Contents of this source
Fixed all-test strict sources need not have a density neighborhood of solvability
Status and precise purpose.
This section proves a new original-category obstruction at a fixed reference source. It is not a new parameterized existence theorem. The reference potential already permits both signs of every original compact smooth scalar direction. Nevertheless arbitrarily small strictly positive original smooth density changes can leave the source image of the entire prescribed strong completion. The proof uses remaining degree one, where a linear moment identity is valid. No nonlinear Gauss-trace pushforward is asserted.
The new statements have status NEW_PROVED relative to the frozen R12–R16 chain, subject to the author-separated audit recorded in the companion ledger. The existing simultaneous probe, canonical convex Gauss traces, global Green energy, and literal fixed-source domination are INTERNAL_INPUT; they are not reproved as new. The full completed moment-Laplacian identity itself is already SO6, following DO6–DO9; the additional boundary and contraction statement below is new. Ordinary real Green theory and almost-everywhere differentiability of a monotone function are explicitly identified EXTERNAL_KNOWN inputs.
One allowed original background, with all original tests retained
Fix the prescribed finite extension , its unchanged absolute value, and an original uniformizer . Set and The closed box lies in the ordinary interior of the original compact affinoid , and extends to a neighborhood of that larger box. All radii are in the original value group. This is an allowed symmetric middle-positive separately - and -closed background, here in fact supplied by a smooth strongly positive form. This additional description is specific to the counterexample; no general positivity cones are identified. Here , , , and .
Let be the unchanged relative Borel strong completion with its printed approximation boundary condition, and let . Its quadratic mixed energy is , so . Write for its completed source measure. Actual defining functions retain boundedness where used, finite mass, compact strict negative sublevels, and the original canonical no-loss conditions. No ordinary boundary value is simply postulated for an arbitrary completed member.
Let be the original joint Gauss section. Frozen NF supplies a canonical finite nonpositive convex trace for each . It is additive, homogeneous, locally uniform under strong convergence, and agrees with only Lebesgue-almost everywhere for a general relative representative. All arguments below use this canonical trace; no point value of a Borel class at an outer-null Gauss point is chosen. The printed NF unit box is replaced by using the same proof after a real affine coordinate rescaling; the original field, absolute value and moment map are unchanged. Formula (FP6) below independently fixes the energy normalization in the present coordinates.
The degree-one moment equation and its completed zero boundary
Lemma (A continuous zero-boundary distribution with an energy bound). Let be a bounded open rectangle. Suppose , , and for some , Then and .
Proof. Extend continuously by zero outside . Let be inner rectangles exhausting , and mollify with a nonnegative even kernel of radius less than half the distance of to , obtaining . For a smooth test on , move the convolution onto the test in (FP2). Its support stays in , and convolution does not increase its gradient norm. Density therefore gives where is normed by the gradient.
Let be the harmonic extension of the smooth boundary values . Rectangles are regular for the ordinary Dirichlet problem. Equivalently one may minimize the real Dirichlet energy with those smooth trace values; the weak maximum principle and the elementary rectangle barriers give its continuous boundary values. Then and . Testing this equality by in (FP3) gives . Extend by zero to and extract a weakly convergent subsequence in .
Uniform continuity of the zero extension of implies . The maximum principle gives the same bound for . Also uniformly on compact subsets. Hence locally uniformly, identifying its weak limit with . Weak lower semicontinuity proves the claimed energy bound. This argument is the step excluding an uncontrolled harmonic boundary summand. ◻
Proposition (The completed moment identity retains the real zero boundary). In (FP1), every satisfies and Formula (FP5) is the frozen SO6 identity in this normalization. The new conclusion is (FP4), including its boundary condition. In particular, equality of two prescribed original source measures fixes the corresponding real zero-boundary Poisson equation uniquely.
Proof. For an actual bounded admissible potential and , original current recursion, compact Stokes and the full original top-form Gauss calibration give The factor is with the unnormalized in (FP1). The test has compact original support because is proper over compact subsets of . It is an exact difference of admissible actual potentials by frozen HC14–HC15. Consequently the full difference energy and its Cauchy–Schwarz inequality apply to it. These identities use actual original tests and the fixed smooth background, and require no unresolved delta-action quotient.
For two bounded actual admissible potentials , put and . Each individual convex trace is continuous in and tends uniformly to zero at its boundary: otherwise a sequence with value at most would lie in the fixed compact strict negative sublevel of the original potential while its moments leave every compact subset of . Thus extends continuously by zero to . Formula (FP6) and the positive energy matrix give (FP2) with . The preceding lemma proves In particular each actual trace lies in .
Every completed member has a bounded actual strongly defining row by the frozen clipping diagonal. In degree one, (FP7) makes its traces Cauchy in . Their NF locally uniform limit is precisely , so it is also the limit. Applying this to two rows proves (FP4) with the original completed boundary condition, rather than imposing a new boundary representative. Pass in the first line of (FP6) using completed source continuity on the fixed original compact test and the local convergence of the traces. This proves (FP5). No expression involving a higher power of has been used. ◻
A real Poisson perturbation that destroys convexity
We record the real lemma with all hypotheses needed for a possibly nonsmooth reference trace. The reference Hessian may have a singular positive part; no smoothness of the reference source density is assumed.
