OpenMath

Proof source

Capacity-controlled signed data in the strong energy dual

Complete proof text in the unsigned reading edition.

Download sourceBrowse research records

Reading edition of the complete source note. Original labels and explicit equation tags are retained; references use source titles where compiled numbering is unavailable. Current result status is recorded separately in the project register.

Contents of this source
  1. Capacity-controlled signed data in the strong energy dual

Capacity-controlled signed data in the strong energy dual

We retain exactly the strict Laurent-box and extension hypotheses (ED1), the arbitrary original middle-positive separately closed background SS, and all original tests. Put d=q+1≥2d=q+1\geq2, C=E^str1(V)\mathscr C=\widehat{\mathcal E}^{1}_{\rm str}(V), and DS=C−C\mathbb D_S=\mathscr C-\mathscr C. No moment presentation or special form of SS is imposed in this section. The outer capacity CS∗(E;V)C_S^*(E;V) always uses the full original bounded classical tester class on the specified whole domain VV.

The datum criterion below is a sufficient condition for membership in the strong-continuous dual, not a nonlinear solvability theorem. It does not require domination by one actual curvature measure.

Definition (An integrable capacity modulus). An integrable capacity modulus in degree dd is a nondecreasing function F:[0,∞]→[0,∞]F:[0,\infty]\to[0,\infty], finite on every finite positive argument, with F(0)=0F(0)=0, such that ∫01F(s)s−1−1/d ds<∞.(CD1)\int_0^1 F(s)s^{-1-1/d}\,ds<\infty. \tag{CD1} The value at infinity is its increasing limit. Let μ\mu be a finite signed original Radon measure on VV. We say that its variation has modulus FF if ∣μ∣(E)≤F(CS∗(E;V))for every Borel E⊂V.(CD2)|\mu|(E)\leq F\bigl(C_S^*(E;V)\bigr) \quad\text{for every Borel }E\subset V. \tag{CD2} The total variation m=∣μ∣(V)m=|\mu|(V) is finite independently of whether CS∗(V;V)C_S^*(V;V) is finite.

Put C0=d2dC_0=d2^d, as in (ED5), and define AF,m:=∫0∞min⁡{m,F(C0s−d)} ds.(CD3)A_{F,m}:=\int_0^\infty \min\{m,F(C_0s^{-d})\}\,ds. \tag{CD3} If m=0m=0, set AF,0=0A_{F,0}=0. Substitution x=C0s−dx=C_0s^{-d} on a tail of the integral shows that (CD1) makes (CD3) finite.

Theorem (Literal signed data and strong continuity). Suppose μ\mu satisfies (CD2) for an integrable capacity modulus. Then every h∈DSh\in\mathbb D_S is absolutely integrable for ∣μ∣|\mu|, and ℓμ(h)=−∫Vh dμ,∥ℓμ∥∗≤AF,m(CD4)\ell_\mu(h)=-\int_V h\,d\mu, \qquad \|\ell_\mu\|_*\leq A_{F,m} \tag{CD4} defines an element of DS,s∗\mathbb D_{S,\mathrm s}^*. More explicitly, if uj,u∈Cu_j,u\in\mathscr C and I(uj,u)→0I(u_j,u)\to0, then ∫V∣uj−u∣ d∣μ∣⟶0.(CD5)\int_V|u_j-u|\,d|\mu|\longrightarrow0. \tag{CD5} All differences and integrals are unchanged by locally outer-null modifications. The assertion holds for every q≥1q\geq1 and every allowed original SS, including degenerate backgrounds after the specified relative quotient.

Status: NEW_PROVED as a full-degree signed datum class in the newly constructed Banach dual. The sublevel and all-local strong capacity estimates are the explicitly inherited R11 inputs (CI3), (EV7)–(EV8).

Proof. For a∈Ca\in\mathscr C, (ED5) and (CD2) give ∣μ∣{a<−t}≤min⁡{m,F(C0r(a)dt−d)},t>0.(CD6)|\mu|\{a<-t\} \leq \min\{m,F(C_0r(a)^d t^{-d})\},\qquad t>0. \tag{CD6} The actual Borel representative of aa is nonpositive and finite outside an outer-null set. Condition (CD2) annihilates this set. The layer-cake formula, followed by t=r(a)st=r(a)s, therefore gives ∫V(−a) d∣μ∣≤AF,mr(a).(CD7)\int_V(-a)\,d|\mu| \leq A_{F,m}r(a). \tag{CD7} When r(a)=0r(a)=0, the class is zero outside a local outer-null set, which is globally outer-null in the fixed domain by the R11 countable compact exhaustion and domain comparison. Thus (CD7) holds in that case too. If h=a−bh=a-b, then ∣h∣≤(−a)+(−b)|h|\leq(-a)+(-b) off the joint null set. Consequently ∫∣h∣ d∣μ∣≤AF,m(r(a)+r(b))\int|h|\,d|\mu|\leq A_{F,m}(r(a)+r(b)). Taking the infimum over its presentations proves absolute integrability and (CD4). This is a literal integral on the actual Borel difference space; no unproved extension of a measure to abstract completion points is used.

