Progress · independent proof diagram
Numerical corrections on regular models
A numerically trivial extension on a regular model is a sufficient condition for a cycle to belong to the local obstruction kernel. The criteria below produce such extensions by intersection theory on the special fiber.
Conditional model criteria · Source edition v0.5.1
Domain of the result
At each finite place, require a pure operational representative on the stated dominant model with zero degree against every vertical test cycle. If every class in both and has such a representative, the pairing is defined on their full product. For individual classes satisfying the criterion, the conclusion is a pairing on the corresponding subgroups.
Read the diagrams from top to bottom. Select a numbered connection for its exact hypotheses and deduction, or follow a node to its source. Analytic, model and comparison assumptions retain their stated scope.
How to read the logic
Read from top to bottom. Parallel premises meet at a numbered connection, then lead to a conclusion. Select a connection to read its hypotheses and deduction; select a node to read the linked statement.
The full scope of each occurrence is recorded below its diagram. A proved conditional implication and an open geometric premise keep their separate statuses.
LOGIC 01
Numerical corrections and the global pairing
Vertical numerical vanishing gives native obstruction zero; both complementary local kernels then give the height domain.
Scope. Over a number field F, use geometrically homologically trivial rational Chow classes, complementary r+s=dim(X)+1, absolute height normalization, and the supplied Green, reciprocity, correspondence and comparison hypotheses. Local auxiliary fields are descended before the global sum.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Numerical detection upstairs AND legitimate descent
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisA pure operational lift with all vertical degrees zero
The character equals the pulled-back cycle in degree r and vanishes in other degrees. Every integral vertical r-cycle is tested, with its native multiplicity and residue degree.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe supplied dominant detector and full-degree finite descent
The witness is smooth and projective over the specified finite extension. Preserve the original valued field; the finite push–pull scalar is [L:K].
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The pure operational character has the prescribed generic class and zero degree on every vertical test. The model detector kills its actual curvature; dominant detection and finite-field injectivity descend zero.
Conclusion / target
A positive-relative-dimensional witness is permitted only with the stated dominant obstruction detector. Finite numerical descent retains the complete extension degree.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Apply the local argument to EACH class in BOTH degrees at EACH finite place
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalThe original local obstruction is zero
A positive-relative-dimensional witness is permitted only with the stated dominant obstruction detector. Finite numerical descent retains the complete extension degree.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The definition of ℋ is the intersection of these native local kernels.
Conclusion / target
Check every finite completion; checking only one degree supplies only that factor of the pairing.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑03AND · BOTH local membership and the admitted-domain height theorem
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalThe certified classes lie in ℋʳ(X) and ℋˢ(X)
Check every finite completion; checking only one degree supplies only that factor of the pairing.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe Green, residue and global reciprocity construction
Includes good-place vanishing, archimedean terms, symmetry, rational-equivalence descent and finite number-field invariance.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Local vanishing identifies the two subgroups contained in ℋ. The separate reciprocity theorem supplies the pairing, its Chow descent and its absolute normalization.
Conclusion / target
The full product Vʳ(X) × Vˢ(X) is obtained only when every class in BOTH degrees has the required certificates at every finite place.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 03 in the diagram ↑All 6 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalA pairing on the numerically certified subgroups
The full product Vʳ(X) × Vˢ(X) is obtained only when every class in BOTH degrees has the required certificates at every finite place.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe certified classes lie in ℋʳ(X) and ℋˢ(X)
Check every finite completion; checking only one degree supplies only that factor of the pairing.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe original local obstruction is zero
A positive-relative-dimensional witness is permitted only with the stated dominant obstruction detector. Finite numerical descent retains the complete extension degree.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisA pure operational lift with all vertical degrees zero
The character equals the pulled-back cycle in degree r and vanishes in other degrees. Every integral vertical r-cycle is tested, with its native multiplicity and residue degree.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe supplied dominant detector and full-degree finite descent
The witness is smooth and projective over the specified finite extension. Preserve the original valued field; the finite push–pull scalar is [L:K].
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe Green, residue and global reciprocity construction
Includes good-place vanishing, archimedean terms, symmetry, rational-equivalence descent and finite number-field invariance.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 02
One-dimensional Gysin images
The component degrees form a zero-sum vector; a weighted Laplacian corrects all of them at once.
