Conjecture Atlas

Proof source

The quadratic mass threshold for a central residual action

Complete proof text in the unsigned reading edition.

Download sourceBrowse research records

Reading edition of the complete source note. Original labels and explicit equation tags are retained; references use source titles where compiled numbering is unavailable. Current result status is recorded separately in the project register.

Contents of this source
  1. The quadratic mass threshold for a central residual action

The quadratic mass threshold for a central residual action

An ordinary punctured action theorem leaves a current supported at its central complement. This note records a quantitative sufficient condition for removing that residual and the critical scaling which a singular background can attain. It concerns the already defined action of one presentation, as in OL.

A fixed-presentation cutoff estimate

Fix an original ordinary domain, a finite actual coordinate tuple tt, an original compact complementary smooth test η\eta, and an allowed original background SS. Retain the quadratic return identity which writes the relevant action, up to its fixed sign, as A=DMS(Z),D=d′d′′.(CR1)A=D M_S(Z),\qquad D=d'd''. \tag{CR1} The singular full-exact term A0A_0 in the original decomposition has not been replaced by a smooth coefficient primitive. CR1 uses its separately justified scalar-module return identity.

Suppose AA is supported in a relatively closed set EE, and suppose a fixed finite smooth moment map tt has constant value t0t_0 on E∩supp⁡ηE\cap\operatorname{supp}\eta. Shrink the fixed compact test neighborhood so that all cutoffs used below remain inside the original domain. Write r=∣t−t0∣,ρδ=χ(r/δ),χ=1 on [0,1],χ=0 on [2,∞),(CR2)r=|t-t_0|,\qquad \rho_\delta=\chi(r/\delta),\qquad \chi=1\text{ on }[0,1],\quad \chi=0\text{ on }[2,\infty), \tag{CR2} where χ\chi is a fixed smooth function, constant near zero. Although rr need not be smooth at its zero set, ρδ\rho_\delta is a legitimate original smooth cutoff. Its value is one on an ordinary neighborhood of the relevant part of EE. Neither injectivity of tt nor exhaustion of EE by its zero fiber is needed for the estimate.

Assume the retained degree-one positive-module order estimate for the represented bounded tensor ZZ, and fix a positive control QQ with ±[Z]≤CQ\pm[Z]\le C Q on this presentation. Choose one positive complementary dominator Ξη\Xi_\eta for the finitely many coefficient forms obtained from η\eta, d′ηd'\eta, d′′ηd''\eta, and DηD\eta by adjoining the coordinate differentials of tt. This is the ordinary finite coefficient domination used in the retained order interface. In particular it is chosen after the fixed test and before δ\delta. Let μS,η=Q∧S∧Ξη(CR3)\mu_{S,\eta}=Q\wedge S\wedge\Xi_\eta \tag{CR3} denote its finite positive top-degree measure on the compact test neighborhood. The existence and positivity of this measure are part of the displayed module hypotheses, rather than an identification of the different positivity cones.

Proposition (Second-order residual bound). For 0<δ<10<\delta<1, ∣⟨A,η⟩∣≤Cηδ−2μS,η(supp⁡η∩{r≤2δ}).(CR4)|\langle A,\eta\rangle| \le C_\eta\delta^{-2} \mu_{S,\eta}\bigl(\operatorname{supp}\eta \cap\{r\le2\delta\}\bigr). \tag{CR4} Consequently the sufficient condition μS,η(supp⁡η∩{r≤2δ})=o(δ2)(CR5)\mu_{S,\eta}\bigl(\operatorname{supp}\eta \cap\{r\le2\delta\}\bigr)=o(\delta^2) \tag{CR5} removes this residual pairing. If CR5 holds for every allowed original SS and every original test, in their actual finite presentations, then the punctured action identity extends across EE with those same quantifiers.