Now let uj→uu_j\to u strongly. The energy-root estimate gives a finite RR with r(uj),r(u)≤Rr(u_j),r(u)\leq R. If R=0R=0 the assertion is immediate. Otherwise, for every L>0L>0, (CD6) gives sup⁡j∫V((−uj)−L)+ d∣μ∣≤∫L∞min⁡{m,F(C0Rdt−d)} dt⟶0(L→∞).(CD8)\sup_j\int_V\bigl((-u_j)-L\bigr)_+\,d|\mu| \leq\int_L^\infty \min\{m,F(C_0R^d t^{-d})\}\,dt \longrightarrow0\quad(L\to\infty). \tag{CD8} The same bound holds for uu. This is a uniform integrability statement for the full finite datum, including its boundary tail.

Fix LL and write uj(L)=max⁡(uj,−L)u_j^{(L)}=\max(u_j,-L) and u(L)=max⁡(u,−L)u^{(L)}=\max(u,-L). On each compact K⋐VK\Subset V, the R11 strong estimate makes CS∗(K∩{∣uj(L)−u(L)∣>ε};V)C_S^*(K\cap\{|u_j^{(L)}-u^{(L)}|>\varepsilon\};V) tend to zero. An integrable nondecreasing modulus satisfies F(s)→0F(s)\to0 as s↓0s\downarrow0: otherwise (CD1) would diverge. Hence (CD2) gives convergence in ∣μ∣|\mu|-measure on KK. The clipped differences are bounded by LL, so their integrals over KK tend to zero. Radon inner regularity and finiteness of ∣μ∣|\mu| allow a compact KK with arbitrarily small ∣μ∣(V∖K)|\mu|(V\setminus K); the same bound LL then passes this convergence to the whole domain. Finally (CD8) removes the clipping uniformly. This proves (CD5) and the defining strong-dual continuity (NI4).

Every capacity in the argument is the frozen full original capacity. Actual moment refinements alter neither the measure integrals nor the classes of tests defining these estimates. No assertion of raw outer regularity on arbitrary Borel sets is needed. ◻

Corollary (Power and logarithmic endpoint moduli). Let m=∣μ∣(V)<∞m=|\mu|(V)<\infty. If, for constants A>0A>0 and γ>1/d\gamma>1/d, ∣μ∣(E)≤A CS∗(E;V)γ(E Borel),(CD9)|\mu|(E)\leq A\,C_S^*(E;V)^\gamma \quad(E\text{ Borel}), \tag{CD9} then ℓμ∈DS,s∗\ell_\mu\in\mathbb D_{S,\mathrm s}^* and ∥ℓμ∥∗≤dγdγ−1m1−1/(dγ)(AC0γ)1/(dγ).(CD10)\|\ell_\mu\|_* \leq \frac{d\gamma}{d\gamma-1} m^{1-1/(d\gamma)} (A C_0^\gamma)^{1/(d\gamma)}. \tag{CD10} There are also endpoint admissible moduli: any nondecreasing extension, for ss bounded away from zero, of F(s)=As1/d(log⁡(e/s))−α(0<s≤1),α>1,(CD11)F(s)=A s^{1/d}\bigl(\log(e/s)\bigr)^{-\alpha} \quad(0<s\leq1),\qquad \alpha>1, \tag{CD11} satisfies (CD1). Neither the unmodified critical power s1/ds^{1/d} nor the range α≤1\alpha\leq1 satisfies this integral criterion. This last statement is about the criterion, not a universal necessity claim for all possible measures.

Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY.

