. 12]. The identification sends a piecewise linear function to its corner divisor. With the standard ambient calibration, that divisor is : on the elementary hinge both conventions assign the normal weight . The ring products are the same transverse, hence stable, intersection products. No rationality or lattice hypothesis appears in this real isomorphism.
The preceding theorem kills its entire defining kernel. Composing with the inverse isomorphism gives the required cycle action. It sends to , including signed PL functions. This also proves agreement with the rational action, because both are generated by these divisors. Homogeneous degree piecewise polynomials are finite linear combinations of products of Courant functions. Their values are consequently finite signed BT currents, giving the asserted closedness and Radon properties.
Locality and affine-germ gluing follow as in the rational case: localize each PL generator to its exact piecewise linear germ at the point in question and discard its constant value. The localized polynomial is the local cycle germ under the corner-locus isomorphism. A zero germ is annihilated by the same ring relation. Composition of potentials proves compatibility with real affine moment changes. Again, this is an ambient relation theorem; it does not discard the remaining actual analytic pullback kernel described above. ◻
An exact additional criterion for analytic relations.
On a local moment image contained in a subfan , every piecewise polynomial representative in has zero relative action over every . The first ideal is killed by actual zero products; the second by pluriharmonicity. It remains a separate question whether every actual zero cycle-presentation on a given analytic chart lies in this sum of ideals. The statement here is an independently proved sufficient criterion, not an assumption that the local tropical image has a Euclidean or matroidal intersection ring.
An arbitrary-background action for fixed-coordinate tropical cycle tests
The ambient cycle action proved in Theorem “Action of the rational fan cycle ring” and Corollary “Local affine cycles, support, and ambient refinements” will be denoted . We use its stated linearity, locality, separate closedness, coefficient-Radon property, support property, and invariance under equality of ambient constant-weight rational cycles. Its hypersurface action is . For signed cycles the action is interpreted by the proved finite polarization of positive classical-potential products.
Coefficients and relations on all polyhedral strata
Theorem (Piecewise smooth coefficient relations). NEW_PROVED, relative to the ambient cycle action. Let be an original moment map and let be any allowed fixed positive separately closed background. Let be constant-weight rational cycles of the same codimension on , and let . If
then the well-defined piecewise coefficient products satisfy
The equality is tested against all original complementary compact smooth forms, including tests requiring further moment refinements. Only degrees within the dimension of are asserted.
Proof. Put . These are separately closed coefficient-Radon currents, not necessarily positive. Their piecewise smooth coefficient products are defined by Theorem “Canonical piecewise smooth multiplication”.
The assertion is local over a compact moment stage. Choose a common finite polyhedral complex subordinate to all the and on a neighborhood of that stage. All arguments below can be localized to slightly smaller stages, so artificial outer faces of the chosen complex play no role. Write for the constant weight of on a cell of dimension , with zero weight when that cell is absent from .
For a face of this complex let These are Borel sets. If is the affine span of , choose affine equations for . The original smooth functions vanish on . Lemma “Tangency of the mass on a smooth level set”, applied separately to each , gives Thus, on this stratum, the multiplier depends only on the restriction of to . In particular all terms vanish if .
Otherwise choose constant tangent coordinate forms on and write, on , These scalar coefficients are smooth on , locally bounded, and Borel after pullback. For every incident cell of dimension , relation (eq:r6-ambient-coefficient-zero) implies Restrict this equality to . For each fixed tangent tensor component, the vector lies in the kernel of the fixed real matrix The case in which no such occurs causes no problem: all vanish on a neighborhood of the stratum by their support property.
Choose a fixed basis of . There are locally bounded Borel scalar functions on such that For each , the cycle vanishes on an ambient ordinary neighborhood of : remove the finitely many nonincident closed top cells and use the zero weights on all incident cells. Local ambient relation invariance therefore gives This is an equality of coefficient-Radon currents. Restricting it to , multiplying by the Borel scalar , and then by the constant tangent form are legitimate coefficient-measure operations. Their finite sum proves Finally sum over the finitely many relevant strata. Since every compact original test is covered by such local stages, this proves (eq:r6-coefficient-action-zero) on every original test. No was treated as an ordinary open set, and no cycle was inserted into a nonclosed coefficient-weighted background. ◻
A full-coordinate torus domain removes the pullback kernel
Let be ordinary open and set We keep this single coordinate moment presentation. The use of instead of is a simultaneous real affine reflection; all weights and differential operations are the original ones. Define as the image under of those real delta-forms on which are locally finite sums of the indicated kind. Its elements are therefore locally presented over coordinate open subsets by where are piecewise smooth superforms and are constant-weight rational cycles. Different tropical codimensions are allowed and are treated in their separate trigraded summands. This is an explicitly specified subalgebra of actual . It is not claimed to be every actual delta-form on .
Theorem (A fixed-coordinate delta-test action). NEW_PROVED, with the stated test scope. For every allowed fixed background of bidegree on , the prescription
is independent of the displayed presentation and defines a linear coefficient-Radon current of the expected total bidegree. It is compatible with restriction from to its real open subsets and thus from to the corresponding saturated torus domains. The independence is equality of original currents on all original tests, not merely equality in the chosen tropical coordinates.
In complementary total degree it gives a well-defined pairing with every compactly supported test in . If is represented by an actual delta-form , this pairing is the usual .
For continuous convex rational PL functions , cycle insertion recovers the relative BT products. More precisely, whenever degrees permit and , Thus identities between these actual fixed-coordinate delta-tests remain valid after relative BT insertion over an arbitrary .
Proof. The standard skeleton of is canonically identified with , with calibration one. Restricting a presented pullback to this skeleton is the original real delta-form on . Consequently, if two displayed expressions agree as actual delta-forms on , their real expressions agree on . Apply Theorem “Piecewise smooth coefficient relations” to their difference, separately in each codimension. This proves presentation independence. The restriction and Radon assertions follow from those of the cycle action and piecewise multiplication.
When the test has compact support, its real expression has compact support in : a point of the support of the real expression gives a support point on the standard skeleton, lying in the compact support of the actual test. Choose a smooth real compact cutoff equal to one near that real support. Ambient locality and the already proved coefficient relations imply that the output is supported over the support of this cutoff. The inverse image of a compact subset of under the torus tropicalization is compact, being a closed subset of a compact polyradius annulus. Thus in complementary degree the output is a compactly supported top-degree signed Radon measure, whose mass defines the pairing. If , the recursion comparison in Theorem “Comparison on an actual delta-form background”, finite polarization, and multiplication by piecewise coefficients identify each term with its actual delta product. This proves the comparison with delta integration.
Finally is the pullback of the rational tropical hypersurface . The ambient polytope action is multiplicative on cycle factors and its hypersurface insertion is . The displayed compatibility follows by applying these identities before multiplying by the piecewise coefficient of each summand of . All inserted intermediate backgrounds are separately closed signed mixed currents for which that cycle action was constructed; no operation on an arbitrary nonclosed current is used. ◻
The remaining actual-pullback gate.
Even on the torus, the saturated-domain statement above does not by itself prove ordinary sheaf locality relative to the actual support of a delta-test. An ordinary open subset of can miss the standard skeleton and need not be a saturated coordinate domain. For example on a curve annulus has actual support consisting only of its Gauss point, whereas also contains residue branches. Its relative action does vanish on those branches, because its potential is locally constant there; this special observation is not a general pullback-kernel theorem. We have proved compact saturated support and presentation independence, not the missing ordinary sheaf locality assertion in general.
For a general moment map , especially with , an actual delta-form can vanish on although its ambient expression is nonzero. Theorem “Piecewise smooth coefficient relations” kills ambient relations. To descend through this additional pullback kernel one needs a further argument. The standard full-coordinate torus domain above has no such kernel because of its standard skeleton. A delta-form involving additional units, such as , is not automatically in ; enlarging the moment tuple returns to the additional pullback problem. No extension to all actual Mihatsch tests, all GK generalized preforms, or arbitrary nonclosed backgrounds is claimed here.
Actual cycle relations on saturated matroidal tropical charts
This section supplies a geometric condition under which an actual analytic pullback relation is stronger than an ambient cycle relation, but is still annihilated over every allowed background. The condition concerns one fixed moment chart and its calibrated tropical image. No existence of such a chart on an arbitrary Berkovich space is asserted.
Definition (A saturated matroidal chart). Let be an allowed pure -dimensional space over the original , and let be original unit moments. The following data will be called a saturated matroidal chart.
is proper onto its image , and , with its induced integral affine structure, is a boundaryless rational tropical manifold of dimension .
There is a positive constant such that the following calibrated affinoid condition holds locally over every point of . One can choose arbitrarily small compact polyhedral neighborhoods , with the point in , for which is affinoid, Here and its weights are exactly the original calibrated tropicalization of Mihatsch, Definition 3.4 and equation (3.8).
The constant can equally be allowed to be a locally constant positive function on , by making the assertions local over . Restriction to a smaller real open subset of always means restriction of to its full inverse image.
The hypotheses explicitly retain the proper fibers. They do not say that is its skeleton, or that an arbitrary ordinary subopen of has the same calibrated tropical image.
Proposition (The required tropical duality). EXTERNAL_KNOWN. If is a rational tropical linear space, then is an isomorphism. Here the source is the direct limit over rational fan subdivisions, and is the ideal generated by global linear functions. The local affine version is an isomorphism of sheaves on every boundaryless rational tropical manifold. These statements remain true after tensoring the integral groups with .
Source and normalization. These are Gross–Shokrieh, Lemma 4.4 and Theorem 4.5, [GS21, printed pp. 13–14]. Their Section 4.3, printed pp. 12–13, defines the local affine piecewise polynomial sheaf and quotients by the ideal generated by affine functions; Remark 4.2 explains why the affine convention is needed at points with nonintegral coordinates. Their Lemma 4.1 identifies the degree-one action with tropical divisor intersection. In our maximum convention this is ; a simultaneous sign reflection in the real moment coordinates changes neither the assertion nor its calibration. Tensoring is exact over with the torsion-free, hence flat, module . Equivalently, on each fixed finite rational fan the relevant polynomial and balanced-weight spaces are obtained from the integral ones by scalar extension. This proves the stated real-weight version. ◻
Lemma (From an actual zero form to a tropical zero cycle). DIRECT_COROLLARY of the actual delta-form definition. On a saturated matroidal chart, let be a real delta-form on . If as an actual analytic delta-form on , then locally on . This assertion applies to forms with piecewise smooth coefficients as well as to constant-weight cycles.
Proof. Mihatsch’s Lemma 4.4(5), [Mih24, printed p. 62], applied with the identity refinement of , gives away from . On the two chart assumptions identify this equality with . Since , it gives the claimed equality. These interiors cover . This is a consequence of the full actual delta-form vanishing; it does not test only one chosen skeleton. ◻
Lemma (Annihilation of relative cycle relations). NEW_PROVED, using the external tropical duality. Let be a constant-weight rational cycle of codimension on , with real weights. If on a relative open subset , then for every allowed fixed positive separately closed background . The same assertion holds for finite real linear relations between such cycles, and on signed mixed tails over .
Proof. Work near a point . Translate to zero. The local cone of is integrally linearly isomorphic, on its ambient span, to a rational tropical linear space : the chart uses the induced affine sheaf, so both directions of this identification are locally restrictions of ambient affine maps. We make this identification; the germ of is a rational fan cycle . By the ambient cycle presentation, choose a homogeneous degree- piecewise polynomial on a finite complete rational fan whose corner-cycle class is . Refine to a simplicial fan adapted to . Compatibility of divisor intersection gives Proposition “The required tropical duality” implies, after a finite rational subdivision, that where are restrictions of ambient real linear functions and are homogeneous piecewise polynomials of degree on . For the assertion instead says directly that on and no sum is needed.
Extend the chosen finite subdivision of to a finite complete simplicial ambient subdivision. This can be done by first taking a finite hyperplane arrangement refining its cones and then a compatible simplicial subdivision. Each extends to an ambient piecewise polynomial : in the Courant presentation, keep its face-supported monomials and assign zero coefficients to the remaining monomials. Thus vanishes pointwise on . The pointwise-image ideal in Theorem “Piecewise polynomial functional calculus” annihilates its operator on the inverse image of a sufficiently small neighborhood of . The operators of the terms are zero because the original moment pullback of is pluriharmonic. This proves there. Local ambient cycle invariance permits these identities to glue over . The argument takes place in the module of signed mixed tails, so the last assertion and real linearity follow at the same time. ◻
Theorem (A fixed-chart actual delta-test action). NEW_PROVED, on the stated chart and test class. On a saturated matroidal chart let be the image of those real delta-forms on which locally are finite sums where are piecewise smooth forms and are constant-weight rational cycles with real weights. For every allowed fixed background the prescription is independent of the displayed presentation as an actual delta-form on . It is linear and coefficient-Radon, and all its identities hold on every original complementary compact smooth test. It is compatible with restriction to saturated subdomains. In complementary total degree it gives a pairing with every compactly supported test in .
For a background represented by an actual delta-form this pairing agrees with the full actual delta product and its integration. Insertion of continuous convex rational PL potentials in the fixed moments agrees with relative BT insertion. No assertion identifies with all of .
Proof. It suffices to annihilate a displayed actual zero relation, one tropical codimension at a time. By Lemma “From an actual zero form to a tropical zero cycle”, that relation gives These are constant-weight rational cycles of dimension on . Put . Lemma “Annihilation of relative cycle relations” shows that vanishes over every real open subset on which vanishes. In particular its support is contained in . It also shows that every constant local relation among the gives the identical relation among the .
Choose one finite common polyhedral subdivision on a compact moment stage, subordinate to the and all coefficients. For every face , the Borel current is tangent to the affine span of , by Lemma “Tangency of the mass on a smooth level set”. Consequently only the tangent restrictions matter. Expand these restrictions in constant tangent tensor components. For each component its scalar coefficient vector is in the kernel of the fixed matrix of weights of the on the incident -dimensional cells. This follows by restricting the displayed zero relation from those cells to .
Choose a fixed basis of that finite-dimensional kernel. Each basis vector defines a constant cycle relation among the on a real neighborhood of , after discarding the finitely many nonincident closed top cells. The preceding lemma annihilates the identical combination of the . Restrict that current equality to the Borel stratum and multiply by the bounded Borel scalar coordinates of the coefficient vector in the chosen kernel basis. Summing tangent components, then faces, proves This is the same coefficient-measure argument as in Theorem “Piecewise smooth coefficient relations”, with the relative cycles in place of the ambient cycles. It does not insert a cycle into a nonclosed coefficient-weighted background.
For compactly supported , the support of is contained in the compact set . Indeed, outside that set the actual form vanishes on a saturated open, and the detector gives the claimed tropical vanishing. The relation argument just proved then shows that has support in , which is compact by properness. Its top-degree mass therefore defines the stated pairing. The remaining comparison and insertion assertions follow termwise from the ambient cycle action, Theorem “Comparison on an actual delta-form background”, and canonical piecewise coefficient multiplication. ◻
Example (Products of three-punctured lines). For every , take and a real open . The saturated domain , if nonempty, has the chart data above with . In one factor the image is the three-ray fan On its first two rays the parameters and , respectively, give degree-one annulus coordinates; on the third ray use . The primitive slopes are , and up to the outward signs, so the original calibrated weights are one. All radii are ordinary Berkovich Gauss radii; no extension or rescaling of is used. Taking products gives the product fan with product calibration one. It is a tropical linear space, as is also explicit in [GS21, Lemma 3.1].
The map is the closed immersion into the torus defined by . Inverse images of compact coordinate boxes are therefore affinoid closed subspaces of compact polyannuli, and the moment map is proper. Boxes with a given point in their interior can be chosen inside . Their analytic boundary maps to the box boundary: the closed immersion is boundaryless, and the polyannulus boundary lies over that boundary. The calibrated tropicalization on the box interior is the indicated product fan. Thus the theorem applies to arbitrary allowed positive separately closed on these -dimensional domains. In dimensions greater than one this allows genuinely non-smooth backgrounds; it is not a theorem only about currents coming from the displayed curves.
The remaining scope.
The theorem is about actual relations on each fixed saturated chart. Its proof uses the whole calibrated tropical image in every compact stage. An arbitrary ordinary subopen may omit part of a tropical fiber and fail these hypotheses. Ordinary sheaf locality for all such subopens, arbitrary analytic moment images, and tests outside the indicated constant-cycle-generated class remain separate questions. The external tropical Poincare duality does not assert that a general analytic space admits matroidal charts or that its actual delta-form sheaf is generated by this one presentation.
Every real delta-form is locally generated over piecewise smooth forms
This section proves an exact finite generation statement. Its proof uses a decomposition of smooth coefficients by their restrictions to coordinate faces. It uses no polynomial density, formal Taylor series, or convergence against singular tests. In particular a smooth flat remainder is retained exactly.
Lemma (Anchored face decomposition). Let be a finite set and let be smooth on a neighborhood of the closed coordinate cube . For put Then Every is smooth and vanishes whenever for one . These formulas commute with every fixed real linear relation between the functions involved. If one first restricts to a coordinate face containing , its anchored -component remains .
Proof. In the sum over , the coefficient of the evaluation is , which is zero unless , when it is one. This proves the identity. If , pair the subsets not containing with ; their evaluations agree and their signs are opposite. Smoothness, linearity, and compatibility with the indicated restrictions follow directly from the finite formula. ◻
Theorem (Local piecewise smooth module generation). NEW_PROVED by the finite construction below; no claim of external priority is made. Let be a real delta-form of tridegree on an open subset of , in Mihatsch’s balanced-polyhedral-current sense. Every point has a neighborhood on which
where is a piecewise smooth -form and is a constant-weight real tropical cycle of codimension . The sum is finite. If the supporting polyhedra have rational directions, the can be chosen with rational directions. All weights and coefficients may be real.
The equality holds in the real delta algebra itself and hence survives its pullbacks and refinements. No positivity, closedness, or diagonal-degree hypothesis is imposed on .
Proof. Fix the point, translate it to zero, and take a finite polyhedral presentation near it. Discard the closed cells not incident to zero by shrinking the neighborhood. Each remaining cell agrees there with its local cone. Refine these cones to a finite complete simplicial fan ; cones off the original support have coefficient zero. This is done only in the real moment space and changes neither the current nor its weights. Put and choose weights for the -dimensional cones, absorbing any scalar factors into their coefficient forms.
Choose one nonzero generator for each ray and let be the corresponding Courant function. On a cone , its own ray functions are independent linear coordinates. Choose one ordering of all rays. There are unique smooth coefficient functions such that Their smoothness up to all coordinate faces follows from the definition of a smooth form on a closed polyhedron. There are only finitely many functions. Choose a common small such that all positive coordinate cubes under consideration, together with every point obtained by setting any coordinates to zero, remain inside the original presentation neighborhood. Each coefficient then has a smooth extension to an open neighborhood of its coordinate cube.
Apply Lemma “Anchored face decomposition” to every . Denote its anchored -component by . Fix a triple which occurs in at least one cone, and let be the face spanned by . For each -cone put using zero when the coefficient is absent. If is empty these are simply constants.
We claim that, for every , the vector is a balanced constant weight vector on the star of . Let be a -cone containing . The balancing criterion for , [Mih23, Definition 3.2 and Theorem 3.3], says Compare the coefficients of in the independent coordinate basis on . Indices outside restrict to zero and contribute nothing. The remaining identity is a fixed linear relation between smooth functions of the coordinates on , with values in . Apply its anchored -projector. Because , compatibility with restriction in Lemma “Anchored face decomposition” gives exactly
This holds throughout the indicated cube, including its faces. It proves the claim.
Let be the finite-dimensional real kernel defined by all equations (eq:r6-anchored-star-balance). Choose a fixed basis . There are smooth functions on the -cube such that Indeed choose a fixed linear coordinate map on and apply it to the vector of smooth functions. Its coordinates extend smoothly to a neighborhood of the cube. Since every vanishes when any -coordinate is zero, the same is true of every on those coordinate faces.
Define the constant cycle The projected cones form the star fan. The lifted cones have the same tangent spaces and the same weights as the original . Their facet normal equations are precisely those defining , so is balanced. This includes the case , when the quotient is zero-dimensional. There is no lattice index or change of calibration: choosing a weight on , dividing by it in the quotient, and multiplying by that same weight in the lift leaves unchanged.
On a smaller neighborhood of zero put It is piecewise smooth. The Courant functions are continuous PL, their piecewise differentials agree tangentially on all faces, and composition with the displayed smooth functions has the same compatibility. Its tangent restriction to any cone missing a ray of is zero: a missing ray in sets one coordinate of to zero, whereas a missing ray in or makes the corresponding differential zero.
We now verify the exact recovery. On the open star of , the lifted cone agrees with wherever the coefficient form can contribute. More explicitly, if is in the relative interior of a cone containing and its quotient lies in , that quotient lies in the relative interior of . The star fan intersection property implies . Thus on the top-dimensional pieces one obtains exactly the original cone and its weight. On every other cone the tangent coefficient is zero by the preceding paragraph. Lower-dimensional intersections do not change a polyhedral current. It follows that Summing over the finitely many triples and applying the anchored decomposition recovers every , hence . All constructions took place in the chosen small neighborhood, so no extension of the smooth coefficients to an entire fan was assumed.
If the original support directions were rational, complete and simplicial subdivisions can be chosen rational, and the star lifts preserve rational directions. Finally equality of the resulting polyhedral currents is equality in the real delta algebra, by its definition and the refinement equivalence of [Mih23, Remark 2.3]. This proves all the assertions, including arbitrary tridegrees. ◻
Corollary (Exact local generation of actual analytic delta-forms). DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Local piecewise smooth module generation” and the definition of Mihatsch’s actual analytic delta-forms. On every original analytic moment neighborhood, each actual delta-form is locally a finite sum of a piecewise smooth form times pullbacks of constant real cycles. By the real cycle presentation, the latter factors can in turn be expressed as finite real linear combinations of products of , where is a continuous PL difference of classical psh potentials in the same original moments.
Consequently, on any class of backgrounds for which the constant-cycle-generated action has been proved to annihilate all actual analytic relations, that action covers the whole actual delta-test sheaf. The generation result does not itself prove that relation-annihilation property for an arbitrary background or an arbitrary analytic moment image.
Relation to the fixed-chart theorems.
For a full-coordinate saturated torus domain, the ambient real cycle action and its coefficient-relation proof apply to every delta-form in the fixed coordinate presentation. For the saturated matroidal theorem, the present generation argument applies to its rational-direction test class. The matroidal duality input used there is a rational fan theorem; no additional nonrational relative duality is inferred here. Both chart statements retain their explicit restriction to saturated domains until ordinary sheaf locality is established by a separate argument.
Degree-one delta relations over every allowed background
The weak approximation hypothesis is unnecessary in total degree . The reason is an order property specific to curvature currents of continuous scalar potentials. Freezing a continuous coefficient produces an arbitrarily small order error; it need not produce an exact constant relation on a neighborhood.
All domains in this section are ordinary opens in the analytic spaces allowed by B, over the original finite . The positive cone and tests are the original ones. We use R, Theorem 2.9, through B’s authorized ordinary local algebraic localization. Thus a finite continuous potential with positive original curvature has locally uniform original smooth positive approximants. No extension of this input to a new base field is being made.
Lemma (Continuous curvature order transfers to a fixed background). Let be an arbitrary allowed symmetric positive separately closed -current, with . If is finite continuous and on an ordinary open, then In particular, if are continuous classical psh, , and satisfy then the same inequalities hold after replacing by .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the authorized continuous regularization theorem R and fixed coefficient multiplication.
Proof. Locally choose uniformly with original-positive smooth forms. Since is coefficient-Radon, on every original test. Separate closedness gives . Applying the continuous distributional operator and passing to the limit gives . The assertion is local and hence glues. Apply it to the two continuous potentials for the last statement. This argument uses uniform smooth approximation directly and does not require a new classicality equivalence. ◻
Theorem (Continuous-coefficient degree-one relation descent). Let be continuous classical psh functions and let be finite continuous real functions on the same ordinary domain. Set These are actual coefficient-Radon currents. Then Consequently implies on all original tests. The last implication also holds when each is a continuous local difference of two continuous classical psh functions.
Status: NEW_PROVED by the local order argument below. The background is arbitrary and fixed; no membership in is assumed.
Proof. Put , , and . All are positive and separately closed. Fix and a point . There is an ordinary neighborhood on which for every . Write . If , positivity of the coefficient measures gives on The preceding lemma transfers this order inequality to . Continuous scalar multiplication of the positive also gives
For a fixed compact original positive test choose a finite subcover of its support by such and a nonnegative original smooth partition subordinate to that cover. Applying the local inequality to the partitioned tests and summing gives . Let . This proves positivity on every original positive test, with the same cone convention as for . If , apply the implication both to and to . The positive test cone spans the symmetric test space; all these currents are symmetric. Thus on every original test.
For local differences expand each and replace the corresponding coefficient by and . On any compact test support only finitely many local expansions and a partition are needed. The already proved statement applies. No freezing step asserted that vanishes on a neighborhood. Only its two-sided small order bound was needed. ◻
Lemma (Local continuous piecewise smooth potentials are differences). Every finite continuous piecewise smooth scalar in a finite original moment presentation is locally a difference of two continuous piecewise smooth classical psh functions. The same holds for a finite product of such scalars.
Proof. It suffices to prove a real local statement before the moment pullback. Work on a convex ball with compact closure in the presentation domain, and refine the finite subdivision by all its facet hyperplanes. A continuous piecewise smooth function has uniformly bounded Hessians on the finitely many closed pieces. Across a facet its tangential derivatives agree, so its gradient jump is normal to the facet and is uniformly bounded there. Choose affine defining functions for the finitely many hyperplanes, with normalized gradients. For sufficiently large positive constants , the function is convex, and has positive semidefinite Hessian in every open piece and nonnegative normal derivative jumps across every facet. Restriction to a generic segment therefore has nonnegative second derivative on each subinterval and nonnegative first-derivative jumps. It is convex. Continuity and approximation of segments give convexity for all segments in a smaller ball. Hence is a difference of convex continuous piecewise smooth functions there.
Convex real functions of original logarithmic unit moments are classical psh: one may mollify the convex functions on a smaller real ball, obtaining locally uniform original smooth positive approximants, or apply convexity to the harmonic coordinate pullbacks on every test curve. This proves the asserted local decomposition over the original field. Products of continuous piecewise smooth scalars are again of that same class, so the same real argument applies to them. ◻
For -forms, “symmetric” below means the usual CLD prime–double-prime symmetry; in a moment coefficient matrix it is ordinary matrix symmetry. Write for that projection. Constant codimension-one cycle factors are symmetric.
Lemma (A continuous Hessian presentation in total degree one). Every symmetric actual Mihatsch delta-form of total degree locally has a finite presentation where are continuous piecewise smooth scalars and are continuous piecewise smooth local differences of continuous classical psh functions. Each may therefore be expanded into two admissible positive potentials in that formula.
For a general -delta-form its antisymmetric part is piecewise smooth, so it is covered by the already canonical PS multiplication.
Proof. Module generation splits a local total-degree-one presentation into a PS -form and continuous PS scalars times constant codimension-one cycles. The real cycle theorem writes the latter cycles as finite sums of of continuous PL functions, which have the required difference decompositions.
For the symmetric PS part use the anchored construction of Theorem “Local piecewise smooth module generation” with codimension zero. Every constant balanced codimension-zero cycle on a connected real neighborhood is a constant multiple of the ambient integration current. The construction consequently writes the PS form as a finite sum with continuous PS and Courant PL scalars . The actual delta Leibniz rule gives Lemma “Local continuous piecewise smooth potentials are differences” applies to every displayed potential and coefficient product. This proves the required presentation. The positive-codimension part has only scalar coefficients and symmetric cycle factors, so the antisymmetric part of a general form comes entirely from its PS part. ◻
Lemma (Piecewise smooth product rule with a Radon derivative). Suppose belongs to the tangential coefficient-Radon module of Theorem “Canonical piecewise smooth multiplication”, and is coefficient-Radon. For a continuous PS scalar , The corresponding identity also holds. In particular, for continuous PS local differences and the fixed ,
Proof. Mollify a continuous PS real representative of on a smaller compact moment stage. The functions converge uniformly, and their first derivatives converge tangentially on each face with uniformly bounded arrays. The conormal annihilation and fixed coefficient dominated convergence in Proposition “Coefficient control and fixed-current smoothing” give in local coefficient variation. Uniform convergence also gives . Pass to the limit in the ordinary smooth product rule. This proves the first assertion and its double-prime counterpart.
For the second assertion, Corollary “First derivatives of continuous piecewise smooth potentials” gives , which belongs to the same tangential module by its PS module property. Its derivative is coefficient-Radon because is a local difference. Apply the first assertion to this current, and similarly with exchanged. The first-derivative product rule for the scalar then yields the displayed formula. This passage uses only fixed Radon measures; it does not require a moving-measure chain rule. ◻
Theorem (Canonical degree-one action for arbitrary fixed ). For every allowed positive separately closed -current , , every actual delta-form of total degree has a canonical ordinary coefficient-Radon current . It is linear, independent of all presentations and refinements, and compatible with restriction and gluing on ordinary opens. It agrees with canonical PS multiplication, with for the continuous local differences above, and with the actual delta product when is a delta-form. Its support is contained in .
If the ordinary current is symmetric and original-positive, then is original-positive. On each fixed finite moment/polyhedral presentation it has the finite coefficient bounds supplied by its Hessian presentation. No hypothesis occurs.
Status: NEW_PROVED by continuous order descent. This is a total-degree-one assertion, not an all-codimension analytic relation theorem.
Proof. For symmetric define . If a presentation represents zero, ordinary delta integration and continuous scalar compatibility give . Theorem “Continuous-coefficient degree-one relation descent” annihilates it after relative insertion. Subtracting presentations gives independence. The same theorem proves the stated positivity for every positive symmetric ordinary .
For a general form add the canonical action of its antisymmetric PS part. Prime–double-prime symmetry commutes with the real delta operations and their actual pullbacks, so this decomposition is intrinsic. To verify agreement with PS multiplication, use the Hessian presentation of its symmetric part. The last identity of Lemma “Piecewise smooth product rule with a Radon derivative” identifies each symmetric Hessian expression with its already defined PS wedge product. The antisymmetric part agrees by definition. Ordinary smooth multiplication is a special case.
All formulas restrict ordinarily. Independence proves their agreement on overlaps and under all original refinements. If vanishes on an ordinary open its presentation there is a zero relation, so its action vanishes; if vanishes there the formula also vanishes. This proves the support assertion. On an actual delta-form background the ordinary BT–delta comparison and continuous multiplication identify the formula with the actual product. If only the ordinary current is initially known to be symmetric, actual delta faithfulness (Proposition “Faithfulness on actual delta-forms”) gives , so the antisymmetric PS action is zero; this justifies the theorem’s stated positivity hypothesis. Finally, on a fixed finite presentation the scalar coefficients in the anchored Hessian expression are fixed finite linear combinations of coordinate-face evaluations of the original arrays. The potentials and their positive/negative decompositions are fixed. Their coefficient variations therefore give the claimed bounds on smaller fixed compact stages. ◻
Corollary (Full complementary delta-tests in remaining degree one). Let be an arbitrary allowed -current. Then is a canonical full actual delta-test extension. It is separately closed, agrees with on all original tests, and is nonnegative whenever the ordinary current is original-positive. It is determined by the ordinary current , not by an auxiliary weak approximation or a choice of representatives.
Proof. Compact actual support and the preceding theorem give the finite pairing and its claimed independence and positivity. To prove closedness, every actual form of total degree is PS. The codimension-zero anchored construction writes it locally as , where are continuous PS scalars. For a compact test, an original smooth partition makes each compactly supported in its moment neighborhood. The actual delta Leibniz rule, agreement with PS multiplication, and Lemma “Piecewise smooth product rule with a Radon derivative” give, term by term, The right side is the derivative of a compactly supported ordinary current, so its integral is zero by an original smooth cutoff equal to one near its support. Summing proves . The prime–double-prime exchanged argument proves the other identity. No higher-codimension delta product is used in this argument. ◻
Corollary (Uniqueness in the stated positive closed class). For , the functional in Corollary “Full complementary delta-tests in remaining degree one” is the unique extension satisfying Definition “The positivity required of an extension”. Thus existence and uniqueness on the whole complementary actual delta-test space hold for every allowed background of remaining degree one, under that explicit symmetry, separate closedness, and generator-positivity convention.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the forced-value theorem and the finite Hessian presentation.
Proof. Our functional is symmetric and separately closed. Each generator in Definition “The positivity required of an extension”, now with or , has positive ordinary current: it is a nonnegative continuous scalar times an original positive smooth form or a positive curvature current. The positivity assertion of Theorem “Canonical degree-one action for arbitrary fixed ” therefore verifies the required generator cone.
Conversely, take any extension with the stated properties. Localize a compact test by a finite original smooth partition. Each symmetric localized test has the Hessian presentation of Lemma “A continuous Hessian presentation in total degree one”; expand its differentiated potentials into admissible positive differences. The forced-value theorem applies with the partition function as the compact original scalar test and with the remaining continuous PS coefficient as its weight. It determines every term to be its relative BT value. The antisymmetric part is killed by symmetry of both functionals. Summing proves equality on the whole actual complementary test space. This is finite generation, not a density argument for singular tests. ◻
Corollary (Weighted decreasing convergence on degree-one delta-tests). Let be any fixed allowed -background, let satisfy , and let for be actual locally bounded classical psh rows with locally bounded limits. For every compact actual , All weights are the actual Borel functions. The background is fixed and arbitrary; no weak-approximation hypothesis is imposed.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen ordinary weighted BT theorem and the new finite Hessian presentation.
Proof. The antisymmetric PS part of pairs to zero with each scalar multiple of a symmetric -current. For its symmetric part, take a finite local Hessian presentation and a compact original smooth partition. After expanding each fixed signed potential, every term has the form where is fixed continuous classical psh, is fixed continuous PS, and is an original smooth compact scalar cutoff. The extra differentiated slot is a constant decreasing row, so the ordinary weighted joint theorem applies after replacing by an original smooth compact scalar approximant. Such approximants converge uniformly on the one fixed compact stage. Relative CLN and the common local bounds of all decreasing rows bound the unweighted positive measures uniformly there; the weights are uniformly bounded there as well. The scalar approximation errors therefore tend to zero uniformly in . Pass first in and then in the scalar approximation, and sum the finite terms. No simultaneously varying discontinuous coefficient measure has been passed without that estimate. ◻
Remaining distinction.
The degree-one result applies to every allowed background, including those carried by ambient complete-polar sets. In larger remaining degree it supplies an action of all total-degree-one delta-forms, but it does not yet annihilate every actual relation among several positive-codimension factors. The full-test theorem in arbitrary remaining degree continues to use or another explicitly proved relation mechanism.
A weak-approximation bridge to an actual delta-test class
This section states a sufficient condition on the background; it does not impose that condition on the frozen ordinary BT theory. Its purpose is to isolate an independent analytic condition which kills the additional pullback relations. All fields, spaces, positivity cones, and original test classes remain those fixed at the start of the round.
Definition (The local weak closure of delta-form backgrounds). For an ordinary open , let be the weak closure, in the topology of all original compact smooth tests, of the cone of currents , where and is symmetric, original-positive, and separately closed. A current belongs to if each point has one ordinary neighborhood on which it belongs to . The closure is allowed to use nets. The same fixed is used throughout each approximating net; it is not a varying-domain notion.
Let be the subsheaf of the actual Mihatsch delta-form sheaf whose sections locally admit finite presentations with original moments , piecewise smooth coefficients , and constant-weight real polyhedral tropical cycles . Nonrational directions, real weights, and real affine offsets are allowed by the real cycle theorem. This is an explicitly specified test class, not an asserted description of all Mihatsch or GK forms.
Lemma (Fixed continuous slots and varying positive backgrounds). Suppose weakly on all original tests, where all these currents are symmetric, original-positive, and separately closed of the same degree. Fix continuous classical psh potentials on their common ordinary domain. Then on every original test. The same holds after wedging with one fixed piecewise smooth form and testing the resulting ordinary current on any original complementary smooth form.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of R’s fixed-continuous-multiplier lemma, the frozen positive BT recursion, and R4’s piecewise-test continuity. The fixed continuity assumption on the inserted potentials is essential to this particular argument.
Proof. For one slot, R’s lemma gives ; applying proves the assertion. Those derivatives are again positive separately closed currents. Induct on the number of fixed continuous slots, applying the same lemma to the already convergent positive tails. For the last assertion, wedge the fixed piecewise smooth coefficient with the chosen original test on a common finite presentation. It is a compatible piecewise smooth test of complementary diagonal degree; replace it by its symmetric part if needed. R4, Theorem 71.4, gives convergence on that test, since weak convergence bounds its finitely many positive mass controls. This proof allows nets and does not invoke any monotone theorem for simultaneously varying discontinuous potentials and backgrounds. ◻
Theorem (Actual relation descent under local weak delta approximation). Let . For every section there is a canonical ordinary coefficient-Radon current . On a local hypersurface presentation of the constant cycles it is computed by the corresponding finite sum of piecewise smooth coefficients wedged with the relative BT products over .