Proof. Ordinary locality and the support condition give ⟨A,η⟩=⟨A,ρδη⟩=⟨MS(Z),D(ρδη)⟩,(CR6)\langle A,\eta\rangle =\langle A,\rho_\delta\eta\rangle =\langle M_S(Z),D(\rho_\delta\eta)\rangle, \tag{CR6} with the harmless fixed current sign suppressed. The full Leibniz rule contains the four types ρδDη,d′ρδ∧d′′η,d′′ρδ∧d′η,Dρδ∧η.(CR7)\rho_\delta D\eta,\qquad d'\rho_\delta\wedge d''\eta,\qquad d''\rho_\delta\wedge d'\eta,\qquad D\rho_\delta\wedge\eta. \tag{CR7} Their coefficient bounds in the fixed coordinates are, respectively, CηC_\eta, Cηδ−1C_\eta\delta^{-1}, Cηδ−1C_\eta\delta^{-1}, and Cηδ−2C_\eta\delta^{-2}. All are supported in supp⁡η∩{r≤2δ}\operatorname{supp}\eta\cap\{r\le2\delta\}. The finite positive domination and ±[Z]≤CQ\pm[Z]\le C Q therefore give CR4. This proof includes the mixed terms in CR7. It does not restrict a current to a radial line. Taking δ↓0\delta\downarrow0 under CR5 gives the stated conclusions. Each later actual refinement merely gives another legal instance of the same original order estimate; no new test class is inferred. ◻

The assertion is conditional on CR5. A finite radial fiber may contain additional points away from EE; their mass also appears in CR4. The estimate does not discard them using the vanishing of the action there. Proving a better carrier estimate, or using a different family of original cutoffs, is a separate way to improve CR4.

A closed positive background can attain the critical rate

The rate in CR5 does not follow solely from bounded finite-PS coefficients, separate closedness and positivity of SS, and point support of DMS(Z)D M_S(Z). The following supplied real example retains all of those latter properties.

Use real superforms on R3\mathbf R^3 with coordinates (x,y,z)(x,y,z). Let H={z=0}H=\{z=0\}, let S=[H]S=[H] be its positive integration current of bidegree (1,1)(1,1), and set Z=121{x>0,y>0}(d′x∧d′′y+d′y∧d′′x).(CR8)Z=\tfrac12{\bf1}_{\{x>0,y>0\}} (d'x\wedge d''y+d'y\wedge d''x). \tag{CR8} Give all coefficient faces their tangential pullbacks. This is a bounded finite closed-cell PS tensor with compatible face pullbacks: on a face contained in x=0x=0 or y=0y=0 both terms pull back to zero. The full plane HH is separately d′d'- and d′′d''-closed, and [H][H] is positive for all the usual positivity tests in this degree. The facewise product in this example is simply MS(Z)=ι∗[ι∗Z]M_S(Z)=\iota_*[\iota^*Z], where ι:H↪R3\iota:H\hookrightarrow \mathbf R^3.

Normalize the positive supervolume on HH by d′x∧d′′x∧d′y∧d′′yd'x\wedge d''x\wedge d'y\wedge d''y. Direct distributional differentiation gives DMS(Z)=−δ0.(CR9)D M_S(Z)=-\delta_0. \tag{CR9} Indeed the cross entry of the symmetric coefficient matrix is Zxy=121x>01y>0Z_{xy}=\tfrac12{\bf1}_{x>0}{\bf1}_{y>0}, while its two diagonal entries vanish. In these conventions the coefficient of D[Z]D[Z] on the plane is ∂y2Zxx+∂x2Zyy−2∂x∂yZxy\partial_y^2 Z_{xx}+\partial_x^2Z_{yy} -2\partial_x\partial_y Z_{xy}, which is −δ(0,0)-\delta_{(0,0)}. The proper linear inclusion commutes with these distributional derivatives, proving CR9.

For the ordinary Euclidean positive coefficient control, the measure CR3 on HH is a positive constant multiple of its two-dimensional area. Therefore μS,η(Bδ(0))≍δ2(CR10)\mu_{S,\eta}(B_\delta(0))\asymp\delta^2 \tag{CR10} when the fixed test is nonzero near the origin. The second-derivative factor in CR4 is exactly critical.

This example does not come from an actual analytic-zero relation. Its ambient D[Z]D[Z] is nonzero on the zz-axis, so it does not satisfy the original ambient closed-current input either. Its conclusion is exactly that bounded coefficients and a closed positive background do not supply a general point-support removal theorem. The missing original-range input must use the actual-zero structure, a stronger background mass estimate, or an exact residual pairing argument. The local positive-face and punctured identities alone do not provide that input.

Sources and scope.

The analytic premises are the retained QA scalar-module return and the fixed-presentation positive order interface, as used in NSA12, together with ordinary locality OL3. CR4 and the real computation CR8–CR10 are the new elementary deductions. No support theorem for general currents, no ordinary-to-GK passage, and no analytic realization of the real example is asserted.