Proof. For (CD9), (CD3) becomes the integral of min⁡(m,AC0γs−dγ)\min(m,A C_0^\gamma s^{-d\gamma}). Splitting at s0=(AC0γ/m)1/(dγ)s_0=(A C_0^\gamma/m)^{1/(d\gamma)} yields (CD10) when m>0m>0, and the zero case is immediate. For (CD11), substitution y=log⁡(e/s)y=\log(e/s) turns (CD1), up to the harmless constant AA, into ∫1∞y−α dy\int_1^\infty y^{-\alpha}\,dy. This proves all printed assertions without an endpoint counterexample being inferred from the failure of a sufficient estimate. ◻

Proposition (Uniform capacity control converts variation to dual convergence). Let μj,μ\mu_j,\mu be finite signed Radon measures such that mj=∣μj−μ∣(V)→0m_j=|\mu_j-\mu|(V)\to0. Suppose the variations ∣μj−μ∣|\mu_j-\mu| all satisfy (CD2) with one common integrable modulus FF. Then ∥ℓμj−μ∥∗≤AF,mj⟶0.(CD12)\|\ell_{\mu_j-\mu}\|_* \leq A_{F,m_j}\longrightarrow0. \tag{CD12} This unconditional statement defines only the functional of the controlled difference. If the individual datum functionals are defined, it is their difference by literal integration. If additionally each ℓμj\ell_{\mu_j} and ℓμ\ell_\mu lies in DS,s∗\mathbb D_{S,\mathrm s}^*, their canonical variational potentials from (NI7) converge strongly, and their normal residuals converge in dual norm. For power domination the right side in (CD12) has the explicit bound (CD10) with m=mjm=m_j. If ℓμj=J(uj)\ell_{\mu_j}=J(u_j) are actual completed source functionals, then the limit is itself J(u)J(u); in that special case μ^u=μ\widehat\mu_u=\mu on every original scalar test.

Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the new datum criterion and nonlinear closed-image theorem.

Proof. Apply (CD4) to μj−μ\mu_j-\mu. Since mjm_j is bounded, the integrands in (CD3) are dominated by one integrable function min⁡(M,F(C0s−d))\min(M,F(C_0s^{-d})) and tend pointwise to zero. Dominated convergence proves (CD12). The quantitative retraction estimate (NI11) supplies strong convergence of the variational potentials and dual convergence of their curvatures; subtracting from the data gives convergence of the residuals. The final assertion is the closed-image criterion (NI1)–(NI3). It assumes source approximants and does not create them from capacity domination. ◻

Relation to the frozen first-order theory.

R11 already solves a different linear transposition equation for arbitrary finite diffuse data in a first-order Dirichlet-form space. That result does not say that the solution is a classical psh strong-completion member. The present theorem places signed data in an all-degree nonlinear energy dual and supplies its variational decomposition. It neither supersedes that linear result nor removes the nonlinear normal residual. In particular, bounded-source domination implies (CD9) with γ=1\gamma=1, but the compact-source examples in Section “Closed positive moment lifts and nonlinear source compatibility” show that even this datum class does not imply the unrestricted source equation.

Source text and edition identity

This reading copy omits personal attribution and places existing mathematical question marks over their relation symbols. The mathematical content and source status are retained.

Reading-copy SHA-256 415cab8b5265bd34d298db187317ac28cd075f4265939e0d362a0b30c42da7e0

Frozen-original SHA-256 415cab8b5265bd34d298db187317ac28cd075f4265939e0d362a0b30c42da7e0

\section{Capacity-controlled signed data in the strong energy dual}
\label{sec:r12-capacity-dual-data}

We retain exactly the strict Laurent-box and extension hypotheses
(ED1), the arbitrary original middle-positive separately closed
background $S$, and all original tests. Put $d=q+1\geq2$,
$\mathscr C=\widehat{\mathcal E}^{1}_{\rm str}(V)$, and
$\mathbb D_S=\mathscr C-\mathscr C$. No moment presentation or
special form of $S$ is imposed in this section. The outer capacity
$C_S^*(E;V)$ always uses the full original bounded classical tester
class on the specified whole domain $V$.

The datum criterion below is a sufficient condition for membership
in the strong-continuous dual, not a nonlinear solvability theorem.
It does not require domination by one actual curvature measure.

\begin{definition}[An integrable capacity modulus]
\label{def:r12-integrable-capacity-modulus}
An integrable capacity modulus in degree $d$ is a nondecreasing
function $F:[0,\infty]\to[0,\infty]$, finite on every finite
positive argument, with $F(0)=0$, such that
\[
                 \int_0^1 F(s)s^{-1-1/d}\,ds<\infty.
 \tag{CD1}
\]
The value at infinity is its increasing limit. Let $\mu$ be a
finite signed original Radon measure on $V$. We say that its
variation has modulus $F$ if
\[
                    |\mu|(E)\leq F\bigl(C_S^*(E;V)\bigr)
                    \quad\text{for every Borel }E\subset V.
 \tag{CD2}
\]
The total variation $m=|\mu|(V)$ is finite independently of
whether $C_S^*(V;V)$ is finite.
\end{definition}

