OpenMath

Proof source

Capacity stability of the graded current and energy calculus

Complete proof text in the unsigned reading edition.

Download sourceBrowse research records

Reading edition of the complete source note. Original labels and explicit equation tags are retained; references use source titles where compiled numbering is unavailable. Current result status is recorded separately in the project register.

Contents of this source
  1. Capacity stability of the graded current and energy calculus

Capacity stability of the graded current and energy calculus

Use the domain, background and power-energy notation of Sections sec:r11-power-all-degree and sec:r11-first-order-power-currents. The limits below are ordinary original-current limits, including every compact smooth complementary test and every actual moment refinement. No assertion about additional GK delta tests is implicit.

Lemma (Capacity-controlled coefficient multipliers). On a fixed ordinary compact test stage, suppose coefficient-Radon currents PlP_l converge to PP on original smooth tests. Suppose that for each fixed complementary test η\eta, all its coefficient variations, including that of PP, are bounded by Cηc(A)C_\eta c(A) on Borel sets AA, where cc is the same specified local relative capacity. Let al,aa_l,a be actual bounded Borel weights, with one common bound, such that al→aa_l\to a in that local capacity and aa is quasicontinuous for its ordinary-open outer version. Then alPl⟶aP(GS1)a_lP_l\longrightarrow aP \tag{GS1} on the original compact tests of that stage. Positivity and closedness of the PlP_l are not required.

Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the frozen capacity multiplier argument, stated for coefficient variation rather than only positive products.

Proof. For a fixed η\eta, split the changing-weight error over {∣al−a∣>δ}\{|a_l-a|>\delta\} and its complement. Its variation is at most 2MCηc({∣al−a∣>δ})2M C_\eta c(\{|a_l-a|>\delta\}) plus δ\delta times the uniformly bounded compact coefficient mass. Next remove an ordinary open set GG of arbitrarily small capacity on whose complement aa is continuous. On the compact remainder extend this bounded continuous function to a bounded continuous function on the compact stage. The latter extension is available in the original metrizable affinoid neighborhood. Both errors over GG are bounded by a fixed multiple of c(G)c(G), for the approximating and limiting coefficient measures separately. Original smooth scalar functions are uniformly dense in continuous functions on the compact stage, by the frozen original separation and cutoff argument. Their test convergence and the uniform coefficient mass bound give convergence with this continuous extension. Let the capacity error and then δ\delta tend to zero. The assumed bound for the limiting current has been used explicitly; it is not inferred by restricting a weak limit to an arbitrary Borel set. ◻

Lemma (Bounded weighted first-order and energy stability). Let bounded classical tuples converge in the exact localized capacity sense of (PE16), with a common actual bound. Over the fixed arbitrary original background, their bounded mixed currents, first-order currents d′(viQα)d'(v_iQ_\alpha) and d′′(viQα)d''(v_iQ_\alpha), and energy currents ΓQα(vi,va)\Gamma_{Q_\alpha}(v_i,v_a) converge on all original compact tests. Each conclusion remains valid after multiplication by a continuous function of the bounded tuple.

Status: NEW_PROVED for the first-order and energy extension; the bounded mixed current assertion is the frozen input already identified in Lemma lem:r11-bounded-analytic-capacity-stability.

Proof. The bounded mixed stability theorem first gives Qα,l→QαQ_{\alpha,l}\to Q_\alpha and all continuous tuple weights needed here. For clarity, a continuous function on the common compact range box is uniformly continuous, so its changing-weight gap is contained in a finite union of potential gap sets. It is quasicontinuous off a union of the finitely many bounded-potential exceptions. Lemma “Capacity-controlled coefficient multipliers” therefore proves its weighted convergence, using the bounded mixed capacity domination, without restricting the scalar composition to one variable.

In particular vi,lQα,l→viQαv_{i,l}Q_{\alpha,l}\to v_iQ_\alpha. Differentiating distributionally proves unweighted first-order convergence. Estimate (FO4), applied to the common bound on each local stage, controls the coefficient variations of these derivatives and their limit by the required local capacity. Apply the preceding multiplier lemma to prove the weighted first-order assertion.

