OpenMath

Proof source

Energy balls need not be weakly compact in either Banach realization

Complete proof text in the unsigned reading edition.

Download sourceBrowse research records

Reading edition of the complete source note. Original labels and explicit equation tags are retained; references use source titles where compiled numbering is unavailable. Current result status is recorded separately in the project register.

Contents of this source
  1. Energy balls need not be weakly compact in either Banach realization

Energy balls need not be weakly compact in either Banach realization

The weak-∗* compact datum family in (CW14) does not by itself supply a weakly compact family of candidate potentials. The following consequence of the proved pole example makes that obstruction explicit. It is a statement about the two new Banach norms, not about failure of the complete strong topology.

Fix n>q≥1n>q\geq1 and the original radial-mixture background SS of (PO3), on its original unit polydisc VV. Retain the original field and absolute value. Put d=q+1d=q+1 and use the already proved actual potentials ψj=max⁡ ⁣(log⁡max⁡1≤i≤n∣Ti∣,−j),u=log⁡max⁡1≤i≤n∣Ti∣,j=1,2,….(WB1)\psi_j=\max\!\left(\log\max_{1\leq i\leq n}|T_i|,-j\right), \qquad u=\log\max_{1\leq i\leq n}|T_i|, \qquad j=1,2,\ldots . \tag{WB1} The value of uu at the origin is −∞-\infty. It represents a member of the same no-loss first-energy cone, and (PO7) gives e(u)=1,e(ψj)=1−e−j,I(ψj,u)=e−j.(WB2)e(u)=1,\qquad e(\psi_j)=1-e^{-j},\qquad I(\psi_j,u)=e^{-j}. \tag{WB2} The pole functional is continuous on both DS\mathbb D_S and LS\mathbb L_S and satisfies L∞(u)=1,L∞(ψj)=0.(WB3)L_\infty(u)=1,\qquad L_\infty(\psi_j)=0. \tag{WB3} All these statements are exactly the earlier original-current pole construction, including its actual Borel representatives.

Proposition (No weak cluster and nonreflexivity in every remaining degree). For the allowed data just specified, the sequence (ψj)(\psi_j) has no weakly convergent subnet, and in particular no weakly convergent subsequence, in either DS\mathbb D_S or LS\mathbb L_S. Consequently BC={v∈C:r(v)≤1}(WB4)\mathcal B_{\mathscr C} =\{v\in\mathscr C:r(v)\leq1\} \tag{WB4} is not weakly compact in either Banach space, and neither DS\mathbb D_S nor LS\mathbb L_S is reflexive.

This holds in every remaining degree q≥1q\geq1 by the specified example in every n>qn>q. It does not say that these spaces are nonreflexive for every possible background SS, including the zero or other degenerate backgrounds.

Status: DIRECT_COROLLARY of the present round’s exact Banach realizations, source-functional continuity and pole functional. The proposed universal weak compactness of bounded potential energy balls is FALSE. The weak closedness of norm-closed convex sets and weak compactness of bounded closed balls in a reflexive Banach space are EXTERNAL_KNOWN functional-analysis facts.

Proof. Let EE denote either DS\mathbb D_S or LS\mathbb L_S. The proved realization theorems say that the same cone C\mathscr C is norm closed and convex in EE, and that ∥v∥E=r(v)(v∈C).(WB5)\|v\|_E=r(v)\qquad(v\in\mathscr C). \tag{WB5} It is therefore weakly closed, by the Hahn–Banach separation theorem. Every source functional J(a)J(a), a∈Ca\in\mathscr C, is continuous on EE. In the lattice case this uses its proved literal extension (OL6), not a newly assumed extension of an arbitrary dual. On the cone these source functionals are also continuous for the strong discrepancy topology, by the frozen tester estimate and (NI4).

Suppose that a subnet (ψjγ)(\psi_{j_\gamma}) converges weakly in EE to vv. The subnet indices are cofinal in the integer row, so (WB2) still makes it converge strongly to uu. Weak closedness gives v∈Cv\in\mathscr C. For every fixed a∈Ca\in\mathscr C, the weak and strong continuities just stated give, respectively, J(a)(v)=lim⁡γJ(a)(ψjγ)=J(a)(u).(WB6)J(a)(v)=\lim_\gamma J(a)(\psi_{j_\gamma})=J(a)(u). \tag{WB6} Choose a=va=v and a=ua=u. The exact energy-discrepancy identity then yields I(v,u)=(J(v)−J(u))(v−u)=0.(WB7)I(v,u)=(J(v)-J(u))(v-u)=0. \tag{WB7} The strong cone is separated, so v=uv=u as its original relative Borel class. On the other hand, continuity of L∞∈E∗L_\infty\in E^* and (WB3) would give L∞(v)=0L_\infty(v)=0, whereas L∞(u)=1L_\infty(u)=1. This is a contradiction. It proves the absence of a weakly convergent subnet in either space.