This operation annihilates every actual analytic zero-presentation of , commutes with ordinary restriction and gluing, and has support contained in . If and is compactly supported, it therefore defines the finite canonical pairing . When itself is an actual delta-form background this agrees with its delta product and integration.
Status: NEW_PROVED under the explicit weak-approximation hypothesis. Its application to every arbitrary positive closed background is CONDITIONAL on the separate density assertion all such backgrounds. That density assertion remains OPEN in this round.
Proof. The real cycle theorem and its piecewise polynomial presentation express each constant cycle as a finite real linear combination of products of PL divisors. Decompose each signed PL potential into two convex PL functions by Lemma “Finite piecewise linear functions give allowed signed slots”, and expand. Thus one obtains a finite real linear combination of mixed products of continuous convex PL potentials pulled back by the original moments. Thus the proposed expression is a well-defined finite sum of ordinary coefficient-Radon currents. The ambient relation theorem above already removes ambient cycle relations, but the following argument also handles the additional analytic kernel.
Work on one fixed ordinary neighborhood on which as in Definition “The local weak closure of delta-form backgrounds”. On each , the BT–delta comparison and piecewise smooth multiplication identify the proposed expression with . In particular it is zero whenever the represented actual delta-form is zero. Lemma “Fixed continuous slots and varying positive backgrounds” passes every term of the finite expression to its corresponding value over . Hence every actual zero-presentation also has zero value over . Subtracting two presentations proves independence.
Restriction is immediate from the formula and the fact that restriction sends into for an ordinary subopen . Independence on overlaps glues the local expressions. If or is zero on an ordinary open, the local formula and actual zero-presentation independence make the resulting current zero there. This proves the support assertion. In top degree the result is a signed Radon measure; compact support makes its total integral finite. The delta-form-background comparison was already used term by term, and yields the final assertion as well. ◻
Proposition (Stability of the approximation class under all bounded slots). If and , then In particular the class contains every bounded classical BT product over , and over every positive separately closed actual delta-form background. These differentiated potentials may be discontinuous.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the authorized local smooth rows, ordinary BT continuity, and the definition as a weakly closed cone.
Proof. It suffices to insert one slot and work on one smaller ordinary neighborhood where the prescribed decreasing original smooth positive row exists. The restrictions of remain in the corresponding weak closure on that fixed neighborhood. For fixed , the map is weakly continuous. It sends each approximating actual delta-form background to an actual delta-form background whose ordinary current is positive and separately closed. Consequently belongs to the weakly closed cone there. The frozen monotone theorem gives , so the latter is in the same closure. Repeat on a common smaller neighborhood for finitely many slots. The current is itself an actual delta-form background. This proves the stated examples. ◻
Lemma (Piecewise-test approximation with a bounded Borel weight). For a fixed compact compatible piecewise smooth test , the smooth approximants and finite positive controls in R4 can be chosen so that, for every allowed positive separately closed and every bounded Borel on that compact stage, In complementary degree zero use the uniform scalar approximation error in place of .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the total-variation version of R4’s normal-factor estimate.
Proof. R4 decomposes the error into a uniformly coefficient array and finitely many bounded normal-factor arrays supported in tubes of width . Its Lemma 71.2 bounds the variations of the normal-factor coefficient measures, not merely their signed total pairings. Multiplication by increases each such variation by at most . The same statement for the regular error follows from fixed coefficient domination. Sum the finitely many terms. The proof uses closedness only for , not for the weighted current. ◻
Theorem (Weighted decreasing convergence on the specified delta-tests). Fix and . Suppose every row , , consists of actual locally bounded classical psh functions and has a locally bounded limit. For every compact , The multiplier is the actual Borel function. No identification of weights modulo their ambient curvature is made.
Status: NEW_PROVED for this actual delta-test class and these backgrounds. The ordinary weighted BT convergence itself is frozen input.
Proof. The preceding stability proposition and actual relation descent define all the currents in the integrals independently of the chosen test presentation. Localize the compact support by a finite original smooth partition and choose local constant-cycle hypersurface presentations. Each term is the pairing of a fixed piecewise smooth coefficient with where the are fixed continuous convex PL classical potentials. All these unweighted tails are positive separately closed. Their finitely many mass controls are bounded by relative CLN and the common local bounds of the decreasing rows and fixed . The weights have one local bound as well.
Replace by its fixed smooth approximant . The frozen weighted joint decreasing theorem gives convergence for this original smooth test, with the fixed treated as constant decreasing rows. Lemma “Piecewise-test approximation with a bounded Borel weight” bounds both approximation errors uniformly in by a quantity tending to zero with . First pass to the limit in , then in . Sum the finite presentations. Compact support and actual relation descent make the resulting integrals independent of all local choices. There is no varying background in this monotone statement. ◻
Full actual delta-testing over the weak approximation class
The exact module generation theorem removes the test-generation restriction from the weak-approximation bridge. The hypothesis on the background remains explicit and independent of that algebraic generation statement.
Theorem (A full actual delta-test extension). Let be as in Definition “The local weak closure of delta-form backgrounds”. For every actual Mihatsch delta-form there is a canonical ordinary coefficient-Radon current of bidegree . It has the following properties.
It is linear in , independent of all actual presentations and refinements, and commutes with restriction and gluing on ordinary opens.
Its support is contained in . Thus complementary compact delta-forms have finite pairings .
It agrees with ordinary smooth multiplication and with the actual delta product on delta-form backgrounds. Curvature factors of continuous PL classical potentials act by their ordinary relative BT insertion.
It satisfies the distributional identities In particular is separately closed on compact actual delta-tests.
On every fixed finite moment, polyhedral, and support presentation it is continuous for smooth coefficient convergence. More precisely, on smaller fixed compact stages each original coefficient pairing is bounded by a constant times finitely many norms of the presented coefficient arrays. Derivative convergence is not needed for this individual pairing bound.
Positivity is asserted on the explicit generator cone: finite sums of nonnegative continuous piecewise smooth scalars times original middle-positive smooth forms wedged with convex PL classical curvature factors. No identification with an unspecified stronger or weaker delta-positivity convention is made.
Status: NEW_PROVED under the stated background hypothesis. It is a full delta-test extension for this class, not a wedge product of two arbitrary currents.
Proof. Theorem “Local piecewise smooth module generation” and its analytic corollary identify the actual sheaf with the locally constant-cycle-generated sheaf of the bridge. Theorem “Actual relation descent under local weak delta approximation” therefore gives the construction and assertions (1)–(3), on the whole actual delta-test sheaf rather than just on a subalgebra.
For (4), work on one fixed ordinary neighborhood with as in the definition. Both and are actual delta-forms and have finite presentations supplied by module generation. The fixed-continuous-slot lemma and the piecewise-test estimate consequently give on every original compact smooth test. Faithfulness of actual delta-forms makes . Their delta Leibniz identity gives Distributional differentiation is weakly continuous; passing to the limit proves the first claimed identity. The second is identical. These local identities glue. For a compact test in the degree preceding top degree, its resulting ordinary current has compact support by (2). Pair its derivative with an original smooth scalar cutoff equal to one near that support. The definition of the derivative and the vanishing of the derivative of that cutoff there give zero. This proves separate closedness of the full delta-test functional.
For (5), inspect the finite anchored construction on a fixed small Courant cube. Each anchored coefficient is a finite signed sum of evaluations of one smooth coefficient on coordinate faces. Taking its coordinates in a fixed star-balancing kernel is another fixed finite linear map. The resulting piecewise smooth coefficient arrays have norms bounded by a fixed constant times those of the original arrays on finitely many enlarged compact coordinate-face stages. All Courant covectors and cycle factors are fixed. The output is therefore a finite sum of these bounded coefficient multipliers applied to fixed coefficient-Radon cycle actions over . Their local finite variation bounds give the asserted estimate on every original test, after its common refinement. Finite partitions handle arbitrary compact support presentations.
Finally each generator-positive term is exactly a nonnegative actual scalar times a positive BT current wedged with an original middle-positive smooth form. Its top pairing is nonnegative by the frozen cone convention and coefficient-Radon multiplication. Summing proves the stated positivity without changing that cone. ◻
Corollary (Full delta-tests for bounded BT products and weights). Fix . Every bounded classical mixed BT current over has the full extension of Theorem “A full actual delta-test extension”. The weighted joint decreasing convergence in Theorem “Weighted decreasing convergence on the specified delta-tests” holds for every compact actual Mihatsch delta-test of complementary degree.
If two such unweighted currents are equal on all original smooth tests, their extensions agree on all actual compact delta-tests. They also agree after the same actual locally bounded Borel multiplier wherever the displayed pairings are defined. In particular this applies to all the bounded classical products over from B and to the ordinary potential-quotient identities over backgrounds in this class.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the full extension, its ordinary-current construction, the class stability proposition, and the bridge’s weighted convergence theorem.
Proof. Proposition “Stability of the approximation class under all bounded slots” puts each unweighted BT current in the same kind of weak approximation class. Module generation makes every actual test admissible in the already proved weighted convergence argument. The extension is determined by the given ordinary current through fixed-potential recursion and piecewise coefficient multiplication, not by a choice of approximating net. Ordinary equality therefore gives equality of the resulting coefficient currents for each delta-form. Multiplying those identical coefficient currents by the same actual Borel function preserves equality. The final applications follow because belongs to the approximation class and the R5 quotient gives the relevant ordinary equalities. ◻
Corollary (Weak continuity on fixed delta-tests). Suppose are positive separately closed and on all original compact smooth tests. Then for every fixed actual delta-form , the ordinary currents converge to . For compact complementary their full delta-test pairings converge as well. This is a statement for a fixed delta-test. It does not assert simultaneous stability with varying discontinuous potential slots and arbitrary varying backgrounds.
Proof. Choose one finite local module presentation of the fixed over each compact test support, expand its PL slots into convex positive and negative choices, and apply Lemma “Fixed continuous slots and varying positive backgrounds” to each term. This proof needs no common approximating delta-form net for the . For a compact complementary test, all the resulting measures are supported in its one fixed actual compact support. An original smooth cutoff equal to one near that compact converts ordinary current convergence into convergence of their integrals. ◻
The precise remaining all-background question.
Every fixed allowed already has the full ordinary bounded BT calculus and the R5 potential quotient. The unsolved assertion here is that every actual zero delta-presentation has zero relative action for that arbitrary . Local weak approximation by positive closed actual delta-forms is one sufficient mechanism, now proved to cover all actual delta-tests. Its availability for every has not been established. The saturated matroidal theorem provides a different, explicitly geometric mechanism in its fixed-chart scope.
Integration currents obtained from smooth regular flags
The weak-approximation hypothesis has geometric examples beyond bounded products over . The approximation below is an iterated weak-closure argument on one fixed ordinary domain. It does not assert a joint limit of singular logarithmic potentials.
Lemma (Exact eventual equality on one original top test). Let be a good Hausdorff pure -dimensional analytic space over the original , and let be a non-zero-divisor. Put with on . For every original compactly supported smooth -form there is such that In particular as original currents. No integrability statement against an arbitrary Radon measure is part of this assertion.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the carrier argument in [CLD12, Lemma 4.6.1 and its proof, printed pp. 72–73].
Proof. Set . It is a dense Zariski open because is a non-zero-divisor. Apply a finite original smooth partition to the compact support of . The cited proof supplies, for each resulting moment presentation , a compact set contained in the interior of its affinoid stage and disjoint from . It contains the support of for every top-degree coefficient form in that fixed presentation. Explicitly, is the intersection of the support of with the union of the inverse images of the standard -dimensional torus skeleta under the standard coordinate projections of . The original top-degree carrier has maximal residual dimension, so it cannot meet the proper analytic zero locus of ; this is exactly the disjointness proved there.
The function is continuous and finite on each such compact , hence has a finite lower bound there. Choose larger than the negatives of the finitely many lower bounds. Then on all these carriers for . The displayed integrals are consequently equal, term by term. The logarithmic integral defines a current by the same cited lemma; thus equality eventually on each fixed test proves the claimed weak convergence in the topology of all original tests. This argument does not require a uniform over varying tests. ◻
Proposition (A smooth regular flag belongs to the approximation class). Let be one fixed ordinary open in an allowed smooth analytic space of pure dimension . Suppose that there are analytic functions on and a flag of closed analytic subspaces such that every is good, Hausdorff, boundaryless, and quasi-smooth of pure dimension , and cuts out the reduced effective Cartier divisor in . Let denote its integration current on , with the original CLD calibration. Then More precisely, if on , then on every original compact complementary smooth test, and every current on the left belongs to . All approximations use this same and the original absolute value.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the preceding lemma, original Poincaré–Lelong, and the fixed-continuous-slot weak-closure mechanism.
Proof. The initial current is an actual delta-form background. Assume that . Each is an actual continuous locally bounded classical psh function on . Indeed it is constant on the ordinary neighborhood of the zero locus, and elsewhere is the maximum of a constant and the logarithm of the norm of an analytic unit. This also proves in the original moment category. The same description after every complete field extension proves the required classicality.
Choose a net on the fixed as in Definition “The local weak closure of delta-form backgrounds”. For fixed , the current is an actual delta-form background. Its ordinary current is positive, symmetric, and separately closed by the ordinary relative BT theorem. The fixed-continuous-slot lemma gives its weak limit . Hence this limit belongs to , with no shrinking of depending on .
Let . Pullback of every original compact smooth test by this closed immersion is again an original compact smooth test. Integration and distributional differentiation give Lemma “Exact eventual equality on one original top test”, applied intrinsically to , passes its right side to . Original Poincaré–Lelong [CLD12, Theorem 4.6.5, printed p. 74] identifies this with . There is no sign or degree factor: the cited convention is , and the divisor is reduced with multiplicity one by hypothesis.
The cone is weakly closed by definition, so it contains . This completes the induction. Only a single logarithmic slot is sent to its singular limit at each induction step; no simultaneous singular-product continuity has been used. ◻
Corollary (Full delta-testing for the flag and its bounded products). Every integration current which locally admits the smooth regular flags of Proposition “A smooth regular flag belongs to the approximation class” lies in . This includes a smooth algebraic closed subvariety of a smooth algebraic variety after restricting to neighborhoods on which its regular immersion has an adapted smooth flag. All its bounded classical mixed BT products belong to the same approximation class in the appropriate degree. They therefore have the canonical full actual delta-test extension of Theorem “A full actual delta-test extension”, including its weighted joint decreasing convergence.
Proof. The proposition proves the local membership. For the stated algebraic example, choose local generators of the conormal bundle whose independent differentials give smooth successive zero loci, and shrink the algebraic neighborhood. Analytification supplies the required flag on the corresponding ordinary open. The bounded product assertion follows from Proposition “Stability of the approximation class under all bounded slots”; the full-test assertions then follow from the cited extension theorem and its corollary. ◻
Scope.
The proof covers the explicit local smooth-flag hypothesis. It neither asserts that arbitrary singular analytic cycles admit such flags nor that every allowed positive closed current belongs to . In particular it adds examples to the sufficient approximation class without replacing the project’s arbitrary-background ordinary theory by a geometric subclass.
Integrable classical potentials and effective Cartier backgrounds
All currents in this section remain currents on the allowed original -space. An extended classical psh function takes values in . Absolute integrability below refers to the total variations of the measures of all original compact smooth top-degree forms. It is not an assertion of integrability against every positive background measure.
Lemma (A fixed approximation domain for individually bounded functions). In an ordinary algebraic neighborhood of a point, fix nested polynomial norm boxes They can be chosen so that every classical psh function on which is bounded on a neighborhood of has, on this same , a decreasing row of continuous semipositive PL functions. The bound for and the row can depend on ; the domain does not. Consequently .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the explicit fixed-box collar in B, Lemma D.2, and its bounded projective regularization theorem. The fixed-domain point is spelled out because it is needed for an unbounded limiting potential.
Proof. Use the ordinary algebraic localization and smooth projective compactification of B, Proposition 4.5. If its constant field is a finite extension of , retain the original extending absolute value; the analytic functions and their moment forms are still original -analytic data on that neighborhood. The single positive integration factor of B, Lemma D.5, appears on both sides of each current limit and does not change weak closure or positivity.
Choose the boxes once. The constructive part of B, Lemma D.2 (printed pp. 27–28), supplies from these boxes a continuous PL collar , a pure Fubini–Study metric , and , with and with the weight of in a frame near . These objects are chosen before the upper and lower bounds of the functions enter that construction.
Normalize the present by a positive constant and an additive constant to a classical function with on a neighborhood of . Fix in the permitted value group and an integer with . The metric with local weight on , and equal to outside , is a bounded classical metric on the same ample line used by that collar. On the overlap the second branch dominates, so this is the identical gluing from B. Near its framed weight is exactly . The choices of boxes, frame, and work for every normalized . No monotonicity of a family of such is needed to construct each metric; in B it was needed only for the additional assertion that the resulting metric family decreases.
Apply B, Theorem 4.4, separately to this bounded metric. Its decreasing pure-FS row restricts on to a continuous semipositive PL row for . Undo the fixed additive shift and the positive normalization to obtain the desired row for . Real shifts and positive real scalings are permitted for actual PS and delta-form data. Each row curvature is an actual delta-form with positive separately closed ordinary current. The bounded original monotone theorem, or fixed top-test bounded convergence, gives its weak limit on this same . This proves membership in . ◻
Theorem (An integrable extended classical potential gives a weak delta background). Let be actual extended classical psh on an allowed original- space of dimension . Assume that is locally absolutely integrable against the total variation of every original compact smooth -form. Then is a degree-zero current, is symmetric positive and separately closed, and For one has on every original compact smooth complementary test. Near each point all these truncation curvatures belong to on one common ordinary .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the fixed-box lemma, original integrability and weak closure. No local potential is supplied for an arbitrary given positive current.
Proof. First the integrability hypothesis defines a current, rather than only individual finite integrals. On a fixed finite compact moment stage the coefficient controls for bound the variation of every top test by its coefficient seminorm times finitely many fixed positive compact top-form measures. Their integrals against are finite. This gives a continuous order-zero functional on that test stage. Finite localization proves continuity in the original test topology. Thus is well defined, with arbitrary values on the sets on which the controlling measures vanish.
Each actual truncation is locally bounded classical. For , wherever is finite, and the integrability hypothesis makes its infinite-value set null for every fixed top-test variation. Fixed-measure dominated convergence therefore gives , hence on every original test. Since each is symmetric positive and separately closed, its limit has the same properties.
Choose the boxes in Lemma “A fixed approximation domain for individually bounded functions” once near a prescribed point. Upper semicontinuity gives a common finite upper bound for on a neighborhood of . Each has the finite lower bound there. The lemma consequently puts every in the same weakly closed cone . Its weak limit also lies there. The geometric domain does not shrink with ; only the rows and their harmless normalizations vary. This proves the local claim. ◻
Corollary (Effective Cartier divisors, with singularities and multiplicities). Let be an allowed ordinary domain and let be a non-zero-divisor. Let be its effective Cartier divisor, with its original generic multiplicities. No smoothness or reducedness of is assumed. Then its ordinary integration current satisfies More precisely, on this same whole , on every original compact complementary smooth test. Hence every locally effective Cartier divisor lies in , and has the canonical full actual delta-test action already proved for that approximation class. Its bounded classical mixed BT tails have that action as well.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of [CLD12, Lemma 4.6.1, 4.6.3 and Theorem 4.6.5, printed pp. 72–74]. The cited statements require pure dimension, topological separatedness and a non-zero-divisor; they do not require the divisor to be smooth.
Proof. Put . It is an actual continuous classical PS function on : near a zero of the constant branch is active, and off the zero locus it is a maximum of affine functions of the original unit moment . These assertions hold after every complete extension. Thus is an actual delta-form, and its ordinary current is symmetric positive and separately closed.
For every fixed original compact top test, the compact carrier in the proof of CLD12, Lemma 4.6.1, avoids the divisor. The logarithm is finite and bounded below on that carrier. Accordingly and have exactly the same pairing with that test for all sufficiently large . This is also Lemma “Exact eventual equality on one original top test”; it assumes only a pure-dimensional space and a non-zero-divisor. Apply it to the top test for any original complementary compact smooth . It yields Original Poincare–Lelong identifies the latter current with the integration current of , including the generic Cartier multiplicities. In the original convention its coefficient is one: . In particular repeated factors contribute their actual multiplicities; no smoothness or reduced-divisor hypothesis has been substituted.
All approximants are actual delta-form backgrounds on itself, so the fixed-domain weak closure gives . For an effective Cartier divisor with only local equations, apply this on the equation neighborhoods; multiplication of an equation by a unit changes its logarithm by a smooth pluriharmonic function. The ordinary currents and the already proved full delta actions therefore glue. Bounded BT stability of gives the final assertion. ◻
Limits of this enlargement.
The extended-potential theorem assumes original-test absolute integrability. It does not assert that every extended classical function has that property, nor that every positive closed current has such a potential. The Cartier corollary is independently unconditional because its original logarithmic carrier calculation is exact. No assertion about general singular higher-codimension intersections or arbitrary analytic cycles is made here.
Barycenters of backgrounds in the approximation cone
The weak approximation class is not restricted to a single geometric background or to countable positive sums. The following elementary closure mechanism is useful for diffuse currents supported on ambient pluripolar sets. Its same-domain hypothesis is explicit.
Proposition (Integrable barycenters in one fixed weak cone). Let be one fixed ordinary open and let be a positive measure space. For almost every let . Assume the following two conditions.
For every original compact smooth complementary test , the scalar is measurable.
On each compact test presentation the finite positive mass controls for the coefficient-Radon estimate are integrable in .
Then defines a symmetric original-positive separately closed current, and . In particular it admits the full actual delta-test extension of Theorem “A full actual delta-test extension”. For each fixed actual delta-form , whenever the corresponding finite inserted mass controls are locally integrable, one also has on all original compact smooth tests.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of convex weak closure and the finite-presentation construction. The same-domain membership is not replaced by an -dependent local membership assertion.
Proof. The positive coefficient controls imply absolute integrability of every displayed scalar pairing and continuity on each compact original test presentation. They therefore define a current. Symmetry, positivity and the two closedness identities pass under the integral.
We check membership without assuming any countable collection of tests generates the topology. Fix finitely many real original tests , and consider Its components are integrable. Its integral belongs to the closed convex cone generated by its essential values: otherwise finite dimensional separation supplies a real linear functional nonnegative on that cone but negative on the integral, contradicting integration of that same nonnegative measurable scalar function. Hence the pairings of on this finite list are approximated arbitrarily closely by positive finite combinations of the pairings of . Every such combination belongs to the convex cone . This proves that every basic weak neighborhood of meets that weakly closed cone, and consequently belongs to it. The argument permits infinite total parameter mass when the stated local controls are integrable.
For the last assertion take a finite module presentation of and express its constant cycles as finite signed products of continuous PL curvature slots. Start with one continuous slot . Uniform approximation of a fixed continuous scalar by original smooth scalars, together with the integrable control bounds, gives . Applying commutes with the integral on original tests. Iterate this argument for the finitely many fixed continuous slots; relative CLN gives the required integrable controls from the stipulated inserted controls, or from the original controls when the fixed potentials have common compact bounds. Finally use the uniform piecewise-test approximation estimate. Its errors are bounded by an integrable finite sum of the same positive control pairings, and the smooth approximants commute with the integral. This passes piecewise smooth coefficient multiplication through the integral without assuming a Borel disintegration on every individual stratum. Summing the finite expression proves the identity. Actual relation independence holds on both sides by the full extension theorem. ◻
Corollary (Diffuse polar-supported fiber backgrounds). In the product-polydisc setting of Proposition “Original-current disintegration over rigid parameters”, the diffuse fiber current belongs to . All its bounded classical BT products admit full actual delta-testing, separately closed extensions, and weighted joint decreasing convergence on these tests. This includes the nonatomic exact complete-pole parameter examples.
Proof. For every fixed , the equations give a smooth regular flag on the same domain . Proposition “A smooth regular flag belongs to the approximation class” therefore puts each fiber integration current in . The fiber-integration proof gives scalar measurability and uniform compact control bounds on the compact parameter space . Apply Proposition “Integrable barycenters in one fixed weak cone”, followed by the stability of under bounded classical slots and Corollary “Full delta-tests for bounded BT products and weights”. No assertion that ambient pluripolar sets are null for these currents is used. ◻
What remains outside this closure argument.
An arbitrary positive separately closed current has not been shown to be an integrable barycenter of the displayed geometric examples, nor to be a weak limit of positive separately closed delta-forms. The proposition enlarges an established class; it does not solve the all-background analytic relation problem by definition.
Values forced by a positive closed delta-test extension
An arbitrary ordinary current is not, by definition, a functional on singular delta-tests. The following result is a uniqueness statement for extensions satisfying explicit positivity and Stokes requirements. It does not assume that such an extension exists.
Fix an allowed positive symmetric separately closed current of bidegree on , and put . An admissible potential below means a continuous function ; local versions on neighborhoods of the relevant compact supports are equally allowed. Write in the actual delta algebra.
Definition (The positivity required of an extension). Consider a real symmetric linear functional on the actual compact delta-tests of complementary total bidegree to . Assume the following three properties.
Its restriction to all original compact smooth complementary tests is .
It is separately - and -closed, in the dual sense on the actual delta-test complex.
Whenever , are admissible, is a continuous piecewise smooth function near the support of a compact original smooth form , and is positive in the original middle/PSD cone of bidegree , one has
This is a stated generator-positivity condition. It is not a claim that every possible convention for positivity of a delta-current automatically has these properties.
Theorem (Forced BT values). DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen ordinary calculus, under the explicitly assumed existence of above. For every , every admissible , every continuous piecewise smooth scalar , and every original compact smooth complementary test , one necessarily has All quantities use the actual original field, points, positivity cone, and full original test class. In particular two extensions satisfying Definition “The positivity required of an extension” agree on the linear span of these tests. Finite signed polarization gives the identical conclusion for differentiated slots which are differences of admissible potentials.
Proof. First consider . If is a positive original compact test and is a real continuous piecewise smooth scalar, then the generator-positivity assumption applied to gives where the supremum is over a fixed compact neighborhood of the support. For an arbitrary symmetric original test, the finite positive-form domination in the original PSD cone gives the same bound with a finite sum of fixed positive controls and a fixed constant. Symmetry reduces a general test to its symmetric part. This is the usual finite-frame coefficient domination; no strong cone spanning assertion is being used.
On this compact stage, a continuous piecewise smooth scalar admits original smooth approximants converging uniformly. In a finite moment presentation they are ordinary mollifications of its continuous piecewise smooth representative on a slightly larger real open; a finite original smooth partition handles several presentations. Positivity gives The original restriction of and the coefficient-Radon property of identify the right side with Thus multiplication by any such scalar agrees with actual continuous multiplication on the ordinary restriction.
For an admissible , define insertion into the functional by It is symmetric and separately closed: is separately closed and the delta algebra satisfies the two graded Leibniz rules. The generator-positivity assumption is inherited by , with one fewer available differentiated slot. The dual Leibniz identity, using separate closedness of , is It is an algebraic identity of functionals on the delta-test complex, not a convergence statement. Restrict it to original tests. The preceding scalar argument identifies the ordinary restriction of with . Differentiation commutes with restriction because original smooth tests form a subcomplex. Hence The right side is a positive symmetric separately closed coefficient-Radon current by the frozen ordinary BT theorem.
Repeat the argument for . Induction identifies the ordinary restriction of insertion of factors with the corresponding relative BT product. Apply the initial scalar argument once more to that inserted functional and to obtain the displayed weighted equality. Finally expand any signed slots by finite real multilinearity. Every intermediate unsigned insertion has the proved positivity and closedness, so no quotient theorem for an arbitrary signed background is silently assumed. ◻
What this does and does not decide.
The theorem determines the extension on a specified test span; it is not a density argument and it is not an existence theorem. It also shows that, if a formal relation between tests in this span fails after the ordinary relative BT prescription, then no extension with the three stated properties can exist. Conversely, annihilating those relations constructs an action only on that span. Generation of the whole actual delta algebra, and the positivity or continuity needed for an extension beyond it, remain separate questions. In particular the unrestricted functional counterexamples from the preceding section do not contradict this uniqueness statement.
Ordinary restriction does not determine an arbitrary delta-test functional
This section concerns functionals on tests, not equality between two actual delta-forms. Proposition “Faithfulness on actual delta-forms” continues to apply to actual delta-forms. The examples below leave its domain and do not contradict it.
Lemma (Top delta-forms have canonical coefficient measures). DIRECT_COROLLARY. On the original good Hausdorff boundaryless pure -dimensional -space , each has a canonical finite signed Radon measure , supported in , characterized by For each locally bounded Borel function on , is a well-defined linear functional. Its restriction to original smooth tests is the ordinary current .
It is continuous on every fixed finite polyhedral presentation stage with a common compact support and coefficient convergence. In particular it is continuous for the stronger coefficient smooth convergence on that stage. This statement specifies the continuity being used; it does not attribute an unmentioned delta-current topology to Mihatsch.
Proof. Choose a finite family of local presentations of over its compact support. By [Mih24, Corollary 4.9 and Definition 4.10], its support is carried by a finite union of calibrated skeletons. On a common refinement, its restriction is a finite sum of smooth top-degree coefficient forms on weighted polyhedra. Their absolute integrals on the compact stage are finite. They therefore define a finite signed Radon measure on that stage and then on .
Different skeletal presentations give the same integrals against every original smooth scalar test, since both compute . Original smooth scalar functions are uniformly dense among continuous functions on a fixed compact neighborhood, with a common compact cutoff. Uniqueness of Radon measures then identifies these constructions. This also proves linearity in . The support assertion follows by ordinary locality.
On a fixed stage the sum of the absolute polyhedral integrals is bounded by a fixed constant times the maximum of the coefficient uniform norms. Hence has the asserted stage bound. The Borel function is multiplied only after the fixed signed Radon measure has been identified; no tropical measurability condition on is needed. For smooth , the measure just constructed is its original CLD integration measure, proving the restriction statement. ◻
The algebraic GK counterpart of the measure construction is [GK17, Corollary 6.15]. Proposition 6.16 there states the functional result for continuous . Its displayed bound (6.16.1), once the signed Radon measure is fixed, gives the same continuity estimate for locally bounded Borel . This observation does not extend the base-field hypotheses of that paper; the proof above uses Mihatsch’s integration directly over the original .
Example (A positive functional invisible to all ordinary tests). FALSE for unrestricted uniqueness; DIRECT_COROLLARY construction. Choose a uniformizer of the original , put , and let The point is an actual -Berkovich point; no algebraic closure or rescaling of the absolute value is used. Let . Every original smooth compact top-degree form has zero mass at : locally its integration measure has one-dimensional Lebesgue densities on finitely many calibrated skeletal cells. Thus On the other hand, has , with coefficient one by the original one-dimensional torus calibration. Consequently The zero functional and therefore have the same ordinary restriction and different values on actual delta-tests. Moreover whenever is a positive measure. This is positivity for the explicitly specified top-degree test cone. The function is not an actual piecewise smooth function, and is not induced by an actual delta-form.
Example (Separate closedness alone does not restore uniqueness). FALSE for closed unrestricted uniqueness. On the same annulus, define the dual derivative on all compact delta-functions by It is a top-degree functional and is separately closed, since its and derivatives have degrees exceeding the dimension. Equivalently, the dual differential identities give . Its ordinary restriction is zero because is a smooth top-degree form for original smooth .
Choose equal to one near zero and put . This is a compactly supported nonnegative actual piecewise smooth function. Its delta-curvature has coefficient one at , so . Therefore is nonzero despite its zero ordinary restriction.
This example does not preserve positivity. Indeed choose a nonnegative original smooth compact cutoff equal to one on , and . Then but It consequently does not disprove uniqueness of an extension that is required to be both separately closed and positive on all appropriate full Mihatsch delta-tests.
Proposition (The closed-cycle test subalgebra). DIRECT_COROLLARY. On the same original- annulus, let be the differential subalgebra of generated by original smooth forms and pullbacks of constant-weight tropical cycle forms. Then restricted to is nonzero, is positive for the Radon top-degree test cone, is separately closed as a functional on , and has zero ordinary restriction.
Proof. A constant-weight tropical cycle generator is separately closed. The derivatives of a product of such generators and a smooth coefficient differentiate only that coefficient. Thus and preserve its tropical codimension. A form of total degree or necessarily has codimension zero. Its derivative of degree still has codimension zero and therefore has a piecewise smooth Lebesgue density on one-dimensional skeletal cells, without an atom at . The functional kills these derivatives, proving separate closedness in this test algebra. It is nonzero because is the pullback of the constant cycle consisting of the origin in and belongs to . The remaining assertions were proved above. ◻
The last proposition is not a closed-positive nonuniqueness theorem for the full Mihatsch test algebra. In that larger algebra, the piecewise smooth function from the preceding example is an admissible test and detects the failure of closedness of . This is one concrete reason to state the test sheaf before comparing delta-currents. We have defined over the original ; we have not identified it with the full algebraic .
The conclusion for arbitrary backgrounds.
The ordinary coefficient-Radon data of a current alone do not specify its values on singular delta-tests. A proposed extension must include its test sheaf, continuity requirements, differential compatibility, positivity requirements, and an independence proof. The examples establish the failures precisely stated above. They do not rule out an additional canonical extension mechanism for separately closed positive currents, and they do not affect the actual delta-form comparison of Theorem “Comparison on an actual delta-form background”.
The ordered potential quotient and compactness
Functoriality of curvature order for actual bounded potentials
The zero-kernel transfer in R5 does not by itself transfer an order inequality. The additional points proved here are positivity of the piecewise traces, positivity on a carried polyhedral set, and positive finite-coefficient descent. These preserve the original middle CLD cone throughout. No pullback operation on arbitrary currents is defined.
Over an auxiliary complete field, a prescribed row means the fixed ordinary-neighborhood smooth positive decreasing row of R5, Definition 3.1. Only pullbacks of rows supplied over the original are used in the final theorem. The field-independent coefficient lemma and piecewise continuity in R5, Lemmas 2.1 and 3.2, remain applicable. All complete fields carry their given extending absolute values.
Lemma (Positivity on the polyhedral set carrying the mass). Let be a symmetric positive separately closed coefficient-Radon current over any complete field in the preceding scope. On a fixed compact original moment stage , suppose its coefficient measures are carried by a Borel set whose moment image lies in a finite polyhedral complex . Let be a smooth or compatible piecewise smooth complementary form. If its restriction to every face of is middle-positive in that face’s affine tangent space, then whenever the displayed test has the stated compact localization. The same conclusion holds after a nonnegative Borel restriction or scalar multiplier supported on this stage. No positivity of an ambient extension away from is required.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the coefficient matrix description and level-set tangency, with the carried-set scope made explicit.
Proof. Use the disjoint inverse images of the relative interiors of all faces of , restricted to . The arctangent proof of Lemma “Tangency of the mass on a smooth level set” uses only smooth differentiation and fixed Radon dominated convergence, so works over the present complete field. On the Borel part over a face , it annihilates every primed and double-primed conormal of its affine span. This remains true after Borel restriction. Thus only the tangential tensor of can contribute on this part.
For completeness, choose a constant basis of the appropriate exterior power of the tangent covectors of and extend it to the ambient moment space by one fixed linear projection. The coefficient measures of this Borel part, relative to one finite sum of diagonal control measures, give a symmetric positive semidefinite matrix almost everywhere. Indeed every constant rank-one square in the middle cone has a positive measure; rational coefficient vectors and continuity give positivity for all vectors. Nondecomposable squares are included. The tangent matrix of is positive semidefinite. The pairing density is in the usual signed identification of superforms. If the face dimension is smaller than the form degree, that tangent form is zero. Sum over the finite faces. Nonnegative multipliers preserve the matrix positivity, proving the final assertion. The definition of this cone and its restriction property are exactly [CLD12, 5.1.1(c), 5.1.5, 5.2.1 and 5.3.1]. ◻
Lemma (The finite and split projected tests preserve positivity). The piecewise trace of an original positive compact test under a finite etale map, as constructed in R5, Lemma 3.3, is tangentially middle-positive on each actual base tropical image. The same holds for the split-disc projected complementary tests of R4, Theorem 72.1. These statements retain every further original moment refinement.