For energies use the identity ΓQα(vi,va)=12D(vivaQα)−12viD(vaQα)−12vaD(viQα).(GS2)\Gamma_{Q_\alpha}(v_i,v_a) =\tfrac12D(v_iv_aQ_\alpha) -\tfrac12v_iD(v_aQ_\alpha) -\tfrac12v_aD(v_iQ_\alpha). \tag{GS2} The weighted bounded mixed theorem passes all three terms in distributions, hence gives unweighted current convergence of the energies. Estimate (PG8), and polarization of the positive energy matrix, bound their coefficient variations by the same local capacity. The multiplier lemma proves the last weighted assertion. Derivatives of nonsmooth weights have not been used anywhere in this proof. ◻

Theorem (Nonmonotone graded stability). Let vi,l∈ES,∂σ(V)v_{i,l}\in\mathcal E^\sigma_{S,\partial}(V), 1≤i≤m1\leq i\leq m, have a uniform bound on their σ\sigma-power energies. Let uiu_i be actual negative extended classical psh functions satisfying BG(ui,0)\mathrm{BG}(u_i,0), and suppose vi,l→uiv_{i,l}\to u_i in (PE16) in every slot. Then all uiu_i belong to the same power class.

Let FF be continuous on the nonpositive orthant with ∣F(x)∣≤A(1−∑ixi)a|F(x)|\leq A(1-\sum_i x_i)^a, a≥0a\geq0. With k=∣α∣k=|\alpha|, the following convergences hold under their respective strict inequalities: F(vl)Nα(vl)⟶F(u)Nα(u),a+k<q+σ,k≤q,F(vl)Jα,i′(vl)⟶F(u)Jα,i′(u),a+k+1<q+σ,k≤q−1,F(vl)Gihα(vl)⟶F(u)Gihα(u),a+k+2<q+σ,k≤q−1.(GS3)\begin{array}{ll} F(\mathbf v_l)N_\alpha(\mathbf v_l) \longrightarrow F(\mathbf u)N_\alpha(\mathbf u), &a+k<q+\sigma,\quad k\leq q,\\[2pt] F(\mathbf v_l){\cal J}'_{\alpha,i}(\mathbf v_l) \longrightarrow F(\mathbf u){\cal J}'_{\alpha,i}(\mathbf u), &a+k+1<q+\sigma,\quad k\leq q-1,\\[2pt] F(\mathbf v_l)G^\alpha_{ih}(\mathbf v_l) \longrightarrow F(\mathbf u)G^\alpha_{ih}(\mathbf u), &a+k+2<q+\sigma,\quad k\leq q-1. \end{array} \tag{GS3} There is the corresponding double-prime statement. Only terms whose indices meet the printed inequalities are asserted.

Equality in any of the three exponent conditions is also permitted if the following additional uniform tail condition holds for wl=∑ivi,lw_l=\sum_i v_{i,l}: lim⁡R→∞sup⁡l∫R∞tq+σ−1CS({wl<−t};V) dt=0.(GS4)\lim_{R\to\infty}\sup_l \int_R^\infty t^{q+\sigma-1} C_S(\{w_l<-t\};V)\,dt=0. \tag{GS4} This endpoint condition is not inferred from a uniform bound on the full power energies alone.

Status: NEW_PROVED. The topology is the exact all-stage capacity topology (PE16). Under the standing one-affinoid condition (DG1), Corollary “The fixed domain detects all local convergence and nullity” now proves its equivalence with fixed-domain capacity convergence on compact cores. This is the explicit analytic tester-extension theorem, not an assumed domain identification.

Proof. Apply Theorem thm:r11-power-capacity-stability to each slot, repeated in the qq differentiated positions, to obtain membership of the limits before constructing their unbounded currents. The energy cone estimate (PE10) bounds eσ(wl)e_\sigma(w_l) uniformly; (PE4) therefore bounds the full integrals Jwl(0){\cal J}_{w_l}(0) uniformly.

For each fixed truncation level jj, the preceding bounded stability lemma applies to every original compact test, including the bounded tuple weight. Equations (PG3), (FO8), and (PG12) bound the errors from removing the truncations, respectively, by constants times ja+k−q−σ,ja+k+1−q−σ,ja+k+2−q−σ,(GS5)j^{a+k-q-\sigma},\qquad j^{a+k+1-q-\sigma},\qquad j^{a+k+2-q-\sigma}, \tag{GS5} uniformly in ll. Their additional factor Jwl(j/4){\cal J}_{w_l}(j/4) may be bounded by its full integral. The finitely many compact core controls are uniform by bounded CLN at level one. The corresponding limiting errors tend to zero by the fixed-tuple estimates already proved. First pass l→∞l\to\infty at fixed jj, then let j→∞j\to\infty. This proves (GS3) whenever the displayed exponent is negative.

