Contents of this source
Failure of the classical total-mass calibration for relative extremals
Status and scope.
This is an original-category obstruction to importing the classical relative-extremal-function proof of Borel capacity regularity unchanged. It is not a counterexample to B1. The background is smooth and strongly positive, , and the original dimension is any . The exact capacity calculation uses every original normalized classical psh tester, not only toric testers. No equality of an actual envelope with its toric trace is assumed, and no nonlinear pushforward identity is used.
Fix the prescribed finite and its absolute value, , the original torus , , and Use normalized moments and write . Let be the joint original Gauss section and set For , define The compact original analytic domain has nonempty ordinary interior. The functions and are actual continuous classical psh functions formed from finite real maxima of original harmonic affine potentials on the same ordinary representative. In particular on .
Lemma (A local linear trace identity for the full bounded tester class). Let be any original bounded classical psh function on . The bounded Borel function has a unique continuous convex representative modulo Lebesgue null sets. As Radon measures on , Pointwise inequalities for actual functions pass to their canonical convex traces. No assertion about arbitrary completed Borel representatives is involved here.
Proof. For , is an original compactly supported smooth CLD scalar test: the moment map is proper over compact subsets of . The current recursion, compact Stokes, and the frozen full original top-form Gauss calibration yield The coefficient follows from in unnormalized moment coordinates: the rescaling contributes from differentiation and from volume.
For completeness, convexity of the canonical trace need not be imported from a completed zero-boundary theorem. Fix a unit vector and an orthonormal basis of . The constant strongly positive form is separately closed. The positive bounded BT measure , tested against nonnegative , gives by the same Stokes and top-form computation Thus every distributional second directional derivative of is nonnegative. Local mollifications have positive semidefinite Hessian and are convex. They remain uniformly bounded on protected compact boxes; the elementary interior slope bound for bounded convex functions makes them locally equicontinuous. Subsequential locally uniform limits produce a continuous convex representative ; convergence in distributions identifies it with almost everywhere. Any two such representatives agree everywhere by continuity. Bounds and order inequalities pass first almost everywhere and then everywhere. This also proves the asserted canonical nature of the trace without asserting equality at every individual Gauss point.
Equation (EC3) now identifies the two positive Radon measures in (EC2). Only local boundedness, current recursion, positivity, and the full original top-form calibration have been used. The energy and zero-boundary assumptions imposed in R17 FP for its later conclusions are not used. This is a linear degree-one identity, not an arbitrary higher-degree Monge–Ampere pushforward assertion. ◻
Proposition (Exact capacity over all original normalized testers). For every ,
Proof. Let be any original tester with . Then . Fix all coordinates other than . The resulting one-variable convex function has Indeed the right derivative is at most by comparison with secants approaching ; the left derivative is at least by secants approaching . Distributional slicing, obtained by Fubini from the definition of , integrates (EC4a) over the other coordinates and gives Summing over and multiplying by in (EC2) gives the upper bound in (EC4) for every original tester. This is a slice computation, not an assertion of an -dimensional atom on a coordinate hyperplane.
For the explicit , fix the other coordinates in the inner cube. In the remaining coordinate the function is , so its derivative measure on has mass , including its two endpoint atoms. Integrating these slice measures gives exactly in each coordinate. This also accounts for all edges and corners, without any extra mass. Therefore so attains the full raw upper bound. For , the open set contains and its capacity is at most the just computed value . Let and use to obtain the outer equality. This special exact calculation does not revive universal compact raw/outer equality. ◻
Proposition (Obstruction to total-mass extremal calibration). Every bounded actual classical psh function satisfying has canonical convex trace and In particular no such assignment of actual extremals can identify their total relative source masses with the original capacities, even up to a fixed multiplicative upper constant as the obstacle varies within this one fixed original domain and smooth background.
Proof. The order-preserving trace lemma and continuity show on and on . If , intersect the ray through with the cubes of radius and , where . Convexity between these two points, followed by , gives The lower bound gives the reverse inequality. This proves the trace identity without asserting equality off the Gauss section.
For , flux through the cube of radius gives Equivalently, the same slicing computation gives derivative jump in each coordinate for almost every fixed choice of the other coordinates in ; integration yields the displayed formula without invoking a boundary regularity theorem. Letting uses only monotone convergence for this single Radon measure, not continuity of an outer capacity. The inner mass is the value already computed in (EC4). Multiplying by and subtracting proves (EC6). For , as , proving the last assertion. ◻
Application to a putative relative extremal function.
Let Replacing any competitor by increases it and preserves the constraints, so the envelope can be taken over bounded competitors. The explicit is a competitor; hence and on . Its ordinary upper semicontinuous regularization satisfies and on . If is an actual classical psh function, (EC6) applies to it. Consequently its source has positive mass away from the compact obstacle and its total mass cannot equal (EC4). If psh-envelope existence is not available, the conjunction of that existence assertion and the classical total-mass calibration is still refuted. No envelope-existence theorem, all-fiber envelope identity, or completed point representative is assumed.
Precise implication for B1.
One cannot import the classical extremal proof simply by replacing with while keeping the original classical psh competitor cone. Already for arbitrary original dimension and remaining degree , the forced convex trace carries relative source mass outside its obstacle. Enlarging the competitor cone to all functions subharmonic for the trace operator changes the tester problem and is not an admissible repair. Original outer Borel compact-inner regularity remains OPEN; this is a failed analytic calibration, not a failure of B1 itself.
Internal dependencies and review boundary.
The proof uses the frozen bounded fixed-background BT recursion and positivity, max stability of bounded classical psh functions, and the full original top-form Gauss calibration (R17 FP6, source 8389d2ce81aa5fd1b563767a3c207a06d0b50e661fb06ee978da2d39634c49be.tex, with its local calculation explicitly extended above). The directional constant forms give a self-contained convex-trace argument. No energy completion, abstract weak-compactness inference, general GQ/KC12 descent, model/conormal restriction, or original raw/outer equality is imported.