Lemma (Small smooth density changes of a locally strict convex source). Let be finite and convex on a rectangle . Put . Suppose on a nonempty ball that There are , , and positive after a subsequence, such that the unique solution of is not convex. Each lies in after discarding finitely many terms.
Proof. Fix a unit direction and an interior line segment in parallel to . The convex restriction of to this segment has a finite second-order expansion at almost every point: its right derivative is monotone and is differentiable with finite derivative almost everywhere; integrating that first-order expansion gives the second-order expansion of the restriction. Choose such a point , so that explicitly Put . Thus is the second derivative, not the coefficient of . This one-dimensional fact suffices; no second-order expansion in every direction is needed. Let be the positive Dirichlet Green function for on , and put for . With polar coordinates around and angle measured from , the fundamental solution and its harmonic correction give Here the correction is uniformly bounded after two derivatives on one fixed inner ball: its boundary data stay uniformly bounded as ranges in that inner ball, and the maximum principle and interior harmonic derivative estimate apply. In particular this statement does not require a smooth boundary at the corners of .
Choose with , small enough that the leading term in (FP10) dominates the bounded remainder on the fixed angular sectors . For take smooth radial cutoffs supported in , equal to one on , and between zero and one. Choose a fixed smooth angular function on the unit circle, with , supported where , and equal to one on a smaller nonempty angular arc. Define These are smooth compact functions, with and pointwise. On the smaller arc and middle annulus, (FP10) gives for a fixed . Thus (FP8) implies Any singular positive part of contributes with the same nonnegative sign. For each fixed , this integral is finite because its support is compact and separated from .
The distribution belongs to : multiplication of an test by the fixed compact smooth is bounded in , and . Let be its unique zero-boundary Poisson potential. It is harmonic near , and the Green formula, differentiated on that source-free ball, gives This formula also holds for the present finite signed measure on its compact support: convolve it there in , use the smooth-source Green formula, and pass to the limit. The solutions converge in ; on the source-free ball harmonic interior estimates give convergence of every derivative, while the smooth kernel on the compact source support passes through the measure limit. This justifies (FP13) without pairing a singular kernel with its pole.
Set and, if desired, pass to a subsequence making these numbers decrease. Then and the unique solution of (FP9) is . Since , the weak maximum principle also gives , so this candidate remains nonpositive and retains the zero boundary; the failed condition is convexity. Its restriction to the chosen line has a second-order expansion at with second coefficient . A convex function cannot have such a negative coefficient, by its centered second difference along . Hence is not convex. Positivity of the density follows for sufficiently large from . ◻
The fixed original source counterexample
Say that a bounded actual admissible has the full two-sided compact test property if All actual refinements of are included. This condition is nonempty: the frozen NP probe has it, is continuous and bounded between and zero, has finite mass and all finite positive power energies, and retains its strict negative-sublevel and no-loss boundary conditions. It is not a Banach interior claim.
Theorem (Failure of local density solvability at every such fixed source). In the one fixed original geometry (FP1), let be any bounded actual finite-mass reference with (FP14) and the printed actual boundary and no-loss hypotheses. Then the following statements hold.
For every nonempty real ball , there are strictly positive original smooth densities , with , such that In particular the reference is fixed throughout the sequence.
Every is a positive original Radon datum, literal and strongly continuous on the entire completed difference quotient. The data share the same null ideal as , and They have one common full original tester capacity bound and one common fixed-source strong modulus.
There is also a sequence as in (FP15) which tends to one in the original smooth compact-open topology on , as well as uniformly. For this additional assertion the compact supports of escape every compact subset of ; no common compact support is asserted.
Proof. First observe why the real lemma applies to the canonical trace of the fixed . Choose a real compact smooth scalar equal to on a neighborhood of . By properness is an original compact smooth scalar. Property (FP14) makes actual psh for some . Its canonical Gauss trace is and is convex. Therefore Formula (FP4) supplies , and (FP5) identifies . Apply the real lemma to get and .
If some had source , its source equality on the original tests would imply Uniqueness of the real zero-boundary Poisson solution identifies with the nonconvex in (FP9), contrary to the full completed Gauss convexity theorem NF. This excludes every source in the unchanged completion, not only toric or actual candidates. The argument uses a subset of the full original test family to derive a contradiction; it does not replace that family by a smaller one in any definition.
Fixed-source domination FD gives all literal and strong assertions, and its positive norm bound applied to gives (FP16). The bounds in (FP15) give equality of null ideals. If , then is an actual full normalized tester and in degree one. Hence This uses no raw/outer equality. The same fixed measure bound provides the common strong modulus from FD.