Put $C_0=d2^d$, as in (ED5), and define
\[
       A_{F,m}:=\int_0^\infty
              \min\{m,F(C_0s^{-d})\}\,ds.
 \tag{CD3}
\]
If $m=0$, set $A_{F,0}=0$. Substitution $x=C_0s^{-d}$ on a
tail of the integral shows that (CD1) makes (CD3) finite.

\begin{theorem}[Literal signed data and strong continuity]
\label{thm:r12-capacity-modulus-strong-dual}
Suppose $\mu$ satisfies (CD2) for an integrable capacity modulus.
Then every $h\in\mathbb D_S$ is absolutely integrable for
$|\mu|$, and
\[
       \ell_\mu(h)=-\int_V h\,d\mu,
       \qquad
       \|\ell_\mu\|_*\leq A_{F,m}
 \tag{CD4}
\]
defines an element of $\mathbb D_{S,\mathrm s}^*$.
More explicitly, if $u_j,u\in\mathscr C$ and $I(u_j,u)\to0$,
then
\[
                    \int_V|u_j-u|\,d|\mu|\longrightarrow0.
 \tag{CD5}
\]
All differences and integrals are unchanged by locally outer-null
modifications. The assertion holds for every $q\geq1$ and every
allowed original $S$, including degenerate backgrounds after the
specified relative quotient.
\end{theorem}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{NEW\_PROVED}} as a
full-degree signed datum class in the newly constructed Banach
dual. The sublevel and all-local strong capacity estimates are
the explicitly inherited R11 inputs (CI3), (EV7)--(EV8).

\begin{proof}
For $a\in\mathscr C$, (ED5) and (CD2) give
\[
       |\mu|\{a<-t\}
       \leq \min\{m,F(C_0r(a)^d t^{-d})\},\qquad t>0.
 \tag{CD6}
\]
The actual Borel representative of $a$ is nonpositive and finite
outside an outer-null set. Condition (CD2) annihilates this set.
The layer-cake formula, followed by $t=r(a)s$, therefore gives
\[
                        \int_V(-a)\,d|\mu|
                                      \leq A_{F,m}r(a).
 \tag{CD7}
\]
When $r(a)=0$, the class is zero outside a local outer-null set,
which is globally outer-null in the fixed domain by the R11
countable compact exhaustion and domain comparison. Thus (CD7)
holds in that case too. If $h=a-b$, then
$|h|\leq(-a)+(-b)$ off the joint null set. Consequently
$\int|h|\,d|\mu|\leq A_{F,m}(r(a)+r(b))$. Taking the infimum
over its presentations proves absolute integrability and (CD4).
This is a literal integral on the actual Borel difference space;
no unproved extension of a measure to abstract completion points
is used.

Now let $u_j\to u$ strongly. The energy-root estimate gives a
finite $R$ with $r(u_j),r(u)\leq R$. If $R=0$ the assertion
is immediate. Otherwise, for every $L>0$, (CD6) gives
\[
 \sup_j\int_V\bigl((-u_j)-L\bigr)_+\,d|\mu|
       \leq\int_L^\infty
                  \min\{m,F(C_0R^d t^{-d})\}\,dt
                   \longrightarrow0\quad(L\to\infty).
 \tag{CD8}
\]
The same bound holds for $u$. This is a uniform integrability
statement for the full finite datum, including its boundary tail.

Fix $L$ and write $u_j^{(L)}=\max(u_j,-L)$ and
$u^{(L)}=\max(u,-L)$. On each compact $K\Subset V$, the
R11 strong estimate makes
$C_S^*(K\cap\{|u_j^{(L)}-u^{(L)}|>\varepsilon\};V)$ tend
to zero. An integrable nondecreasing modulus satisfies
$F(s)\to0$ as $s\downarrow0$: otherwise (CD1) would diverge.
Hence (CD2) gives convergence in $|\mu|$-measure on $K$.
The clipped differences are bounded by $L$, so their integrals
over $K$ tend to zero. Radon inner regularity and finiteness of
$|\mu|$ allow a compact $K$ with arbitrarily small
$|\mu|(V\setminus K)$; the same bound $L$ then passes this
convergence to the whole domain. Finally (CD8) removes the
clipping uniformly. This proves (CD5) and the defining
strong-dual continuity (NI4).