At exponent zero retain the tail factor instead of bounding it by the full integral. Assumption (GS4) then supplies the same two-limit argument. This proof does not pass a moving Borel restriction through weak convergence or presume equality of raw and outer capacities. ◻

Corollary (Full endpoint continuity for decreasing power families). If vi,l↓ui∈ES,∂σ(V)v_{i,l}\downarrow u_i\in \mathcal E^\sigma_{S,\partial}(V) are actual negative extended classical psh functions, then (GS3) holds with weak inequalities at every endpoint. In particular, for σ=1\sigma=1, the top energy currents GihαG^\alpha_{ih} with ∣α∣=q−1|\alpha|=q-1 are jointly decreasing-continuous on all original tests.

Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the proved graded estimates and bounded local decreasing capacity convergence.

Proof. Upward stability and (PE9) put all rows in the same power class with uniformly bounded energies. The analytic common-collar theorem gives (PE16) for each fixed bounded truncation. Since wl≥w=∑iuiw_l\geq w=\sum_i u_i, their capacity tails are bounded pointwise by the tail of ww. Thus (GS4) follows from the finite integral Jσ(w)J_\sigma(w). Apply the endpoint assertion. ◻

Why an endpoint needs a hypothesis.

The bounded shell family in Proposition “Same-power energy need not be continuous in capacity” has uniformly unit σ\sigma-power energy and converges in (PE16) to zero, while its critical weighted top measures converge to a nonzero mass at the rigid origin. This refutes removal of the strict exponent or uniform-tail qualification in the top weighted case of (GS3). It does not contradict decreasing endpoint continuity with an actual power-class limit.

References requiring source context

Some references in this note depend on its original surrounding manuscript. Their source labels are retained in the reading edition; its TeX is available above.

Source text and edition identity

This reading copy omits personal attribution and places existing mathematical question marks over their relation symbols. The mathematical content and source status are retained.

Reading-copy SHA-256 0971c89b91c0cdc780abf598b793fc3e0a252293bd781f1fa3bb71a96502e75b

Frozen-original SHA-256 0971c89b91c0cdc780abf598b793fc3e0a252293bd781f1fa3bb71a96502e75b

\section{Capacity stability of the graded current and energy calculus}
\label{sec:r11-graded-capacity-stability}

Use the domain, background and power-energy notation of
Sections~\ref{sec:r11-power-all-degree} and
\ref{sec:r11-first-order-power-currents}.
The limits below are ordinary original-current limits,
including every compact smooth complementary test and
every actual moment refinement. No assertion about
additional GK delta tests is implicit.

\begin{lemma}[Capacity-controlled coefficient multipliers]
\label{lem:r11-general-coefficient-capacity-multiplier}
On a fixed ordinary compact test stage, suppose
coefficient-Radon currents $P_l$ converge to $P$ on
original smooth tests. Suppose that for each fixed
complementary test $\eta$, all its coefficient variations,
including that of $P$, are bounded by $C_\eta c(A)$ on
Borel sets $A$, where $c$ is the same specified local
relative capacity. Let $a_l,a$ be actual bounded Borel
weights, with one common bound, such that $a_l\to a$ in
that local capacity and $a$ is quasicontinuous for its
ordinary-open outer version. Then
\[
                         a_lP_l\longrightarrow aP
 \tag{GS1}
\]
on the original compact tests of that stage.
Positivity and closedness of the $P_l$ are not required.
\end{lemma}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}} of
the frozen capacity multiplier argument, stated for
coefficient variation rather than only positive products.