Proof. Localize the original positive form by a nonnegative smooth partition, using positive presentations from [CLD12, Definition 5.3.1]. For a finite etale piece, the fixed trace formula is where the joint vectors are listed by the characteristic polynomials of finitely many monomials and are affine on a finite subdivision. Each vector over an actual base point is realized by a source point, with the full positive algebraic multiplicity. Refine the base cells by inverse images of the finitely many source faces in a positive presentation. On each resulting base face, the affine map maps its tangent space into the tangent space of an actual source face. Pullback preserves the middle-positive cone by [CLD12, Remark 5.1.5]; hence every summand and their sum are positive on that face. Matching on smaller faces preserves positivity there. The extension off the consistent moment locus in the trace construction is immaterial by Lemma “Positivity on the polyhedral set carrying the mass”. This argument also works after adjoining extra base moments; the same actual sheets and positive calibrated degrees are retained.
For the split disc, use the exact formula of R4, Theorem 72.1: After the finite chamber subdivision, these maps are affine and their values on actual base points and their assigned radial intervals are actual source Gauss-ray points. Restricting further by source faces makes the tangent maps land in their actual tangent spaces. The form is consequently middle-positive there. Its vertical top contraction is positive: on a positive semidefinite tensor it is the compression obtained by wedging a base exterior vector with the one vertical vector, on both sides of the corresponding quadratic form. Its sign is the positive product-calibration sign. Integrating this positive tensor against , summing the assigned rays once, and multiplying by the nonnegative localization all preserve positivity. Collapsed intervals contribute zero. Tangential matching on base faces, proved in the frozen formula, gives the same conclusion on their intersections. There are no additional wall currents in that formula. ◻
Proposition (Finite etale and original product order transfer). Let be actual locally bounded classical functions with prescribed rows over a complete characteristic-zero field . If , then for a finite etale map , Over the original , the same implication holds for projection from an ordinary polydisc product of any finite dimension.
Proof. Put and . In the finite etale case take a positive original compact test upstairs and let . Localize by a nonnegative base partition so that both prescribed rows exist on a common neighborhood of the projected support. The frozen finite trace is a finite compatible piecewise form, and is one fixed signed compact Radon measure. For the smooth rows , compact Stokes gives Piecewise continuity, applied separately to the positive closed currents and , and fixed-measure bounded convergence give the exact nonzero identity
The inequality follows from the preceding two lemmas. This does not assume that has positive curvature.
For an original- disc product, follow the finite rational localization of R4, Theorem 74.3, with nonnegative partitions. For one positive localized test , take the same fixed finite polynomial list, remove its base discriminant by the finite etale splitting map, and set , where vanishes near and increases pointwise to one off that fixed analytic divisor. These remain positive tests. Finite etale order transfer gives positivity of the pulled-back base curvature. For the split test upstairs, the same smooth-row calculation as in (eq:r6-finite-order-identity), now with the split projected test, gives a nonnegative pairing. The original finite-flat integration formula multiplies the downstairs pairing by the positive finite degree, so the downstairs pairing with is nonnegative too.
The signed current is the difference of the two positive ambient prescribed-row curvature currents. Every coefficient variation of these two currents vanishes on the removed analytic divisor, by the frozen first-order nonconcentration theorem (R5, Theorem 2.3, or its original- predecessor). Dominated convergence against these fixed coefficient measures gives No uniform differentiability bound on is needed. Iteration gives all finite-dimensional polydisc products, always over the original and with the pulled-back prescribed rows. ◻
Lemma (Positive finite-coefficient descent and positive fiber extraction). The following two refinements of the frozen test-spreading arguments hold.
In exact finite-coefficient descent from to , , a positive original test can be descended to a positive original test. The analogous exact descent from a completed algebraic closure to a finite extension has the same property.
Let be the full fiber over a parameter point, with its completed residue field. Suppose a symmetric positive separately closed current on the product is carried by this fiber and satisfies for all original compact complementary product tests, where is a coefficient-Radon current on the fiber. If exact spreading of its original fiber tests is available as in R5, Lemma 4.4, then is positive.
The second statement does not assert that a positive fiber form has a positive extension to the whole ambient product.
Proof. For (1), start with positive presentations from [CLD12, Definition 5.3.1] and use nonnegative scalar localizations. Perform the frozen rational-unit replacement on slightly larger compact norm boxes. It preserves the actual unit logarithms on each box, so preserves the positive tensor on its tropical image. Include all coefficients of the rational units and of the domains and cutoff profiles in the finite field. The resulting domain over is the scalar extension of the corresponding domain over . Scalar projection of an affinoid base change is surjective; their images under these common unit moments are therefore identical. The same real coefficient form is positive on exactly this common polyhedral image, which is the definition of original positivity. The descended localized tests are consequently positive.
For descent from a completed algebraic closure, approximate the finite coefficients by one finite algebraic extension, with errors strictly below all unit lower bounds and all positive profile thresholds. Closed upper and lower norm inequalities are unchanged under these ultrametric error bounds, and profiles near possible zeros are constant. Thus the same compact boxes and active norms are recovered exactly after scalar extension. The identical-image argument again proves positivity. This is stronger information than equality of the signed integrated forms, and follows from retaining the positive presentation itself.
For (2), take a positive compact fiber test and partition it into nonnegative localizations of positive moment presentations on compact fiber norm domains. Spread these particular presentations by the frozen exact construction: it retains all unit logarithms, norm-domain cutoffs, and zero-protected scalar profiles on the fiber. A local spread can be written , where is nonnegative, its restriction is the original localizing scalar, and is positive on the finite tropical image of the corresponding fiber domain.
The current is positive, and its coefficient mass on the fiber is supported inside that domain. Every level tangency of survives multiplication by and Borel restriction. Stratify this mass by the faces of , whether or not those faces occur in the original ambient tropical complex. Their affine conormals are original smooth affine combinations of the spread unit logarithms. Lemma “Positivity on the polyhedral set carrying the mass” therefore gives . Add the finite localizations and use the displayed restriction identity. The arbitrary positive fiber test has a nonnegative pairing with , as required. Only the tangential tensor on the mass-carrying fiber was required to be positive. ◻
Theorem (Order transfer through every complete scalar extension). Let on an allowed original- space and suppose on all original tests. Then for every complete , on every original -test.
Status: NEW_PROVED, using the positive trace and carried-fiber lemmas. The corresponding zero equality was already proved in R5.
Proof. Work locally in one original algebraic neighborhood with prescribed rows for . Put . Finite scalar extensions preserve positivity by Proposition “Finite etale and original product order transfer”; the same-space calibration factor is the positive number . Part (1) of Lemma “Positive finite-coefficient descent and positive fiber extraction”, and the factor-one fixed signed-measure scalar integration formula [CLD25, Proposition 15.3.1], then preserve positivity on passing from an auxiliary to its completed algebraic closure.
Here is the one-parameter step, specifying the new point where order differs from the zero-kernel argument. Suppose on and the same holds for its pullback to . Given a point of the parameter line, embed its residue field in a completed algebraic closure and then take there, as in R5, Proposition 4.6. The induced point has a residue field containing the original parameter residue field. Both assumed positive currents remain positive over .
For a nonrigid , R5, Proposition 4.3, gives the full-fiber potential : for types II and III it is , and for type IV it is the uniform limit of the corresponding nested-disc potentials. Each is locally uniformly approximable by original smooth positive functions: smooth the real convex maximum, and in type IV also use the proved uniform error . These are explicit functions, not an invocation of R over .
On the product let and put The equality is R5, Lemma 4.1, applied separately to the prescribed rows for and . Smooth positive approximation of and fixed coefficient-Radon multiplication show that is positive and separately closed. The second expression shows that it is carried by the full parameter fiber. Its exact restriction identity is by the full-fiber formula and its fixed Borel version. Part (2) of Lemma “Positive finite-coefficient descent and positive fiber extraction” now proves on every original fiber test. A rational parameter point requires no new extension. Finally, pull a positive test over the original parameter residue field to ; positive smooth pullback and factor-one scalar integration descend the inequality. This proves the one-parameter step without a positive ambient extension of an arbitrary fiber test.
Propagate these statements simultaneously with every finite number of affine-space factors. The initial assertions over are Proposition “Finite etale and original product order transfer”. If they hold over for all , the assertion with supplies the product hypothesis for the one-parameter step applied to the assertion with . Hence they hold over the residue field of every point of . Iterating through proves them over every finite parameter field. These fields have the countable dense subfields used in the frozen R5 construction; their algebraic closures and all the prescribed rows are exactly those in that construction.
For an arbitrary complete , descend any positive original compact test exactly to one such finite parameter field by part (1) of the preceding lemma. The fixed Borel scalar integration identity identifies its pairing with the already nonnegative pairing over that field. Nonnegative original partitions handle the initial algebraic neighborhoods. This proves the theorem on all original tests, without extending B’s regularization hypothesis to any new complete field. ◻
Theorem (Analytic functoriality of the represented order). Under the hypotheses of the preceding theorem, let be any complete extension and let be an analytic morphism from an allowed -analytic space. Then on every original compact complementary test of . This is an order statement for the specified actual bounded classical functions, not a pullback of an arbitrary positive current.
Proof. First observe that the normal trace in R5, Lemma 5.2, preserves order. If on , test it with for an original positive compact complementary on . The normal form is smooth positive of degree , hence strongly positive; its wedge with is positive. The frozen trace identity, applied to and separately, gives The trace uses actual Gauss radial limits of the two classical functions and the already checked normal coarea, including its full finite-field degree. It applies over any complete field and iterates in finitely many normal coordinates.
Use the precise geometry of R5, Theorem 5.3. Over the original , B’s ordinary algebraic localization and R’s tubular neighborhood embed the target in an affine space and extend constantly in normal polydisc directions. Proposition “Finite etale and original product order transfer” gives the order on this ordinary ambient neighborhood and on all its finite affine products. Theorem “Order transfer through every complete scalar extension” gives those same inequalities after extension to .
At a source point use the genuine ordinary finite etale coordinates of R5, Lemma 5.1. Their product with the ambient target is finite etale; Proposition “Finite etale and original product order transfer” transfers the inequality to that product. Translation by the analytic map makes its graph the zero section. Analytic isomorphisms preserve the original forms, calibration, and their positive cone. The frozen compact-tube argument supplies a whole normal polydisc tube around the zero section on a smaller ordinary source neighborhood. Apply the positive normal trace just proved in each coordinate. The restriction is exactly the actual difference . Zero-dimensional source or target cases are immediate. Locality proves the assertion globally on .
Every algebraic or tubular neighborhood used in this step is over the original . The new source over is handled by genuinely etale ordinary-open coordinates and normal trace. All new-field rows are the pullbacks of the original prescribed rows. ◻
Scope of the advance.
The represented current order is now functorial for actual bounded classical differences. A bounded Borel function with distributionally positive curvature is not covered by this result. Nor has an arbitrary positive current acquired a pullback, a potential, or an action on all higher-codimension delta-tests. The carried-fiber argument specifically avoids claiming that positivity of an arbitrary fiber test extends to a positive ambient test.
Continuity on a curve under a continuous Laplacian dominator
This section uses an order inequality of actual curve Laplacian measures. It does not pull back an ambient current inequality. That distinct operation is isolated in the order-transfer argument.
Lemma (Positive potential splitting). Let be a topological space, let be lower semicontinuous, and suppose is finite and continuous. Then and are finite and continuous. Consequently, for a nonnegative potential kernel , if positive measures satisfy , their kernel potentials are lower semicontinuous, and is finite continuous on , then is finite continuous there.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of semicontinuity and additivity of nonnegative integrals.
Proof. Finiteness follows from the nonnegative sum. Each is also upper semicontinuous, since it is the continuous sum minus the other lower semicontinuous function. For the potential assertion, use and Tonelli’s theorem. ◻
Proposition (Actual continuity under domination on a curve). Let be complete, algebraically closed, nontrivially valued and of characteristic zero, with its fixed absolute value. Let be a good Hausdorff boundaryless smooth -analytic curve. Suppose is a finite continuous subharmonic function and is an actual locally bounded subharmonic function on an ordinary open . If as Radon measures on , then and are continuous on , and is subharmonic there. The values at points of all four Berkovich types are their given actual values.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the curve potential kernel and distributional harmonic kernel, with the actual-value passage specified in the proof. This assertion is not a higher-dimensional distributional positivity converse.
Proof. Local algebraization, in the precise complete-field scope of R5, Lemma R5–6.1, places a neighborhood of the point under consideration in a smooth projective algebraic curve over . Choose a compact affinoid neighborhood of that point contained in , and choose a type-II point . Shrinking if necessary makes this possible. Set They are finite positive Radon measures and .
Use the potential kernel of [Wan22, Definition 4.4, Lemma 4.7 and Proposition 4.8]. For a finite positive measure supported in , write Its lower semicontinuity and its limits along paths to endpoints are the kernel-potential properties in [Wan22, Proposition 6.5]. Its distributional Laplacian is , as follows from the fixed-kernel Laplacian identity and integration against a compact lisse test. These facts concern the original absolute value. A positive constant change in the convention for logarithmic lengths changes both sides by the same factor and is not performed here.
For type-II or type-III , the function is finite continuous on the compact curve, so is finite. Thus defines a degree-zero curve distribution on with Laplacian zero. The distributional harmonic kernel theorem (Thuillier, Lemma 3.3.12, as explicitly used in [Wan22, Remarks 7.2 and 7.12] and in R5) gives a continuous harmonic function agreeing with on the type-II and type-III points of that interior.
This equality holds at the remaining actual points as well. If has type I or IV, choose an open-ball neighborhood inside and nested closed discs with boundary Gauss points on the segment toward . The subharmonic maximum principle and upper semicontinuity of give ; here continuity of would already suffice. The path-limit property of the positive kernel potential gives , including a possible infinite limit before the equality is used. Since is finite, we obtain The same equality was already known on the other two types. It follows that is finite continuous throughout .
Apply Lemma “Positive potential splitting” to . It shows that and are continuous on this interior. Similarly, has harmonic degree-zero distribution, so it agrees on type-II and type-III points with a continuous harmonic . At a type-I or type-IV point, the same nested-disc argument now uses the given subharmonicity of : Thus . Continuity of and gives at that point too. This proves continuity of the actual on .
Finally is continuous and its curve distribution has Laplacian . The continuous distributional criterion for curve subharmonicity gives that it is subharmonic; see [Wan22, Definition 3.11 and Remark 3.12]. The interiors of such cover , proving all assertions locally and hence on the entire open. ◻
How this enters the higher-dimensional argument.
For a classical and a continuous classical , a separately proved order-transfer statement would give on every smooth curve after every complete scalar extension. The proposition then makes and continuous and the latter subharmonic. This step uses actual curve functions. Ordinary continuity on the higher-dimensional space still requires the finite Shilov interpolation argument; it is not inferred from continuity along a dense collection of curves alone.
Positive curvature in the actual bounded classical difference class
The difference class in this section consists of actual functions, not arbitrary representatives of degree-zero currents. Its two positive parts belong to on the same ordinary neighborhood. This restriction is essential to the curve endpoint arguments and to the ambient semicontinuity proof.
Lemma (A positive difference of actual curve Laplacians). Let be algebraically closed, complete, nontrivially valued and of characteristic zero. Let be actual locally bounded subharmonic functions on an ordinary open in a smooth boundaryless analytic -curve. If , then the actual function is locally bounded subharmonic. Neither nor is assumed continuous.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the positive curve kernel, with actual endpoint values retained.
Proof. Use the local projective algebraization and compact affinoid of Proposition “Actual continuity under domination on a curve”. Choose its type-II kernel base point outside , and put , and . For any of these finite positive measures write . These are nonnegative lower semicontinuous potentials with the path-limit and Laplacian properties of [Wan22, Propositions 6.5–6.6]. They are finite at type-II and type-III points.
On the distributions and have Laplacian zero. The curve distributional kernel theorem gives continuous harmonic functions agreeing with them on those two types. At a type-I or type-IV point , use nested closed discs inside an open-ball neighborhood, with boundary points along its incoming path. The actual subharmonic maximum principle and upper semicontinuity give and separately. The kernel path limits then identify at as well, and show that both are finite there. No continuity of or has been used for this actual-value identification. The same identities already hold on types II and III.
Additivity of nonnegative integrals now yields , with all terms finite on the interior. Consequently is upper semicontinuous there. We verify harmonic comparison with these actual values, rather than use an unrestricted representative criterion. Put . Let be a connected strictly affinoid domain and let be harmonic on with on . For a type-II or type-III point , the compact nonnegative lisse Green function of [Wan19, Proposition 2.12] satisfies The boundary measure is nonnegative: the lisse Green function is nonnegative, vanishes on the boundary and outside , and its outward slope sum at a boundary point is therefore nonnegative. Its mass is one, as follows by taking . Evaluation of the positive distribution on this nonnegative lisse test gives At a type-I or type-IV interior point, the earlier nested-disc argument gives the actual path limits of and separately. Pass the last inequality along type-II/III points on that path, using continuity of , to obtain there as well. Thus satisfies the original affinoid harmonic comparison principle, so it is subharmonic. Local boundedness is inherited from the original difference. Cover by such interiors. ◻
Lemma (One-sided Shilov bounds without ambient semicontinuity). In the geometric setting of R5, Theorem R5–7.2, replace harmonic curve pullbacks by actual subharmonic curve pullbacks. Then an actual finite function satisfies No upper semicontinuity of on the ambient space is assumed. The same bound applies on each of the frozen semistable charts.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the one-sided argument in the frozen curve-slicing proof.
Proof. Use the finite flat map whose coordinates extend regularly to the algebraic ambient space. Fixing all but one coordinate and passing to its completed residue field gives the full affinoid curve fiber. Its algebraic normalization is a smooth curve defined across the whole compact fiber. Subharmonicity of the actual pullback and the curve maximum principle bound its value at every point by its maximum on that fiber’s finite Shilov boundary. The boundary is the preimage of the corresponding one-variable Gauss point, by the frozen finite flat Gauss-fiber lemma.
If is the maximum of on the finite nonempty fiber over , this proves for each coordinate Gauss operation . These operations commute and their composition is the full Gauss point. Iterating proves the displayed inequality. All maxima of finite fibers are actual finite numbers. The argument uses only one sign and no ambient semicontinuity. For a semistable chart, its regular topological generators give the required finite flat algebraic Noether coordinates by R5, Lemma R5–9.1. ◻
Theorem (Upper semicontinuity of a curvewise subharmonic difference). Let on an allowed original- space, and put as an actual function. Suppose every pullback of to a smooth analytic curve after every complete extension is an actual subharmonic function. Then is upper semicontinuous on . In particular .
Status: NEW_PROVED. The essential step is an upper semicontinuous majorant obtained from a proper finite-chart cover; no ambient regularity is assumed for the difference.
Proof. Fix and . Since is upper semicontinuous, choose an ordinary neighborhood of with for every . Use the frozen algebraic localization and norm-box construction to obtain with . Let and its finitely many compact semistable charts be the cover of R5, Proposition R5–9.3.
For each chart, use its nonnegative unit-logarithm coordinates , summing to one, to define the continuous pluriharmonic interpolants All functions are defined on genuine ordinary neighborhoods of the charts. The Shilov values of vanish, and this difference has actual subharmonic curve pullbacks. Lemma “One-sided Shilov bounds without ambient semicontinuity” therefore gives The ordinary classical maximum principle applied to gives . Since every lies in and the coefficients are nonnegative and sum to one, on the entire chart. In particular, for every chart point above ,
Take the disjoint union of these finitely many compact charts and let be its continuous surjection. The function which equals on each component is continuous. Define Every fiber is nonempty and compact. For any real , the set is the image under of the compact set on which this continuous componentwise function is at least ; it is closed in the Hausdorff space . Hence is upper semicontinuous. The preceding inequalities give on and . Since is in the ordinary interior, Let . This proves upper semicontinuity at . The difference is locally bounded. Once this ambient upper semicontinuity has been established, the smooth-curve testing reduction in [GR25, 4.1.3 and Definition 3.4] applies to the assumed complete-extension curve property and gives membership in the actual classical class. In particular it covers test curves with boundary or singularities by the compositions appearing in that definition. Zero-dimensional components are locally discrete and immediate. ◻
Theorem (Positivity determines the bounded classical difference cone). On an allowed original- ordinary open , let with . Then The same assertion holds for a locally represented difference, with possibly different decompositions on different ordinary neighborhoods. No assertion is made for an arbitrary locally bounded Borel function whose associated degree-zero distribution has positive curvature.
Status: NEW_PROVED, relative to the order-functoriality theorem and the preceding semicontinuity mechanism.
Proof. The reverse implication is the positive-current assertion already contained in B. Suppose . For every complete extension and every smooth analytic curve map, Theorem “Analytic functoriality of the represented order” gives positive original curvature for the actual pullback difference. Over an algebraically closed complete field, the frozen curve algebraization and B’s explicitly complete-field Lemma A.2, in the scope checked in R5, Lemma R5–6.1, identify this as as Radon measures. Indeed the inequality holds on all nonnegative original smooth scalar tests; their compact uniform density extends it to nonnegative continuous tests. Lemma “A positive difference of actual curve Laplacians” makes the actual difference subharmonic on the curve.
For a curve over a non-algebraically closed complete field, perform the argument after completed algebraic closure. Upper semicontinuity descends through scalar projection: on a compact affinoid neighborhood it is a continuous surjection from a compact space onto a Hausdorff space, and the upper level sets of the fiber-constant pullback are closed; their images give the upper level sets downstairs. Subharmonicity then descends by [GR25, Proposition 3.5(7)]. We have proved the actual subharmonicity assertion on every smooth complete-extension test curve. Theorem “Upper semicontinuity of a curvewise subharmonic difference” now supplies the missing ambient upper semicontinuity and then applies the full classical smooth-curve reduction. Local boundedness is already known. This proves the forward implication. Ordinary restriction and locality prove the locally represented version. ◻
Corollary (Order of represented curvatures transfers to every background). For any allowed fixed positive separately closed -background , with , and , All inequalities and equalities use every original complementary compact smooth test. The same order replacement is valid in any one differentiated slot of a mixed BT product, with its other slots fixed in .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY. Equality of the represented curvatures was already handled by the R5 quotient; the new conclusion preserves their order, including discontinuous actual potentials.
Proof. The difference is actual classical by the theorem. Its product is positive by the frozen arbitrary-background calculus, and equals by linearity of Borel multiplication and . For another differentiated slot, use symmetry and replace by the positive separately closed tail containing the other fixed potentials. No arbitrary-current wedge is introduced. ◻
Theorem (Continuous coefficient relations for bounded potential slots). Let be actual locally bounded classical potentials, and let be finite continuous real functions. Define the coefficient-Radon currents For every fixed allowed background , implies . In particular implies on all original tests. Finite continuous-coefficient presentations by curvatures of locally bounded classical differences therefore have a well-defined positive linear action over , independently of their presentation. The differentiated potentials need not be continuous. The scalar coefficients in this statement are continuous.
Status: NEW_PROVED extension of the continuous-potential module theorem to all actual bounded classical slots. The coefficient-bearing currents are not asserted separately closed merely because their individual curvature factors are closed.
Proof. Put . Fix . Near any point choose constants with . On this ordinary neighborhood, The actual function inside parentheses is a bounded classical difference, by separating its finitely many positive and negative real coefficients. Theorem “Positivity determines the bounded classical difference cone” therefore makes it classical, and its curvature over is positive. Thus . The coefficient error gives on this neighborhood. Cover the support of a positive original test by finitely many such neighborhoods and apply a nonnegative original smooth partition. Positivity is local, so the same inequality holds on that test globally. Let , using its fixed finite control mass against . This proves .
If , apply the implication both to the coefficients and to . The original middle positive cone of currents is pointed, so . To compare two signed-potential presentations, expand each classical difference into its positive classical parts, subtract the presentations, and use the proved zero relation. Addition and continuous scalar multiplication are then well defined; the positive-order assertion is exactly the first part of the theorem. ◻
Corollary (No a priori continuity is needed in a curvature order interval). Let and let be continuous classical. If for some , then and are continuous classical functions. Consequently all compactness, represented-quotient, actual-image and joint-continuity conclusions above for normalized continuous curvature order families remain true when their defining family initially allows all actual . This also applies to the family with for some in a fixed compact continuous upper-potential family .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new bounded-difference positivity criterion.
Proof. The actual difference has positive curvature, so it is classical and upper semicontinuous. Since is continuous, this says that is lower semicontinuous. It is already upper semicontinuous, hence continuous; the complement is then continuous as well. Thus the enlarged defining family is exactly the previously proved continuous family. In the compact- case apply this argument separately with the upper potential attached to each member. All prior conclusions apply without a new approximation step. ◻
Dependency and remaining limits.
The proof uses the order-transfer construction for the prescribed functions, the curve kernel and actual endpoint values, the frozen semistable geometric covers, and the one-sided Shilov bound. It does not infer ambient semicontinuity from curve continuity alone, nor invoke an unproved general distributional regularization theorem. The bounded-difference criterion does not supply a potential for an arbitrary positive closed current. The continuous-coefficient theorem has one curvature factor in each summand; it does not annihilate every higher-degree analytic delta relation or permit arbitrary Borel coefficient replacements.
An actual upper-semicontinuous spike is outside the DSH criterion
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of original smooth top-form atomlessness and the curve maximum principle. The proposed replacement of the actual bounded classical difference hypothesis by bounded upper semicontinuity is FALSE. This is the one-dimensional version of the already recorded R5 assigned-spike obstruction, not a new counterexample mechanism.
Fix a uniformizer of the original , and let The actual function is bounded, Borel and upper semicontinuous, since its nonzero level set is a closed singleton. Nevertheless while is not classical psh and is not continuous.
Proof. Every original compact smooth -form has an atomless signed integration measure. The finite-moment proof is the one given in Section “An atomic solution with no nonzero two-sided smooth direction”: positive smooth top-form controls push forward to calibrated one-dimensional smooth densities, which have no atom at a tropical point; positivity then gives no mass to its entire inverse image. Rank-zero presentations give the zero top form, and finite localization covers every test. Thus the total variation of every such test measure gives mass zero to . Integrating the bounded assigned function yields zero on every original test, proving both current equalities. This does not say that arbitrary positive currents have no atoms.
If were classical on , it would be subharmonic on this same original analytic curve. On the compact subannulus the two Shilov boundary points are different from and have value zero. The subharmonic maximum principle would give throughout , contradicting . The distinct Gauss points with also show directly that is not continuous at . ◻
In particular cannot be an actual difference of two locally bounded classical psh functions on any ordinary neighborhood of . Such a presentation would have equal original curvatures for its two terms. The proved R5 kernel theorem would make their actual difference pluriharmonic and continuous there, contrary to this spike. Equivalently, the R6 ordered-DSH criterion applied to both signs would give the same contradiction.
This check preserves the exact representative scope of Theorem “Positivity determines the bounded classical difference cone”. It does not disprove existence of a continuous classical representative of the zero distribution: the constant zero function is such a representative. The failure lies in prescribing the spike’s actual point value and then treating it as if it were already in the classical-difference domain of that theorem.
Products in the continuous coefficient curvature module
This section records a consequence of the represented-order theorem. The input currents have a prescribed local finite potential presentation. No product of completely arbitrary positive closed currents is defined.
Definition. On an allowed ordinary open , let be the -module of original coefficient-Radon -currents locally admitting a finite expression The expression is local; actual equality of currents is the equivalence relation. Signed bounded classical potentials can be used after expanding them into two classical parts. Its positive cone consists of those represented currents which are positive in the original middle CLD sense. Variable continuous coefficients need not preserve separate closedness.
Theorem (Positive products of continuously weighted curvatures). Let be any fixed allowed -background and . There is a well-defined symmetric -multilinear map characterized on finite local presentations by
It commutes with ordinary restriction and gluing. If every is positive, its image is positive. In particular the map is increasing in each slot when all the other slots are positive. When every slot is , it is the frozen bounded BT product.
No separate closedness of the output is asserted for general continuous coefficients. The map does not factor through every higher-degree ordinary-current relation merely from its construction.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new bounded-difference positivity criterion and continuous-coefficient relation theorem, with the positivity argument written out.
Proof. Each expression in (eq:r6-continuous-module-product) is a finite sum of continuous multiples of positive coefficient-Radon currents. Suppose the presentation of one slot is changed without changing its original current. Fix one multi-index in the remaining slots and put This is an allowed positive separately closed background. The zero-relation assertion of Theorem “Continuous coefficient relations for bounded potential slots”, applied to , makes the change in that slot zero. Multiplication by the remaining continuous coefficient product and finite summation preserve zero. Changing the slots one at a time proves presentation independence. Finite linearity, scalar multiplication, symmetry of the frozen BT tails, ordinary locality and gluing give the stated module and sheaf properties.
For positivity fix a positive original compact complementary test . Use finitely many local presentations near its support and nonnegative smooth localization; it suffices to treat one presentation. All its coefficients are bounded by a fixed number on a slightly larger compact neighborhood. For , subdivide the test support into finitely many ordinary neighborhoods on which for suitable constants . On one such neighborhood put It is an actual bounded classical difference, and Theorem “Positivity determines the bounded classical difference cone” therefore gives on that neighborhood. Hence there.
For every multi-index the scalar difference between its coefficient in (eq:r6-continuous-module-product) and its coefficient in has absolute value at most . This follows by telescoping the product of scalars, since each paired scalar differs by at most . Let be the finite sum of all the positive BT tails in (eq:r6-continuous-module-product), without coefficients. On this neighborhood the positive test cone therefore gives The same constant and the same work for every member of the finite subdivision. Apply a nonnegative original smooth partition to , sum the inequalities, and let . The fixed control mass is finite. The pairing of with is nonnegative. This proves positivity on all original tests in the specified cone.
For monotonicity subtract the two products and telescope their slots. Each term has one positive difference slot and all other slots positive, so the proved positivity applies. The BT specialization is its defining one-term presentation. ◻
Example (Borel coefficients do not preserve current relations). The word continuous in the preceding module cannot be replaced by bounded Borel, even when all potential functions are continuous. Take the ordinary bidannulus and let , , and . This is a continuous locally bounded classical psh function. The frozen first-order analytic-divisor nonconcentration theorem, applied to , gives as an ambient coefficient-Radon current. On the other hand, the restriction and projection formulas for the subvariety background, and the one-variable slope computation, give Here is the radius-one Gauss point in the annulus; the slope jump of is exactly one. An original nonnegative compact smooth scalar test equal to one near this point pairs with the displayed measure to give one. Thus the failure is visible on original tests, not only on an enlarged test sheaf.
Status: FALSE for the proposed Borel extension; the example is a DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen polar-carrier obstruction and first-order nonconcentration. It is not counted as a new counterexample mechanism. R5, Corollary R5–23.2 and Remark R5–22.4, already show why arbitrary assigned bounded upper semicontinuous values must also be excluded from the bounded-classical-difference positivity criterion.
What this construction does not settle.
Independence of the degree-one presentations means that relations in may be substituted inside (eq:r6-continuous-module-product). It does not say that every ordinary zero current formed from several curvature factors is such a relation. The higher-degree analytic delta kernel remains a separate problem. Nor is the output of a continuous coefficient product an admissible new background unless its required positivity and separate closedness are independently available.
Quantitative stability in the represented curvature order
The ordered quotient gives a quantitative convergence statement which is stronger than weak convergence but has correspondingly stronger, explicit hypotheses. The upper potentials here may be discontinuous. The background is fixed throughout.
Proposition (A mixed order bound). Let be any fixed allowed -background and . Let and let be finite constants such that, on all original ambient tests, Set Then
in the original positive cone. If , these are Radon measures and their signed difference satisfies on all Borel sets. In particular this controls total variation on every compact subset, without continuity of any .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new order-preserving quotient and the frozen mixed calculus.
Proof. Telescope the mixed difference, replacing the slots one at a time. The th signed term has differentiated potential , with all earlier slots chosen from the list and all later slots from the list. Their product with is a positive separately closed tail. Corollary “Order of represented curvatures transfers to every background”, applied to the two inequalities for , bounds this term above and below by times the same tail with slot . Replace each other slot in that positive tail by , using the same order corollary and mixed symmetry. Its bound is . Summation proves (eq:r6-mixed-order-difference). No division by is used, so vanishing constants cause no difficulty.
In top degree the inequalities say as signed Radon measures. Radon–Nikodym differentiation with respect to gives with almost everywhere, hence . This proves the Borel and total-variation assertions. ◻
Corollary (Weighted total-variation convergence). Let and let be sequences with common finite constants such that Put , and . Let be actual Borel functions which are uniformly bounded on every compact subset and satisfy -almost everywhere. Then for every compact . The weights need not be continuous or psh under these hypotheses.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY. This is not a consequence of bare weak convergence with arbitrary Borel weights.
Proof. Let , and put . The proposition gives and order replacement gives . Therefore, if bounds on , The first term tends to zero and the second tends to zero by fixed finite-measure dominated convergence. The sequence hypothesis is intentional: arbitrary pointwise convergent nets do not satisfy this version of dominated convergence. ◻
Scope.
The propositions concern finite locally represented curvature order intervals and their explicit order errors. They neither turn ordinary weak convergence into order convergence nor enlarge the continuous coefficient relation module to arbitrary Borel coefficients. The Borel weights in the last corollary are multiplied only after the relative measures and a common relative dominating measure have been fixed. No varying-background theorem is inferred from these estimates.
A qualified varying-background continuity theorem
The original fixed-background monotone theorem must not be replaced by an arbitrary varying-background assertion. Local uniform convergence to continuous potentials supplies a sufficient additional hypothesis. It also gives weak continuity of the new degree-one delta action on the full cone of allowed backgrounds.
Proposition (Continuous potentials and weakly varying backgrounds). On one common ordinary domain, let be a net of allowed positive separately closed currents of degree , converging on every original compact smooth test. Suppose that, for , the actual functions are continuous classical psh and locally uniformly. Then on all original compact smooth tests. If are finite continuous real functions with locally uniformly, the same assertion holds after multiplying the two sides by and respectively. Finite signed expansions of the continuous potential slots are allowed when their positive parts satisfy these same hypotheses.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of R’s fixed continuous multiplier lemma, coefficient control and the frozen BT recursion. No monotonicity is required under these stronger uniform and continuity hypotheses.
Proof. First record a multiplier fact. If are positive currents of one degree and locally uniformly with continuous, then for each original compact test , The second term converges by R. The first is bounded by on a fixed compact stage times finitely many positive control pairings of . Those controls are eventually bounded by weak convergence. This proves the fact for nets, without a global mass bound or a topology determined by countably many tests.
Use induction on . The positive separately closed tails with slots converge by induction. Apply the multiplier fact with and then the continuous distributional operator . The frozen recursion identifies the two derivatives with the stated mixed currents. The weighted assertion is one further application of the same multiplier fact to those positive currents. Finite signed expansions are handled term by term. ◻
Corollary (All-background weak continuity on a fixed degree-one delta-test). Let be as above and let be a fixed actual delta-form of total degree . Then the canonical ordinary currents converge on every original compact smooth test. If and has compact actual support, the full delta pairings converge. Thus, on the positive separately closed cone in remaining degree one, the ordinary weak topology already controls every fixed compact actual delta-test.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the proved degree-one relation theorem and continuous multiplier stability.
Proof. For the symmetric part use a fixed local Hessian presentation , with continuous PS coefficients and continuous PS classical-difference potentials. Expand each into its fixed continuous positive parts. The proposition, first with one constant potential row and then with the fixed continuous coefficient , proves convergence of each term on every original test. A finite partition covers a compact test support. The antisymmetric part is PS; the frozen piecewise-test convergence theorem applied to handles it on any original complementary test. Actual relation independence makes these local formulas the canonical action for all backgrounds in the statement.
For a compact complementary , the ordinary supports of all outputs are contained in the same actual compact support of . An original smooth cutoff equal to one near that compact converts the current convergence into convergence of their total integrals. Original smooth tests are themselves actual delta-tests, so the assertion about the two weak topologies follows in this degree. ◻
Excluded extension.
Neither assertion allows a simultaneously varying discontinuous Borel weight under mere weak background convergence. Likewise locally bounded psh rows converging only pointwise cannot be substituted for the local uniform continuous rows in the proposition. The frozen weak-current counterexamples and the main fixed- monotone hypothesis retain their force.
Compactness of continuous curvature order intervals
The order bound in this section is on the original ambient curvature. It holds on the whole domain on which the functions are normalized. No finite-dimensional assumption on these curvatures is made. Fix an allowed ordinary open , a continuous , and a real constant . Put
The inequalities between currents use every original positive complementary test. All scalar extensions below retain the given absolute value.
Lemma (The continuous curvature converse used here). Let be a finite continuous function on an allowed ordinary open. If is original CLD-positive, then is locally bounded classical psh. In particular, both and are continuous classical psh for every .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the authorized continuous regularization in R and the external smooth curve criterion. This is not a converse for discontinuous distributional potentials.