For the last assertion, choose balls escaping every compact subset of , with closures still inside . At each repeat (FP17) and the real lemma, choosing one of its perturbations with amplitude below . Each has compact support , contained in by properness. Every compact analytic has compact image in , disjoint from these supports for all sufficiently large . Thus is identically zero on an ordinary neighborhood of eventually, as an original smooth germ after every actual refinement; the zero representative is available there. This gives convergence in the original smooth compact-open topology. It does not claim that every ambient presentation of a zero germ vanishes away from its actual analytic image. Uniform convergence follows separately from the chosen amplitudes. ◻
Corollary (Degree-one density openness is already linear saturation). For at any nonzero completed in the general original scope of LI, existence of a two-sided density neighborhood of sources is equivalent to the known-source linear saturation condition LI13. In particular LI13 fails at every fixed actual of (FP14) in (FP1).
Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of LI, degree-one source linearity and injectivity. This is part of the same linearization mechanism, not another example family.
Proof. The reverse implication is LI with zero nonlinear remainder. For the forward implication, shrink a density radius if necessary and choose such that have sources for every real with . Degree-one additivity and source injectivity give . Thus Homogeneity gives the bound for every bounded . Linearized injectivity in LI makes this solution a bounded linear inverse. The last assertion follows from (FP15). No order-Lipschitz assumption on a pre-existing nonlinear solution map is needed for this degree-one argument. ◻
Consequences, topology limits, and failed shortcuts
The universally proposed implication “a fixed reference admits both signs of all original compact smooth tests, therefore every sufficiently small smooth density change of its source is compatible” is FALSE when smallness means uniform density norm, even with support in one fixed compact moment core. All data in this counterexample are already literal strong data. It neither refutes LG nor uses a nonliteral functional.
For the common-support construction, derivatives of the may grow as their inner annuli shrink. It does not assert convergence in all smooth seminorms on that same compact core. The smooth compact-open convergence in the last part instead uses supports escaping the boundary and is not convergence in the usual common-support topology of compact test functions. Treating either of these stronger unsupported topologies as proved would be a FAILED_ATTEMPT.
The actual reference and domain never change in either sequence. This differs from the already proved IS transfer, whose strict references vary with the density parameter. For , the principal-ideal linear inverse hypothesis LI13 necessarily fails at every in (FP14), since LI would otherwise solve all small uniform density perturbations. This diagnoses a real geometric obstruction to that sufficient condition, rather than silently assuming a bounded-Hessian estimate from scalar ellipticity.
In fact the perturbations can be chosen entirely upward: . Thus even this arbitrarily narrow one-sided Radon source bracket at the same full-test-strict reference does not force compatibility.
The real boundary identification is essential. Distributional equality of Laplacians alone would leave a harmonic summand and would not prove the counterexample. Likewise the positivity of is essential: it prevents an unexamined singular part of the reference Laplacian from cancelling the logarithmic lower bound. Both discarded shortcuts are recorded as FAILED_ATTEMPT.
No general GQ/CTO statement, KC12 converse, general literal rooftop theorem, or new capacity recovery conclusion follows. The independent geometric Dirichlet compatibility problem remains OPEN. All positive general implications elsewhere continue to use arbitrary original middle-positive with their exact printed hypotheses. No ordinary current identity here is promoted to all GK delta tests.
Exact input and external-source boundary.
The internal sources are DO6–DO9 and SO5–SO6 for the prior full-cone moment-Laplacian obstruction; NF6–NF11 for canonical full completed convex traces; GE7 and ED12 for positive quadratic energy and its completion; HC14–HC15 and HD14 for original compact scalar decomposition and the unnormalized full torus calibration; NP1–NP5 for the nonempty all-test strict reference class; and FD1–FD8 for full literal fixed-source domination. Their exact files, hashes, and read scopes are in the companion ledger. The actual boundary-to- bridge, its application to the full completed cone, and the fixed-source obstruction above are new proofs in this round.
The one-dimensional almost-everywhere second expansion follows from differentiation of the monotone derivative and the integral formula for a convex function. A primary exposition of this elementary one-dimensional input, and of the stronger theorem which is unnecessary here, is Ralph Howard, Alexandrov’s theorem on the second derivatives of convex functions via Rademacher’s theorem, May 1998, Remark 6.2, printed page 19; the convex integral formula is recalled in Section 2. The ordinary Green decomposition, weak Poisson uniqueness, maximum principle and interior harmonic estimates are the standard real facts documented in Jeff Viaclovsky’s MIT 18.156 lecture notes, Lectures 1–3 (interior estimates, Green decomposition and weak harmonic regularity), together with Lecture 17 for the weak Dirichlet problem via the Hilbert-space representation theorem. Their basic real statements are not claimed as new. The particular nonnegative angular-annular multiplier, its protection against singular reference mass, and the original-category conclusions are proved explicitly above. A targeted search of the exact frozen local sources found no prior fixed all-test-strict-source version; this is an internal novelty boundary, not a claim of world priority.