\begin{proof}
For a fixed $\eta$, split the changing-weight error over
$\{|a_l-a|>\delta\}$ and its complement. Its variation
is at most
$2M C_\eta c(\{|a_l-a|>\delta\})$ plus $\delta$ times
the uniformly bounded compact coefficient mass.
Next remove an ordinary open set $G$ of arbitrarily small
capacity on whose complement $a$ is continuous.
On the compact remainder extend this bounded continuous
function to a bounded continuous function on the compact
stage. The latter extension is available in the original
metrizable affinoid neighborhood. Both errors over $G$
are bounded by a fixed multiple of $c(G)$, for the
approximating and limiting coefficient measures separately.
Original smooth scalar functions are uniformly dense in
continuous functions on the compact stage, by the frozen
original separation and cutoff argument. Their test
convergence and the uniform coefficient mass bound give
convergence with this continuous extension. Let the
capacity error and then $\delta$ tend to zero.
The assumed bound for the limiting current has been used
explicitly; it is not inferred by restricting a weak
limit to an arbitrary Borel set.
\end{proof}

\begin{lemma}[Bounded weighted first-order and energy stability]
\label{lem:r11-bounded-first-energy-capacity-stability}
Let bounded classical tuples converge in the exact
localized capacity sense of (PE16), with a common actual
bound. Over the fixed arbitrary original background,
their bounded mixed currents, first-order currents
$d'(v_iQ_\alpha)$ and $d''(v_iQ_\alpha)$, and energy
currents $\Gamma_{Q_\alpha}(v_i,v_a)$ converge on all
original compact tests. Each conclusion remains valid
after multiplication by a continuous function of the
bounded tuple.
\end{lemma}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{NEW\_PROVED}} for the
first-order and energy extension; the bounded mixed
current assertion is the frozen input already identified
in Lemma~\ref{lem:r11-bounded-analytic-capacity-stability}.

\begin{proof}
The bounded mixed stability theorem first gives
$Q_{\alpha,l}\to Q_\alpha$ and all continuous tuple
weights needed here. For clarity, a continuous function
on the common compact range box is uniformly continuous,
so its changing-weight gap is contained in a finite
union of potential gap sets. It is quasicontinuous off
a union of the finitely many bounded-potential exceptions.
Lemma~\ref{lem:r11-general-coefficient-capacity-multiplier}
therefore proves its weighted convergence, using the
bounded mixed capacity domination, without restricting
the scalar composition to one variable.

In particular $v_{i,l}Q_{\alpha,l}\to v_iQ_\alpha$.
Differentiating distributionally proves unweighted
first-order convergence. Estimate (FO4), applied to
the common bound on each local stage, controls the
coefficient variations of these derivatives and their
limit by the required local capacity.
Apply the preceding multiplier lemma to prove the
weighted first-order assertion.

For energies use the identity
\[
 \Gamma_{Q_\alpha}(v_i,v_a)
 =\tfrac12D(v_iv_aQ_\alpha)
       -\tfrac12v_iD(v_aQ_\alpha)
       -\tfrac12v_aD(v_iQ_\alpha).
 \tag{GS2}
\]
The weighted bounded mixed theorem passes all three
terms in distributions, hence gives unweighted current
convergence of the energies. Estimate (PG8), and
polarization of the positive energy matrix, bound
their coefficient variations by the same local
capacity. The multiplier lemma proves the last
weighted assertion. Derivatives of nonsmooth weights
have not been used anywhere in this proof.
\end{proof}

\begin{theorem}[Nonmonotone graded stability]
\label{thm:r11-nonmonotone-graded-stability}
Let $v_{i,l}\in\mathcal E^\sigma_{S,\partial}(V)$,
$1\leq i\leq m$, have a uniform bound on their
$\sigma$-power energies. Let $u_i$ be actual negative
extended classical psh functions satisfying
$\mathrm{BG}(u_i,0)$, and suppose
$v_{i,l}\to u_i$ in (PE16) in every slot.
Then all $u_i$ belong to the same power class.

Let $F$ be continuous on the nonpositive orthant with
$|F(x)|\leq A(1-\sum_i x_i)^a$, $a\geq0$.
With $k=|\alpha|$, the following convergences hold
under their respective strict inequalities:
\[
\begin{array}{ll}
 F(\mathbf v_l)N_\alpha(\mathbf v_l)
       \longrightarrow F(\mathbf u)N_\alpha(\mathbf u),
       &a+k<q+\sigma,\quad k\leq q,\\[2pt]
 F(\mathbf v_l){\cal J}'_{\alpha,i}(\mathbf v_l)
       \longrightarrow F(\mathbf u){\cal J}'_{\alpha,i}(\mathbf u),
       &a+k+1<q+\sigma,\quad k\leq q-1,\\[2pt]
 F(\mathbf v_l)G^\alpha_{ih}(\mathbf v_l)
       \longrightarrow F(\mathbf u)G^\alpha_{ih}(\mathbf u),
       &a+k+2<q+\sigma,\quad k\leq q-1.
\end{array}
 \tag{GS3}
\]
There is the corresponding double-prime statement.
Only terms whose indices meet the printed inequalities
are asserted.