Scope. K/ℚₚ is the original finite extension with its prescribed absolute value. X is smooth projective geometrically integral. Retain the actual obstruction, exact support complement, full actual tests, native residue degrees and complete finite degrees. Analytic and model comparison inputs remain conditional. The supplied regular projective reduced strictly semistable model has n≥3, smooth geometrically integral components and smooth closed strata.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The zero-sum condition AND the connected positive weighted graph
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisSpecialization trace gives Σᵢ λᵢ=0
Choose a Chow extension of the specified geometrically homologically trivial generic cycle.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe dual graph is connected and wᵢⱼ>0 on its edges
One relatively ample H supplies the intersection weights.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The weighted Laplacian has kernel the constants and image the vectors with total sum zero; all coefficients are rational.
Conclusion / target
Here λᵢ=degₖ(iᵢ!Θ·Hᵢⁿ⁻ʳ), and wᵢⱼ=degₖ(H|Eᵢⱼ)ⁿ⁻¹, summing disconnected intersections with residue degrees.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Degree cancellation AND one-dimensional detection
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalRational coefficients solve Σⱼ wᵢⱼ(vⱼ−vᵢ)=λᵢ
Here λᵢ=degₖ(iᵢ!Θ·Hᵢⁿ⁻ʳ), and wᵢⱼ=degₖ(H|Eᵢⱼ)ⁿ⁻¹, summing disconnected intersections with residue degrees.
Scope & sources - HypothesisEach total Gysin image is one-dimensional
The condition is imposed on the sum over all adjacent strata, not separately on each summand.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Specialization places each component class in its total Gysin image. In that one-dimensional image, degree against Hᵢⁿ⁻ʳ detects the class.
Conclusion / target
The correction is vertical, so the generic cycle is unchanged. A common change of all vᵢ adds the principal total-fibre class times Hʳ⁻¹.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑03AND · The corrected numerical lift AND the numerical-model input
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalΘad = Θ − Σᵢ vᵢ iᵢ*Hᵢʳ⁻¹ has zero component classes
The correction is vertical, so the generic cycle is unchanged. A common change of all vᵢ adds the principal total-fibre class times Hʳ⁻¹.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe pure operational lift and numerical comparison apply
This remains the analytic numerical-model input of the paper.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
A zero component cycle class has zero numerical degree against every vertical test, so the numerical-model criterion applies.
Conclusion / target
Fix 1≤r≤n and an invertible coefficient prime. The TOTAL sum of Gysin images at each component must have dimension one.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 03 in the diagram ↑All 7 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalEvery homologically trivial codimension-r class has zero obstruction
Fix 1≤r≤n and an invertible coefficient prime. The TOTAL sum of Gysin images at each component must have dimension one.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalΘad = Θ − Σᵢ vᵢ iᵢ*Hᵢʳ⁻¹ has zero component classes
The correction is vertical, so the generic cycle is unchanged. A common change of all vᵢ adds the principal total-fibre class times Hʳ⁻¹.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalRational coefficients solve Σⱼ wᵢⱼ(vⱼ−vᵢ)=λᵢ
Here λᵢ=degₖ(iᵢ!Θ·Hᵢⁿ⁻ʳ), and wᵢⱼ=degₖ(H|Eᵢⱼ)ⁿ⁻¹, summing disconnected intersections with residue degrees.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisSpecialization trace gives Σᵢ λᵢ=0
Choose a Chow extension of the specified geometrically homologically trivial generic cycle.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe dual graph is connected and wᵢⱼ>0 on its edges
One relatively ample H supplies the intersection weights.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisEach total Gysin image is one-dimensional
The condition is imposed on the sum over all adjacent strata, not separately on each summand.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe pure operational lift and numerical comparison apply
This remains the analytic numerical-model input of the paper.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 03
The two-factor hypersurface model
The blowup of (A,ϖ) produces the two components used in the scalar calculation.
Scope. K/ℚₚ is the original finite extension with its prescribed absolute value. X is smooth projective geometrically integral. Retain the actual obstruction, exact support complement, full actual tests, native residue degrees and complete finite degrees. Analytic and model comparison inputs remain conditional.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The specified transverse strata and generic smoothness
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisThe A, B, intersection and Σ strata satisfy the supplied smoothness hypotheses
Require all the smooth transverse geometrically integral strata in the equation, not only a smooth generic fibre.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The normal-crossings model is obtained for these supplied equations, with the stated integral strata.