Proof. After B’s ordinary algebraic localization, R, Theorem 2.9, supplies on a fixed neighborhood smooth original functions with positive curvature forms and locally uniformly. An original smooth function with positive curvature form is classical psh: original smooth forms pull back along analytic maps and complete scalar extension, and positive forms remain positive. On a smooth curve the resulting smooth function is subharmonic by the smooth case of Wanner’s Theorem 4.7 [Wan19]. The passage to all analytic curves and all complete extensions is exactly the smooth-function argument recorded in [GR25, §1.2, p. 3; §4.1.3]. It concerns pullback of smooth forms, not pullback of an arbitrary current. Wanner’s auxiliary normalization of the logarithmic value group is harmless here: multiplying all logarithmic lengths by a positive constant preserves positivity and the subharmonic comparison inequality, and the absolute value in the present construction is never changed.
The continuous pointwise limit is classical psh by [GR25, Theorem 6.5]. This assertion can also be checked directly by passing a local uniform limit through the curve comparison inequalities. Thus no regularization theorem over a new complete field has been used. Continuity gives local boundedness. Apply this to for the last assertion. ◻
Lemma (Positive Shilov interpolation on the fixed charts). Let be an original algebraic norm box as in R5, Lemma 9.2, contained in an ordinary algebraic neighborhood. Use the compact surjective semistable cover and one of its finitely many affinoid charts from R5, Proposition 9.3. Write its Shilov boundary as and its logarithmic coordinates as Then and on . If is continuous classical psh on an ordinary neighborhood of , then For every and every such chart over ,
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen semistable charts and the affinoid maximum principle.
Proof. The regular functions are power bounded on their formal generic fiber, and . Hence the logarithmic coordinates are nonnegative and sum to one. R5, Lemma 8.2, identifies their values at the Shilov points as . Each is an analytic unit on a genuine ordinary algebraic neighborhood of the chart. Therefore is a real linear combination of logarithms of units and is pluriharmonic there.
The function is classical psh near the entire chart and vanishes at each of its Shilov points. The affinoid maximum principle [GR25, Theorem 6.4] proves the asserted inequality. Apply it first to and then to , which is classical by Lemma “The continuous curvature converse used here”. Linearity of gives the middle inequality in (eq:r6-shilov-order-error). Since is a convex combination of values of in , the final inequality follows. No arbitrary vertex interpolant is assumed harmonic: these are precisely the unit-logarithm interpolants on the frozen charts. ◻
Theorem (Finite evaluation and local uniform compactness). For each compact and each there is a finite set , depending on and the chosen geometric neighborhoods, such that
The family is compact in the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of . In particular, every net in this family has a subnet converging locally uniformly to an actual member of the same family.
The sets need not be independent of . Neither finite-dimensionality of the family nor convergence in total variation of its curvature measures is asserted.
Status: NEW_PROVED, using R’s continuous regularization, the external affinoid maximum principle, and the frozen R5 geometric construction. This label makes no claim about priority over other compactness theorems.
Proof. By continuity of , cover by finitely many ordinary neighborhoods on each of which . Use B’s ordinary local algebraization and R5, Lemma 9.2, to choose finitely many norm boxes within these neighborhoods whose ordinary interiors cover . Apply the frozen semistable cover to each . It gives finitely many charts and finitely many Shilov points on each chart. Define to be all their images in . These points and covers depend on and the accuracy, but not on or .
For , choose a box containing it and a preimage in one of its charts. The preceding lemma and the nonnegative coordinates give
This proves (eq:r6-curvature-order-finite-evaluation). In particular, a finite grid in gives finite uniform nets on : choose one actual family member for each occupied grid cell and apply the estimate to any two members in that cell. No interpolant has to descend through the alteration.
For full compactness, take any net in the family. Tychonoff compactness of gives a pointwise convergent subnet; write its actual limit as . Given a compact and a positive tolerance, choose so that is smaller than half the tolerance (when choose any ). The subnet is Cauchy on the finite set , so the displayed estimate makes it uniformly Cauchy on . Completeness of gives uniform convergence there, and that uniform limit is the already chosen pointwise function .
The space is locally compact Hausdorff and has compact neighborhoods, so these compact restrictions show that is continuous and that convergence is locally uniform. The inequalities persist. Every fixed original compact test pairs continuously with under local uniform convergence: apply the fixed signed top-form measure to . Consequently . Finally, is classical by [GR25, Theorem 6.5], or by Lemma “The continuous curvature converse used here”. Hence belongs to the same family. The net characterization of compactness now proves the assertion without a countability assumption on . ◻
Lemma (Uniform continuity of the fixed-background BT map). Fix an allowed positive separately closed background . Suppose are continuous classical psh, for , and locally uniformly. Then, on every original compact complementary smooth test, The assertion remains true after multiplication by continuous locally uniformly, with locally bounded .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the fixed-continuous-multiplier result in R and relative CLN.
Proof. Proceed by induction through the ordered recursion. If the positive tails converge to , relative CLN gives uniform coefficient variation bounds on each fixed compact test stage. Thus by local uniform convergence. R’s fixed continuous multiplication gives , so applying proves the next induction step. The same two-term decomposition with proves the weighted assertion. This proof works for nets, uses all original test forms, and never varies the initial background . ◻
Corollary (Actual representatives of weak limits on the same domain). Fix and, for each , continuous classical on the whole and constants . For every fixed allowed background , the set is compact and closed in the ordinary weak current topology. Every member of its weak closure therefore has a representation with actual normalized continuous classical potentials on the same , satisfying the same ambient curvature bounds. The corresponding diagonal image is also compact and closed.
For , the restricted diagonal raw capacity has no compact mass gain under weak closure. This conclusion concerns the displayed family; no common continuous curvature dominator for the unrestricted normalized family is asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Finite evaluation and local uniform compactness”.
Proof. The finite product of the potential families is compact, and the BT map is continuous by Lemma “Uniform continuity of the fixed-background BT map”. Its image is compact, and the weak current topology is Hausdorff because all original tests are retained. Thus the image is closed. Restrict the same argument to the diagonal when all slots use one family. A measure in that diagonal image is itself one of the normalized test measures defining the restricted raw capacity, which proves the final compact-mass assertion with constant one. This argument does not infer compact-mass continuity from weak convergence. ◻
Corollary (Ambient weak curvature stability within an order interval). For each , let and suppose that the ambient currents converge weakly on all original tests to . There are actual with , and for every fixed allowed background , The right side is independent of the chosen cluster potentials. No statement for varying backgrounds or for an undominated family is made.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY using the frozen R5 arbitrary-background potential quotient, Theorem 10.2.
Proof. Compactness gives a simultaneous locally uniform cluster tuple, and pairing with original tests identifies its curvatures with the . Every other cluster tuple has those same curvatures. The R5 quotient and differentiated-slot symmetry identify their mixed products over , slot by slot with a positive closed tail. Lemma “Uniform continuity of the fixed-background BT map” identifies every cluster of the mixed-current net with this same current. Since its image lies in a compact Hausdorff set, a unique cluster point implies convergence of the whole net. No convergence of a chosen pluriharmonic gauge is needed. ◻
Limits of the conclusion.
The local uniform compactness is a property of continuous actual potentials under a fixed continuous ambient order bound. It does not follow from a relative energy bound alone. In particular the sine example in Section “Sharp regularity under continuous ambient-curvature domination” is compatible with this theorem: its potentials converge uniformly, while the curvature measures fail to converge in total variation. If the order bound is known only on a smaller , the argument gives compactness on compact subsets of ; it does not produce a normalized representative on all of .
The weak topology on represented curvature order intervals
This section states the topological consequence on ambient curvature currents themselves. Its compactness input concerns actual normalized continuous potentials on one common ordinary domain. It is not a compactness assertion for the unrestricted bounded psh class.
For continuous classical on and , define where is defined in (eq:r6-curvature-order-family). Give the subspace topology of ordinary weak current convergence on every original test. Write for the cone of allowed symmetric original-positive separately closed currents, with the same weak topology.
Proposition (The curvature quotient has its ordinary weak topology). The set is compact, convex, and Hausdorff. The map is a closed quotient map. Its fibers are exactly the equivalence classes obtained by allowing pluriharmonic differences while retaining membership in the normalized potential family.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the compactness theorem and the frozen R5 actual potential quotient.
Proof. The potential family is compact by Theorem “Finite evaluation and local uniform compactness”. Its map to currents is continuous, since a fixed original pairing with is an integral of against a fixed signed top-form measure. The target weak current space is Hausdorff. A continuous surjection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is closed and is a quotient map. Both the potential family and its curvature image are convex, by the defining linear order inequalities. R5, Theorems 10.1–10.2, identify equality of the actual bounded-classical curvatures with a continuous pluriharmonic difference. This identifies the fibers without selecting a gauge or asserting the existence of a continuous section. ◻
Theorem (Joint weak continuity in background and ambient curvatures). Fix . For each , fix a continuous classical on the whole and , and put . There is a well-defined continuous map
All topologies in this display are the ordinary weak topologies on all original compact smooth tests. In particular, for nets and in these specified spaces, For each fixed actual delta-form of total degree , with , the same map followed by the canonical operation is continuous on original tests. If , this includes convergence against every fixed compact complementary actual delta-test.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Finite evaluation and local uniform compactness”, Proposition “Continuous potentials and weakly varying backgrounds”, and the frozen arbitrary-background potential quotient. The hypotheses on the represented order intervals are essential to the deduction.
Proof. Choose representatives in the normalized continuous potential families. The R5 quotient, with positive separately closed mixed tails, shows that replacing any representative by another with the same ambient curvature leaves the product unchanged. This proves that (eq:r6-curvature-interval-joint-map) is well defined.
To check continuity, consider a convergent net of input tuples and choose arbitrary normalized representatives for its curvature slots. Every subnet of the resulting tuple of representatives has a further subnet converging locally uniformly, simultaneously in its finitely many slots, by compactness of their finite product. Let be such a limit. Its ambient curvatures are the specified limits , by local uniform convergence on original tests. The backgrounds still converge to along this further subnet. Proposition “Continuous potentials and weakly varying backgrounds” gives The right side is the value prescribed in (eq:r6-curvature-interval-joint-map), independently of this choice of cluster representatives. Thus every subnet admits a further subnet converging to the same output. This is precisely convergence of the original output net: if an output neighborhood failed to contain a tail, one could take a subnet lying in its complement and obtain a contradiction. This proves joint continuity without metrizability, a gauge, or a continuous choice of representatives.
The outputs are positive separately closed currents. Corollary “All-background weak continuity on a fixed degree-one delta-test” therefore applies to them and proves the final assertion. Its actual delta-test is fixed; no convergence of varying delta-test presentations is asserted. ◻
Weights are not curvature classes.
The theorem concerns differentiated slots. A weight cannot be passed to the same quotient: the constants and have the same ambient curvature, while their products with any nonzero background are different. If continuous actual weights converge locally uniformly, the weighted conclusion follows instead from Proposition “Continuous potentials and weakly varying backgrounds”. Likewise, the theorem does not concern arbitrary weakly convergent curvature currents outside the displayed compact represented intervals, nor does it assert total variation convergence.
Compact families of continuous upper potentials
A curvature upper bound supplied by one continuous potential is a useful sufficient condition, but it can be replaced by compactness of the upper potentials themselves. All families and normalizations in this section live on one common ordinary domain .
Let be a nonempty compact subset of for the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets. Define
The curvatures are already nonnegative by membership in the classical class. No convexity of or of the displayed unions is assumed.
Proposition (Compactness with varying upper potentials). The family is compact in local uniform topology. Its curvature image is compact Hausdorff in the ordinary weak topology, and the curvature map is a closed quotient map with the frozen pluriharmonic fibers. For every compact and , there is a finite set such that
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of positive Shilov interpolation, with a larger compactness scope than one fixed curvature dominator.
Proof. First, compactness of gives uniform small oscillation near each point. Choose a compact neighborhood of a given point . The restrictions of to form a compact subset of , so choose finitely many functions giving a uniform net. Continuity of these finitely many functions gives an ordinary neighborhood of inside on which all their oscillations are less than . Every then has oscillation less than on that neighborhood.
Cover by finitely many such neighborhoods and choose the frozen norm boxes and finite semistable Shilov covers inside them. For any choose an upper potential . Both and are continuous classical by Lemma “The continuous curvature converse used here”, so positive Shilov interpolation gives on each of the fixed charts The covers and their finite set of Shilov image points depend only on , not on either chosen potential. Subtract the inequalities for and use the positive barycentric coordinates. This proves the finite-evaluation estimate.
For a net choose an associated . Compactness of gives a simultaneous subnet with pointwise and locally uniform . The finite-evaluation estimate makes the same subnet uniformly Cauchy on each compact set, hence locally uniformly convergent to . The actual limit is continuous classical, lies between zero and one, and satisfies by original smooth testing. Thus it belongs to the displayed family. This proves compactness without a countable exhaustion. The quotient and fiber assertions follow exactly as in Proposition “The curvature quotient has its ordinary weak topology” from the continuous curvature map, Hausdorff target, and frozen R5 quotient. ◻
Corollary (Joint stability and actual weak-image closure). For finitely many compact upper-potential families , the operation is well defined and jointly continuous for ordinary weak convergence of the positive separately closed background and all ambient curvature slots. For fixed its image is compact and closed, with actual normalized representatives on the whole . The same is true for the diagonal image of one such family. Consequently, in top degree this diagonal family has sharp compact no-gain under weak closure. These conclusions do not assert general Borel outer regularity, setwise convergence, or a common measure dominator.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY.
Proof. For every subnet of representatives choose a further subnet converging locally uniformly in the compact finite product of their potential families. The qualified varying-background theorem identifies its mixed-current limit, and the frozen quotient makes the answer independent of the cluster representatives. The every-subnet argument of Theorem “Joint weak continuity in background and ambient curvatures” proves convergence of the whole net. For fixed the image of the compact family is compact in the Hausdorff current space, hence closed. In top degree a weak-limit diagonal measure is itself one of the actual normalized testers on , so its mass on any compact set is bounded by the raw capacity. This uses actual representatives, not an invalid compact-set Portmanteau inequality in the opposite direction. ◻
Example (Compact upper potentials without a common measure upper bound). On the original annulus with , put These are continuous classical functions, lie in , and depend uniformly continuously on . Their family is compact even in the uniform norm, and with the original logarithmic calibration. Thus they are included in the preceding compactness statement by choosing each potential as its own upper potential.
There is no single locally finite positive Radon measure on this annulus for which every is at most with a finite constant . Otherwise would have a positive atom at every one of the uncountably many displayed Gauss points in a fixed compact subannulus. A finite measure has only countably many positive atoms: for each integer only finitely many can have mass at least . In particular no single continuous psh potential has curvature dominating this whole family, even with member-dependent finite multipliers.
Also, if with , then uniformly and their measures converge weakly, whereas So the compact upper-potential theorem cannot be upgraded to setwise convergence. It genuinely differs from the common-Radon-dominator mechanism in Section “Sharp regularity under continuous ambient-curvature domination”.
Status of the example: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the original annular hinge calibration and elementary measure countability. It limits this new sufficient criterion; it does not supply a counterexample to general compact C1.
Compact continuous dominators do not give Borel outer regularity
This example concerns the full normalized family with a curvature dominated by one member of a specified compact continuous family. It does not replace that family by just the displayed extremizers. It realizes the frozen abstract vertical-fiber obstruction on an actual smooth Berkovich torus, with its original tests and calibration.
Theorem (A restricted capacity with different Borel and outer values). Work over the original , with its original absolute value. Put Let The family is compact in and consists of continuous classical psh functions with . For the entire family define There is an subset of a fixed compact subset of such that Thus Borel outer regularity fails for this restricted capacity even though the whole potential family is compact in the local uniform topology and its represented measure image is weakly compact.
Status: NEW_PROVED realization in the actual normalized curvature-order family, using the frozen abstract vertical-fiber example. No new general abstract capacity counterexample or failure of unrestricted BT capacity is claimed.
Proof. The background is an original smooth, symmetric, positive, separately closed -current. The affine unit moment is pluriharmonic after every complete extension, so its maximum with zero is classical psh. Since and , one has . Also The parameter space is compact, hence is compact even for the global uniform norm. By Proposition “Compactness with varying upper potentials” and Corollary “No a priori continuity is needed in a curvature order interval”, the full displayed family is compact in ; it is not necessary to assume continuity in its definition.
Let be the original two-variable Gauss section, with radii . Original torus calibration gives the equality of Radon measures
The slope jump of is , and the factor in cancels it. There is no change of the field or its absolute value. This is an identity on every original smooth compact scalar test: on a common moment refinement, torus top integration is supported on the original Gauss section and has degree one. Equivalently, smooth convex approximations of the one-variable hinge give the same product-calibrated measure in the limit. The identity is therefore not a prescription of pairings only against functions which factor through the two radius coordinates.
If , choose its parameter . The arbitrary-background order theorem gives Conversely for every . It follows for every Borel that
This equality establishes the upper bound for all normalized competitors, not only for the hinges. Local uniform BT continuity also shows that the full represented measure image is weakly compact.
In the real radius box set The Gauss map is a topological embedding, and is compact in . Every half-open vertical segment in this formula is a countable union of compact segments. Thus is in the actual Berkovich space. Each assigns it mass , so (eq:r6-full-family-vertical-capacity) gives .
Let be any ordinary open set containing . The inverse image is an ordinary real open set containing . Compactness of gives a such that For every sufficiently large , this includes the lower half of the vertical segment at , while its upper half already belongs to . Hence and . The full-family identity proves for every such ordinary open .
For the opposite bound, take and the ordinary open set It contains , and every gives it mass . Thus by the same identity. Taking the infimum and then proves . ◻
Corollary (The restricted outer capacity fails continuity from below). There are increasing compact sets in the preceding example such that
Proof. For let These are compact, increase, and have union . Their raw capacity is by (eq:r6-full-family-vertical-capacity). To see the outer value directly, separate the finitely many parameters by pairwise disjoint small real open intervals, each containing no other point of . Around use one disjoint interval containing only and a tail of . Take their products with slightly enlarged versions of the respective vertical segments, and pull back the resulting real open union by . For any the enlargements can be chosen so that every gives this ordinary open neighborhood of mass at most . The outer value is consequently at most , and the reverse inequality follows from monotonicity. The theorem supplies the strict increase at the union. ◻
What the example excludes.
Compactness of an actual normalized potential family, compactness of its weak measure image, and sharp compact-set outer regularity do not imply Borel outer regularity for its upper-envelope capacity. This example does not contradict the fixed-Radon domination theorem: the measures charge distinct vertical fibers, and no locally finite Radon measure can dominate all of them with one fixed density bound on this compact rectangle. Nor is this a counterexample for the unrestricted capacity formed from every normalized classical psh function on . Additional unrestricted competitors may change both displayed capacity values; no value for that larger capacity is asserted here.
The restricted outer-regularity failure in every positive relative degree
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “A restricted capacity with different Borel and outer values”, mixed order replacement, and original product calibration. This is a dimensional propagation of the same restricted-family obstruction.
Proposition. For every pair there is an allowed smooth background of bidegree on a smooth -dimensional original- torus domain, and a compact continuous normalized upper-potential family, whose restricted relative degree- capacity satisfies on one set contained in a fixed compact subset. The family defining includes every normalized actual classical potential whose ambient curvature is bounded by a member of the specified upper family.
Proof. Use coordinates and put , . Let Take An empty hinge sum for is zero. The background is smooth, symmetric, strongly positive and separately closed. Every is continuous classical psh, , and Thus is a compact normalized continuous family on this same whole domain.
Let be the original -variable Gauss section. The exact ordinary top measure is
To check the coefficient, each one-variable hinge curvature has calibration one and squares to zero. In the th power of their sum, only terms using all distinct coordinate curvatures survive; there are such terms. The remaining scalar is Wedging with the smooth passive-coordinate top factors gives their product Lebesgue measure. This verifies the entire product calibration, rather than multiplying or independent field degrees. As in the two-dimensional case, smooth convex approximants of each hinge and the original torus top-form measure identify (eq:r6-all-degree-vertical-measure) on all original compact scalar tests, including further moment refinements.
Define the whole competitor family by For a competitor with parameter , replace the differentiated slots one at a time using Corollary “Order of represented curvatures transfers to every background”. Each remaining mixed tail is a fixed positive separately closed background, so this yields Each is itself a competitor. Consequently the restricted capacity is exactly for every Borel , with no restriction to just the displayed hinge testers.
Write , interpreted as a point if , and set It is and lies in the compact Gauss image of . Every assigns mass , proving the raw value.
For any ordinary open , its inverse image under contains the compact lower plate . A uniform small displacement in the -direction stays in this real open set. Therefore, for all sufficiently large , it contains the lower plate over . The upper plate there already belongs to . The entire passive cube at this parameter is contained in , so and . Conversely the ordinary open sets contain and have -mass for every . Let to obtain . This proves the assertion for all , including the requested , case. ◻
The ambient background in this construction is smooth and belongs to the full delta approximation class. The failure is caused by the restricted normalized family, not by a lack of delta tests or by singularity of the background. It neither disproves compact-set outer regularity for that compact represented family nor determines the unrestricted relative Bedford–Taylor capacity of the same set.
A local finite-point normalization of the potential quotient
A differentiated potential quotient does not itself determine a multiplier. On the compact represented families constructed above, one can nevertheless make an explicit local choice of representatives. The choice depends on a fixed affinoid and finitely many normalization points; it is not a canonical global gauge for all psh functions.
Fix a compact affinoid norm box with nonempty ordinary interior, and let be its finite Shilov boundary. Let be the vector space of restrictions to of continuous pluriharmonic functions defined on some ordinary neighborhood of inside . The neighborhood may depend on the function. Finite sums are defined on intersections of these neighborhoods, so this is a vector space of actual continuous functions on .
Lemma (Finite Shilov normalization). The space has dimension . There are points , a basis of represented by pluriharmonic functions on one fixed ordinary neighborhood of , and a bounded linear projection The projection is the identity on . Its construction uses actual values at the displayed points.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the classical Shilov maximum principle and finite-dimensional linear algebra.
Proof. Apply the affinoid maximum principle to both signs of any representing pluriharmonic function, as in [GR25, Theorem 6.4]. Its restriction to is determined by its values on : zero values there force the function to vanish on all of . Evaluation therefore embeds in , proving the dimension bound. Choose a basis, intersect its finitely many defining ordinary neighborhoods, and call the intersection .
The evaluation matrix of this basis on has rank . Choose rows with invertible matrix and set This is a bounded linear map in the uniform norm, interpolates the selected values, and reproduces every member of . In the vacuous zero-dimensional vector-space case use the zero map. ◻
Theorem (Continuous local representatives from weak curvature data). Let be any compact family in for local uniform topology, with for all its members. Fix as above, shrinking inside if necessary, and give the ordinary weak topology on every original compact test in . For put
This is independent of the chosen , and defines a continuous map . Its values are actual continuous classical potentials on , with Here the curvature equality refers to the unique restriction to the ordinary interior. Each representative is also defined classically on a neighborhood of , although no common choice outside is part of the section. In particular, weak convergence within implies uniform convergence of these specified representatives on .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen actual potential quotient and compactness, with the local normalization explicitly constructed.
Proof. If , the frozen R5 quotient makes a continuous pluriharmonic function on . Its restriction belongs to , and hence on . Subtracting proves independence in (eq:r6-local-potential-section).
The curvature map from onto is continuous, as seen on each original compact test. Its domain is compact and its target is Hausdorff, so it is a closed quotient map. The map is continuous into and constant on its fibers. The defining property of a quotient topology therefore gives continuity of . This argument uses no metrizability or choice of convergent lifts.
For any lift , subtract the fixed finite linear combination of the pluriharmonic basis functions on . This produces an actual continuous classical potential near , has unchanged curvature, and restricts to . Reproduction and the interpolation identities give the normalizations; the operator norm gives the uniform bound. Different lifts give the same actual function on , hence the same potential on its ordinary interior. Nothing is asserted about their values outside . ◻
Corollary (Weighted stability after the specified local normalization). For , let be nets in the restricted curvature images of compact normalized families as in the theorem, and put , . Let be arbitrary allowed positive separately closed backgrounds on . Then on all original compact complementary smooth tests in that interior. The same conclusion holds against a fixed actual degree-one delta-test when it is complementary to the displayed mixed currents.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY.
Proof. All displayed potentials converge uniformly on by the theorem. Their restrictions are continuous classical on its interior. Proposition “Continuous potentials and weakly varying backgrounds” proves the original-test assertion. For the degree-one delta assertion, insert its fixed continuous-coefficient Hessian presentation, expand its fixed continuous classical-difference slots, and use the same proposition term by term with the locally uniformly convergent continuous weight. For its PS part the fixed PWS test approximation has the uniform normal coefficient bound, and multiplication by the uniformly bounded weights preserves that bound. A compact cutoff converts each top-degree current convergence into the desired pairing. ◻
Scope of the normalization.
This section does not identify arbitrary actual multipliers with their curvatures. For example and have equal curvature but are distinct multipliers; the specified normalization sends both to zero. Its weighted conclusion applies only after this explicit local choice. The compact families of Theorem “Finite evaluation and local uniform compactness” and Proposition “Compactness with varying upper potentials” are concrete inputs. There is no continuous-section claim for the unrestricted weak space of bounded classical curvatures, and no global compatibility of different choices of , normalization points, or projections is asserted.
Sharp relative capacity estimates
A sharp Hardy estimate for every normalized relative tester
Fix an arbitrary original-positive symmetric separately closed -current on an allowed ordinary open . For original real compact smooth write The first estimate below needs only the frozen bounded BT calculus and its local coefficient-Radon energy measures. The faithful closed form is used subsequently for the capacity and Dirichlet consequences.
Lemma (Polynomially weighted local energy limits). On a fixed local compact regularization stage let be finitely many bounded classical psh rows. Let be real polynomials in these functions and in finitely many fixed smooth local classical differences. Put , and similarly for . Then on original compact smooth scalar tests. All functions and measures use their actual representatives.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the weighted one-slot theorem and the definition of .
Proof. After shifting the finitely many psh functions by constants on the compact stage, they are nonnegative. Every polynomial in them is a finite real linear combination of powers of their positive sums, by the ordinary polarization formula for monomials. Each such power is classical psh and decreases along the given rows. Fixed smooth local classical differences have the same description after choosing their finite psh decompositions; these functions are constant rows. Thus every polynomial belongs to the local bounded classical-difference algebra. Expand Every term is a finite linear combination of weighted one-slot products of decreasing bounded psh rows. The frozen weighted theorem passes each term. The limiting identity is the Borel multiplier of the coefficient-Radon measure defining . ◻
Theorem (Sharp normalized-tester Hardy inequality). Let satisfy everywhere. For every original real and every ,
Consequently
The coefficient one in (eq:r6-sharp-hardy) cannot be decreased uniformly over all allowed domains and backgrounds.
Status: NEW_PROVED for the sharp uniform estimate. It strengthens the earlier square-root estimate; that weaker estimate is not used in its proof.
Proof. First suppose is smooth near the support of . Put . The positive covector square gives Compact Green and therefore yield
For bounded possibly discontinuous , a global smooth row near the entire support is not assumed. Choose finitely many nonnegative original smooth functions , supported in local compact regularization stages, with on a neighborhood of . On the stage for , choose a decreasing original smooth classical row . After discarding a prefix, on a fixed neighborhood of the relevant compact support. Indeed the increasing open sublevel sets below cover that compact set. Set The form a bounded decreasing classical psh row on that fixed neighborhood: the scalar reciprocal function of is convex and increasing on its range. The limit is .
Multiply the smooth positive-square inequality by before integrating. The localized Green identity is The first term passes by weighted one-slot continuity for the two rows . The second passes by Lemma “Polynomially weighted local energy limits”, treating as an additional psh row. Fixed original smooth and are local classical differences by the frozen smooth compensator construction. Consequently Sum these finitely many inequalities. Their cross terms cancel exactly: by bilinearity and ordinary locality, near the support of . Also is supported there. This proves (eq:r6-relative-picone) without a partition error or a global regularization assumption. Since , it gives . Let to obtain (eq:r6-sharp-hardy).
For sharpness let , take the original annulus , put , and set , . Then Choose smooth compact functions on converging to in the usual norm and with values at zero tending to one; smoothing slightly truncated tents gives such a sequence. The numerator in (eq:r6-sharp-hardy) tends to , as does the energy. All functions used as tests are original smooth functions of the unit moment. Thus a universal smaller coefficient is impossible. ◻
Corollary (Weak limits and the energy-capacity bound). Assume the faithful form exists on as in R4. Every positive weak limit of normalized measures on all original tests satisfies (eq:r6-sharp-hardy). This includes the normalized completed image defined by global normalized classical rows. Moreover, for every subset ,
For original smooth compact and there is the sharper direct level-set bound
These are one-way bounds. Neither the reverse capacity inequality nor the general raw-versus-completed compact equality is asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the sharp estimate and the already verified regular-form compact-core capacity formula.
Proof. For weak limits, is one fixed original compact smooth scalar test, so its inequality passes directly, also for nets. For a compact and original smooth core on , every normalized tester satisfies The verified compact-core formula gives , with the same bound for all testers. For a relative ordinary open , inner regularity of each fixed Radon measure therefore gives . Choose an ordinary open with . All these measures are supported on . If contains , then contains , and taking the supremum over testers bounds its raw BT capacity by the energy capacity of . The two outer infima give (eq:r6-linear-energy-capacity). Only a uniform compact estimate was used before Radon inner regularity; no infimum/supremum exchange has been made.
Finally, Chebyshev and (eq:r6-sharp-hardy) give for every normalized tester. The level set is an ordinary open, so its raw capacity equals its outer capacity by definition. Taking the supremum proves (eq:r6-sharp-capacity-chebyshev). ◻
Corollary (Linear capacity domination is enough for finite energy). Let be a positive Radon measure supported on a compact subset of , with mass , and suppose for every Borel subset of that support. Then It has the unique energy solution of Theorem “Finite-energy measure Dirichlet problem”. More generally, if with , then No boundedness or ambient psh property of that solution follows from these assertions alone.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY by layer cake.
Proof. For a core function of energy , the preceding level-set bound gives Split the integral of this tail at . Since , its two pieces sum to the stated constant times . The case gives . A zero-energy core function has zero integral by the same level-set bound. Taking the core supremum completes the proof. ◻
Frozen higher-degree tails.
For an arbitrary allowed -background and , fix bounded classical potentials and put . The theorem applies verbatim to this fixed degree-one background. Its capacity is and its energy is . No single quadratic form is thereby asserted to control the nonlinear diagonal family when all slots vary.
A sharp strong-capacity inequality and energy traces
Retain the arbitrary fixed degree-one background and the notation of Section “A sharp Hardy estimate for every normalized relative tester”. Capacities below use normalized actual classical testers on the entire fixed . All smooth functions and tests are original CLD objects.
Theorem (Strong capacitary inequality with optimal constant). For every real original ,
The level sets are ordinary open, so the same formula holds with outer capacity. If a positive Radon measure satisfies
for every Borel , then
Both universal constants four are optimal, already on one original analytic annulus with .
Status: NEW_PROVED for the sharp capacitary and trace estimates. The proof uses only the preceding Hardy theorem and explicit scalar truncations; no raw-capacity outer regularity is assumed.
Proof. Fix and put . To apply the smooth-core Hardy inequality, choose smooth functions on the real line such that , , for , and for . They may be obtained by integrating a smooth transition from derivative one below to zero above , chosen symmetrically so the final constant is one. For the functions are exactly near zero and satisfy for .
Then is an original smooth compact function. For each fixed normalized tester , Hardy and the ordinary chain rule give On the fixed compact support both measures are finite. Bounded convergence on the left and dominated upper limits on the right yield The inclusion of the equality level makes this argument independent of any assertion about energy mass on a level set. The right side is independent of , so the same bound holds for the raw capacity.
Multiply by and integrate. Tonelli’s theorem for the nonnegative measure gives At , the inner-integrand contribution is interpreted before integration as identically zero; no expression is used. The capacity of these level sets equals their outer capacity because they are ordinary open. Finally layer cake and (eq:r6-linear-capacity-domination) imply which proves (eq:r6-capacity-energy-trace). ◻
Example (Sharpness on an original annulus). Put and take Let be the Gauss point of radius . For define the finite compactly supported measure It satisfies for every Borel .
Indeed, if is nonempty, put . Then For each the globally normalized classical hinge has original curvature . Thus the capacity is at least . If is empty the assertion is immediate. No formula for the capacity of a general set is being assumed.
Choose fixed smooth scalar cutoffs with on , on , on , and on . Set These are original smooth compact tests. Direct integration gives For the energy, the derivative on is . Its two cutoff collars have uniformly bounded energy: the lower collar has length and derivative , and the upper collar is fixed. The mass calculation has the same bounded collar errors. Hence the trace ratio tends to four. Since each is dominated by the raw capacity with coefficient one, its layer-cake integral also gives a lower bound for the left side of (eq:r6-strong-capacity-four). Both constants are therefore optimal. The field and all tests remain the original ones, including Gauss points of non-strict radii.
Corollary (Canonical energy traces). Assume the faithful form exists and satisfies (eq:r6-linear-capacity-domination). The original smooth restriction map extends uniquely to a bounded linear map It is represented by the canonical relative capacitary representative of , -almost everywhere. The same assertion holds on every part space .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the trace bound and the frozen canonical energy representative.
Proof. The estimate makes any energy-Cauchy core sequence Cauchy in , proving existence, independence and the norm bound. On a fixed compact stage, the same core sequence converges locally in outer relative capacity to the canonical representative by R4. For each Borel gap, its -mass is at most times its raw capacity and hence at most times its outer capacity. Thus it converges in -measure on every compact stage. Its limit must be that representative almost everywhere. This argument selects the canonical representative; it does not identify arbitrary modifications on -null sets. ◻
Corollary (A controlled negative measure perturbation). Fix , put , and let be carried by and satisfy (eq:r6-linear-capacity-domination). For with , the bilinear form is continuous and coercive on , with For every bounded energy functional there is a unique with for all , and If for a finite-energy Radon datum, this is the original-current equation The boundary condition is the stated energy part space. No ambient psh, nonlinear Monge–Ampere, or Markov property of the perturbed form is claimed.
Proof. Cauchy–Schwarz in and the preceding bound give . The displayed lower bound follows. Thus is an equivalent Hilbert inner product, and its Riesz theorem gives the solution and estimate. For an original compact test, the ordinary Green identity identifies its energy term with . The trace factor is locally -integrable by Cauchy–Schwarz and local finiteness, so it defines the indicated Radon measure. Rearranging the two terms gives the claimed sign in the current equation.
The coefficient threshold is a uniform sufficient threshold. The annular family in Example “Sharpness on an original annulus”, scaled by , with part domains containing the respective compact test supports, shows that for these forms need not even be nonnegative. At the equality threshold it supplies no uniform positive coercivity constant. This does not decide critical behavior for one fixed measure. ◻
As throughout this energy discussion, a fixed higher mixed tail can replace . The resulting capacity and energy belong to that fixed degree-one tail; this does not control all slots of a nonlinear diagonal family by one quadratic form.
A square-integrable capacity modulus for finite-energy data
Throughout the first statement, is an arbitrary allowed original positive separately closed current of bidegree on the fixed ordinary domain . The energy and part spaces are the frozen faithful ones. All capacities use normalized actual classical testers on the whole .
Theorem (A modulus criterion from the strong capacity inequality). Let be a finite positive Radon measure, carried by an ordinary , with total mass . Suppose that is nondecreasing, finite, locally absolutely continuous, and , and that For infinite capacity, means its monotone extended limit. If satisfies and , then has finite energy on and
Consequently the energy-class Dirichlet equation has its unique solution in whenever this coercive part space is defined as in Theorem “Finite-energy measure Dirichlet problem”.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new sharp strong-capacity inequality, with the displayed modulus criterion proved explicitly. It is an energy-class solvability statement; no classical or completed-psh membership is asserted.
Proof. Let be one original real compact smooth core function in , extended by zero to , and put The function is nonincreasing. Its superlevel sets in the variable are therefore initial intervals, up to endpoints. Tonelli’s theorem and Theorem “Strong capacitary inequality with optimal constant” give All analytic level sets here are ordinary open, so neither a raw/outer identification on general Borel sets nor Choquet regularity is used. Since , the datum bound gives Absolute continuity and justify the second Tonelli identity; its derivative is nonnegative almost everywhere. This proves the core dual bound, and the frozen energy Riesz theorem supplies the stated solution. If , the same conclusion is immediate. ◻
Corollary (The critical logarithmic family). For every finite measure satisfying the preceding capacity-growth bound has finite energy if . In contrast, for every there is a finite positive measure on the original unit disc, compactly supported inside one fixed ordinary smaller disc, satisfying that same bound with , whose energy dual norm is infinite.
Status: NEW_PROVED for the exact universal logarithmic threshold within this specified family. The sufficient direction is the preceding direct criterion; the counterexample uses the frozen original radial calibration. This is not an if-and-only-if criterion for an individual measure.
Proof. Write . For , For this is positive, and its square is integrable near zero exactly when . The function is unbounded at infinity, so a finite with always exists. This proves the sufficient direction.