Source text and edition identity

This reading copy omits personal attribution and places existing mathematical question marks over their relation symbols. The mathematical content and source status are retained.

Reading-copy SHA-256 56a91375a6bfab302cb2710b99fdaa114299225a61425582c08340d30b21a6a9

Frozen-original SHA-256 56a91375a6bfab302cb2710b99fdaa114299225a61425582c08340d30b21a6a9

\section{The quadratic mass threshold for a central residual action}
\label{sec:r13-point-residual-mass-threshold}

An ordinary punctured action theorem leaves a current supported
at its central complement.  This note records a quantitative
sufficient condition for removing that residual and the critical
scaling which a singular background can attain.  It concerns the
already defined action of one presentation, as in OL.

\subsection{A fixed-presentation cutoff estimate}

Fix an original ordinary domain, a finite actual coordinate tuple
\(t\), an original compact complementary smooth test \(\eta\),
and an allowed original background \(S\).  Retain the quadratic
return identity which writes the relevant action, up to its fixed
sign, as
\[
                  A=D M_S(Z),\qquad D=d'd''.
\tag{CR1}
\]
The singular full-exact term \(A_0\) in the original decomposition
has not been replaced by a smooth coefficient primitive.  CR1
uses its separately justified scalar-module return identity.

Suppose \(A\) is supported in a relatively closed set \(E\), and
suppose a fixed finite smooth moment map \(t\) has constant value
\(t_0\) on \(E\cap\operatorname{supp}\eta\).  Shrink the fixed
compact test neighborhood so that all cutoffs used below remain
inside the original domain.  Write
\[
 r=|t-t_0|,\qquad
 \rho_\delta=\chi(r/\delta),\qquad
 \chi=1\text{ on }[0,1],\quad \chi=0\text{ on }[2,\infty),
\tag{CR2}
\]
where \(\chi\) is a fixed smooth function, constant near zero.
Although \(r\) need not be smooth at its zero set, \(\rho_\delta\)
is a legitimate original smooth cutoff.  Its value is one on
an ordinary neighborhood of the relevant part of \(E\).
Neither injectivity of \(t\) nor exhaustion of \(E\) by its
zero fiber is needed for the estimate.

Assume the retained degree-one positive-module order estimate
for the represented bounded tensor \(Z\), and fix a positive
control \(Q\) with \(\pm[Z]\le C Q\) on this presentation.
Choose one positive complementary dominator \(\Xi_\eta\) for
the finitely many coefficient forms obtained from \(\eta\),
\(d'\eta\), \(d''\eta\), and \(D\eta\) by adjoining the
coordinate differentials of \(t\).  This is the ordinary finite
coefficient domination used in the retained order interface.
In particular it is chosen after the fixed test and before
\(\delta\).  Let
\[
                    \mu_{S,\eta}=Q\wedge S\wedge\Xi_\eta
\tag{CR3}
\]
denote its finite positive top-degree measure on the compact
test neighborhood.  The existence and positivity of this
measure are part of the displayed module hypotheses, rather
than an identification of the different positivity cones.

\begin{proposition}[Second-order residual bound]
\label{prop:r13-quadratic-residual-mass-threshold}
For \(0<\delta<1\),
\[
 |\langle A,\eta\rangle|
       \le C_\eta\delta^{-2}
            \mu_{S,\eta}\bigl(\operatorname{supp}\eta
                                  \cap\{r\le2\delta\}\bigr).
\tag{CR4}
\]
Consequently the sufficient condition
\[
  \mu_{S,\eta}\bigl(\operatorname{supp}\eta
                      \cap\{r\le2\delta\}\bigr)=o(\delta^2)
\tag{CR5}
\]
removes this residual pairing.  If CR5 holds for every allowed
original \(S\) and every original test, in their actual finite
presentations, then the punctured action identity extends
across \(E\) with those same quantifiers.
\end{proposition}