Conclusion / target
Σ=(A=B=G=0). Blowing up the ideal (A,ϖ) produces these components; the companion computation retains their restriction and Gysin maps.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The scalar calculation AND the transverse blowup geometry
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalApply the scalar-image criterion in each degree
The connected two-vertex graph and native intersection degrees are those of the actual resolved model.
Scope & sources - ConditionalComponents: BlΣ(A=0) and (B=0), meeting in (A=B=0)
Σ=(A=B=G=0). Blowing up the ideal (A,ϖ) produces these components; the companion computation retains their restriction and Gysin maps.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The component and restriction computations verify the scalar-image hypothesis in every degree, so the preceding graph correction applies degree by degree.
Conclusion / target
deg A=a, deg B=b and deg G=a+b; the generic hypersurface and all specified strata are smooth and geometrically integral.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 4 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalThe supplied AB+ϖG degeneration has all-degree vanishing
deg A=a, deg B=b and deg G=a+b; the generic hypersurface and all specified strata are smooth and geometrically integral.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalApply the scalar-image criterion in each degree
The connected two-vertex graph and native intersection degrees are those of the actual resolved model.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalComponents: BlΣ(A=0) and (B=0), meeting in (A=B=0)
Σ=(A=B=G=0). Blowing up the ideal (A,ϖ) produces these components; the companion computation retains their restriction and Gysin maps.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe A, B, intersection and Σ strata satisfy the supplied smoothness hypotheses
Require all the smooth transverse geometrically integral strata in the equation, not only a smooth generic fibre.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 04
Positive primitive intersection forms on fourfolds
A weighted zero sum of positive primitive self-intersections annihilates the complete residual.
Scope. K/ℚₚ is the original finite extension with its prescribed absolute value. X is smooth projective geometrically integral. Retain the actual obstruction, exact support complement, full actual tests, native residue degrees and complete finite degrees. Analytic and model comparison inputs remain conditional. The original variety and its dominant witness have dimension four; the model has SNC support and positive multiplicities mᵢ.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The weighted residual identity AND strict primitive positivity
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisΣᵢmᵢdeg(Rᵢ²)=0 for Rᵢ∈ker(H:N²(Dᵢ)→N³(Dᵢ))
The residual theorem is a supplied model input.
Scope & sources - Hypothesisdeg(xy) is positive definite on every P²_H(Dᵢ)
The statement is over rational numerical classes; the supplied list includes abelian fourfolds and the stated projective-bundle hosts.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Retain the native constant-field factors in Σᵢmᵢdeg(Rᵢ²)=0 and mᵢ>0.
Conclusion / target
Every term mᵢ deg(Rᵢ²) is nonnegative; their sum is zero, so positive definiteness forces each vector to vanish.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Every primitive residual vanishes AND witness descent applies
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalRᵢ=0 on every component
Every term mᵢ deg(Rᵢ²) is nonnegative; their sum is zero, so positive definiteness forces each vector to vanish.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe numerical and dominant witness descent hypotheses hold
Preserve the finite extension and all multiplicities of the supplied witness.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Zero residual completes the vertical numerical correction. The original-field detector then kills the obstruction.
Conclusion / target
The companion correction theorem constructs a canonical primitive residual Rᵢ on each component.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑03AND · Codimension two AND the endpoint and one-cycle cases
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalThe codimension-two operational lift is numerically admissible
The companion correction theorem constructs a canonical primitive residual Rᵢ on each component.
Scope & sources - ConditionalDegrees 1,3,4 are covered by endpoint and one-cycle vanishing
Use those established conditional inputs on the original variety.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
These cover degrees 1,2,3,4 on a fourfold.
Conclusion / target
Codimension two comes from the numerical residual; divisors, one-cycles and zero-cycles supply the other degrees.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 03 in the diagram ↑All 7 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalThe original fourfold has vanishing obstruction in every degree
Codimension two comes from the numerical residual; divisors, one-cycles and zero-cycles supply the other degrees.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe codimension-two operational lift is numerically admissible
The companion correction theorem constructs a canonical primitive residual Rᵢ on each component.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalRᵢ=0 on every component
Every term mᵢ deg(Rᵢ²) is nonnegative; their sum is zero, so positive definiteness forces each vector to vanish.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisΣᵢmᵢdeg(Rᵢ²)=0 for Rᵢ∈ker(H:N²(Dᵢ)→N³(Dᵢ))
The residual theorem is a supplied model input.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisdeg(xy) is positive definite on every P²_H(Dᵢ)
The statement is over rational numerical classes; the supplied list includes abelian fourfolds and the stated projective-bundle hosts.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe numerical and dominant witness descent hypotheses hold
Preserve the finite extension and all multiplicities of the supplied witness.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalDegrees 1,3,4 are covered by endpoint and one-cycle vanishing
Use those established conditional inputs on the original variety.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 05
Multiplicity-free finite-group actions
The invariant residual is totally isotropic; a multiplicity-free nondegenerate representation has no such nonzero submodule.