The sequence lies in (WB4), by (WB2) and (WB5). Every net in a compact space has a convergent subnet; thus (WB4) is not weakly compact. Finally (WB4) is the intersection of the norm-closed convex cone with the closed unit ball, so it is weakly closed in that ball. If EE were reflexive, its closed unit ball would be weakly compact, making (WB4) weakly compact as well. This contradiction proves nonreflexivity. ◻

Consequence for the compact-capacity attempt.

The mechanism “bounded first energies imply weakly compact potential candidates; then use weak-∗* compactness of the localized source data” is invalid in these Banach realizations. The first assertion is disproved by (WB1)–(WB7), even though the displayed row actually converges strongly. This does not contradict strong completeness of C\mathscr C, completeness of the curvature metric dJd_J, or the weak-∗* compactness of the specified datum family in the dual space. It also gives no counterexample to (FG1), to compact ordinary outer regularity, or to the analytic relation quotient.

Exact dependency snapshots.

The energy-difference closed-cone theorem is energy/energy_difference_banach.tex, SHA256:

12bde9976ef8d8dcb3abbfc23f71f8e1a1ae37a6195de0dcdd13f09c5c0f5f45.

The lattice realization and source extension are nonlinear/order_energy_lattice_completion.tex, SHA256:

754db6baac08f682e94d5342aa3e757914f3442592bd10cb288f8f2c7ce1bb69.

The exact energies and pole dual are nonlinear/radial_pole_order_dual_obstruction.tex, SHA256:

f57f4ccac82fc36cbfb4c6663091bdc738d800ebaf022eb9c602176854fa4365.

The source strong-continuity and discrepancy identity are energy/nonlinear_dual_source_geometry.tex, SHA256:

29a083c0f65d93f777cae9bbe0c02a36385510e7b1a6c9542552322439168743.

Source text and edition identity

This reading copy omits personal attribution and places existing mathematical question marks over their relation symbols. The mathematical content and source status are retained.

Reading-copy SHA-256 8a394524508dc204480a49e2620cb5cd49e9e906c31598c689d7d0a7a963049d

Frozen-original SHA-256 8a394524508dc204480a49e2620cb5cd49e9e906c31598c689d7d0a7a963049d

\section{Energy balls need not be weakly compact in either Banach realization}
\label{sec:r12-energy-ball-weak-compactness-obstruction}

The weak-$*$ compact datum family in (CW14) does not by itself
supply a weakly compact family of candidate potentials. The
following consequence of the proved pole example makes that
obstruction explicit. It is a statement about the two new
Banach norms, not about failure of the complete strong topology.

Fix $n>q\geq1$ and the original radial-mixture background
$S$ of (PO3), on its original unit polydisc $V$. Retain the
original field and absolute value. Put $d=q+1$ and use the
already proved actual potentials
\[
 \psi_j=\max\!\left(\log\max_{1\leq i\leq n}|T_i|,-j\right),
 \qquad
 u=\log\max_{1\leq i\leq n}|T_i|,
                    \qquad j=1,2,\ldots .
 \tag{WB1}
\]
The value of $u$ at the origin is $-\infty$. It represents
a member of the same no-loss first-energy cone, and (PO7)
gives
\[
       e(u)=1,\qquad e(\psi_j)=1-e^{-j},\qquad
                               I(\psi_j,u)=e^{-j}.
 \tag{WB2}
\]
The pole functional is continuous on both $\mathbb D_S$
and $\mathbb L_S$ and satisfies
\[
                   L_\infty(u)=1,\qquad L_\infty(\psi_j)=0.
 \tag{WB3}
\]
All these statements are exactly the earlier original-current
pole construction, including its actual Borel representatives.

\begin{proposition}[No weak cluster and nonreflexivity in every remaining degree]
\label{prop:r12-energy-ball-nonreflexivity}
For the allowed data just specified, the sequence $(\psi_j)$
has no weakly convergent subnet, and in particular no weakly
convergent subsequence, in either $\mathbb D_S$ or
$\mathbb L_S$. Consequently
\[
      \mathcal B_{\mathscr C}
            =\{v\in\mathscr C:r(v)\leq1\}
 \tag{WB4}
\]
is not weakly compact in either Banach space, and neither
$\mathbb D_S$ nor $\mathbb L_S$ is reflexive.