For the opposite direction fix , let , , and put The total mass is , the support is contained in , and . All nonzero-mass support points are original divisorial Gauss points. As in Proposition “The exponent one half cannot be included”, take the fixed . The normalized hinge with curvature proves for every Borel containing a least-index support atom that The inequality is immediate for sets containing no support atom.
Use the finite test functions from that proposition with these new coefficients, Their energy and partial-measure pairing are again equal: The quantities increase to Here monotone convergence is applied to the nonnegative discrete sum; no rate estimate for is needed. The same original smooth compact approximations inside the fixed as in Proposition “The exponent one half cannot be included” pass both energy and integrals against the finite . A finite core dual norm would imply , a contradiction. ◻
Power bounds and scope.
For , , taking gives One may use the smaller of this bound and the earlier direct layer-cake bound. The new improvement is at the half-power endpoint; the linear case still gives . A fixed higher-degree background with frozen mixed slots may be replaced by its resulting degree-one current, with that current’s own capacity and energy. No bound for a nonlinear capacity with all slots varying is inferred.
Sharpness of the power-growth threshold for finite energy
The following construction reuses the frozen radial Gauss-point calibration and first-atom tail comparison from Section R4–60. Its new conclusion concerns finite faithful energy, rather than bounded classical Monge–Ampere solvability.
Proposition (The exponent one half cannot be included). For every there is a finite positive Radon measure on the original open unit disc , supported on a fixed compact subset of an ordinary , such that
but for the faithful degree-one energy of . Therefore it has no solution in of on all original scalar tests. The measure is carried by divisorial Gauss points and gives zero mass to their rigid limit point.
Status: NEW_PROVED as the sharpness application for the R6 finite-energy criterion. The radial curvature and original integration normalization are frozen inputs, not new results of this proposition. No additional bounded-classical Dirichlet conclusion is claimed.
Proof. Fix and put Set . Its total mass is . Since , all are points of the original -analytic disc and are divisorial. They converge to its rigid origin, so is compact. The measure gives no mass to zero. Take the fixed ordinary disc It contains .
For each , the actual normalized classical function on the whole is assigned value zero near the origin and has , by the original radial calibration. If contains some support atom, choose its least index . Then If it contains none, its mass is zero. This proves the bound for every Borel set, including sets containing the limit point. It uses neither compact outer regularity nor an optimizing envelope.
On the punctured unit disc put . For define the nonnegative continuous radial function with its constant terminal value at the origin. It is zero for , and constant for . For , where , its derivative is The one-dimensional original energy is consequently
This tends to infinity for every . No factor of is missing: is the unnormalized unit moment , so its energy calibration is itself.
Let . A direct finite sum gives Since and , one has .
We now realize these comparisons by original smooth core functions, rather than testing a current with a merely PL function. Extend to the real line by zero to the left and its terminal constant to the right, and convolve with smooth nonnegative kernels of radius . The resulting is zero for and constant for . It therefore extends as an original smooth function across the rigid origin and has compact support inside the fixed . For each fixed the approximation is uniform on the entire analytic disc, and its derivative converges in to . The original calibration gives The second assertion uses the finite total mass of and uniform approximation, not a singular-test convergence theorem.
If , apply its core bound to and let . It would give for every , contradicting (eq:r6-radial-energy-divergence). This proves infinite energy. Any energy solution in the specified part space would make the core datum bounded by its own energy norm through the original Green identity, so such a solution cannot exist. ◻
Ambient dimension and scope.
The same remaining-degree-one example can be embedded in every ambient dimension by taking to be the integration current of the coordinate disc in a product polydisc. The radial normalized testers pull back from its first coordinate, while the core functions are multiplied by fixed smooth cutoffs equal to one on the other coordinate origins. Their restriction and energy are exactly the displayed ones. This preserves arbitrary original-test meanings. It does not turn this linear energy obstruction into a claim about a nonlinear operator with several moving energy slots.
The universal finite-energy criterion for concave moduli
The word “universal” in the following statement quantifies over all measures obeying a fixed growth modulus. It does not characterize the energy of an individual measure and does not characterize classical Monge–Ampere solvability.
Theorem (An exact criterion within the concave class). Let be finite, nondecreasing and concave, with and continuous at zero. The following universal finite-energy assertion holds if and only if
for every allowed original degree-one background on a fixed ordinary domain carrying the faithful energy form, and every finite positive Radon measure supported on a compact satisfying the core dual norm is finite.
If (eq:r6-concave-modulus-threshold) fails, the counterexample already occurs for on the original open unit disc. Its support is a fixed compact sequence of divisorial Gauss points and their rigid limit, inside one fixed smaller ordinary disc; the limit point has mass zero. Thus failure of the criterion does not require a varying domain, an atomic rigid pole, or a complicated background.
Status: NEW_PROVED as the exact universal threshold for this specified concave class, obtained by combining the new strong-capacity criterion with the explicit radial construction. All original Gauss and energy calibrations are frozen inputs.
Proof. A finite concave function is locally absolutely continuous away from zero. Its nonnegative decreasing almost-everywhere derivative integrates to also from zero, by continuity there. In particular, it is absolutely continuous on every finite closed interval. On intervals bounded away from zero its derivative is bounded. Thus (eq:r6-concave-modulus-threshold) for one implies the same condition on every finite interval.
Suppose first that the condition holds. Relative CLN gives . If , the growth bound gives . Otherwise . Apply Theorem “A modulus criterion from the strong capacity inequality” with . It gives, explicitly, This proves the full arbitrary-fixed-background direction.
Conversely, assume that the integral of diverges near zero. Concavity and imply, almost everywhere, Indeed the right-hand side is the average of the decreasing derivative on . Hence for every . Fix , let and . Monotonicity of gives It follows that .
Set , and Continuity at zero implies , so is finite with total mass . It is supported in and gives zero mass to zero. The normalized original hinge of curvature proves the growth bound for every Borel set: if is the least index of an atom of positive mass in that set, its mass is at most , and its capacity is at least . If no such index exists, its mass is zero. No capacity regularity is used.
The finite radial test functions have, with , Their energies increase to The original smooth compact approximations inside this same fixed are exactly those justified in Proposition “The exponent one half cannot be included”: mollify each finite real PL profile, retaining its zero initial region and its constant terminal region. Uniform convergence and derivative convergence pass both the finite-measure pairing and the energy. A finite core dual norm would therefore bound the displayed diverging energy by a constant times its square root, which is impossible. This completes the necessity assertion. ◻
Qualification.
Concavity is used only for the sharp converse. For a general nondecreasing absolutely continuous modulus, the square-integrable derivative condition remains sufficient, but this proof asserts no necessity. Neither direction identifies the energy capacity with relative BT capacity. The conclusion supplies the energy-class linear equation through the Riesz theorem; all psh feasibility and trace constraints remain separate.
Capacity domination does not characterize the normalized image
This is a scope consequence of the two sharp estimates just proved. It concerns a fixed normalization on a fixed ordinary domain; it is neither a counterexample to C1 nor an assertion of Dirichlet nonexistence after removing the normalization.
Corollary (A strict distinction on an original annulus). There are an ordinary annulus over the original field and a finite positive Radon measure , compactly supported in , such that but does not belong to the weak closure, on all original compact smooth scalar tests, of In particular it is not the curvature of a normalized completed potential defined by a same-domain row in this normalized classical family.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Sharp normalized-tester Hardy inequality” and Example “Sharpness on an original annulus”. No new compact-regularity assertion is used.
Proof. Put and . Write , and let be its Gauss section. For take These measures have compact support and finite mass. The normalized hinges have on this same annulus. For a Borel set meeting the support of , put . Then The bound is immediate when misses this support. Attainment of the infimum is unnecessary.
The original smooth compact tests constructed in Example “Sharpness on an original annulus” satisfy Choose and then fix one sufficiently small for which this ratio is greater than one. On the other hand, the sharp Hardy estimate gives The same inequality holds in the weak closure of because is one fixed original compact smooth scalar test. Thus the displayed strict inequality separates from that weak closure, for sequences and nets alike. The completed-image conclusion follows from the fixed-bound completed continuity in Corollary “Weak limits and the energy-capacity bound”. ◻
Direction of the implication.
C1 asks whether a weak-limit or completed measure is dominated, on compact sets, by the raw classical-test capacity. The present measure already has that domination and fails to be a weak limit. It disproves the converse characterization, not C1. In particular a capacitary upper bound cannot replace the support-functional constraints in Theorem “A smooth-test alternative for completed solvability”. No assertion is made here about unnormalized classical potentials or arbitrary boundary values.
Relative BT and energy capacities can have different null sets
The sharp one-way energy bound cannot be reversed, even at the level of null sets. The counterexample below uses a smooth original-positive background on a full torus polyannulus. It is not a counterexample to compact no-gain or to ordinary-open outer regularity of BT capacity.
Fix , let , and put The background has bidegree , is symmetric, original-positive, and separately closed. Write for the original Gauss section. The original torus calibration gives, for ,
The factorial in is chosen precisely for these identities. In particular no normalization of the original absolute value is made.
Lemma (Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers). There is a constant such that, for every actual with , and every Euclidean ball ,
Consequently, if is compact and , then
Proof. Put . We first justify a restriction property of rather than assume it from the word “skeleton.” Fix all but one of its logarithmic coordinates. Let be the completed residue field of the Gauss point of the corresponding -torus over . Its coordinate elements have the prescribed radii. The analytic map from an annulus over that varies the remaining coordinate and keeps these elements fixed sends its Gauss point of each radius to the corresponding original -Gauss point in . This is the iterated Gauss seminorm identity on Laurent polynomials; it concerns actual points, not replacement of full analytic fibers in integration.
By the defining complete-extension curve test for classical psh, the pullback of is subharmonic. On a closed subannulus, subtract the affine harmonic function of the logarithmic radius that agrees with its two Gauss endpoint values. The subharmonic Shilov maximum principle on that annulus gives a nonpositive difference. If necessary one first extends to realize the two endpoint radii in its value group; the same actual Gauss identities and classical curve test remain valid. Thus is convex in the one varying coordinate. Repeating for each coordinate proves separate convexity.
The bound on now gives a uniform Lipschitz bound on : the one-dimensional convex slope bounds hold uniformly in all the fixed other coordinates, and one joins two points by coordinate segments. In particular has bounded weak first derivatives there, by a constant depending only on .
Let , a positive Radon measure by the frozen calculus. For every , recursion and (eq:r6-torus-laplace-calibration) give Tropicalization is proper on compact subsets of , so this is an identity of Radon measures: . Choose a nonnegative scalar cutoff equal to one on , supported in , with gradient bounded by a fixed multiple of . Integration by parts against the bounded weak gradient of gives The constant is independent of ; this proves (eq:r6-uniform-gauss-ball-mass).
Cover by finitely many sufficiently small balls with , keeping the doubled balls in . Their tropical inverse images form one ordinary open neighborhood of in the same . The uniform estimate and finite subadditivity give . Let . This proves outer capacity zero directly; no compact outer-regularity theorem has been used. ◻
Lemma (Every original energy dominates the Gauss restriction energy). For every original real compact smooth on , the actual function , extended by zero outside , belongs to and satisfies
Proof. The function is continuous and compactly supported in . For , compact Green, the torus calibration, and the original energy Cauchy–Schwarz inequality give
This uses every original , not just a torus-invariant subcore.
Choose a nonnegative even smooth probability mollifier . For small enough , both and are smooth and compactly supported in . Symmetry, Fubini and ordinary integration by parts give Substitute into (eq:r6-restriction-dual-bound). After cancellation, or trivially when this norm is zero, one obtains . As in , weak compactness in and lower semicontinuity prove (eq:r6-energy-restriction-bound). This argument requires no assertion that a smooth original test has a smooth restriction in one fixed real moment chart. ◻
Lemma (A compact real set with the two needed size properties). There is a compact with and a probability measure on such that Moreover there is a constant such that every continuous compactly supported with on satisfies .
Proof. Take a small affine copy of the middle-third Cantor set, a small -cube , and put . At scale it is covered by at most cubes of that side length. The sum of their st diameter powers is at most , proving the Hausdorff measure assertion.
Let , and let be the product of the Cantor Bernoulli probability, normalized Lebesgue measure on , and the point mass at zero. The usual interval count in the Cantor construction gives Layer cake for now bounds its near-diagonal integral by a constant times ; the remainder is bounded. This proves the finite energy assertion.
For completeness, this energy supplies the required Sobolev lower bound directly. For a real , the divergence formula for the Newton kernel gives with a fixed dimensional constant (its sign is irrelevant below). The convolution of the two nonnegative kernels is : translation, rotation and scaling give this form, and the defining integral is finite away from zero since . Tonelli and Cauchy–Schwarz therefore imply
For continuous compactly supported , convolution approximates uniformly as well as in ; thus the same inequality holds. If on , its left side is at least one. Take . ◻
Theorem (Strict separation of the two capacity null ideals). For the smooth background above and the compact set of Lemma “A compact real set with the two needed size properties”,
Here the second capacity is that of the frozen faithful regular Dirichlet form on . Thus neither a reverse comparison with a finite constant nor equality of the two null ideals holds in general.
Status: NEW_PROVED explicit obstruction to the reverse energy-capacity route, in every . It makes no negative claim about the general relative C1 or C2 conjectures.
Proof. The first equality follows from Lemma “Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers”. Every Gauss point of lies in : a nonnegative original cutoff supported in any neighborhood of it, paired with , has positive integral on a nonempty real neighborhood of that point. Hence .
In the verified compact-core formula for , let be any original smooth compact admissible function, so on . Its continuous Gauss restriction is at least one on . The preceding two lemmas give Taking the infimum proves the second assertion. In particular the failure cannot be repaired by passing to all original smooth tests: the energy lower bound was proved for that full test class. ◻
Exact scope of the obstruction.
This example has a fixed smooth background and remaining degree one. Its BT outer capacity is already zero, so it exhibits no compact weak-closure gain and no raw/outer discrepancy. It shows why the new sharp Hardy bound, although valid for every normalized tester and its weak limits, cannot close C1 merely by identifying the controlling energy capacity with BT capacity. The actual nonlinear psh constraint is visible in the uniform Gauss-section Lipschitz bound.
Exact capacity reduction on a Gauss section
Let , let be a nonempty bounded convex ordinary open set, and set Write for the original Gauss section and define for Borel . The Laplacian is the positive distributional Radon measure on the real domain. All noncompact sets considered below are contained in a fixed compact subset of . Let be the outer capacity obtained using ordinary real open neighborhoods in the same .
Lemma (Joint convexity from complete-extension annuli). Every actual with has . Conversely every gives a normalized continuous classical psh function on the same .
Proof. The coordinate-annulus argument in Lemma “Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers” applies on every real box compactly contained in . It proves separate convexity and local Lipschitz continuity of .
Fix a primitive integral vector . Complete to the first column of a matrix . The associated monomial change of torus coordinates has logarithmic coordinates . Fix and form the completed residue field of their Gauss point. The analytic annulus over that field varying maps into over exactly the interval cut out by . Its Gauss point at each radius maps to the original Gauss point of with those coordinates. This is the monomial Gauss-seminorm identity, not a fiber-integration assertion.
The complete-extension classical curve test and the subharmonic maximum principle on each closed subannulus therefore show that is convex along every segment parallel to . Endpoint radii can first be realized after a further complete extension, as in the coordinate case. Convexity follows along every rational direction. For , approximate by rational vectors with . Convexity of keeps all the corresponding segments inside . The already proved continuity of passes their convex inequalities to the segment . Thus is jointly convex.
For the converse, on each relatively compact real box one may approximate the continuous convex locally uniformly by smooth convex functions. Each such function of the unit-log coordinates is classical psh: after any complete extension and analytic curve map, the coordinates are harmonic and the convex Hessian chain rule is nonnegative. Locally uniform limits preserve the subharmonic curve inequalities. Hence is classical on , with precisely the original normalization . ◻
Theorem (Raw and outer capacities reduce to real convex traces). For every Borel contained in a fixed compact core of ,
Every competitor in these identities is normalized on the entire displayed capacity domain; no smaller-domain tester is substituted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the actual complete-extension curve test, ordinary torus calibration, and the frozen fixed-background calculus. It identifies a concrete real capacity, rather than proving general relative Borel outer regularity.
Proof. For as in the preceding lemma, write and . The calculation against original toric scalar tests in Lemma “Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers” gives
It is an identity of Radon measures because tropicalization is proper over compact subsets of . Conversely, for the toric competitor one has the stronger identity
For smooth real this is the original torus calibration on all original scalar tests. Local uniform smooth convex approximation, fixed coefficient-Radon multiplication, and positivity pass it to continuous convex . The restriction of an arbitrary original test to is used only as a continuous compact function.
Equation (eq:r6-gauss-push-laplacian) bounds both raw capacities in (eq:r6-gauss-raw-reduction) by , while (eq:r6-toric-convex-laplacian) supplies the reverse bounds. The sets are Borel: is a closed embedding over every compact real core, and tropical inverse images preserve Borel sets.
If is any ordinary open set containing , then is a real open neighborhood of . Toric competitors alone give No saturated-neighborhood assumption is made in this lower bound. Conversely, for every real open , the ordinary saturated open set has capacity by the raw identity. These two bounds prove the outer formula for . Since , the same saturated upper bound and monotonicity prove it also for the full inverse image. All infima can be restricted to neighborhoods inside one larger relatively compact core by intersection, so local mass bounds suffice. ◻
Corollary (Compact no-gain on the Gauss section). The family is compact in the topology of local uniform convergence, and is continuous for local weak Radon convergence. Consequently, for compact , If a net of normalized original relative measures converges weakly to on , then These statements give no Borel identity for arbitrary Borel sets.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY. The C1 consequence for this smooth nonpolar remaining-degree-one background is already within the frozen R3 nonpolar C1 theorem. The new explicit description here is the reduction to and its exact ordinary-open outer counterpart.
Proof. Normalized convex functions have one uniform Lipschitz bound on each compact subset of . Arzela–Ascoli on a countable real compact exhaustion gives compactness of ; local uniform limits retain convexity and the same bounds on all of . Distributional convergence of their Laplacians, together with uniform local mass bounds, gives weak Radon convergence. This is compactness of the real normalized family, not a claim that arbitrary relative currents have actual classical representatives.
If are compact sets in one core, choose with . Pass to a locally uniformly convergent subsequence with limit . For every fixed , compact Portmanteau gives Let and use finite Radon continuity above. This proves . Taking shrinking compact neighborhoods of now yields .
For the final assertion, compactness gives a subnet locally uniformly. Equation (eq:r6-gauss-push-laplacian), tested first by compact real smooth functions, gives . Positivity therefore implies as required. The weak limit itself need not be toric. Nothing in this proof exchanges an infimum over open neighborhoods with a supremum over measures on a general Borel set. ◻
Remaining real question.
The equality for all Borel would, by the exact reduction, settle C2 on these Gauss-section sets. Compactness of the convex measure image alone does not prove that equality, as the frozen abstract weak-compact-family counterexample already demonstrates. This restricted real question is distinct from the full arbitrary-background C2 problem.
Borel outer regularity on Gauss sets of finite codimension-one size
Retain the full convex torus domain and the smooth remaining-degree-one background of Section “Exact capacity reduction on a Gauss section”, and assume . Fix a compact real core . Hausdorff measure below refers to the ordinary Euclidean metric on , not to a metric on the Berkovich space.
Proposition (An outer bound by codimension-one Hausdorff measure). There is a constant such that every subset satisfies Equivalently the same bound holds for the ordinary-open outer relative capacities of and . For non-Borel sets only these outer capacities are asserted.
Proof. The normalized convex family has a uniform Lipschitz bound on a fixed larger real core. The cutoff calculation in Lemma “Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers” therefore gives for all sufficiently small balls centered near , with their doubled balls in the larger core. Cover by countably many such balls. Their union is one real open neighborhood; countable subadditivity, valid directly for the supremum of the positive measures , bounds its capacity by . Taking the infimum over covers of arbitrarily small diameter proves the bound, up to the fixed normalization of Hausdorff measure.
The exact outer comparison proof of Theorem “Raw and outer capacities reduce to real convex traces” used only open neighborhoods and monotonicity. It therefore applies to arbitrary subsets for the outer capacities, and gives the stated equivalent formulations. Alternatively the saturated inverse images of the covering balls give the Berkovich upper bounds directly. ◻
Corollary (A concrete Borel C2 class). If is Borel and , then Consequently raw and ordinary-open outer relative capacities agree for both and , with capacity domain the same whole . This includes every Borel subset of a compact smooth real hypersurface in of finite area.
If instead is a countable union of Borel sets of finite measure, then The second assertion is an equality of null classes; it does not claim equality of positive capacity values for every such countable union.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the uniform growth bound and the already proved compact C1 theorem. This is a qualified Borel outer-regularity result, not general C2.
Proof. The finite Borel measure on the real core is Radon. For every choose compact with . Compact C1 and the preceding proposition give Let and combine with the always valid reverse inequality. The exact raw and outer reductions then yield the Berkovich statements. No uniform setwise continuity of individual tester measures is asserted or needed.
For the last assertion write with each Borel and of finite Hausdorff measure. If , then ; the first part gives . Countable subadditivity gives . The converse follows from . ◻
What remains.
The proof uses a finite measure on the particular Borel set to approximate it by a compact subset, together with an independent outer estimate on the residual set. Merely knowing compactness of the potential family supplies neither that residual estimate nor ordinary-open outer continuity for all Borel sets. In particular the argument leaves the general real Borel C2 gate, and a fortiori the arbitrary-background Berkovich C2 gate, open.
A coordinate-projection criterion for real and Gauss Borel capacities
Retain , the Gauss section, and the smooth remaining-degree-one background from Section “Exact capacity reduction on a Gauss section”, with . Fix a compact rectangular core and open real boxes Let delete the th coordinate. Lebesgue outer measure on this target is denoted by .
Lemma (Uniform projected-size bound). There is a finite constant such that every subset satisfies The same inequality holds for the ordinary-open outer relative capacities of and .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the uniform convex slope bound, directional Fubini, and the exact outer Gauss reduction. It is an upper bound, not an identification of capacity with projected size.
Proof. All have one common Lipschitz bound on . Fix . On each coordinate line with transverse parameter , the restriction is convex, and its one-dimensional second derivative on the interval cut out by is a positive measure of mass at most .
Directional distributional Fubini gives For completeness, for a compact smooth test this follows by writing as the iterated integral on these lines and applying the one-dimensional distributional identity. The kernels are weakly Borel: their compact smooth pairings are integrals of the continuous against second derivatives, or limits of such pairings after restriction to compact line intervals. The uniform mass bound makes the resulting positive Radon kernel integral well defined and identifies the measures. In particular, for every real open ,
For choose open with The real open set contains . The preceding inequality is uniform in all normalized convex testers and bounds by . Let . The outer comparison proof in Theorem “Raw and outer capacities reduce to real convex traces” applies to arbitrary subsets, so it gives both Berkovich formulations as well. ◻
Proposition (Borel coordinate sheets). Let be Borel. Suppose that for each the restriction is one-to-one, its image is Borel, and its inverse is Borel. Then The corresponding same-domain raw and ordinary-open outer relative capacities agree on both and . The same conclusion holds for a finite union of such Borel sheets. No Hausdorff-measure bound on is assumed.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the projection bound and compact C1. All Borel inverse hypotheses are explicit, so no unproved measurable selection is being invoked.
Proof. For each , push the finite measure forward by , and call the resulting finite Borel measure on . Finite Borel measures on Euclidean space are Radon. Put ; it is carried by . For every compact , injectivity gives These projections are Borel, since is compact. Inner Radon regularity on the Borel set supplies compact with . The projection bound and compact C1 imply Let and use .
For a finite union of sheets, add their finitely many projection pullback measures. For every residual , its coordinate projections lie in the unions of the corresponding sheet projections, so the same upper bound by holds. The same compact approximation proves the result. Finally apply the exact raw and outer Gauss reductions. ◻
A directly specified class in dimension two.
Let be Borel subsets of bounded real intervals, and let be a bijection such that both and are Borel. If its graph lies in , it satisfies the proposition: the inverse coordinate maps are and . Thus these Borel Gauss graphs and their full tropical inverse images have exact ordinary-open outer regularity. Continuity or a finite area assumption is not used.
Scope of the remaining gate.
The finite Radon measure constructed here lives on the particular Borel set and controls the outer capacity of its residual subsets. It is not a common neighborhood dominator for all tester measures. The proposition gives no such residual control for an arbitrary Borel set, and leaves general real Borel C2, and general relative Berkovich C2, open.
A finite gluing mechanism for open sets with compact additions
Retain the bounded convex real domain , normalized convex class , and Laplacian capacity of Section “Exact capacity reduction on a Gauss section”. All sets below lie in one fixed compact core of . The normalization is on the whole .
Lemma (Pasting one local-uniform row on two fixed pieces). Let with locally uniformly, and let be disjoint compact sets. There are and numbers such that, for every Borel , The same works for all these Borel subsets.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the explicit maximum-and-compensator method in frozen Theorem R4–79.4. We give the real proof because only local uniform convergence is assumed here, while the normalization must remain global.
Proof. Choose smooth with disjoint compact supports in , each identically one near . A sufficiently large positive quadratic on is nonnegative on and makes convex on the whole . Since is bounded, Fix a compact neighborhood of the two regions where the cutoffs equal one. Choose positive numbers such that on ; this is possible by local uniform convergence, enlarging the errors to decreasing tail suprema if necessary. Set Both branches are convex on the entire , and their maximum is convex. The global bounds give . Closeness outside is neither assumed nor needed.
Near the first branch strictly exceeds the second by at least , and near the second strictly exceeds the first. Ordinary locality of distributional Hessians therefore gives Here the positive added quadratic curvature is simply discarded. The assertions first hold on neighborhoods and hence on every Borel subset of the compact pieces. Their disjointness proves the lemma with . ◻
Theorem (Borel outer regularity for an open set plus a compact set). Let be real open and let be compact. Then Consequently raw and ordinary-open outer relative capacities agree on both and in the same whole torus domain.
Status: NEW_PROVED for this exact set class, using the displayed finite gluing argument. Weak compactness of an arbitrary measure family would not prove this assertion.
Proof. The case is immediate. Otherwise choose decreasing open metric neighborhoods of , with compact closures in one fixed core, such that . They are cofinal among open neighborhoods of the compact . Thus are cofinal among open neighborhoods of that contain , and Choose with . The already proved local-uniform compactness of gives a subsequence converging locally uniformly to . Keep this subsequence fixed for the rest of the proof. Its Laplacians converge weakly on the fixed core, and its displayed open-set masses still tend to .
Now fix an arbitrary open neighborhood of with compact closure in that core. Eventually , so Compact Portmanteau implies
The sets and are fixed disjoint compacts: lies inside the open , while lies in its closed complement. Apply the preceding lemma to these pieces, with the Borel subsets and . Since both subsets lie in , it gives This does not discard mass on : the second cutoff is one on a neighborhood of the entire compact closure . Combining with (eq:r6-open-compact-upper) yields Only after taking the row limit do we shrink through nested neighborhoods of . The fixed finite Radon measure then makes the last difference tend to zero. This order of choices is essential: the cutoff cost may grow as shrinks, but for each fixed the local-uniform error already tends to zero. The opposite inequality is always true. The exact raw and outer Gauss reductions finish the Berkovich statement. ◻
Corollary (Adding a Borel set with controlled compact residuals). Let be open and let be Borel in one compact core. Suppose that for every there is compact with . Then This applies when has finite measure, or when is a finite union of the Borel coordinate sheets in Proposition “Borel coordinate sheets”.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY.
Proof. Outer subadditivity and the theorem give Let . The two specified residual estimates were proved in the Hausdorff and projection criteria, respectively. ◻
The unresolved general Borel step.
For a general Borel , its open neighborhoods need not differ from only near one compact piece, and no compact-residual estimate has been proved. The argument therefore does not establish continuity of outer capacity from below on arbitrary increasing Borel sets. General real Borel C2 and arbitrary-background C2 remain open.
A boundary criterion for qualified C1 and C2 statements
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY. Let be an arbitrary fixed original-positive symmetric separately closed -current on an ordinary norm-box domain with the frozen faithful energy form. Put . All capacities use normalized actual classical testers on all of . Fix a compact core .
For a Borel , set Then
The quantities on the left are finite by local CLN. In particular gives Borel ordinary-open outer regularity for this ; for compact it gives sharp compact C1.
Proof. Every normalized BT measure is carried by the closed . An ordinary open set may be chosen with , and may be intersected with a fixed relatively compact neighborhood of . Its raw capacity equals that of this relative interior and is at most the raw capacity of . The part of outside is contained in an ordinary open set of zero capacity. Finally Finite outer subadditivity and the sharp one-way inequality from Corollary “Weak limits and the energy-capacity bound” prove (B1). Only relative topology on is used; the ambient boundary would give an unnecessarily strong condition for polar-carried backgrounds. ◻
There is also a quantitative continuity-set statement. Suppose a net of normalized measures converges weakly on all original tests to a positive Radon measure . Then
Hence makes a simultaneous weak continuity set.
Proof. The fixed-core mass bounds and smooth scalar density turn the stated weak convergence into ordinary local vague convergence. All measures are carried by , so this may be considered on ; compact continuous functions there extend locally to the ambient space. The sharp Hardy inequality passes to on each fixed original square test. Its compact-core and ordinary-open argument therefore also gives . Apply the open and compact inequalities for vague convergence to the relative interior and closure of . Their differences from lie in , proving (B2). One may insert a fixed original cutoff equal to one near to reduce every step to finite measures on one compact set. ◻
These statements do not close general C1: the energy capacity of a boundary can be positive even when its BT outer capacity is zero, as Theorem “Strict separation of the two capacity null ideals” demonstrates. They also do not assert a converse boundary criterion. A fixed higher mixed tail can replace , with its own faithful energy form. For a family with all higher slots moving, one would need a uniform estimate for those varying tails; no such estimate is implicit here.
Sharp regularity under continuous ambient-curvature domination
This criterion applies in every remaining degree and to an arbitrary fixed background. The finite-dimensional curvature hypothesis from R5 is replaced by an order bound in an infinite-dimensional family. The conclusion concerns that explicitly dominated family, or a weakly convergent net lying in it; no uniform domination of all normalized psh testers is assumed to exist.
Let be an allowed ordinary open, let be symmetric, original-positive and separately closed of bidegree , and put . Fix an ordinary open and a compact core . All actual competitors below are defined and normalized on the whole domain .
Lemma (Ambient order gives mixed relative order). Let . Suppose are continuous on , and . If, for constants , then on every original complementary test in one has
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of R’s continuous regularization, expressed in Lemma “Continuous curvature order transfers to a fixed background”, and the frozen mixed BT calculus.
Proof. For any fixed positive separately closed tail , the continuous function has positive original curvature on . The cited order-transfer lemma gives This uses uniform smooth positive approximation of , not a claim that an arbitrary discontinuous difference with positive distributional curvature is classical psh. Symmetry permits each slot to be placed first, while the other bounded psh slots form a positive separately closed tail. Replace the slots one at a time. All intermediate tails retain positivity and separate closedness, which proves (eq:r6-mixed-curvature-domination), including zero values of the . ◻
Theorem (An all-degree dominated-family capacity criterion). Fix continuous classical on and constants . For each , let be any subfamily of actual satisfying Let be the family of positive measures with , or any subfamily of these measures. Define its restricted raw capacity by Its outer regularization uses ordinary open neighborhoods in the same . Then:
For every Borel , .
If a net from converges on all original compact smooth scalar tests in to a Radon measure , then for every bounded Borel supported in . In particular for every such Borel .
The same restricted capacities have continuity from above on decreasing Borel sequences in . Together with their usual increasing-sequence continuity and Borel inner regularity, this supplies these finite compact-core regularity properties for the restricted family.
No conclusion of convergence in total variation is made.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY with an explicit infinite-dimensional sufficient hypothesis. The transfer from ambient curvature bounds to a uniform measure bound for an arbitrary is the substantive input.
Proof. On put The preceding lemma proves on for every . Choose an ordinary with . The positive Radon measure is finite on .
For Borel , Radon outer regularity supplies an ordinary open with and . For every family member, Take the supremum and then . Since these are ordinary neighborhoods in , this proves the first assertion. The local nature of the dominator does not change the capacity domain.
For the second assertion, fixed nonnegative smooth tests first imply on . A bounded Borel supported in can be approximated in by original smooth compact scalars supported in : use Radon regularity, compact continuous approximation, and the original smooth scalar density on that compact stage. For such an approximant , The middle smooth pairing converges by hypothesis. Let the error tend to zero. This works for nets as well as sequences and proves the asserted fixed-Borel convergence. It is setwise convergence on the core, not uniform convergence over all Borel indicators.
If are Borel subsets of , domination gives For , the two suprema over the index and over family members commute, giving increasing continuity. For a Borel , inner regularity of each fixed member similarly gives . These statements, with the preceding ordinary-open regularity and finite core bound, prove the stated restricted regularity properties. No continuity assertion for arbitrary decreasing Borel nets is used. ◻
Corollary (A maximal dominated subfamily and a sharp C1 test). For fixed and , set The restricted diagonal capacity using this entire subfamily is Borel outer regular on , and its weak closure has no compact mass gain. In particular, if normalized lie in this family and weakly on , then for every compact , The mixed restricted capacities in the theorem are not identified with diagonal capacities. If the unrestricted normalized family has no such common ambient bound, no full C1 or C2 conclusion follows.
Proof. Use the diagonal subfamily of the preceding theorem, with all and . The last upper bound holds because every member is still a normalized actual tester on all of . ◻
Example (Infinite-dimensional curvature and failure of TV convergence). On the original annulus put , take , and define These are smooth classical functions, throughout the annulus, and Their curvature currents span an infinite-dimensional real space. They converge weakly, and setwise on every fixed compact core, to . On the compact skeleton segment , however, the total variation of the difference is All calibrations use with the original absolute value. Thus the criterion extends beyond exact finite-dimensional curvature families and does not falsely upgrade setwise convergence to TV.
Variable curvature bounds and integrable relative density control
The continuous coefficient relation theorem allows upper bounds with variable scalar coefficients. Its measure consequences require a uniform integrability hypothesis, which is stated explicitly. The result concerns the specified family of normalized testers, not all normalized psh functions without that hypothesis.
Proposition (Variable continuous curvature bounds). Fix any allowed -background and . Suppose and are finite continuous functions on , with as original coefficient-Radon current inequalities. Then Neither the nor the are assumed continuous. No closedness of the continuously weighted upper current is required or asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Continuous coefficient relations for bounded potential slots”.
Proof. For the positive separately closed tail containing all slots other than , apply the module theorem to . This gives the displayed inequality with replaced by and scalar factor outside the product. Use symmetry, apply the same argument to the next remaining inside the still positive separately closed tail, and multiply the result by the already extracted nonnegative scalar factors. Iterating proves the assertion. At no step is a variable-coefficient current used as a closed background. ◻
Hereafter let and fix an ordinary on which has finite mass. Let be a nonempty family of actual normalized tuples , each defined on the same whole normalized domain, whose restrictions to satisfy the preceding bounds with coefficients . For some assume
Put , and define the restricted raw capacity . The corresponding star is the infimum over ordinary open neighborhoods in the same normalized domain.
Theorem (Qualified C1, C2 and Borel-weighted convergence). Under (eq:r6-variable-density-bound), the following hold.
For every Borel , For every Borel , the restricted raw capacity equals its ordinary-open outer capacity.
If a net of measures from this family converges weakly on every original compact scalar test in to a Radon measure , then it converges setwise on every Borel . In particular there, giving sharp compact no-gain without asserting that has an actual normalized representative.
Write . On compact localizations in , the Radon–Nikodym densities of the net and its limit converge weakly in . Consequently Borel weights converging strongly in may vary jointly with the measures in their pairings. Locally uniformly bounded weights converging locally in -measure satisfy this condition. This last assertion is valid for nets with convergence in measure; mere pointwise convergence of nets is not substituted for it.
The analogous conclusions hold with a uniform density bound, using weights and weak-star density convergence. No total- variation convergence follows solely from these hypotheses.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of variable curvature order, finite Radon regularity and elementary duality. It enlarges the stated common bounded-density criterion; general unrestricted arbitrary-background C1 and C2 are not asserted.
Proof. The preceding proposition gives , where . Thus its density satisfies and . Holder’s inequality proves (1)’s mass bound. If is Borel, finite Radon outer regularity gives ordinary open with and arbitrarily small. For every family member, Take the supremum and then shrink this error. Ordinary outer monotonicity gives the reverse inequality, proving the asserted C2. The same argument allows opens in the original normalized domain, since the displayed open neighborhoods already belong to it.