Scope. K/ℚₚ is the original finite extension with its prescribed absolute value. X is smooth projective geometrically integral. Retain the actual obstruction, exact support complement, full actual tests, native residue degrees and complete finite degrees. Analytic and model comparison inputs remain conditional. The regular projective model has n≥4 and a finite group preserving the numerical ample class H.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 4 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Multiplicity-free representation AND nondegenerate invariant Q
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisThe relevant rational primitive representation is multiplicity-free and Q is nondegenerate
In dimension four, numerical duality and divisor Hodge index supply nondegeneracy.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The same argument applies to eP²_H when the hypotheses hold on that selected sector.
Conclusion / target
Averaging a positive rational form makes every rational simple finite-group representation self-dual; multiplicity-freeness and nondegeneracy of Q give the claim.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Invariant isotropy AND no nonzero invariant isotropic summand
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisThe canonical residual image is invariant and totally isotropic
This is the supplied equivariant residual identity, not a consequence of group action alone.
Scope & sources - ConditionalDistinct simple summands are orthogonal and each is nondegenerate
Averaging a positive rational form makes every rational simple finite-group representation self-dual; multiplicity-freeness and nondegeneracy of Q give the claim.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
An invariant submodule is a sum of simple summands. Each such summand is nondegenerate, so none can lie in a totally isotropic submodule.
Conclusion / target
Q(x,y)=Σᵢmᵢdeg(xᵢyᵢHᵢⁿ⁻⁴), on P²_H=⊕ᵢker(Hⁿ⁻³:N²(Dᵢ)→Nⁿ⁻¹(Dᵢ)).
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑03AND · Residual zero AND numerical correction with descent
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalThe invariant totally isotropic residual image is zero
Q(x,y)=Σᵢmᵢdeg(xᵢyᵢHᵢⁿ⁻⁴), on P²_H=⊕ᵢker(Hⁿ⁻³:N²(Dᵢ)→Nⁿ⁻¹(Dᵢ)).
Scope & sources - HypothesisZero residual gives an admissible lift and native obstruction descent
Use the same model comparison as in the numerical criterion.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The equivariant residual theorem is applied on the same actual model and the same rational representation.
Conclusion / target
For the full primitive representation this covers every homological codimension-two class. For a central isotypic projector e, it covers the corresponding eCH² subgroup.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 03 in the diagram ↑All 9 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalThe selected codimension-two classes have zero obstruction
For the full primitive representation this covers every homological codimension-two class. For a central isotypic projector e, it covers the corresponding eCH² subgroup.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe invariant totally isotropic residual image is zero
Q(x,y)=Σᵢmᵢdeg(xᵢyᵢHᵢⁿ⁻⁴), on P²_H=⊕ᵢker(Hⁿ⁻³:N²(Dᵢ)→Nⁿ⁻¹(Dᵢ)).
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe canonical residual image is invariant and totally isotropic
This is the supplied equivariant residual identity, not a consequence of group action alone.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalDistinct simple summands are orthogonal and each is nondegenerate
Averaging a positive rational form makes every rational simple finite-group representation self-dual; multiplicity-freeness and nondegeneracy of Q give the claim.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe relevant rational primitive representation is multiplicity-free and Q is nondegenerate
In dimension four, numerical duality and divisor Hodge index supply nondegeneracy.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisZero residual gives an admissible lift and native obstruction descent
Use the same model comparison as in the numerical criterion.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalIn dimension four the full-group criterion gives every complementary height
For a restricted e-sector in higher dimension, the resulting subgroup pairs with the admitted complementary group.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalFull codimension-two vanishing at each completion
Use e=1 and n=4, with the model hypotheses satisfied at every finite place.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisEndpoint, one-cycle and global reciprocity inputs
All the global analytic assumptions continue to apply.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Remaining problem
The required vertical correction is established only under the listed model hypotheses. Constructing it for arbitrary models and arbitrary homologically trivial cycles remains the general problem.