Every capacity in the argument is the frozen full original
capacity. Actual moment refinements alter neither the measure
integrals nor the classes of tests defining these estimates.
No assertion of raw outer regularity on arbitrary Borel sets
is needed.
\end{proof}

\begin{corollary}[Power and logarithmic endpoint moduli]
\label{cor:r12-power-capacity-dual-data}
Let $m=|\mu|(V)<\infty$. If, for constants $A>0$ and
$\gamma>1/d$,
\[
                 |\mu|(E)\leq A\,C_S^*(E;V)^\gamma
                    \quad(E\text{ Borel}),
 \tag{CD9}
\]
then $\ell_\mu\in\mathbb D_{S,\mathrm s}^*$ and
\[
 \|\ell_\mu\|_*
 \leq \frac{d\gamma}{d\gamma-1}
       m^{1-1/(d\gamma)}
                  (A C_0^\gamma)^{1/(d\gamma)}.
 \tag{CD10}
\]
There are also endpoint admissible moduli: any nondecreasing
extension, for $s$ bounded away from zero, of
\[
             F(s)=A s^{1/d}\bigl(\log(e/s)\bigr)^{-\alpha}
                   \quad(0<s\leq1),\qquad \alpha>1,
 \tag{CD11}
\]
satisfies (CD1). Neither the unmodified critical power
$s^{1/d}$ nor the range $\alpha\leq1$ satisfies this
integral criterion. This last statement is about the criterion,
not a universal necessity claim for all possible measures.
\end{corollary}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}}.

\begin{proof}
For (CD9), (CD3) becomes the integral of
$\min(m,A C_0^\gamma s^{-d\gamma})$. Splitting at
$s_0=(A C_0^\gamma/m)^{1/(d\gamma)}$ yields (CD10) when
$m>0$, and the zero case is immediate. For (CD11), substitution
$y=\log(e/s)$ turns (CD1), up to the harmless constant $A$,
into $\int_1^\infty y^{-\alpha}\,dy$. This proves all printed
assertions without an endpoint counterexample being inferred
from the failure of a sufficient estimate.
\end{proof}

\begin{proposition}[Uniform capacity control converts variation to dual convergence]
\label{prop:r12-capacity-dini-data-stability}
Let $\mu_j,\mu$ be finite signed Radon measures such that
$m_j=|\mu_j-\mu|(V)\to0$. Suppose the variations
$|\mu_j-\mu|$ all satisfy (CD2) with one common integrable
modulus $F$. Then
\[
         \|\ell_{\mu_j-\mu}\|_*
                \leq A_{F,m_j}\longrightarrow0.
 \tag{CD12}
\]
This unconditional statement defines only the functional of the
controlled difference. If the individual datum functionals are
defined, it is their difference by literal integration.
If additionally each $\ell_{\mu_j}$ and $\ell_\mu$ lies in
$\mathbb D_{S,\mathrm s}^*$, their canonical variational
potentials from (NI7) converge strongly, and their normal
residuals converge in dual norm. For power domination the
right side in (CD12) has the explicit bound (CD10) with
$m=m_j$. If $\ell_{\mu_j}=J(u_j)$ are actual completed source
functionals, then the limit is itself $J(u)$; in that special
case $\widehat\mu_u=\mu$ on every original scalar test.
\end{proposition}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}} of
the new datum criterion and nonlinear closed-image theorem.

\begin{proof}
Apply (CD4) to $\mu_j-\mu$. Since $m_j$ is bounded, the
integrands in (CD3) are dominated by one integrable function
$\min(M,F(C_0s^{-d}))$ and tend pointwise to zero. Dominated
convergence proves (CD12). The quantitative retraction estimate
(NI11) supplies strong convergence of the variational potentials
and dual convergence of their curvatures; subtracting from the
data gives convergence of the residuals. The final assertion is
the closed-image criterion (NI1)--(NI3). It assumes source
approximants and does not create them from capacity domination.
\end{proof}

\paragraph{Relation to the frozen first-order theory.}
R11 already solves a different linear transposition equation for
arbitrary finite diffuse data in a first-order Dirichlet-form
space. That result does not say that the solution is a classical
psh strong-completion member. The present theorem places signed
data in an all-degree nonlinear energy dual and supplies its
variational decomposition. It neither supersedes that linear
result nor removes the nonlinear normal residual. In particular,
bounded-source domination implies (CD9) with $\gamma=1$, but
the compact-source examples in Section~\ref{sec:r12-positive-moment-lifts}
show that even this datum class does not imply the unrestricted
source equation.