For (2) and (3), the closed positive ball of radius is weakly compact. Every subnet of densities has a weakly convergent further subnet, with some nonnegative density of norm at most . Its integrals against every original compact smooth scalar test equal the assumed current limit. Original smooth scalar tests are uniformly dense on compact stages; the uniform finite-mass bound and cutoffs therefore identify on . Radon uniqueness also makes this density unique up to -null sets. The same identification on every convergent subnet proves weak convergence of the whole density net. This argument does not require a countable exhaustion or a selected convergent lifting of the potentials.
In particular testing with gives setwise convergence and the sharp capacity bound. If strongly in , then For local statements multiply weights by a fixed compact cutoff and apply the same estimate on its support. Locally bounded convergence in measure gives strong convergence on finite- measure compact localizations: split into and its complement, use the common bound on the latter, then let . This proof works for nets. The case uses the weak-star compact ball and the same argument with tests and weights. ◻
Interpretation and limitations.
The scalar functions enter through original ambient current inequalities; the dominating Radon measure is the fixed relative BT product on the actual space. Thus the hypothesis supplies a common relative density control, including on carriers that may be ambient pluripolar. It is not an assertion of nonconcentration on all ambient polar sets. The existence of such coefficients with uniform integrable products must be established for the intended tester family; normalizing alone does not supply it.
Diffuse fiber backgrounds and exact capacity on rectangles
This section gives an all-dimensional class of relative capacities on which sharp ordinary-open outer approximation can be computed. The parameter measure may be diffuse and may be carried by an ambient complete pluripolar set. The set being tested is a rectangle; arbitrary nonrectangular compact sets are not included in the conclusion.
Fix integers , put , and let and be the open unit polydiscs of dimensions and over the original . Write and let be compact. Here means actual -rational analytic points, not all Berkovich points. Let be an arbitrary finite positive Radon measure on . For , denote the closed fiber embedding by , .
The set is naturally homeomorphic to the ordinary topological product . Indeed every residue field at a point of is exactly , so each full analytic fiber is . On compact affinoid stages the map is continuous by uniform polynomial approximation of analytic functions; for a polynomial the assertion follows from the ultrametric estimate when its coefficients vary with . It is a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space and hence a homeomorphism there. These stages cover . We use this identification for the Borel rectangles below. It does not replace a general nonrigid analytic fiber by an independent section.
Proposition (Original-current disintegration over rigid parameters). The formula
defines a symmetric original-positive separately - and -closed -current, carried by . For any and ,
for every original compact smooth complementary test . At this is an equality of positive Radon measure kernels on the actual product . In particular it holds on every Borel set, not only on smooth tests or on a selected skeleton.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen fixed-background calculus and CLN estimates, together with the original fiber-integration theorem. The explicit disintegration proof is given to fix the test class, measurability and calibration.
Proof. The projection is separated, flat, boundaryless, and of pure relative dimension . Original fiber integration [CLD25, Theorem 16.3.3(d), pp. 447–450] shows that is continuous, in particular bounded on the compact set . Its integration in (eq:r6-laminar-current) is therefore defined. On a fixed compact original moment presentation, dominate a smooth test by finitely many fixed positive controls as in R. Their fiber integrals are continuous and bounded on . This gives the requisite finite coefficient seminorm bound for the displayed functional and proves continuity in the original test topology. Pullback preserves the original positive cone and symmetry, so the functional is symmetric and positive. For a compact test of one lower degree, pullback commutes with and , and Stokes on the boundaryless fiber gives zero. Thus is separately closed. A test supported off has zero restriction on every fiber, proving the carrier assertion. The fibers are the original -space ; there is no residue-degree factor or absolute-value renormalization in this formula.
Here are the measurability and uniform bounds needed for the higher formula. A compact test is covered by finitely many original local regularization stages for the bounded potentials, with a smooth partition. On each stage take the frozen simultaneous smooth majorizing rows. After restriction to of that stage they are legitimate rows on the same original -space . The smooth-row fiber pairings are continuous in by the same fiber-integration theorem. Their pointwise limits are the fiber BT pairings by the already proved calculus with background . They are consequently Borel functions of .
The relative CLN proof on a finite original presentation is uniform after restriction to these fibers: the real coefficient bounds and cutoff derivatives are the same, while the finitely many background control pairings are fiber integrals of fixed original smooth forms. Those pairings are bounded on by fiber integration. The local bounds of the on the fixed compact stage give one integrable bound for all pairings under discussion. This argument permits degenerate restricted moment frames; no strictly positive frame on every fiber is assumed.
One can therefore define the right side of (eq:r6-fiber-bt-disintegration) as a current . It is positive and separately closed by the corresponding fiber properties, and has the finite coefficient controls just established. Thus it has the actual coefficient-Radon property. For fixed tests its coefficient measures are the integrals of the fiber coefficient measures: first test this against original smooth scalar multipliers, then use uniqueness of Radon measures and their bounded Borel multiplication. The same statement is valid with a bounded Borel scalar on a compact stage, including the actual .
Induct on . The assertion at zero is (eq:r6-laminar-current). Assuming it for the tail product, the coefficient-measure statement and commutation of pullback with give This is precisely the fixed-background recursion. It proves the formula on all original tests and hence equality with . For , the fiber measures are weakly Borel measurable and locally uniformly finite, as proved above. The usual Radon kernel integral on is therefore defined. Its compact continuous pairings agree with the current formula; original smooth scalar density identifies the Radon measures, giving the Borel assertion. ◻
Write and , with normalized actual classical testers on the indicated whole domains. Stars denote infima over ordinary open neighborhoods in those same domains.
Theorem (Sharp rectangular capacity and ordinary-open regularity). Fix an ordinary core . For every Borel and every Borel , the rectangle satisfies
In particular compact rectangles have sharp compact outer regularity, in every dimension and every remaining degree .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the preceding disintegration and the frozen ambient Borel outer-regularity theorem: R2, Corollary R4–36.9 (Corollary 36.9, printed p. 126 of the frozen R2 report). That theorem applies to , an exhaustion polydisc, and to in its fixed relatively compact core. It is not an assumption of general relative Borel outer regularity.
Proof. For any classical on all of , every restriction is normalized classical on all of . Disintegration gives Conversely a normalized classical on pulls back to the normalized classical on all of . Its integral over is . Taking suprema proves the raw equality, including the case . All quantities are finite here by CLN on the fixed core and finiteness of .
For , the cited ambient theorem supplies an ordinary open with The finite measure extended by zero from the compact to is Radon. Choose an ordinary open containing such that . The ordinary open set contains . The same raw rectangle formula, and the carrier of , give Let decrease to zero. The general inequality gives the reverse bound. This proof does not assert that an arbitrary nonsaturated open neighborhood contains one fixed product neighborhood of a noncompact Borel rectangle. ◻
Example (A diffuse complete-pole parameter measure). These backgrounds need not be nonpolar or countable sums of fiber integration currents. For , choose a uniformizer and put The coding by the binary product space is continuous and injective; thus is compact. Give it the nonatomic Bernoulli probability measure . With , set Every is continuous classical and nonpositive on . Indeed the integrand is continuous jointly on compact stages, so finite positive atomic quadratures converge uniformly on each such stage; each quadrature is continuous classical. Decreasing closure then makes extended classical.
For , the parameters agreeing with its first digits have measure and satisfy . Hence Thus on . If an analytic point , the continuous function is everywhere positive on the compact set and has a positive minimum. Therefore is finite. This proves that is an exact complete pole set. For larger embed as and use the witness .
The current in (eq:r6-laminar-current) is carried by the complete pole set , yet gives zero coefficient mass to each individual fiber because has no atoms. It is consequently not a positive order limit of finite sums of nonzero subcurrents carried by individual fibers. Formula (eq:r6-laminar-rectangle-capacity) nevertheless applies exactly.
The next laminar gate.
For a general compact , disintegration gives only the fiberwise upper bound by the integral of intrinsic capacities, when that upper envelope is measurable. Choosing an optimizing tester independently on uncountably many fibers does not supply one ambient classical function normalized on . In particular a compact graph of varying fiberwise Gauss points is not a rectangle, and no claim of C1 or C2 for that graph follows from this section. This is a concrete diffuse polar-supported test case for the remaining sharp selection and extension mechanism.
Exact capacity on moving Gauss graphs over diffuse pole carriers
Retain the original field, polydiscs, compact rigid parameter set , finite parameter measure , and disintegrated background of Section “Diffuse fiber backgrounds and exact capacity on rectangles”. The following computation handles a nonrectangular family. Its moving atoms are followed by an actual ambient psh threshold; no countable dense family of fixed fiber testers is substituted for that construction.
For let be the diagonal Gauss point with all coordinate radii . On the whole unit polydisc ,
This is the same exact computation as Lemma R4–60.1, now with any real : has by the original slope-simplex calibration. The normalized tester gives the lower bound. Comparison of with an arbitrary normalized tester minus one gives the upper bound on the closed polydisc; let . No change of the original absolute value, strict-radius assumption, or outer-regularity interchange is involved.
Theorem (A sharp formula for moving Gauss graphs). Let satisfy on all of and Suppose that admits finite partitions into compact sets such that each is an exact complete pole set of a nonpositive extended classical psh function on , and For any Borel put Then, with normalized actual classical testers on the whole ,
In particular is compact and has sharp compact outer regularity. The theorem holds for every .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the proved disintegration, exact radial calibration, and frozen finite pole-carrier additivity, with the explicit same-domain testers below. This computes a new nonrectangular class; it does not prove general relative C1 or C2.
Proof. The map is continuous: on every polynomial, the Gauss seminorm is a finite maximum of continuous functions of the radius. Together with the product identification in Section “Diffuse fiber backgrounds and exact capacity on rectangles”, this makes a compact graph homeomorphic to and a Borel subset of it. All its -coordinates lie in the one fixed compact polydisc of radius .
For a normalized ambient tester , the fiber function is normalized on all of . The Borel kernel identity and (eq:r6-arbitrary-radius-capacity) therefore give This proves the raw upper bound.
Fix one of the finite partitions and abbreviate its parts by . Let be the background obtained by integrating the same full fibers against . Proposition “Original-current disintegration over rigid parameters” proves directly that each is an allowed positive separately closed current, and . The pullback of the pole witness of has exact pole set and carries every coefficient of . These closed carriers are pairwise disjoint. Ordinary restriction and locality make every BT measure for vanish on the carrier of for . Thus the hypotheses of the frozen Theorem R4–79.1 hold for these actual diffuse currents, not merely for individual fiber integration currents. It follows that
Put and , omitting empty parts. The globally defined function is continuous classical psh and satisfies on all of . The inner maximum is finite because is finite; the outer maximum supplies the global lower bound even away from . For the outer floor is redundant, and exact radial calibration on the fiber gives Consequently (eq:r6-graph-finite-additivity) implies
The carrier theorem takes the independent finite suprema in one same-domain normalized class; no existence of a single exactly optimizing tester is asserted here.
For the outer upper bound set . It is compact, contains the Gauss point of the largest radius , and is contained in the closed polydisc of that radius. Equation (eq:r6-arbitrary-radius-capacity) implies . The Borel rectangles cover . The already proved rectangle theorem and finite subadditivity of ordinary-open outer capacity therefore give
The function is uniformly continuous on . The partition oscillation condition makes the difference of the upper and lower sums tend to zero, bounded by times that uniform modulus. Both sums converge to the displayed integral in (eq:r6-gauss-graph-capacity). The inequalities (eq:r6-graph-lower-sum), , and (eq:r6-graph-upper-sum) prove the theorem. ◻
Corollary (Diffuse complete-polar Cantor parameters). For the explicit parameter set in Example “A diffuse complete-pole parameter measure”, the preceding theorem applies to every continuous classical satisfying the stated strict negative bounds on , and to every finite positive Radon measure on , including nonatomic ones.
Proof. Partition by its first binary digits. Each part is compact, and the diameters of the parts tend to zero, so continuity of gives the required uniform oscillation condition. Each part has an exact complete-pole witness: use the same logarithmic integral as in Example “A diffuse complete-pole parameter measure”, with the Bernoulli probability conditioned on that cylinder. The divergent estimate is unchanged up to its fixed positive normalization, and compactness gives finiteness at every analytic point outside that cylinder. For higher , include the other zero coordinates by the same finite maximum. This construction depends on the parameter set, not on the chosen measure . ◻
Why this does not give arbitrary fiberwise optimization.
A weakly dense or countable family of fixed fiber testers can miss all the atoms of a moving graph. The proof above instead follows its radius through the actual joint psh function , and only the normalizing slopes are discretized. For a general compact , no such joint psh threshold is supplied. The existence of measurable fiberwise optimizers, even if established, would still not produce normalized ambient classical testers. Neither general compact no-gain nor actual representability of every completed relative measure follows from the graph formula.
Exact interpolation on a pole Cantor set and Borel Gauss graphs
Let be the ordinary open unit disc over the original field , and retain the compact set from Example “A diffuse complete-pole parameter measure”. A cylinder means the subset obtained by prescribing finitely many initial digits. The following interpolation statement concerns this specified set. It is not an extension theorem for arbitrary pluripolar sets.
Lemma (Continuous pole wells on cylinders). Let be the nonempty cylinders of one finite partition of . There are pairwise disjoint ordinary open discs with the following property. For every there are continuous classical functions on the whole such that
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the explicit logarithmic pole witnesses, with the uniform bound recorded.
Proof. The finite cylinders have strictly smaller internal diameters than their mutual distances. Choose a disc around each cylinder with radius strictly between these two quantities. The discs are ordinary open, pairwise disjoint, and contain the respective cylinders.
Let be the Bernoulli probability conditioned on and put The construction in Example “A diffuse complete-pole parameter measure” shows that is extended classical and has exact pole set . It is continuous and finite off : on a compact neighborhood of any such point the continuous positive function has a uniform positive lower bound for , so the logarithmic integral is continuous there. Since is upper semicontinuous, is locally constant equal to near every point of , and is continuous everywhere. It is a bounded classical function by the maximum and decreasing-closure properties.
If has center and radius , then for and one has , by the ultrametric inequality and . Thus uniformly on the whole complement of . Taking sufficiently large makes there. This proves the claimed uniform, same-domain wells. ◻
Theorem (Continuous interpolation with arbitrary range slack). For every and every , there is an actual bounded continuous classical function on the whole such that For , the same assertion holds on the whole -dimensional unit polydisc , by pullback.
Status: NEW_PROVED for this explicit pole Cantor set. The proof uses the displayed continuous wells and a uniformly convergent decreasing construction; it does not infer an ambient representative from relative capacity convergence.
Proof. Write , , and start with the constant classical function . Put We construct continuous classical decreasing on , with continuous residuals . Initially . At step assume , and let . Choose a finite cylinder partition such that the oscillation of on each part is at most . Define Use the preceding lemma with pairwise disjoint discs , choosing so small that . Set This is continuous classical and at most .
At a point of , the th well is exactly and every other well lies in . Therefore In particular , so the induction continues. At any point of at most one of the disjoint occurs. The corresponding well contributes at most to the absolute decrement; all others contribute together at most . Consequently For one has . The tail decrements are uniformly summable, and converges uniformly on the entire disc to a bounded continuous function . Decreasing classical closure with bounded limit makes this actual function classical. The residual bounds give exactly.
The upper bound is . Also Hence . This proves the range claim. Pullback by the first coordinate projection gives the final assertion and preserves the original-field classical curve condition. ◻
Corollary (Every bounded Borel radial graph in this lamination). Let and be as in Section “Diffuse fiber backgrounds and exact capacity on rectangles”, with this explicit embedded Cantor set and any finite positive Radon measure on . Let be Borel, where . For every Borel , define Then, in every , with normalized actual classical testers on the same whole ,
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new interpolation theorem, the proved continuous-threshold graph formula, Lusin approximation, and the rectangle formula. The datum need not be continuous or the trace of a preassigned psh function.
Proof. The real radius interval parametrizes a compact Gauss arc in . The graph of the Borel map is Borel in its product with the compact metrizable . The original rigid-fiber product identification makes a Borel subset of a fixed compact core of .
For any normalized ambient tester, its fiber restrictions are normalized on the entire . The Borel disintegration and exact singleton capacity in (eq:r6-arbitrary-radius-capacity) give the upper bound Fix . Finite Radon inner regularity and Lusin’s theorem give a compact with such that is continuous. Extend it continuously to by the Tietze extension theorem on the compact metrizable space . Apply Theorem “Continuous interpolation with arbitrary range slack” with range slack smaller than . It gives a continuous classical on the whole with . Every prefix partition consists of exact complete pole sets and its -oscillation tends to zero. Thus the already proved Theorem “A sharp formula for moving Gauss graphs”, applied to the Borel parameter subset , gives
Let be the compact Gauss arc of radii in . Its intrinsic capacity is : it contains the largest-radius Gauss point and is contained in the closed polydisc of that radius. The remaining graph is contained in the Borel rectangle . The rectangle theorem and outer subadditivity therefore imply On the other hand . Let and use . Every comparison uses the original whole capacity domain; no fiberwise supremum is interchanged with an integral. ◻
The remaining selection problem.
This result treats one scalar moving radial threshold over the explicit pole Cantor set. It does not extend an arbitrary family of intrinsic psh functions to a jointly psh ambient function, identify the capacity of arbitrary Borel subsets of , or settle unrestricted C1 or C2 for general backgrounds. The successful mechanism is exact scalar interpolation followed by finite-measure Lusin localization; weakly dense lists of fixed fiber testers would not follow these moving atoms.
Filled Borel radial tubes and their intermediate sets
Retain the explicit pole Cantor lamination, the finite measure , the background , and the same whole capacity domain from Corollary “Every bounded Borel radial graph in this lamination”. Let be Borel, , and let be Borel. Write for its diagonal Gauss graph and set The latter is the filled moving closed polydisc on each parameter fiber. Both sets are Borel and lie in the fixed compact core consisting of the radius- closed polydisc times .
Corollary (Exact capacity of filled tubes). Every Borel set with satisfies In particular this holds for the entire filled tube , in every .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the Borel graph formula and the same-domain rectangle formula. There is no new fiberwise selection or extremal-function assumption.
Proof. For each mesh size , partition the compact interval into finitely many disjoint Borel intervals of diameter at most . Put These are Borel parameter pieces and fixed compact intrinsic polydiscs. Their rectangles cover . The rectangle theorem and the exact radial calibration give Since is uniformly continuous on , the right side differs from by at most times its modulus of continuity at . Let . The graph inclusion and the proved graph formula give the matching raw lower bound. For any displayed , so every term equals the claimed integral.
The Borel assertion follows from the actual rigid-fiber product identification and the Borel inequality between the continuous function and the parameter function . Every tester used in the rectangle and graph inputs is normalized on the original whole domain . ◻
This computation includes nonsaturated Borel intermediate sets whenever they contain the Gauss graph. It does not identify the capacity of an arbitrary Borel subset of the lamination or settle general relative C2.
Why an ambient upper contact cannot recover relative compact mass
The following example eliminates a specific proposed route to compact outer regularity. It is not a counterexample to compact outer regularity itself. The completed representative and its ambient upper envelope must be kept separate even after the potential-quotient theorem of R5.
Proposition (Loss of all relative mass under an ambient upper envelope). Let , , and let be the open unit polydisc over the original , with coordinates . Put and . There are continuous classical with and such that:
belongs to the bounded relative completion for , and is a fixed nonzero positive measure;
the ambient upper semicontinuous regularization is , so ;
at every point of , no normalized upper semicontinuous majorant of on an ordinary neighborhood can contact . Such a is identically one on that part of .
In particular, if the majorant is classical, its relative top measure vanishes there. Nevertheless, itself is realized by a globally normalized continuous classical potential on .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen increasing completion and integration-current compatibility, with an explicit example. The upper-contact strategy it disproves is recorded as FAILED_ATTEMPT.
Proof. Choose a uniformizer , write , and fix . Set These are actual continuous classical functions, with . Define with on . The function is extended classical and nonpositive. Its logarithmic singularity is removed by the finite continuous lower branch in . Hence is continuous classical, , and increases. Its actual limit is The fixed-background increasing-limit theorem puts this actual function in the relative completion. For each classical row, restriction to the smooth analytic subspace gives where . Completed convergence gives exactly the same measure for . On the original product calibration each has mass at the radius- Gauss point in its coordinate. Thus, if is the Gauss point with all these radii, Only nonvanishing is needed below; the formula also makes it explicit.
Every point of is an ordinary limit of points outside . For example, after passage to its completed residue field, take the normal Gauss polydisc of radius centered at zero and let tend to zero; its images in approach the original point and lie outside . Therefore at every point of , and it is already one off . If is an upper semicontinuous majorant of on an ordinary neighborhood, upper semicontinuity along the same points forces on its intersection with . Since , there is no contact with there. When is classical, integration-current compatibility and ordinary locality imply on that neighborhood.
Finally the function , pulled back by the coordinate projection, is globally normalized and continuous classical on , and its relative measure is precisely the same . The example therefore invalidates upper-contact recovery for this representative, without invalidating the raw-capacity inequality for the measure. ◻
The precise excluded inference.
One cannot start from a completed potential , replace it by or by normalized ambient classical majorants, and use a contact inequality to conclude that the mass of on a compact set survives. In the example the contact set is empty near its positive atom. Any successful proof of general compact outer regularity must instead choose different testers, or supply an additional mechanism that transfers their compact mass while retaining the normalization on the same whole domain.
Relative Dirichlet problems and their constraints
A dual solvability criterion for the completed degree-one Dirichlet problem
Throughout this section is the original finite extension, with its prescribed absolute value. Let be an ordinary algebraic norm-box domain relatively compact in a smooth affine analytification of pure dimension . Fix an arbitrary symmetric original-positive, separately - and -closed -current . All tests are original compact smooth CLD tests. In particular, no smoothness, nonpolarity or geometric origin of is assumed.
Use the faithful measure and closed coercive form of Theorem R4–84.3. Choose where is compact and lies in a smaller norm box and is ordinary open. Write , with Hilbert norm . Fix the smooth classical outer potential and common bound from Section R4–80. Let be any nonempty convex subfamily of Let be its bounded global closure for all-domain local outer -capacity convergence, modulo local relative-null equality. Thus membership means approximation by this specified classical family, with its one bound and its actual exterior values. For put and .
Identification of the constraint in the faithful energy space
Proposition (The completed collar constraint is an energy-closed convex set). The map identifies with the nonempty closed bounded convex set It is injective on the indicated relative classes and satisfies
For every original compact smooth scalar supported in ,
Each class retains an actual representative bounded by and equal to on .
Status: NEW_PROVED for the identification of this completed constraint with a closed convex subset of the faithful form. Its ingredients are the previously proved energy and completion theorems.
Proof. For , the actual difference vanishes off . Choose an original smooth cutoff equal to one near and supported in . Proposition R4–86.1, including its support-preserving core approximations, puts in . The compact Green identity gives Relative CLN and the common bound give one uniform finite bound on , so these vectors form a bounded subset of .
Suppose a defining row converges in all-domain local outer capacity to a bounded completed potential . The completed weighted calculus, applied to the four terms defining , shows that as . In each of these four weighted terms insert the fixed original compact smooth cutoff equal to one near and supported in . The full signed energy is unchanged because vanishes off ; the individual terms are thereby legitimate compact test pairings. No finite total mass on all of or weak convergence against a Borel indicator is used. For complete detail, failure would give indices with a fixed positive lower bound; all four weighted terms along those two rows have the same completed limits with cancelling signs, a contradiction. Thus is Cauchy in .
Its limit is . Indeed the faithful reference potential is normalized and classical on , so on the fixed compact its measure satisfies for Borel . Capacity convergence, the common bound, and a positive-gap splitting therefore give convergence. Off all these differences are zero. Passing the energy identity through two defining rows proves (eq:r6-energy-completion-isometry).
Conversely, an -Cauchy sequence with is capacity Cauchy by the fixed-collar energy-capacity estimate. Reverse framed domain comparison gives the all-domain local condition. The bounded completion theorem supplies a limit in ; the preceding paragraph identifies its limit. Hence the energy closure is precisely the displayed set . Convexity follows either from the defining family or from its energy closure. If two classes have the same energy vector, their energy difference is zero; the same energy-capacity estimate makes every positive gap outer-null. This proves injectivity. The actual limsup representative from the bounded completion retains the common bound and exterior equality.
Finally Green’s identity holds for each classical defining row by Proposition R4–86.1. Its left side passes by strong form convergence, and its right side by completed weak convergence on the fixed original test. This proves (eq:r6-energy-current-pairing). ◻
An explicit family of linear inequalities on the datum
Let be ordinary open, or let . Set , regarded as a closed subspace of . The choice is allowed, with . For an original compact smooth scalar supported in , define the support functional of the prescribed classical constraints by
This is finite. It involves only the prescribed classical family and the fixed coefficient measures ; it contains no unknown solution and no unknown completed Monge–Ampere measure.
A finite positive Radon datum on is called finite-energy here if satisfies
This condition includes annihilation of energy-zero core functions. For example, with satisfies it, with norm at most , by coercivity. Neither for general bounded potentials nor an equality of energy-null and BT-null ideals is assumed.
Theorem (A smooth-test alternative for completed solvability). For a finite-energy datum , the following are equivalent.
There is with on all original compact smooth scalar tests, equivalently as Radon measures on .
For every original real compact smooth supported in ,
If these conditions fail, one such original smooth scalar test gives a strict reverse inequality. Thus nonsolvability has a single smooth-test separation certificate.
If the defining family additionally has one fixed actual exterior on , then the solution class is unique. If its defining rows are trapped between fixed continuous barriers on having the same boundary value , the selected solution representative has the ordinary boundary limit . These exterior and barrier conditions are hypotheses on the nonempty classical family; their availability for arbitrary boundary data is not asserted.
Status: NEW_PROVED for this exact finite-energy criterion over arbitrary fixed . The separating-space argument is elementary Hilbert-space duality. The criterion retains the full prescribed classical constraints through the explicit functional (eq:r6-classical-support-functional); it is not a bounded-subsolution criterion and does not assert that every positive datum is feasible.
Proof. The datum functional extends continuously to . Let be its Riesz vector: Let be orthogonal projection and put . The set is closed, bounded and convex in a Hilbert space, hence weakly compact. Its continuous linear image is weakly compact and convex, hence norm closed. In particular it is not necessary to assume that the image of an arbitrary unbounded closed convex set under a linear map is closed.
For every let . On the original smooth core this equals , by the energy closure defining and Green’s identity. Both support functionals are Lipschitz in the energy norm, with constant . Core density therefore extends (eq:r6-smooth-test-feasibility) to all .
If , all these inequalities hold. If , let be its nearest point in this closed convex set. The elementary projection inequality is For it gives Approximating in the energy norm by an original smooth core function preserves a strict positive gap. This proves the stated separation alternative and shows that the inequalities are equivalent to .
If for some , equation (eq:r6-energy-current-pairing) gives the required equality on all original tests in . Conversely such equality gives by core density. This proves the equivalence. Original smooth scalars determine the Radon measures by the same original compact Stone–Weierstrass argument already used for the strong data metric.
For uniqueness under fixed actual exterior values, choose the actual representatives supplied by the common defining rows. Then at every point of , including . The completed weighted product is therefore exactly when the two interior equations agree. Thus , and (eq:r6-energy-completion-isometry) and the capacity estimate give equality of the relative classes. No equality of their boundary measures is used. The actual limsup construction preserves the exterior values and both barriers, so continuity of the barriers at each ordinary boundary point gives the asserted boundary limit. ◻
Best feasible data and a quantitative certificate
Corollary (The energy-distance defect is exactly a support gap). With the preceding notation, set . Then
The minimum is attained. Its image measure is unique; under the fixed actual exterior hypothesis its completed potential class is unique. The retraction onto this feasible image is firmly nonexpansive in the negative-energy norm. More precisely, if are the Riesz vectors of two data and their nearest points in , then For , the feasible potential vectors themselves are the projections , so their energy distance is at most the data distance. For a proper interior domain the assertion concerns the projected vectors and the interior data; no unproved energy bound for the inverse of is asserted.
Proof. For any and , the bracket in (eq:r6-exact-separation-distance) is at most . For the nearest point , if , the direction attains equality in the Hilbert space. Approximation by the smooth core, with rescaling to the unit ball, gives the same supremum over the displayed original tests. If , every bracket is nonpositive and the zero test gives zero. The current pairing identifies the negative-energy norm of a data difference with , proving the minimum formula. Every point of has a lift in by its definition, so attainment gives an actual completed potential. Hilbert projection is unique, and original scalar tests distinguish the corresponding measures. Adding the two projection inequalities gives the displayed firm nonexpansiveness. The uniqueness and full-domain claims then follow from the theorem and from when . ◻
When the datum also lies in the admissible class of R4 and , this projection agrees with the previous variational retraction. Indeed for the degree-one Aubin–Mabuchi energy is so its datum objective equals . For completed potentials, this identity follows by classical defining rows and their strong energy limits; when actual datum integrals are used, R4’s capacity absolute continuity permits the same limit. The present finite-energy construction does not require that extra absolute continuity merely to define the Hilbert projection.
Frozen mixed slots.
For an arbitrary original-positive closed -background , put and fix . Apply this entire section to . It gives the same exact criterion for the linear mixed equation Here belongs to the completed constraint constructed for this fixed degree-one tail , and the displayed left side means . This does not assert that or that all of its slots may instead be varied in a jointly completed product over . This is a qualified all-dimensional mixed result with one free slot. It does not turn the diagonal equation with into a linear problem, and it does not establish an unrestricted bounded-subsolution theorem.
The feasibility inequalities themselves force finite energy
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “A smooth-test alternative for completed solvability”. This removes an a priori data assumption from the solvability alternative. Finite energy is still required for the quantitative Hilbert projection of arbitrary infeasible data.
Retain its fixed degree-one background, prescribed nonempty convex classical family , completed constraint , and ordinary interior domain . Let be any positive Radon measure on , initially only locally finite. Define on compact subsets and use the same support functional on original smooth compact scalars. Then the following are equivalent:
for some ;
for every real original ,
If they hold, is in fact finite on , has finite negative-energy norm, and all boundary and uniqueness conclusions of the preceding theorem apply. If they fail, there is an original compact smooth scalar giving a strict reverse inequality.
Proof. Set . By the support-functional identity and Cauchy–Schwarz, Applying the assumed feasibility inequality to both signs therefore gives Thus the datum defines a bounded functional on the original form core, annihilates its null vectors, and extends to the part space. The Riesz and projection proof of Theorem “A smooth-test alternative for completed solvability” now applies verbatim: its construction uses the datum only on these compact tests until it produces a completed potential. It gives as Radon measures. The left side has finite mass on , since lies in the fixed compact collar stage and relative CLN applies to the common defining bound. Hence .
Conversely, a completed solution has its energy vector in and hence satisfies every displayed support inequality. The strict failure alternative is the logical negation of these inequalities; for a finite-energy infeasible datum it is also supplied by the explicit Hilbert separation proof. If the datum has infinite negative-energy norm, the uniform bound shows directly that at least one signed original smooth test violates the inequality. ◻
This is not a replacement of the condition by positivity or by a bounded subsolution. The right side retains the full prescribed ambient classical constraints, and the toric certificate shows that those constraints exclude some smooth positive dominated data. The same corollary applies to a fixed mixed tail exactly in the qualified sense stated at the end of Section “A dual solvability criterion for the completed degree-one Dirichlet problem”.
Measure data and bounded subsolutions in the relative energy class
This section deliberately changes the admissible solution class. The solutions belong to the faithful relative energy space; they need not be ambient classical psh or belong to a bounded classical capacity completion. This distinction is essential even for smooth nonpolar backgrounds.
Fix an arbitrary original-positive symmetric separately closed -current on an ordinary norm-box neighborhood in the allowed space. Let , let and be the faithful measure and coercive regular form of Theorem R4–84.3, and fix an ordinary open . Put The part-space closure is the energy boundary condition. No pointwise boundary trace is built into that definition.
For a signed Radon measure on , define its possibly infinite core dual norm by Finiteness includes vanishing on zero-energy core functions. Total mass on need not be finite for this definition.
Lemma (Positive finite-energy functionals preserve order). Suppose a positive Radon measure has finite core dual norm. Its core integral extends to a bounded functional on , and for every with -almost everywhere. If and both have finite core dual norm, their extended functionals have the same order.
For every real ,
Proof. Core density gives the unique bounded extension. To verify positivity without assuming an integral formula for arbitrary energy vectors, take core in . Smooth nonnegative normal contractions approximating give nonnegative core functions whose energies are bounded by those of , and with in . For example choose the smoothing error small enough on the finite -mass of each individual core support. Since in , every weakly convergent subsequence of the bounded in has limit . Their nonnegative functional values therefore give . Apply this argument to for the order assertion.
The normal-contraction property from the frozen form theorem gives and . Expanding the two quadratic forms yields . Since , the displayed inequality follows. Thus no extra strong-local chain rule is needed for the order argument. ◻
Theorem (Finite-energy measure Dirichlet problem). Every signed Radon measure with finite has a unique satisfying Its coefficient-defined original current satisfies on every original compact smooth scalar test. The solution map is linear and For positive data the solution is nonpositive almost everywhere. If and both norms are finite, then almost everywhere and for the canonical energy-quasicontinuous representatives outside an energy-polar set.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the R4 faithful coercive form, now applied to finite-energy Radon data instead of only densities. It is not an ambient psh existence theorem.
Proof. Riesz representation in the energy Hilbert space gives the solution, uniqueness, and both equalities. Coefficient domination and coercivity make a well-defined current: on every compact stage its coefficient variations are bounded by a fixed multiple of , and . Approximation by the original core passes compact Green’s identity to This proves the asserted full original-test equation.
For positive , test the weak equation with . The preceding lemma gives Coercivity implies . Apply the identical argument to , whose datum is positive, for order comparison. A zero vector has zero canonical quasicontinuous representative outside an energy-polar set; normal contraction gives the stated representative version of these inequalities. This does not authorize arbitrary changes on merely -null sets. ◻
Theorem (Bounded subsolution domination in the energy class). Suppose and its original curvature on is a positive Radon measure. Then every positive Radon measure has finite energy and admits the unique solution from the preceding theorem, with The order and bound first hold almost everywhere, and hold for canonical energy representatives outside an energy-polar set.
If in addition has a continuous energy representative on extending to a bounded continuous function on , with on and on the ordinary boundary, then has a bounded actual Borel representative on such that at every point. Consequently has ordinary boundary limit zero. It represents the same current and canonical relative energy class. No interior continuity or classical psh property is asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY with a complete proof of the datum bound. This is a bounded-subsolution criterion in the larger relative energy class; the corresponding unrestricted claim in the bounded classical completion remains false.
Proof. For a real core function set . It is nonnegative, smooth, vanishes at zero, and has derivative of absolute value at most one. Thus is a nonnegative original core function and its energy is at most that of . The original current equation for and compact Green give Let using monotone convergence on the compact support. Since , This proves the required dual bound without assuming finite total mass near . The same argument shows that has finite energy. Its energy solution is exactly , by uniqueness and the original core equation. The order comparison gives and the stated bounds.
For the last assertion take the canonical energy representative on . Outside one energy-polar exceptional set it is finite and lies between and zero. Assign value zero on that exceptional set and off . This gives a Borel representative with the displayed pointwise bounds. The exceptional set is -null, hence these changes preserve the coefficient-defined current; by the one-way energy-to-BT capacity theorem they also preserve the canonical relative capacitary class. The squeeze between and zero proves the ordinary boundary limit. The role of is explicit; a part-space boundary condition alone was not turned into an ordinary pointwise boundary assertion. ◻
Proposition (Relative Dini-capacity growth supplies finite energy). Let be compact and let be a positive Radon measure supported in , of mass . Let be finite and nondecreasing, and assume Suppose for every Borel , where the right side is zero when the capacity is zero. Then has finite energy and hence a unique relative energy Dirichlet solution. If is the constant in the frozen one-way capacity comparison, then
For , , the right side is at most These hypotheses alone do not assert boundedness, ambient psh, or membership in the bounded classical completion of the solution.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem R4–85.2, by the following layer-cake calculation. The two capacities are not identified.
Proof. For an original real core function , put . The energy capacity definition, applied to , and coercivity give Consequently, with , The growth hypothesis and monotonicity of imply If , the same capacity estimate makes the integral zero. Otherwise split its layer-cake integral at , and substitute in the upper part. One obtains Take the core supremum and then the infimum over . The Dini assumption makes these quantities finite (also for every other finite , by local boundedness of ). For a power choose when ; the zero-datum case is trivial. ◻
Frozen mixed slots.
All statements apply with in place of , for any arbitrary allowed original background and fixed bounded classical slots. The solution then lies in the faithful part energy space for and satisfies . This is a linear equation in its one unfrozen potential, not a diagonal nonlinear equation with moving energy potentials. In particular no new arbitrary-current wedge or unproved completion inclusion is being introduced.
Sharp Hardy control from a bounded energy subsolution
Retain the arbitrary degree-one background, faithful measure , and part Hilbert space of Section “Measure data and bounded subsolutions in the relative energy class”. The potential in this section is an energy vector, not an assumed classical or completed psh function. In particular its values on an arbitrary -null set are never used to define a measure multiplier.