Equality in any of the three exponent conditions is
also permitted if the following additional uniform
tail condition holds for $w_l=\sum_i v_{i,l}$:
\[
 \lim_{R\to\infty}\sup_l
       \int_R^\infty t^{q+\sigma-1}
              C_S(\{w_l<-t\};V)\,dt=0.
 \tag{GS4}
\]
This endpoint condition is not inferred from a
uniform bound on the full power energies alone.
\end{theorem}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{NEW\_PROVED}}.
The topology is the exact all-stage capacity topology
(PE16). Under the standing one-affinoid condition (DG1),
Corollary~\ref{cor:r11-affinoid-local-capacity-topology}
now proves its equivalence with fixed-domain capacity
convergence on compact cores. This is the explicit analytic
tester-extension theorem, not an assumed domain identification.

\begin{proof}
Apply Theorem~\ref{thm:r11-power-capacity-stability} to
each slot, repeated in the $q$ differentiated positions,
to obtain membership of the limits before constructing
their unbounded currents. The energy cone estimate
(PE10) bounds $e_\sigma(w_l)$ uniformly; (PE4) therefore
bounds the full integrals $ {\cal J}_{w_l}(0)$ uniformly.

For each fixed truncation level $j$, the preceding
bounded stability lemma applies to every original
compact test, including the bounded tuple weight.
Equations (PG3), (FO8), and (PG12) bound the errors
from removing the truncations, respectively, by
constants times
\[
 j^{a+k-q-\sigma},\qquad
 j^{a+k+1-q-\sigma},\qquad
 j^{a+k+2-q-\sigma},
 \tag{GS5}
\]
uniformly in $l$. Their additional factor
$ {\cal J}_{w_l}(j/4)$ may be bounded by its full
integral. The finitely many compact core controls
are uniform by bounded CLN at level one.
The corresponding limiting errors tend to zero
by the fixed-tuple estimates already proved.
First pass $l\to\infty$ at fixed $j$, then let
$j\to\infty$. This proves (GS3) whenever the
displayed exponent is negative.

At exponent zero retain the tail factor instead
of bounding it by the full integral. Assumption
(GS4) then supplies the same two-limit argument.
This proof does not pass a moving Borel restriction
through weak convergence or presume equality of
raw and outer capacities.
\end{proof}

\begin{corollary}[Full endpoint continuity for decreasing power families]
\label{cor:r11-decreasing-graded-endpoints}
If $v_{i,l}\downarrow u_i\in
\mathcal E^\sigma_{S,\partial}(V)$ are actual negative
extended classical psh functions, then (GS3) holds
with weak inequalities at every endpoint.
In particular, for $\sigma=1$, the top energy
currents $G^\alpha_{ih}$ with $|\alpha|=q-1$
are jointly decreasing-continuous on all original tests.
\end{corollary}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}}
of the proved graded estimates and bounded local
decreasing capacity convergence.

\begin{proof}
Upward stability and (PE9) put all rows in the
same power class with uniformly bounded energies.
The analytic common-collar theorem gives (PE16)
for each fixed bounded truncation. Since
$w_l\geq w=\sum_i u_i$, their capacity tails
are bounded pointwise by the tail of $w$.
Thus (GS4) follows from the finite integral
$J_\sigma(w)$. Apply the endpoint assertion.
\end{proof}

\paragraph{Why an endpoint needs a hypothesis.}
The bounded shell family in
Proposition~\ref{prop:r11-power-energy-continuity-failure}
has uniformly unit $\sigma$-power energy and converges
in (PE16) to zero, while its critical weighted top
measures converge to a nonzero mass at the rigid
origin. This refutes removal of the strict exponent
or uniform-tail qualification in the top weighted
case of (GS3). It does not contradict decreasing
endpoint continuity with an actual power-class limit.