This holds in every remaining degree $q\geq1$ by the
specified example in every $n>q$. It does not say that
these spaces are nonreflexive for every possible background
$S$, including the zero or other degenerate backgrounds.
\end{proposition}

\noindent\textbf{Status: \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY}} of
the present round's exact Banach realizations, source-functional
continuity and pole functional. The proposed universal weak
compactness of bounded potential energy balls is
\texttt{FALSE}. The weak closedness of norm-closed convex
sets and weak compactness of bounded closed balls in a
reflexive Banach space are \texttt{EXTERNAL\_KNOWN}
functional-analysis facts.

\begin{proof}
Let $E$ denote either $\mathbb D_S$ or $\mathbb L_S$.
The proved realization theorems say that the same cone
$\mathscr C$ is norm closed and convex in $E$, and that
\[
                         \|v\|_E=r(v)\qquad(v\in\mathscr C).
 \tag{WB5}
\]
It is therefore weakly closed, by the Hahn--Banach
separation theorem. Every source functional $J(a)$,
$a\in\mathscr C$, is continuous on $E$. In the lattice
case this uses its proved literal extension (OL6),
not a newly assumed extension of an arbitrary dual.
On the cone these source functionals are also continuous
for the strong discrepancy topology, by the frozen
tester estimate and (NI4).

Suppose that a subnet $(\psi_{j_\gamma})$ converges
weakly in $E$ to $v$. The subnet indices are cofinal
in the integer row, so (WB2) still makes it converge
strongly to $u$. Weak closedness gives $v\in\mathscr C$.
For every fixed $a\in\mathscr C$, the weak and strong
continuities just stated give, respectively,
\[
      J(a)(v)=\lim_\gamma J(a)(\psi_{j_\gamma})=J(a)(u).
 \tag{WB6}
\]
Choose $a=v$ and $a=u$. The exact energy-discrepancy
identity then yields
\[
              I(v,u)=(J(v)-J(u))(v-u)=0.
 \tag{WB7}
\]
The strong cone is separated, so $v=u$ as its original
relative Borel class. On the other hand, continuity of
$L_\infty\in E^*$ and (WB3) would give
$L_\infty(v)=0$, whereas $L_\infty(u)=1$. This is a
contradiction. It proves the absence of a weakly
convergent subnet in either space.

The sequence lies in (WB4), by (WB2) and (WB5).
Every net in a compact space has a convergent subnet;
thus (WB4) is not weakly compact. Finally (WB4) is
the intersection of the norm-closed convex cone with
the closed unit ball, so it is weakly closed in that
ball. If $E$ were reflexive, its closed unit ball
would be weakly compact, making (WB4) weakly compact
as well. This contradiction proves nonreflexivity.
\end{proof}

\paragraph{Consequence for the compact-capacity attempt.}
The mechanism ``bounded first energies imply weakly compact
potential candidates; then use weak-$*$ compactness of the
localized source data'' is invalid in these Banach realizations.
The first assertion is disproved by (WB1)--(WB7), even though
the displayed row actually converges strongly. This does not
contradict strong completeness of $\mathscr C$, completeness
of the curvature metric $d_J$, or the weak-$*$ compactness
of the specified datum family in the \emph{dual} space.
It also gives no counterexample to (FG1), to compact ordinary
outer regularity, or to the analytic relation quotient.

\paragraph{Exact dependency snapshots.}
The energy-difference closed-cone theorem is
\path{energy/energy_difference_banach.tex}, SHA256:
\begin{quote}\small
\nolinkurl{12bde9976ef8d8dcb3abbfc23f71f8e1a1ae37a6195de0dcdd13f09c5c0f5f45}.
\end{quote}
The lattice realization and source extension are
\path{nonlinear/order_energy_lattice_completion.tex}, SHA256:
\begin{quote}\small
\nolinkurl{754db6baac08f682e94d5342aa3e757914f3442592bd10cb288f8f2c7ce1bb69}.
\end{quote}
The exact energies and pole dual are
\path{nonlinear/radial_pole_order_dual_obstruction.tex}, SHA256:
\begin{quote}\small
\nolinkurl{f57f4ccac82fc36cbfb4c6663091bdc738d800ebaf022eb9c602176854fa4365}.
\end{quote}
The source strong-continuity and discrepancy identity are
\path{energy/nonlinear_dual_source_geometry.tex}, SHA256:
\begin{quote}\small
\nolinkurl{29a083c0f65d93f777cae9bbe0c02a36385510e7b1a6c9542552322439168743}.
\end{quote}