Lemma (The bounded chain test in the closed core). Let satisfy -almost everywhere, where . For an original real compact smooth in and , the function class belongs to and has support in the compact support of . Its form pairing satisfies
No integral of against is required to formulate or prove this assertion.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the closed-core gradient calculus. The following construction records the approximation and admissibility explicitly.
Proof. For original core functions , their energy measures are absolutely continuous with respect to . The original positive-square inequality gives their measure-valued Cauchy–Schwarz inequality. One may therefore form the Hilbert module generated by symbols with bounded Borel coefficients, with first for finite sums and then by quotient and completion. Positivity holds pointwise after taking densities; for any finite family the matrix is positive semidefinite almost everywhere, as can be tested on rational coefficient vectors. Bounded Borel multiplication is well defined in this module.
If is an original core sequence converging to in , then is Cauchy and defines . The energy-measure inequality also shows that is Cauchy in total variation, with limit absolutely continuous with respect to . In particular These are closed-form objects, independent of any actual representative of on a null set.
For a smooth function with and bounded derivative, this construction proves the chain rule directly. Pass to a subsequence with -almost everywhere. The smooth core rule and show convergence in the gradient module. The second term tends to zero by bounded convergence against the fixed . Lipschitz continuity gives the limit , so closability yields and . The approximants are still original core functions in , since .
Choose such a smooth global agreeing with on . Multiplication by a fixed original compact smooth function is bounded in the form norm, by the frozen coefficient estimate. Hence with original core approximations supported inside . The product and chain rules give The nonnegative module square is now exactly This proves (eq:r6-closed-core-picone). Writing would give the usual Picone identity, but no global form membership of the constant is needed. ◻
Theorem (The energy-subsolution Hardy constant). Let and suppose that is a positive Radon measure on . Put . For every positive Radon measure and every original real compact smooth in ,
The coefficient one multiplying is optimal.
The core restriction map extends uniquely to It is the trace of the canonical part-form energy-quasicontinuous representative, not of an arbitrary -almost-everywhere representative. The bounded energy solution from Theorem “Bounded subsolution domination in the energy class” still satisfies . If , its norm also obeys
No membership of or in a psh class is asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the closed-core Picone identity and the already proved positive-functional and bounded-energy-subsolution theorems. The sharp constant and the measure-trace consequence are included in full.
Proof. The original core Green identity identifies , so has finite core dual norm. The bounded-energy-subsolution theorem gives finite energy for , and the positive-functional lemma gives their extensions with on the positive cone of . That same theorem gives in the energy order.
For the test of the preceding lemma, the almost-everywhere inequality is an inequality between vectors of . Consequently Only the first integral is an integral of an original smooth core function. In particular this argument has not presumed an actual integral formula for , nor used the trace inequality it is proving. Let to obtain (eq:r6-energy-subsolution-hardy); the case follows too.
The inequality makes original core approximations Cauchy in and gives the unique bounded map . It also shows that charges no part-form energy-polar Borel set: for a compact set, apply the compact-core formula for the part energy capacity to functions at least one on it, and then use Radon inner regularity. A form-convergent core sequence has a subsequence converging outside an energy-polar set to the canonical energy-quasicontinuous representative. Its limit is therefore that representative -almost everywhere. This identifies the trace without authorizing arbitrary changes on a merely -null set.
The already proved bounded-energy-subsolution theorem supplies the order bounds and . If , ordinary Cauchy–Schwarz for a core and (eq:r6-energy-subsolution-hardy) give Riesz isometry proves (eq:r6-bounded-energy-data-height). ◻
Example (Sharpness with an original annular tent). Let on an annulus containing , and put , . For any the function belongs to , has essential supremum norm , and satisfies on . Its part-space membership follows by cutting off its zero-boundary linear tails and smoothing; both the real one-dimensional energy and the bounded actual functions converge. Original smooth compact approximations of have Thus the constant in the trace inequality cannot be reduced. The same example attains the height-mass norm bound in the limit.
Corollary (Form-small perturbations from a bounded energy barrier). Under the theorem’s assumptions, if and , then is a bounded coercive form on , with . Every functional therefore has a unique weak solution , and . For this is, on all original compact tests, The product is locally integrable by the trace bound and local Radon finiteness. This is a linear energy equation; no Markov property of the perturbed form and no classical psh solution are asserted.
Proof. The trace inequality gives boundedness and the displayed lower bound. The coercive Hilbert-space Riesz theorem proves existence, uniqueness and the norm estimate. The original core Green identity gives the stated sign of the distributional equation. ◻
For the annular example, with , one has . At the nonzero vector is even a weak kernel vector, since at the support of and . For the form is negative on . Thus the universal strict coercivity threshold cannot be enlarged under only the stated barrier-height hypothesis.
A bounded continuous energy solution with no local classical potential
Retain , the full torus box , its smooth background , the real compact set , and the probability from Section “Relative BT and energy capacities can have different null sets”. Scale inside a real ball with and put The ordinary domain is relatively compact in .
Lemma (A bounded local potential can be extended near Gauss points). Let , let be an ordinary neighborhood of , and let . There are a real box , an ordinary neighborhood of inside , and a bounded classical psh function on the full polyannulus such that for a Laurent polynomial that is an analytic unit there, and finite constants . Consequently on .
If a family of such has one bound on a fixed ordinary neighborhood, the box, , , , , and the bound for can all be chosen independently of the member of that family.
Status: NEW_PROVED elementary local extension for this Gauss-section geometry. A general ordinary neighborhood is not assumed to contain a full tropical box.
Proof. Shrink the given ordinary neighborhood so that there. The topology of the affine torus analytification is generated by absolute values of Laurent polynomials. A finite basic neighborhood therefore gives nonzero Laurent polynomials and strict lower and upper bounds around their values at . For every analytic point of the torus, by the ultrametric inequality on its Laurent monomials. The Gauss norms on the right vary continuously with the real coordinates. After shrinking a real box around , all upper bounds of the basic neighborhood consequently hold on its entire tropical inverse image. Thus for suitable the set lies in the fixed ordinary neighborhood where the bound holds. If no lower bound is needed, this is already a full polyannulus; take and the assertion is immediate.
Otherwise set , , , and . Shrink further so that On the Gauss section over one has . At any relative boundary point of inside the full polyannulus, at least one lower bound is an equality; the remaining Gauss upper bounds imply there. Put and choose with . Define Near each relative boundary point the expression inside the maximum is negative, by the uniform bound on and continuity of . Thus the two definitions agree with the constant zero on an ordinary neighborhood of every gluing point. They define a bounded classical psh function on the full polyannulus. Its bound is at most .
On the ordinary open subset of where , the second branch is strictly positive. This subset contains the whole Gauss section over the small box. There , an original smooth pluriharmonic function since is a unit. Separate closedness of gives the current equality. All choices used only the fixed neighborhood and the bound , proving the uniform assertion. ◻
Proposition (Local outer-nullity for every bounded classical trace). Let be any ordinary neighborhood of in the torus, with restricted there. Every satisfies More locally, on each sufficiently small ordinary neighborhood of a point of , the corresponding portion of has relative outer BT capacity zero for normalized testers on that neighborhood. The same nonconcentration holds for locally uniformly bounded completed relative potentials.
Proof. At each point of apply the preceding lemma, and then restrict to a smaller real box with compact closure in . The full-box Gauss-section growth estimate of Lemma “Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers”, after a fixed affine normalization of the bounded , implies that gives zero mass to every Gauss subset of zero measure in that smaller box. On the protected ordinary neighborhood its curvature equals . Finitely many such neighborhoods cover , proving the first assertion.
For the capacity assertion start with normalized on one fixed ordinary neighborhood. The extension lemma uses the same data and the same bound for every such tester. Cover a compact portion of in the protected neighborhood by small real balls with arbitrarily small sum of st radius powers. Intersect their ordinary tropical inverse images with a fixed relatively compact protected neighborhood. The full-box mass estimate gives arbitrarily small capacity for these ordinary open neighborhoods, uniformly over the original normalized class. This proves the local outer-null assertion on its stated capacity domain.
For completed potentials use their locally uniformly bounded defining rows on smaller ordinary neighborhoods. The same construction and normalization give the same uniform open-neighborhood mass bound. Ordinary weak convergence and the open-set inequality pass that bound to the positive completed curvature measure. Letting the bound tend to zero proves the last assertion. No restriction to is passed directly through a weak limit. ◻
Theorem (Finite energy and bounded continuous solution without a psh trace). The probability has finite core energy norm on . There is a bounded continuous actual function on , zero on the ordinary boundary, such that on every original compact smooth scalar test. This is the unique energy-class solution.
Nevertheless, no ordinary neighborhood of has a locally bounded actual classical psh potential with . Nor can such an equation be solved by a locally uniformly bounded completed relative potential. In particular there is no bounded classical subsolution whose relative curvature dominates near .
Status: NEW_PROVED separation of solution classes and local representability, using the preceding null-set construction. The energy Riesz theorem itself remains a direct input.
Proof. For an original compact smooth in , the Newton trace inequality and the all-original-test restriction-energy bound give Thus has finite energy.
We construct its bounded continuous solution explicitly. Let be the positive Newton kernel with , and put . The Frostman bound used in Lemma “A compact real set with the two needed size properties” implies uniformly in Splitting the kernel into this small tail and its continuous far part proves that is bounded and continuous. Its weak gradient is locally square integrable: the vector-kernel convolution bound from the same lemma, applied first to smooth approximations of , bounds its gradient norm by a fixed multiple of . Passing weakly and using local uniform convergence identifies the gradient of .
The measure is supported away from , so is smooth near that sphere. Let be the ordinary real Poisson extension to of its boundary values, and set . Equivalently, is the positive Dirichlet Green potential of in the ball. Hence The standard ball Poisson kernel gives the displayed harmonic extension; positivity of its Green kernel gives the sign. These are ordinary real integral identities, not an elliptic regularity claim for a Berkovich distribution.
To verify the zero-boundary energy class directly, put . It is continuous with compact support in . The Sobolev contraction rule and show in : the gradient difference is supported where and tends to zero by dominated convergence. Mollification then gives real smooth compact functions converging to in energy and uniformly on . Their toric pullbacks are original compact smooth functions in , and (eq:r6-torus-laplace-calibration) makes their energy differences exactly the real ones. The frozen coercivity and uniform convergence identify their part-space limit with the actual bounded continuous function . Thus . Continuity on and the ordinary zero boundary value follow from the real boundary values and proper tropicalization.
It remains to check the equation on all original tests. Extend by zero beyond and convolve on the real box. The resulting smooth converge locally uniformly to . On each fixed compact subset of , for sufficiently small convolution radius, ; any boundary contribution is outside that compact set. For an arbitrary original compact smooth scalar test in , the original torus calibration gives Here is a continuous compact test, not assumed smooth in one real chart. On the other hand, uniform coefficient multiplication of the fixed gives convergence of the left-hand currents to . This proves the equation on the full original test class. Energy uniqueness is the frozen Riesz uniqueness theorem.
Finally, Proposition “Local outer-nullity for every bounded classical trace” makes every locally bounded classical or locally uniformly bounded completed relative curvature give zero mass to . Since , it cannot equal or be dominated by such a curvature. This proves all the asserted nonrepresentability statements. ◻
Scope.
The background is smooth and fixed, the solution is actually bounded and continuous, and the failure is local near its compact datum. It is therefore stronger than a failure of one prescribed boundary value problem. The successful solution belongs to the larger faithful energy class. It supplies neither a new ambient psh solution nor a counterexample to general relative compact no-gain or Borel outer regularity.
Consequences of the toric capacity and energy separation
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY. Retain the notation of Theorems “Strict separation of the two capacity null ideals” and “Finite energy and bounded continuous solution without a psh trace”; in particular , , and .
No local difference of bounded classical psh potentials.
There is no locally bounded actual function near which is locally a difference of two members of and satisfies . Indeed, on each ordinary neighborhood with , Proposition “Local outer-nullity for every bounded classical trace” makes both positive measures and vanish on the corresponding portion of . Their signed difference therefore vanishes there. A finite ordinary covering of the compact gives , contradicting . The same argument applies to local differences of locally uniformly bounded completed relative potentials. In particular the explicit bounded continuous energy solution in Theorem “Finite energy and bounded continuous solution without a psh trace” lies outside the local bounded DSH class near its datum. This statement does not assert a failure of the frozen potential-quotient theorem, whose hypotheses require an actual classical difference from the start.
Relative BT nullity does not mean ambient pluripolarity.
Fix . Choose larger than every positive coordinate increment for , and put It is a normalized continuous convex function on , so its toric pullback is an actual ambient classical tester on the whole . The original torus slope-simplex calibration gives Indeed the only full-dimensional slope polytope is at ; its volume is , canceled by the original top-degree factor . The identity is valid on all original scalar tests, by the same convex smoothing calibration used for the frozen radial examples. Consequently The tester can be restricted to any ordinary neighborhood of while preserving its normalization and its atom. Thus the frozen local ambient polar outer-zero theorem (Corollary R4–26.3) excludes a local pluripolar witness at every point of . The discrepancy already occurs for the smooth fixed used here; it does not depend on a background carried by an ambient pluripolar set.
An explicit energy-dual certificate for the nonpolar obstruction
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new separation criterion, with the following explicit real-variable calculation. The underlying failure of a bounded-subsolution theorem is the frozen R4 counterexample. The added conclusion is a strictly positive, quantified distance from the datum to the feasible completed image in the negative-energy norm, witnessed by an original compact smooth test.
Let , on the original -torus, and Choose a larger ordinary norm-box domain in the torus, containing , and ordinary and compact with . Put and choose a common bound larger than its bound on . Use the nonempty convex family All its members have one common global bound and collar. Its selected completed limits retain ordinary boundary value zero.
Take a nonzero radial with , supported in for some . Set The smooth subsolution has on . The signed datum has finite energy: on the compact , the smooth coefficient measure has a bounded density against the faithful , so its density and that of belong to .
Proposition (A positive distance despite a bounded subsolution). There are , , and such that
In particular the smooth-test feasibility inequality fails for some original compact smooth scalar on . Here is precisely the bounded global capacity closure of the displayed family, not an unspecified local sheaf.
Proof. Write and consider the explicit radial function It is the smooth real solution of with zero boundary value; the integral is regular at zero because its inner integral is . Moreover because . For , with one has and . Choose with . On a sufficiently small real neighborhood of , for some . Choose a nonzero nonnegative smooth compactly supported there.
Let be the real weak solution of It is obtained directly by Riesz representation for the gradient norm: . Consequently
Choose converging to in that norm and set . These are original compact smooth scalars on . The original torus calibration gives Thus they converge to a vector , with . Only this form-domain vector and its original smooth approximations are needed; no arbitrary energy representative is called a classical psh function.
For let be its actual Gauss trace. The R4 full-annulus argument makes separately convex and continuous on , and . These bounds also put in . To see this without an unproved trace assertion, for set . On each coordinate segment of radius about , one has . Convexity bounds each slope at in absolute value by . On interior real boxes, Fubini therefore gives uniformly bounded weak coordinate derivatives. The zero boundary limit, squeezed between and zero, makes the zero extension a Sobolev function with zero trace. Hence .
For each original , calibration and Green give Pass in the real gradient pairing and in the faithful form pairing to obtain The inequality uses the positive distribution and . It is uniform over the entire classical family. Thus its support functional satisfies .
Let be the Riesz vector of the datum. The same calibration, together with and zero real boundary values, gives
Subtract the support bound. The gap is at least . Normalize by and use (eq:r6-real-test-energy) and Corollary “The energy-distance defect is exactly a support gap” to obtain (eq:r6-toric-distance-lower-bound). The support functional is energy-continuous on the bounded constraint, so the strict gap persists for some original . This is the promised original-test certificate, not only an abstract nonsmooth separating direction. ◻
The pointwise lower and upper barriers are satisfied by itself. The obstruction is its negative coordinate Hessian in the outer annulus, which a Gauss trace of a globally defined classical psh row cannot have. This calculation does not identify raw BT capacity with energy capacity, and does not assert that all coefficient measures of live on the Gauss skeleton. Only the specified toric top pairings are used.
A checkable radial criterion for a smooth toric background
This qualified family supplies actual classical solutions as well as an exact obstruction. It is a remaining-degree-one statement for the specified smooth background, not a replacement for the arbitrary- criteria above.
Fix , put , and let Write for the original Gauss section. The ordinary boundary below is taken in the ambient analytic torus. Its Gauss points include ; it is not necessary to identify the entire boundary with every fiber above .
Proposition (Radial classical solvability). Let be nonnegative and set There exists a bounded actual classical psh on such that on every original compact scalar test and if and only if
When this condition holds, one such solution is the continuous torus-invariant function
Every bounded classical solution with the stated boundary values has this same actual Gauss-section trace . This assertion does not claim uniqueness of all actual values away from that trace.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen whole-domain Gauss-trace argument, original toric calibration, and the elementary radial computation below. No general relative subsolution theorem is assumed.
Proof. The formula for gives For , Both and tend to at zero. Thus is on , continuous on its closure, solves , and has boundary value zero.
Suppose an actual bounded classical solution exists, and put . On every coordinate segment contained in , the complete-extension annulus construction of Lemma “Uniform Gauss-section growth for all classical testers” applies inside this full tropical inverse-image domain. Its two-endpoint Shilov comparison shows that is separately convex. Its boundedness therefore makes it locally Lipschitz on .
For each , the pullback is an original compact smooth scalar on . Recursion and the original toric calibration give Only this top trace is calibrated; no assertion about support of every lower coefficient measure of is used.
Every Gauss point with belongs to the ordinary boundary of , by approaching through the real ball and using continuity of . The specified ordinary boundary limit hence extends continuously by zero to . Therefore is a continuous distributionally harmonic function on with zero boundary values, and is zero. One can verify this last uniqueness directly: mollify on successively smaller balls, apply the ordinary smooth harmonic maximum principle there, and let their boundaries approach , using uniform continuity on the closed ball.
Consequently every such solution has trace . Separate convexity on the first coordinate axis, at , implies . The displayed derivative formula is exactly (eq:r6-radial-convexity-condition), proving necessity.
Conversely, suppose that condition holds. Then and . The radial Hessian has eigenvalues in the radial direction and in the tangential directions, with their stated common limit at zero. It is positive semidefinite, so is convex. A continuous convex function of original logarithmic unit moments is classical psh: on compact smaller moment domains one may use convex smooth mollifications, or the defining curve test with harmonic logarithmic unit coordinates. Thus the function in (eq:r6-radial-toric-solution) is actual continuous classical psh on .
The calibration first holds for smooth real . Apply ordinary real mollification on compact smaller balls to , with convergence, or pass the fixed continuous multiplier through the original distributional recursion. It gives on every original scalar test. Finally every ordinary boundary point of has , by continuity of ; the continuous formula gives the required boundary limits. ◻
Two immediate checks.
If is nondecreasing, then , so the criterion holds. In particular constant density gives . In contrast, if is nonzero and vanishes on some terminal interval , then there while , and the criterion fails. The latter recovers the frozen compact radial-source obstruction while the former gives a direct solvable family in every ambient dimension. No nonlinear Gauss-pushforward formula is asserted for several moving slots.
Admissible variations in every remaining degree
Fix the original field and test sheaf, an arbitrary fixed original-positive separately closed -background , and . Retain the norm-box domain , compact outer collar set , smooth outer potential , and common bound of the R4 completed variational construction. Let be ordinary open with . As in Section R4–81, prescribe an actual exterior function on and continuous barriers on with the same ordinary boundary value . Assume that the classical family is nonempty. Its bounded global capacity closure is denoted . It is convex and capacity closed, and its selected actual representatives retain the exterior, both barriers, and boundary value.
Let be admissible data in the precise R4 sense, and write . The completed variational objective is Its unique maximizing class is denoted . Different admissible extensions of outside change by a constant on , because every selected representative has the same actual exterior . Thus they do not change .
What a verified two-sided variation gives quantitatively
Proposition (A stationarity estimate with an explicit admissible radius). Let be original smooth. There is a finite , depending only on the fixed collar data, , the common bound and this test, with the following property. If and for some , then for ,
In particular, at the maximizer the displayed integral is zero whenever some two-sided admissible radius exists for this test. Moreover, for all ,
The previously proved energy-dual and energy-capacity estimates turn this into the corresponding quantitative errors for the fixed-background measure and potential class.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the proved compact-collar energy polynomial, relative CLN and the R4 midpoint inequality. The displayed radius is an actual admissibility hypothesis; an obstacle gap alone does not provide it.
Proof. Convexity makes admissible for . The finite-polynomial energy identity and compact Green formula give and These identities for completed potentials follow from their defining classical rows and the completed weighted calculus, exactly as in Lemma R4–82.2. Equivalently the second identity follows by polarization of the finite polynomial; the smooth compact function is the only differentiated direction. The last integrand is positive. Relative CLN applied to the fixed positive test bounds its total mass by , uniformly over the admissible segment. Every member has the same bound . Hence The left side is at most ; use both signs and the support of to obtain (eq:r6-stationarity-defect). At a maximizer let .
For the last assertion, the midpoint belongs to and the linear datum term cancels from its midpoint difference. Thus which is (eq:r6-objective-energy-gap). ◻
A classical curvature reserve that supplies the missing directions
For each original compact smooth in , the explicit R4 compensator lemma supplies a bounded nonnegative original smooth classical function on such that Its proof uses finite unit-moment presentations and a positive sum of smooth convex functions of logarithms of affine regular functions. In particular this assertion does not invoke a general equivalence between original-current positivity and classical psh.
Theorem (A qualified interior Dirichlet criterion in all degrees). Suppose there is a classical maximizing sequence , with , having the following property for every original . There are an ordinary neighborhood of , with , constants , , and an index , such that for all :
the actual function belongs to ;
on one has the simultaneous margins
Then the maximizing completed class solves on all original compact tests. Its selected representative retains the actual exterior and ordinary boundary value . It is the unique relative class in solving this interior equation.
Status: CONDITIONAL as a Dirichlet existence criterion: the stated uniform reserve and margins are the additional input. Their availability is not claimed for arbitrary data or from a bounded subsolution. The implication itself is proved below for every remaining degree and every allowed fixed background.
Proof. Fix and choose a positive with On the decomposition is a sum of classical psh functions. The second factor is classical by convexity of the classical cone and the two compensator endpoints. Off the support of it equals . These local assertions glue on the ordinary topology. The value margins preserve all bounds and barrier inequalities, and the compact support inside preserves the entire actual exterior. Therefore
Every maximizing sequence converges to in all-domain local outer capacity by the R4 variational theorem. Adding the same smooth function does not change its positive gap sets. The two sequences just constructed therefore define in the same completed constraint . The preceding proposition, or the exact R4 Euler inequality applied to these two competitors, gives This holds for every original compact smooth scalar test in , so it is the required Radon-measure equality. No maximum locus has been treated as an ordinary open set, and no contact-support formula is used.
For two solutions , their selected actual difference vanishes on , including the ordinary boundary. Consequently The fixed-collar energy-capacity estimate proves equality of their relative classes. The preserved continuous barriers give the ordinary boundary limit, as in the R4 interior theorem. ◻
How the reserve can be checked, and what it does not assert.
Condition (1) is an actual classical decomposition on a prescribed ordinary neighborhood. For potentials represented on one finite unit chart, a uniform Hessian margin that dominates the compensator Hessian on an open neighborhood of the compact moment image verifies it by convex composition after every complete-extension curve pullback. For a finite cover one verifies the condition on every member of that cover. A merely positive difference of two original currents is not silently substituted for this actual-function hypothesis.
The radius must be independent of the index for each fixed test. Vanishing margins or reserves along a maximizing row do not justify the limit argument. The smooth nonpolar counterexample of R4 shows why some additional condition of this kind is necessary for this route: ordinary boundary barriers and a bounded subsolution alone do not supply the two-sided psh variations. No strict psh exhaustion of an arbitrary analytic domain is assumed here.
Approximate admissible directions and vanishing reserves
Retain the arbitrary fixed original-positive separately closed , all , the common defining bound and collar, the convex completed constraint , and the actual boundary data of Section “Admissible variations in every remaining degree”. Write , let be the same admissible datum, and put All pairings below use actual selected representatives, or equivalently their relative classes: each measure being used annihilates the relevant relative-null sets. Measures are restricted to the fixed compact when an norm is written. No whole-domain finite mass is required.
Lemma (The completed first-order energy remainder). For define Then
The map is convex, , and for each fixed one has as .
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Corollary R4–38.4 and the completed weighted calculus; it is not a new energy inequality.
Proof. For classical common-collar potentials the frozen polynomial calculation gives Pass to bounded defining classical rows. Every term is evaluated with one fixed compact original smooth cutoff equal to one near , so the completed weighted calculus passes each finite term. Positivity gives the two stated bounds. The objective identity is its defining algebra. Convexity follows from concavity of . Along a fixed segment the energy is a polynomial, and the derivative at zero is precisely . Thus its constant and linear remainders cancel, which proves the assertion. ◻
Theorem (A criterion using approximate feasible variations). Let be a maximizing sequence and set ; monotonicity of these numbers is unnecessary. Suppose that for every original real there are numbers and feasible such that
Then the maximizing completed class solves on all original compact smooth tests. It retains the prescribed actual exterior and ordinary boundary trace, and is the unique solution class in .
More precisely, for each sign and each index,
Status: CONDITIONAL as a solvability criterion, with the explicitly stated feasible-direction conditions. Its implication and error estimate are DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen energy identities. No availability of these competitors for arbitrary data is asserted.
Proof. Since , the exact identity (eq:r6-energy-remainder-identity) gives The signed residual is dominated in total variation by . Subtract the indicated approximate direction and use the upper bound for to obtain (eq:r6-approximate-variation-defect).
Every maximizing sequence converges to in all-domain local outer relative capacity. The completed calculus therefore gives on the fixed original test . Let in both signs of the estimate. The residual pairing vanishes for every such , proving equality of the Radon measures on . The boundary and uniqueness assertions are those of Theorem “A qualified interior Dirichlet criterion in all degrees”: actual differences of two feasible representatives vanish outside , including its boundary, so the interior equation gives . No assertion that boundary Monge–Ampere masses themselves agree is needed. ◻
Corollary (An admissible radius may tend to zero). Suppose for each original there are positive radii such that Then the conclusion of the preceding theorem holds. The radii need not have a positive lower bound.
For classical , these hypotheses are verified by the actual curvature reserve and value margins of Theorem “A qualified interior Dirichlet criterion in all degrees”, with index-dependent positive reserves and margins , provided one can choose
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY as an implication; the existence of such a rate-controlled maximizing row is an additional CONDITIONAL hypothesis, not a consequence of a bounded subsolution.
Proof. Write . If , choose . Then and . If , choose . Convexity preserves feasibility at the smaller radius. Proposition “A stationarity estimate with an explicit admissible radius” gives The maximizing-sequence limit proves the equation. For the final assertion, the compensator decomposition and ordinary-open gluing in the earlier reserve proof apply separately for each index, with the displayed radius. No fixed-radius perturbation is passed to the limit. ◻
The exact tangent cone that these tests must reach
Proposition (Feasible tangent directions and the residual). Fix and set . In let This is a closed convex cone. A function belongs to it if and only if there exist and with At the variational maximizer the residual has the exact polar condition Conversely this condition characterizes the maximizer. The residual annihilates the lineality space . Consequently, if that space contains every original compact smooth scalar test in , the maximizer solves the interior equation.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of convexity and the proved energy polynomial. This identifies a precise remaining admissibility condition; it does not assert that this lineality space contains all smooth tests for a general background.
Proof. The set before closure is a convex cone: the sum of two elements is their total nonnegative coefficient times a convex combination of the two competitors minus . Any sequence in the displayed equivalent description lies in this cone, proving one inclusion.
For the converse choose in . Along the fixed segment to , the last assertion of Lemma “The completed first-order energy remainder” implies for each fixed . Choose decreasing to zero, with , and with this quotient at most . Then is feasible, its normalized difference is exactly , and it has the required negligible first-order cost.
The functional is continuous on with norm at most one. The frozen Euler inequality holds on , hence on its cone and closure. Conversely the polar inequality includes every and therefore is the frozen characterization of maximality. Using both and gives zero on the lineality space. For original tests this is precisely the stated measure equality. ◻
The first-order energy requirement does not enlarge this closed feasible tangent cone: the proposition proves equality with the usual tangent cone. In particular energy estimates cannot silently remove incompatible trace, curvature, or actual-boundary constraints. Vanishing reserves alone give no conclusion; the objective-defect to radius ratio in Corollary “An admissible radius may tend to zero” is the quantitative condition that permits them.
An exact curvature test for actual admissible variations
The new bounded-difference positivity theorem removes one previously separate feasibility premise in the variational argument. It applies to actual classical potentials and their smooth perturbations. It does not identify an arbitrary relative completed representative with an ambient classical function.
Lemma (Smooth directions belong locally to the difference class). Every real original smooth function is locally a difference of locally bounded classical psh functions. Consequently, for actual and , on all original compact complementary positive tests.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of Theorem “Positivity determines the bounded classical difference cone”.
Proof. Near a given point write in original unit logarithms. Shrink to a relatively compact convex real ball on which the Hessian of is bounded. For a sufficiently large , both and are convex there. Their pullbacks are bounded classical on a smaller ordinary neighborhood: after every complete extension and curve pullback the unit logarithms are harmonic, and convex composition is subharmonic. Their difference is . Thus is locally a bounded classical difference for either sign of . The new positivity criterion, applied locally and glued on ordinary opens, proves the implication from the curvature condition. The converse implication is the established positivity of classical curvature. ◻
Retain the actual constrained family and its data from Section “Admissible variations in every remaining degree”. In particular every member is bounded by , equals the prescribed actual exterior on , and lies between the actual barriers on . Fix and a real original . On put Define two extended nonnegative numbers by
The infimum of an empty family is . Tests in the second line range over the full original positive cone, with arbitrary compact support and moment refinements.
Proposition (Exact two-sided radius in the actual family). For , In particular these two explicitly defined quantities give the maximal admissible two-sided radius, including its finite endpoint. The curvature radius is equivalently It is unchanged by adding an actual pluriharmonic function to ; the value radius need not be unchanged.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY. This is an actual feasibility criterion, not a Dirichlet existence assertion.
Proof. The two original-current inequalities hold exactly when for every displayed positive test. Tests with zero denominator give an automatic inequality. Thus the curvature inequalities are equivalent to , including the infimum endpoint. The preceding lemma identifies them with actual classicality of both perturbed functions.
The simultaneous bounds and are exactly the inequalities on the support of . They hold precisely when . Elsewhere nothing changes. Compact support in preserves the entire prescribed actual exterior, hence also the fixed outer collar. These are all the defining conditions of , proving the equivalence. The curvature-radius assertion about pluriharmonic functions follows from ; the value constraints refer to the actual chosen function and do not have that invariance. ◻
Corollary (The variational reserve can be checked in current order). In Theorem “A qualified interior Dirichlet criterion in all degrees”, replace its first hypothesis by the original-current inequality Retain every other hypothesis, in particular the actual classical maximizing sequence, the uniform positive reserve for each fixed test, the actual bound and barrier margins, and the specified datum class. Then the same completed interior Dirichlet conclusion and relative-class uniqueness hold for every remaining degree and every allowed fixed positive closed .
The vanishing-radius version in Corollary “An admissible radius may tend to zero” can likewise use these current inequalities in place of its actual classical reserve, while retaining the stated quantitative relation between objective deficit and radius.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY for this replacement. As a Dirichlet criterion it remains CONDITIONAL on the displayed reserves, margins and maximizing sequence; their existence is not proved for arbitrary data.
Proof. On the actual function is a locally bounded classical difference. Its original curvature is nonnegative by the new hypothesis, so Theorem “Positivity determines the bounded classical difference cone” makes that actual function classical. This is precisely the previous first hypothesis. The remaining proof, including the capacity passage of the two actual perturbed rows and preservation of the ordinary boundary data, is unchanged. The same reasoning applies separately at each positive radius in the vanishing-radius argument; it does not supply the required rate automatically. ◻
What remains essential.
Curvature positivity now decides whether an actual bounded classical potential admits the specified smooth perturbation. It does not provide slack in the pointwise obstacle or norm constraints, nor a uniform radius along a maximizing row. For an arbitrary completed potential, an actual ambient difference presentation has not been supplied, so the positivity theorem cannot simply be applied to it. The completed variational inequalities still require either verified feasible directions or a separate argument producing them.
An atomic solution with no nonzero two-sided smooth direction
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of original one-dimensional torus calibration, atomlessness of original smooth top-form measures, and the curve maximum principle. This example limits a sufficient variational criterion; it is not a Dirichlet nonexistence example.
Let The function is continuous classical, satisfies , and has ordinary boundary limit at both ends of the annulus. With the original unit Gauss point, the exact original curvature is Thus is an actual bounded classical solution of this atomic Dirichlet datum. In the normalized constraints , it has pointwise obstacle margin at least everywhere.
Nevertheless, if is original smooth and , then In particular the curvature radius in (eq:r6-original-curvature-radius) is zero for every nonzero compact original smooth direction, despite the uniform value slack.
Proof. The slope jump of is . Original torus integration therefore gives the displayed Dirac measure with no rescaling of the absolute value. The boundary values and the stated range follow from the formula for .
Every original smooth -form on a curve has an atomless coefficient measure. Indeed, on a compact stage a finite original moment presentation and its positive coefficient controls dominate its variation by finitely many positive smooth top-form measures. The pushforward of each such control by that presentation is calibrated integration of a smooth density on finitely many real one-dimensional polyhedra. It gives zero mass to a single real point, hence the positive measure gives zero mass to the inverse image of that point. In particular it gives zero mass to any individual analytic point. If the presentation has rank zero, its top form is zero. Finite localization proves the assertion without claiming that arbitrary positive currents are atomless. Applied to the compact smooth top form , this shows that its signed Radon measure has no atom at .
Positivity of both proposed classical curvatures would imply Thus would be carried by the singleton . Its atomlessness forces . The smooth function is locally a bounded classical difference by Lemma “Smooth directions belong locally to the difference class”; the frozen actual kernel theorem therefore makes it harmonic on the curve. Equivalently, apply the new bounded-difference positivity criterion to both and .
Choose a closed subannulus compactly contained in whose ordinary interior contains . The two Gauss boundary values of vanish. The maximum principle for both harmonic signs gives on that subannulus, and it is already zero outside its support. This proves the implication. Hence no positive two-sided radius is available for a nonzero direction. ◻
Meaning for the earlier criterion.
An objective can attain the correct atomic Dirichlet solution at a point where its actual psh constraint has no nonzero two-sided original smooth direction. The reserve theorem is therefore a sufficient route to its Euler equation, not a necessary property of all solvable data. The pointwise obstacle margins and the curvature reserve are independent requirements. This example does not alter the exact radius formula or the conditional variational conclusions.
Relative Hessian concavity and hyperbolicity can fail
Status of the proposed general assertions: FALSE. The following is an explicit construction over the original finite extension , using smooth bounded classical potentials and a smooth strongly positive separately closed background. It excludes two possible extensions of the relative Dirichlet theory: unconditional root-concavity of the relative top density, and an elliptic admissibility cone obtained merely by taking the positive component of that density. It does not challenge the established BT products, gradient Cauchy–Schwarz inequality, or compact-collar energy concavity.
Fix , let , and work on an ordinary bounded full polyannulus in the original -torus. Write The empty sum is zero when . Set Each summand is strongly positive. Pullback to every enlarged original moment presentation preserves this cone, and its wedge with a weakly positive complementary test is a positive top form. Thus is in particular positive in the original middle CLD cone. It is symmetric and separately closed because all the coordinate logarithmic differentials are closed. Its bidegree is , so its remaining degree is exactly . The brackets mean the ordinary current of the displayed smooth form, not a current pushed forward from a skeleton.
Define These functions are original smooth and bounded on . They are classical psh after every complete extension: on any analytic curve each unit logarithm is harmonic, and the displayed convex quadratic compositions are subharmonic. Their curvatures are
Proposition (A smooth strongly positive counterexample in every remaining degree). For every , the following equality holds on all original compact smooth scalar tests:
Consequently the th root of the relative density is not concave on the cone of semipositive Hessians. For one also has Thus a reverse Cauchy–Schwarz or Alexandrov–Fenchel inequality for these relative mixed top densities is false for arbitrary backgrounds.
Proof. Every is zero, and the -factors commute. The diagonal curvature of has coefficients in its first four directions and in every remaining direction. Wedge with the first summand of leaves the product with coefficients , and the second leaves . Each surviving top monomial occurs times in the th power. This proves the equality as an identity of original smooth forms and hence on every original test and refinement.