\begin{proof}
Ordinary locality and the support condition give
\[
 \langle A,\eta\rangle
   =\langle A,\rho_\delta\eta\rangle
   =\langle M_S(Z),D(\rho_\delta\eta)\rangle,
\tag{CR6}
\]
with the harmless fixed current sign suppressed.  The full
Leibniz rule contains the four types
\[
 \rho_\delta D\eta,\qquad
 d'\rho_\delta\wedge d''\eta,\qquad
 d''\rho_\delta\wedge d'\eta,\qquad
 D\rho_\delta\wedge\eta.
\tag{CR7}
\]
Their coefficient bounds in the fixed coordinates are,
respectively, \(C_\eta\), \(C_\eta\delta^{-1}\),
\(C_\eta\delta^{-1}\), and \(C_\eta\delta^{-2}\).
All are supported in \(\operatorname{supp}\eta\cap\{r\le2\delta\}\).
The finite positive domination and \(\pm[Z]\le C Q\)
therefore give CR4.  This proof includes the mixed terms
in CR7.  It does not restrict a current to a radial line.
Taking \(\delta\downarrow0\) under CR5 gives the stated
conclusions.  Each later actual refinement merely gives
another legal instance of the same original order estimate;
no new test class is inferred.
\end{proof}

The assertion is conditional on CR5.  A finite radial fiber
may contain additional points away from \(E\); their mass
also appears in CR4.  The estimate does not discard them
using the vanishing of the action there.  Proving a better
carrier estimate, or using a different family of original
cutoffs, is a separate way to improve CR4.

\subsection{A closed positive background can attain the critical rate}

The rate in CR5 does not follow solely from bounded finite-PS
coefficients, separate closedness and positivity of \(S\),
and point support of \(D M_S(Z)\).  The following supplied
real example retains all of those latter properties.

Use real superforms on \(\mathbf R^3\) with coordinates
\((x,y,z)\).  Let \(H=\{z=0\}\), let \(S=[H]\) be its
positive integration current of bidegree \((1,1)\), and set
\[
 Z=\tfrac12{\bf1}_{\{x>0,y>0\}}
                   (d'x\wedge d''y+d'y\wedge d''x).
\tag{CR8}
\]
Give all coefficient faces their tangential pullbacks.  This
is a bounded finite closed-cell PS tensor with compatible
face pullbacks: on a face contained in \(x=0\) or \(y=0\)
both terms pull back to zero.  The full plane \(H\) is
separately \(d'\)- and \(d''\)-closed, and \([H]\) is
positive for all the usual positivity tests in this degree.
The facewise product in this example is simply
\(M_S(Z)=\iota_*[\iota^*Z]\), where \(\iota:H\hookrightarrow
\mathbf R^3\).

Normalize the positive supervolume on \(H\) by
\(d'x\wedge d''x\wedge d'y\wedge d''y\).  Direct
distributional differentiation gives
\[
               D M_S(Z)=-\delta_0.
\tag{CR9}
\]
Indeed the cross entry of the symmetric coefficient matrix
is \(Z_{xy}=\tfrac12{\bf1}_{x>0}{\bf1}_{y>0}\), while
its two diagonal entries vanish.  In these conventions the
coefficient of \(D[Z]\) on the plane is
\(\partial_y^2 Z_{xx}+\partial_x^2Z_{yy}
             -2\partial_x\partial_y Z_{xy}\), which is
\(-\delta_{(0,0)}\).  The proper linear inclusion commutes
with these distributional derivatives, proving CR9.

For the ordinary Euclidean positive coefficient control,
the measure CR3 on \(H\) is a positive constant multiple
of its two-dimensional area.  Therefore
\[
                   \mu_{S,\eta}(B_\delta(0))\asymp\delta^2
\tag{CR10}
\]
when the fixed test is nonzero near the origin.  The
second-derivative factor in CR4 is exactly critical.

This example does not come from an actual analytic-zero
relation.  Its ambient \(D[Z]\) is nonzero on the
\(z\)-axis, so it does not satisfy the original ambient
closed-current input either.  Its conclusion is exactly
that bounded coefficients and a closed positive background
do not supply a general point-support removal theorem.
The missing original-range input must use the actual-zero
structure, a stronger background mass estimate, or an exact
residual pairing argument.  The local positive-face and
punctured identities alone do not provide that input.

\paragraph{Sources and scope.}
The analytic premises are the retained QA scalar-module
return and the fixed-presentation positive order interface,
as used in NSA12, together with ordinary locality OL3.
CR4 and the real computation CR8--CR10 are the new elementary
deductions.  No support theorem for general currents, no
ordinary-to-GK passage, and no analytic realization of the
real example is asserted.