The measure is nonzero and positive. More explicitly, on this standard torus its original calibration is , whereas . A nonnegative compact smooth scalar depending on with positive real integral therefore has positive integral against . No equality of the lower-degree coefficient measures of with skeleton-supported measures is needed.
At and the density in (eq:r6-relative-density-polynomial) equals , but at their midpoint it equals . Hence its th root at the midpoint is strictly smaller than the arithmetic mean of its endpoint roots. When , comparison of the coefficient of gives the vanishing mixed term; the two diagonal terms are positive. ◻
The failure is not caused by a zero eigenvalue in the endpoint toric Hessians. Add to both and the same small positive multiple of . Their Hessians in the displayed coordinate directions become positive definite. The strict failure of the root inequality persists by continuity of the finite polynomial.
For the two-free-slot reverse Cauchy–Schwarz failure can also be retained by freezing the remaining slots. Put and . With and one obtains This is a computation of legitimate mixed products over the original fixed , not an assertion about wedging arbitrary currents.
Proposition (The positive density component is not an elliptic branch). For this same background, let be the coefficient of relative to , where is a real symmetric matrix. The homogeneous polynomial is not hyperbolic in the direction . Moreover the connected component of containing contains matrices at which adding a positive semidefinite direction decreases .
Proof. On diagonal matrices the exact polynomial is For , It has the nonreal roots and , whereas . This violates the defining real-root condition for hyperbolicity.
The path , , has and joins to . But although is positive semidefinite. This proves the asserted failure of ellipticity on the positive component. ◻
The indefinite matrix in the last proof is used only to test a proposed enlargement of the admissible class. It is not called a psh Hessian. The first proposition already disproves root-concavity using genuinely classical psh potentials.
Separation from the valid energy inequalities.
The proved Cauchy–Schwarz inequality is for first-derivative energy measures over a fixed positive closed degree-one tail . The failed inequality here concerns second-derivative mixed top densities; it is a different statement. Likewise the valid second variation of compact-collar Aubin–Mabuchi energy is along admissible segments. Its sign needs positivity of the indicated tail and no pointwise root-concavity of . Consequently all earlier relative energy arguments remain compatible with this counterexample.
The actual relative Dirichlet image need not be convex
R3 already disproved the unrestricted classical relative subsolution theorem. The new assertion here is different: two data which each have explicit continuous classical solutions on the same domain can have an unsolvable midpoint. This occurs in every remaining degree . It obstructs a convex-image extension of the degree-one Hilbert separation criterion.
Fix , set , and write the coordinates as two blocks and . On the ordinary unit polydisc take the closed analytic coordinate polydiscs Their only intersection is the rigid origin . The fixed is symmetric, original-positive, separately closed, and has bidegree . Thus its remaining degree is . Put and, on a block polydisc, define The maximum is assigned its finite constant value at . It is continuous classical psh, lies in , and has ordinary boundary limit zero. Let be the radius- Gauss point of , and let be the radius-, respectively radius-, Gauss points of . These are original analytic points, intrinsically divisorial on their carriers, and are distinct from and from the other carrier.
Theorem (Nonconvexity with fixed continuous matching boundaries). Let consist of the measures for all bounded actual having ordinary boundary limit zero. The measures belong to and have continuous classical solutions. Neither nor belongs to . In particular this actual relative zero-boundary image is not convex. Nevertheless each of these two unsolvable data has a bounded continuous classical subsolution with the same zero boundary values.
Status: NEW_PROVED for the nonconvexity assertion and its explicit all- construction. The general failure of the classical relative subsolution theorem is already an R3 result; it is not counted again as a new conclusion.
Proof. We first specify the frozen intrinsic uniqueness input. Each is a connected ordinary -polydisc relatively compact in its smooth affine -space. The function is a bounded continuous negative classical exhaustion with ordinary boundary value zero. It therefore satisfies condition R4–H. Theorem R4–48.4 gives uniqueness among all bounded actual classical potentials, including nontoric and discontinuous ones, for each finite divisorial datum below. We use this exact intrinsic theorem, not uniqueness merely in an energy or completed class.
The original radial calibration gives At the indicated Gauss point the slope simplex has volume , which the original top-product factor cancels; positive scaling gives the second identity. These are all-original-test identities, as in Lemma R4–60.1 and its frozen smoothing calibration.
Define on the whole ambient Both are continuous classical, take values in , and have ordinary boundary limit zero. Indeed any ordinary boundary point is a limit of points of with at least one block norm tending to one, where its corresponding branch tends to zero. Their restrictions are For example the unused branch of is exactly on each opposite carrier, so it does not change the indicated restriction. Integration-current compatibility and background linearity give, for every bounded actual classical ,
This is the same all-original-test identity as R4–64.4; it uses the restrictions of classical potentials, not a pullback of an arbitrary current. Thus and .
Suppose were a bounded actual classical solution for . Its analytic restrictions remain bounded actual classical. The two positive summands in (eq:r6-nonconvex-carrier-splitting) are carried by their respective . Restriction off separates them, and the total measure has zero mass at . Positivity hence forces the intrinsic equations There is no possible cancellation on the intersection. Moreover every intrinsic ordinary boundary point of is an ambient ordinary boundary point of : it is a limit of points of and lies outside because a free block coordinate has unit norm. Thus both restrictions have boundary limit zero.
The first intrinsic solution is , whose actual origin value is . For the second, set This is continuous classical and has zero boundary limit. The exact two-shell radial calculation in R4–60.3–R4–60.4 gives outer mass and inner mass . Explicitly, the slope shell at the outer point has volume , and the inner slope simplex has volume ; the original factor gives precisely those masses. Its actual origin value is The pinned intrinsic uniqueness theorem therefore forces these two different values for the single actual number . They are indeed different: strict convexity of the norm, for , gives The vectors are not proportional, so the inequality is strict. This contradiction excludes .
If a bounded actual classical zero-boundary potential solved the midpoint datum, multiplication by would solve , by positive homogeneity. The midpoint is therefore also excluded. Finally mixed positivity gives Thus is the asserted continuous matching subsolution for the sum, and is one for the midpoint. This uses only the positive mixed expansion, not an invalid root-concavity inequality for arbitrary relative backgrounds. ◻
Uniform capacity bounds do not repair the example.
The normalized functions and are actual testers on the whole . Every point in therefore has relative singleton capacity at least . Each of , and their midpoint has mass at most two. Hence for every fixed they all satisfy, on every Borel , If misses the three support points the inequality is immediate; otherwise the stated singleton lower bound proves it. The failure therefore concerns actual carrier compatibility, even within a fixed finite compact support and fixed common growth bounds.
Linear versus nonlinear image geometry.
For the curvature map is linear, and addition of two classical zero-boundary solutions solves the sum datum. The strict inequality above becomes equality. The construction thus identifies a nonlinear obstruction to extending the degree-one convex-image/Farkas method. It does not disprove a conditional feasible-tangent theorem, and it makes no nonexistence assertion for the larger completed or energy solution classes.
An explicit trace-compatible relative Dirichlet criterion
The following qualified theorem gives a numerical solvability test, not a condition formulated as membership in an unknown operator image. It concerns a specified family of analytic integration backgrounds and finite radial data. It does not replace the arbitrary-background energy alternative or assert sufficiency of a general bounded psh subsolution.
Fix integers and , and put . On the ordinary unit polydisc write the coordinates as blocks of length . Let be the coordinate -polydisc on which all blocks other than vanish. Thus for , where is the rigid origin. Choose constants and set This is an allowed original-positive separately closed background of bidegree , with remaining degree .
Put . For each fix an increasing finite list of positive integer multiples of , and nonnegative real numbers . Write for the radius- Gauss point of , viewed as a point of the original ambient analytic space. These points are intrinsically divisorial, lie off every other carrier, and are distinct from . Zero masses are allowed. Define
Theorem (Finite radial data on coordinate carriers). There is a bounded actual with ordinary boundary limit zero and if and only if When these depths have common value , a continuous classical solution is given explicitly by
It has . Every bounded actual classical zero-boundary solution has restriction on , and its supremum norm is at least . Uniqueness off the union of the carriers is not asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen all-original-test radial calibration, intrinsic bounded classical uniqueness, and integration-current compatibility. The explicit equal-depth criterion and extension formula record their consequence for this family; no new general relative Dirichlet existence theorem is being claimed.
Proof. Every is nonnegative. The functions and are therefore continuous classical on the whole intrinsic polydisc and have ordinary boundary limit zero. Their finite values at the rigid origin are assigned by the displayed maxima. The frozen radial-shell calculation R4–60.3–R4–60.4 gives These are identities against all original compact tests. At a shell, the slope polytope has volume ; the original top-product calibration multiplies it by . Thus no additional factorial or residue-degree normalization occurs. The same calculation is valid when two successive slopes agree, giving zero mass at that shell.
Summation by parts gives Moreover , so everywhere and the lower bound is attained at . Each intrinsic polydisc satisfies R4–H, for example with the negative exhaustion . The pinned intrinsic uniqueness theorem R4–48.4 therefore applies to these finite divisorial measures among all bounded actual classical solutions, including nontoric and discontinuous ones.
Suppose an ambient bounded actual classical solves the stated problem. Its analytic restrictions to are actual bounded classical, and the frozen integration-current identity gives All summands are positive. Off their carriers are disjoint, whereas the prescribed total measure has zero mass at . Consequently each intrinsic measure is exactly the one displayed for . An intrinsic ordinary boundary point is a limit of points of and is outside , because a free block coordinate has unit norm. It is therefore an ambient ordinary boundary point, and the restriction of has boundary limit zero. Intrinsic uniqueness gives at every actual point. In particular the single number equals every . This proves necessity, the asserted trace uniqueness, and the lower bound for the norm of any solution.
Conversely suppose all depths equal . Pulling the continuous classical back by the block projections and taking their finite maximum gives the continuous classical function in (eq:r6-radial-carrier-ambient-solution). On , every other branch has the constant value , while . Hence . The same integration-current identity proves .
The bounds and give its exact norm. At any ordinary boundary point of , at least one block norm tends to one. Along that block every tends to zero, so its tends to zero. Since is at least this branch and at most zero, it has ordinary boundary limit zero. This also handles the case , when all data vanish and . ◻
A numerical distinction between remaining degrees.
For , the depth is the linear expression For higher it is a sum of th roots of tail masses. Thus the actual compatibility condition is still a finite explicit condition, but generally not a linear constraint on the data. The nonconvex image in Theorem “Nonconvexity with fixed continuous matching boundaries” is one instance. Equal depths prove sufficiency here because the specified radial traces have a common attained global minimum and possess the explicit ambient block extensions. No such extension assertion is made for general intersecting analytic carriers or arbitrary intrinsic trace data.
Completed solvability has no equal-depth obstruction.
For every datum (eq:r6-radial-carrier-data), whether or not the agree, the frozen completed class already contains a bounded zero-boundary solution. This is a DIRECT_COROLLARY of Proposition R4–66.1, not a new completed existence theorem. To verify its bound explicitly, choose and , and put On each carrier, The last inequality follows by adding the nonnegative terms in (eq:r6-radial-carrier-intrinsic-solution) and using . Apply the frozen coordinate separator construction with branch functions , backgrounds , and the common continuous floor . It gives uniformly bounded continuous ambient classical functions increasing to an actual completed potential with The same floor gives ordinary boundary limit zero. Multiplying a carrier background by the positive constant preserves every outer-null hypothesis of that construction. Thus the equal-depth condition distinguishes actual classical compatibility at the shared point from the already available completed solution class.
Compact radial measures on transverse coordinate carriers
The equal-depth criterion extends from finite shell data to arbitrary finite measures on a compact radial interval. This is an explicit nonatomic family in every remaining degree; the geometry of the carriers and their ambient extensions remains specified.
Retain the coordinate carriers , weights , and background of Theorem “Finite radial data on coordinate carriers”. For each , let be a finite positive Radon measure supported in a compact interval . Let be the radius- diagonal Gauss point of , viewed in the original ambient space, and put All depths are finite. The convention at a jump of the tail function does not affect these integrals.
Proposition (A radial-measure compatibility criterion). There is a bounded actual classical on the whole -dimensional unit polydisc, with ordinary boundary limit zero and , if and only if . When the depths agree, write their common value as and define where . Then is a continuous classical solution with norm . Every bounded actual classical solution has exactly these restrictions to the carriers. No uniqueness away from their union is asserted.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the finite-shell calibration, locally uniform continuous-potential stability, and frozen pointwise ambient uniqueness. The measure may be nonatomic, singular continuous, or mixed.
Proof. We first prove the intrinsic equation on one -polydisc, suppressing the index and retaining its positive weight . Choose positive finite atomic measures with the same total mass as , supported in one fixed compact interval , and converging weakly to . Such measures are obtained by finite interval partitions and one representative per part; the representatives may be chosen at rational multiples of . Their tails converge to the tail of at every continuity point, hence at Lebesgue-almost every . They are bounded by the same total mass and vanish for . Therefore For atomic , summation by parts identifies the displayed integral profile with the finite positive combination of in (eq:r6-radial-carrier-intrinsic-solution). The original radial-shell calibration thus gives The same calibration is valid at any real radius: it is the slope-polytope computation used in (eq:r6-arbitrary-radius-capacity), with shell masses given by the difference of the th powers of adjacent slopes. In particular no strict-radius or new-field normalization is required here.
The estimate holds even at the rigid origin, since every profile is constant past . Thus is a bounded continuous classical function on the whole intrinsic polydisc. Locally uniform continuous-potential stability, Proposition “Continuous potentials and weakly varying backgrounds” with fixed background , gives against every original compact smooth test. On the right, continuity of the Gauss section on the fixed compact interval proves weak convergence. The profile is between and zero, attains at the origin, and tends to zero at every ordinary boundary point.
Intrinsic uniqueness for these possibly diffuse measures is the frozen Corollary R4–22.5, rather than an assumption that a finite-atomic existence theorem includes diffuse data. The unit polydisc is an ordinary open set with compact closure in smooth affine space, so it satisfies R4–(G). Two bounded actual classical functions with ordinary boundary limit zero satisfy the strict compact-gap condition in both orders: a finite open cover of the compact ordinary boundary excludes every fixed positive-margin gap. Equal intrinsic Monge–Ampere measures therefore force actual pointwise equality.
Now let be any ambient actual bounded classical solution. Its restrictions are bounded classical on each carrier, and original integration-current compatibility decomposes its relative measure as the sum of their positive intrinsic measures weighted by . The carrier intersections consist only of the origin, while has no mass there: its radial parameters are bounded above. Positivity therefore identifies every individual intrinsic measure with . Intrinsic ordinary boundary points are also ambient ordinary boundary points. The preceding uniqueness argument gives , so its single actual origin value equals every . This proves necessity and trace uniqueness.
If the depths agree, each has common attained minimum . The finite maximum of their block pullbacks is continuous classical; on all other branches are the constant , so its restriction is . Integration-current compatibility gives the required relative measure. The bounds and origin value give norm . At any ordinary boundary point some block norm tends to one; the corresponding tends to zero, and the maximum is squeezed between this branch and zero. This proves the boundary condition. ◻
Completed potentials and scope.
The frozen completed carrier-gluing theorem also applies to these continuous intrinsic profiles for arbitrary depths. Indeed, with and , one has on every carrier, since and is supported in . The same global floor as in the finite-shell theorem gives a bounded zero-boundary completed solution. Equal depths are precisely the additional actual point-value compatibility for the specified ambient classical construction. This statement neither extends arbitrary intrinsic psh data to ambient classical functions nor asserts a general relative subsolution theorem.
A finite-depth criterion for noncompact radial data
Corollary (Exact radial tail integrability). Retain the coordinate carriers and weights of Proposition “A radial-measure compatibility criterion”, but let each be any finite positive Radon measure on . Set The datum has a bounded actual classical solution on the whole ambient unit polydisc with ordinary boundary limit zero if and only if all are finite and equal. In that event the same integral profiles and finite maximum from the cited proposition give a continuous classical solution. The measures may accumulate at the rigid origin or towards the ordinary boundary; no mass is assigned to the origin itself.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the compact radial-measure construction, frozen actual measure order, and uniform continuous-potential stability. This is a criterion for the specified radial data, not for arbitrary measures.
Proof. On one intrinsic carrier put . The corresponding tail roots increase pointwise to , up to the irrelevant choice of values at endpoints, and . The intrinsic construction in the compact radial-measure proposition gives continuous classical zero-boundary with If an actual bounded classical zero-boundary has intrinsic measure , then . The frozen measure-order lemma R4–48.5 gives at every actual point. Thus for all , excluding . This use of order does not assume the existence of a solution for the limiting datum.
If , the integral profile , with , satisfies Hence its radial pullback is bounded continuous classical on the entire intrinsic polydisc, including the rigid origin. Uniform BT stability and monotone convergence of the finite measures give on all original compact tests. Since , the estimate proves the ordinary boundary limit zero. Intrinsic actual uniqueness follows from Corollary R4–22.5 and its two compact-gap conditions, exactly as in the compact radial-measure proposition.
For an ambient solution, positivity of the carrier decomposition identifies the individual intrinsic measures. The datum gives no mass to the shared origin, and the other carrier parts are disjoint. The preceding argument forces each depth to be finite, and actual intrinsic uniqueness forces its value at the common origin to be every . Conversely finite equal depths give the same max-of-blocks solution as before. Boundary convergence follows from the displayed linear bound near radial parameter zero. No compact support of the datum is needed for these steps. ◻
A bounded completed solution when the depths differ.
If every is finite, bounded completed solvability remains a direct consequence of the frozen carrier-gluing theorem, even when the depths differ. Choose For the intrinsic radial parameter , Thus on every carrier, and the same global continuous floor supplies bounded completed gluing and the ordinary zero-boundary squeeze. This paragraph asserts sufficiency only in the completed class; it makes no boundary-representative claim for an arbitrary completed solution.
Failed mechanisms and the next proof gates
Small analytic translations do not regularize a transverse Cantor current
Status: FAILED_ATTEMPT for a proposed regularization mechanism; the construction and its calculation are DIRECT_COROLLARY of torus calibration and the finite polyhedral description of actual delta-forms. This is not a counterexample to weak delta approximation or to the conjectural equality of all allowed backgrounds with the weak approximation class.
Fix the original finite extension , choose a uniformizer , and put . On the ordinary bidannulus let be a nonzero finite atomless singular measure supported on a middle-thirds Cantor subset of . Define The function is convex and : its derivative is the continuous distribution function of the atomless measure . Its distributional second derivative is exactly . The potential is continuous, locally bounded and classical psh. Indeed convex piecewise affine approximants are finite sums of maxima of affine functions of the pluriharmonic function , and converge locally uniformly to it. Thus is an allowed symmetric positive separately closed original -current on the smooth two-dimensional -space .
Proposition. The following assertions hold.
For every with , the analytic automorphism of satisfies . Consequently averaging such translates, with any probability law for which the scalar averages are defined, leaves unchanged.
On any smaller bidannulus whose -interval contains the support of , the current is not the ordinary current of an actual delta-form.
Nevertheless belongs to the fixed-domain weak closure of positive separately closed actual delta-forms.
Proof. At every Berkovich point of , the ultrametric inequality and give . The inverse translation has the same property, so is an automorphism and . Naturality of under an analytic isomorphism proves the first assertion. The scalar average of a fixed current is that same current.
For the second assertion, choose nonnegative smooth real cutoffs compactly supported in the smaller radius intervals, with on and . The smooth original form has compact analytic support. Original torus calibration, first for smooth convex and then by locally uniform convergence of its convex approximants, shows that the pushforward of the positive top measure under is exactly . All constants in this assertion use the original absolute value; the two coordinate moments have calibration one.
Suppose instead that for an actual delta-form near this compact support. Then . Take a finite common moment presentation of this compactly supported top delta-form, adjoining to the moments. The integration definition expresses its measure as a finite sum of pushforwards of integrable piecewise smooth densities on calibrated polyhedral cells. On each cell, the coordinate is affine. If its linear rank is one, pushing the density to the real line is absolutely continuous by Fubini. If its rank is zero, the pushforward is supported at one point. Hence the total pushforward is the sum of an absolutely continuous signed measure and finitely many atoms. This remains true after every original refinement and after adding the finitely many local presentations. It cannot equal the nonzero singular continuous measure . This proves the contradiction without restricting a delta-form along an arbitrary analytic embedding.
Finally, take convex polygonal interpolants on nested finite partitions containing the endpoints of an interval which contains . Extend them by the unchanged affine tails. They are finite convex piecewise affine functions, and uniformly on compact real intervals. Each is an actual delta-form whose ordinary current is positive and separately closed. Distributional differentiation of locally uniform functions gives on every original compact test of . Thus lies in the same-domain weak approximation class, despite being fixed by all the indicated analytic translations. ◻
The failed inference is therefore specific: analytic automorphisms which are sufficiently close to the identity in the non-Archimedean additive coordinates do not move tropical radii at all. A complex-style average over these automorphisms supplies no smoothing in the real transverse variable. Convex polygonal approximation succeeds here by changing that transverse distribution directly; the example supplies no such operation for a general positive closed background.
Why one positive stratum decomposition does not settle higher delta relations
Status: FAILED_ATTEMPT for a proposed reduction. The explicit nonclosed restriction below is a proved scope counterexample, not a counterexample to a full delta action.
The positive bounded-difference theorem makes every continuous scalar relation among represented -curvatures act independently of its presentation over any allowed background. It does not alone identify the kernel of the map from polynomials in those curvatures to actual higher-codimension delta-forms. In particular, freezing scalar coefficients in a relation between products still leaves a relation between products. It does not turn that relation into a degree-one curvature relation.
A tempting next step is to stratify the actual moment image, restrict the positive background to each Borel stratum, and apply the closed background cycle calculus to those restrictions. Level tangency does hold after Borel restriction. Separate closedness, however, need not survive, even in a very simple positive actual delta example.
Example (A wall restriction of a positive closed current is not closed). Let be the original field, and work on the ordinary tropical box Write and , and set Then is continuous classical psh, is a symmetric positive separately closed original current, and is coefficient-Radon and positive, but neither nor is zero.
Proof. On this box , so The two smooth functions have real Hessian matrices and . They are original smooth psh, and their maximum is continuous classical psh. Its piecewise smooth expression also defines an actual delta curvature. Therefore has all the stated positivity and closedness properties. Borel multiplication defines .
Choose , with , , and . Put This is an original compact smooth -test. On the toric test subspace, the smooth Hessian pieces of have two-dimensional Lebesgue coefficient measures, so restricting their pairing with to gives zero. The singular wall contribution is The torus moments have calibration one. Since the term of containing is annihilated by this wall factor, With the original total-degree current convention, Likewise, using gives . Thus neither separate derivative vanishes. Every test in this calculation is an original compact smooth test on the actual Berkovich space.
The wall expression was used only to evaluate this toric test subspace. It is not asserted to be a full-current formula for after all moment refinements. For example, a refined moment can detect smooth coefficient mass in branches on which . Such mass contributes zero to the displayed toric tests, so it cannot change the nonzero derivative calculation. This distinction avoids an independent false assertion about all refined coefficient measures. ◻
Exact remaining gate.
Let denote a finite local presentation algebra generated by continuous piecewise linear curvature operators and compatible piecewise smooth coefficient forms. The established constructions annihilate ambient cycle relations, pointwise piecewise-polynomial zero relations, and actual degree-one curvature relations. For a general analytic moment presentation , the remaining assertion is that the additional kernel of annihilates every allowed positive separately closed background. The statement must be proved with the full original refinement equivalence, not merely on the tangent spaces of one selected image. The example explains why the following argument does not prove it: “restrict the background to each face and reapply closed-background cycle insertion.” Those restricted backgrounds need not be closed.
This leaves two mathematically distinct requirements: either an actual local relation theorem reducing the higher kernel to relations already annihilated by the operator calculus, or a separate approximation or continuity theorem controlling the corresponding current actions. No such general relation theorem is asserted here. The already proved matroidal saturated case supplies one sufficient relation theorem; the weak delta approximation class supplies one sufficient continuity mechanism. The example itself is in that approximation class and therefore cannot refute either construction.
The wall is a real moment-level set, not the complete analytic pole set used in the frozen polar-restriction theorem. The latter theorem’s separate closedness is unaffected.
Status change from R5 and the remaining minimal gates
What is already settled before this record
The seven bounded BT properties over an arbitrary fixed original positive separately closed background remain PROVED in the frozen calculus. The arbitrary-background potential quotient is also PROVED by R5. The present record neither reopens that quotient nor claims those previous proofs as new results. Its main further advance is the ordered potential quotient: positivity of the original curvature of an actual bounded classical difference forces that actual difference to be classical psh. This is stronger than preservation of the zero kernel. Further results concern the actual delta-test category, quantitative relative capacities, compact represented curvature families, and verifiable Dirichlet constraints.
Precise assertion | Before R6 | R6 conclusion |
|---|---|---|
Ordinary fixed- bounded calculus and differentiated potential quotient |
| Unchanged input. The positive-cone question explicitly left aside in R5’s signed-current section is closed below only for its actual bounded classical difference class. |
Positive curvature in the actual bounded classical difference class | R5 settled the zero kernel only |
|
Represented curvature order over arbitrary | No general order transfer for discontinuous differences |
|
Continuous scalar relations among bounded-potential curvatures | Q handled constant differentiated-potential relations |
|
Actual total-degree delta-tests over arbitrary | No general actual relation theorem |
|
Ambient real cycle relations | Generator formulas did not remove all relations |
|
Generation of every real delta-form | Constant-cycle generation alone did not cover all smooth coefficient arrays |
|
Full actual delta-tests in arbitrary remaining degree | Ordinary equality alone was insufficient |
|
Geometric and diffuse examples in | No R6 closure description |
|
Saturated torus/matroidal charts | No all-background relation mechanism at this scope |
|
Represented curvature compactness | No common-domain compactness mechanism for these families |
|
Weak curvature and varying-background stability | Unrestricted weak stability is false |
|
Relative energy versus normalized degree-one BT measures | A square-root capacity upper bound was available |
|
Capacity-growth data with finite degree-one energy | A weaker sufficient growth condition |
|
Reverse equality of energy and BT capacity null sets | Not established |
|
General relative C1 and C2 |
| Still |
Capacity domination characterizes the normalized image | Not proved |
|
Completed degree-one Dirichlet feasibility | A general usable criterion remained open |
|
Relative energy-class Dirichlet solutions | Faithful form available |
|
Actual nonlinear Dirichlet image | Earlier subsolution obstructions existed; image convexity was not settled |
|
Higher-degree stationary solutions | Feasible variations not automatic |
|
Unrestricted relative Hessian root concavity and hyperbolicity | No justified general hypothesis |
|
The eleven classical directions, with current qualifications
Direction | Current mathematical scope |
|---|---|
1. Locally bounded psh | B’s actual class and regularization are inputs. R5’s zero kernel is continuous PH; R6 now identifies the positive cone within the actual bounded classical difference class. Every actual member under a continuous curvature upper bound is continuous. Arbitrary bounded USC/Borel representatives are excluded. |
2. Positive closed currents and mixed products | Ordinary arbitrary fixed- calculus and Q are proved. R6 adds the order-preserving quotient, continuous coefficient products, all-background degree-one actual delta action and full higher-degree testing on the stated weak approximation class. |
3. CLN | The earlier finite-control relative CLN estimates remain. They provide uniform masses in the new fixed-test and capacity arguments; no arbitrary moving-background theorem is inferred. |
4. Symmetry and weighted monotonicity | The ordinary fixed- theorem remains. R6 adds explicit order-error bounds, qualified joint weak curvature/background convergence, and weighted convergence after a fixed local normalization. Full delta-test convergence retains the stated background/degree scopes. |
5. Locality and maximum principles | Frozen ordinary and Borel maximum locality remain. The new degree-one action has ordinary locality; saturated chart theorems retain their more limited scope. Strict gaps of two discontinuous psh functions need not be ordinary open. |
6. Capacities | General C1/C2 remain open. Sharp energy bounds, compact upper-potential families, exact full-torus convex reduction, finite-Hausdorff Borel sets and explicit diffuse polar carriers add distinct qualified mechanisms. |
7. Quasicontinuity and capacity convergence | Frozen bounded and energy-representative results retain their exact hypotheses. New energy traces use these representatives, rather than arbitrary coefficient-null modifications. |
8. Pluripolar and negligible sets | Arbitrary backgrounds can charge ambient complete-polar sets. Diffuse examples in this record are not countable sums of fiber subcurrents. The BT and energy capacity null ideals can themselves differ. |
9. Comparison and domination | The qualified compact-gap and relative-q.e. principles remain. Energy order comparison and Dirichlet distance statements do not imply unrestricted actual pointwise classical uniqueness. |
10. Extremal functions | The frozen constrained and qualified ambient results remain. The upper-contact counterexample rules out a simple ambient-envelope repair of relative compact mass. |
11. Monge–Ampere and Dirichlet | Linear energy solutions, completed-class dual feasibility and actual classical nonlinear feasibility are distinguished. The latter image is explicitly nonconvex in every ; scalar energy solutions and capacity growth do not resolve the carrier compatibility constraint. General existence retains the false/open scopes recorded here. |
Primary comparisons that do not close the remaining gates
Mihatsch’s actual sheaf is faithful in ordinary currents [Mih24, Proposition 4.11]. This resolves equality for two actual delta-forms and is not an arbitrary-current extension theorem. The real balanced definition and its product are [Mih23, Theorem 3.3 and Theorem 4.1]. Esterov’s ring theorem [Est12, Theorem 3.1] removes ambient real fan relations; Gross–Shokrieh [GS21, Lemma 4.4 and Theorem 4.5] supplies the distinct matroidal relative-duality input. None of these inputs was silently extended to arbitrary singular moment images.
The focused capacity-source check also preserves a genuine distinction. Dhouib–Elkhadhra’s discussion of arbitrary-background capacity [DE15, Section 3] does not provide the missing general compact continuity theorem. In Elaini–Elkhadhra, [EE21, Proposition 3] gives basic relative-capacity properties, whereas the extremal-capacity results used in Section 4.2 have the explicit specialization. Their subsolution theorem has an additional current class and approximation/tail hypotheses. It cannot be cited as unconditional arbitrary-background classical psh Dirichlet existence in this project. Exact printed locations and hypothesis pins are retained in the source register.
Minimal proof gates after the proved advances
Higher-degree actual relation annihilation. Given an actual zero delta-presentation of total complementary degree at least two, show its prescribed finite PL/PS BT expression vanishes over every allowed fixed . Exact generation is now proved, so surjectivity of the test presentation is no longer the gap. The missing assertion is its analytic kernel. Weak positive closed delta approximation is sufficient, not yet proved universal. The degree-one order argument does not automatically lift to a higher-degree relation theorem. The explicit real-wall example “A wall restriction of a positive closed current is not closed” shows that Borel stratum restrictions need not be separately closed. They therefore cannot simply be reused as admissible backgrounds, despite level tangency. The Cantor example also rules out small analytic translations as a universal smoothing mechanism; it does not refute weak delta density.
C1 without a uniform domination mechanism. On the same whole normalized domain, recover the compact mass of a weak-limit or completed measure from actual normalized testers. The new compact upper-potential argument solves this for its entire represented family, even without one common measure dominator. The general problem still needs lower compact-mass approximation, not merely weak density or a capacitary upper bound on the datum.
C2 beyond the established set and family classes. Control the simultaneous compact extraction and normalized-tester pasting losses needed for arbitrary Borel ordinary-open regularity. Already on a full torus box this reduces exactly to the upper envelope of Laplacian masses of normalized convex functions. Finite Hausdorff measure, Borel coordinate sheets, open sets with compact additions, and sigma-finite nullity are solved there; positive-capacity Borel sets outside those hypotheses remain a concrete gate. Even compact normalized curvature families can have restricted raw/outer values and , so their compactness alone cannot supply the missing simultaneous extraction. On the explicit pole Cantor lamination, exact scalar interpolation and Lusin localization now handle arbitrary bounded Borel radial graphs. Arbitrary Borel subsets with general fiber geometry still require a joint extension or selection mechanism; independent measurable fiber optimizers do not supply that mechanism.
Classical feasibility of nonlinear Dirichlet data. Supply verifiable admissible directions or a separate construction inside the actual classical constraint. The exact actual variation radius separates current-order slack from pointwise obstacle slack. For intersecting coordinate carriers, the depths of intrinsic unique solutions must agree at their common actual point; the nonconvexity example violates this compatibility. The radial coordinate-carrier theorems give a necessary and sufficient finite-equal-depth condition for arbitrary finite radial data, with depth given by the integral of the th root of the weighted tail mass and an explicit max extension when it holds. When every individual depth is finite, a bounded completed solution exists even if the depths differ; no necessity for arbitrary completed solutions is asserted. The relative energy solution operator solves a larger linear problem. Hessian root concavity and hyperbolicity cannot be assumed for every positive background.
Excluded shortcuts
The following implications have deliberately not been used: ordinary current equality implies equality for arbitrary delta-test functionals; ambient cycle relations remove every analytic pullback relation; generator formulas alone cover smooth flat coefficient remainders; energy capacity and BT capacity have identical null sets; capacity domination characterizes the normalized measure image; a pointwise obstacle gap supplies a classical psh variation; or an arbitrary positive background has the usual relative Hessian hyperbolicity. Each failure or missing hypothesis is recorded with its own example or proof gate above. The project still defines no wedge of two completely arbitrary positive closed currents and claims no blanket replacement of GK’s nonclosed, nonpositive, off-diagonal calculus.
The capacity gap for convex compact potential families
This is a supplemental consequence of the accepted restricted-capacity example. Convexity of the entire normalized potential family does not repair its Borel outer regularity. The unrestricted relative BT capacity is not determined by this construction.
Proposition (Convex compact potential families with a Borel gap). In the setting of Proposition prop:r6-compact-dominator-all-degrees, for every one may take the upper-potential family and the entire associated normalized competitor family to be convex and compact, while their restricted capacity still satisfies on the same set in a fixed compact core. Compactness of the competitor family is in local uniform topology; its actual degree- measure image is weakly compact.
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the accepted product example, its mixed order theorem, and compact upper-potential compactness. The single varying Hessian direction is essential to the linear barycenter formula proved below.
Proof. Use exactly the original field, domain, background and coordinates of Proposition prop:r6-compact-dominator-all-degrees: For a probability measure on the compact real set , put These integrals are ordinary real-valued integrals. They do not require an integration operation on psh classes over another field.
We first verify actual classicality and compactness. Collapse the tail of a probability onto , retaining the first masses, and call the resulting finite probability . The uniform Lipschitz estimate of the product example gives, on the entire , Each is a finite convex combination of continuous actual classical functions. The uniform classical-closure property therefore makes continuous classical. The same bound holds globally.
The map is continuous from weak probability convergence to the global uniform norm. Indeed, the first isolated singleton masses are continuous weak-probability coordinates, because their indicator functions are continuous on . Thus the finite collapsed barycenters converge uniformly for fixed , and the displayed uniform tail estimate is independent of the probability. Compactness of now proves compactness of in the global uniform norm. Its convexity follows from .
Let be the original full Gauss section. The exact top measure is
Here every passive coordinate has range . To justify this identity without a false general nonlinear barycenter rule, write Only this first-coordinate term varies with ; the other hinge terms remain fixed. Smooth convex one-variable approximations show that two curvature factors in the same coordinate wedge to zero. This holds for bounded continuous BT products by their local uniform continuity. Consequently, in the th power of the sum only the terms using each of the coordinates once remain. There are such terms, and the coefficient is exactly For finite , linearity of the surviving first-coordinate factor and the accepted product calibration give (eq:r6-convex-barycenter-top-measure). Passing uses the global uniform convergence just proved and fixed-background continuous BT convergence. On the measure side it uses weak probability convergence and continuity of the original Gauss section; pairings with every original compact smooth scalar test converge. Thus the identity is on all original tests, not only on tests which factor through the displayed radius coordinates. The product measures are finite Radon, and the same identity gives the displayed Borel barycenter formula.
Now take the entire normalized family It is convex: if have upper probabilities , then has upper probability . Every member is continuous by Corollary “No a priori continuity is needed in a curvature order interval”. Proposition “Compactness with varying upper potentials” therefore proves local-uniform compactness of this whole family. Its degree- measure image is weakly compact by Corollary “Joint stability and actual weak-image closure”.
For each such , mixed order replacement in all slots gives For every Borel , it follows that The scalar function is Borel by the product kernel formula, so the middle equality follows from averaging and Dirac probabilities. Conversely every is a member of the enlarged family and attains . Hence equality holds throughout for all Borel , in particular for every ordinary open set. The raw and outer capacities are therefore identical to those in the accepted all-degree example, which gives the claimed and . ◻
Exact limitation.
Convexity here refers to the actual normalized potential family and its upper family. For its measure image is also convex, by linearity; no such nonlinear image-convexity assertion is needed or made for . Closure under arbitrary maxima is not asserted. The example still concerns a restricted competitor class and does not establish failure of unrestricted relative BT C1 or C2.