Contents of this source
Continuous potentials and the scalar-boundary action gate
Status and purpose.
This is a FAILED_ATTEMPT audit within the frozen RV route. The action implications proved below are DIRECT_COROLLARY consequences of the exact R6 degree-one theorem. The required continuous-potential existence statement remains OPEN. The scalar rank-one interpretation tested below is FALSE in its stated scope, but it has neither the centered homogeneity nor the hypotheses of RV15. No principal theorem or new counterexample-family count is assigned to this note. In particular we do not prove KC12, quadratic Aeppli exactness, or CTO.
Fix the original finite extension , its unchanged absolute value, and an original good, Hausdorff, boundaryless, quasi-smooth space. On a sufficiently small ordinary representative assume the dimension is the constant . The notation denotes the actual Mihatsch delta-form sheaf, with every actual local refinement retained. We use the anticommuting CLD convention , and write for the ordinary current of an already existing delta-form. The potential space is the unchanged space of finite continuous differences of locally bounded original classical psh functions. Every background below is symmetric, middle-positive, and separately - and -closed. No stronger positive cone or model origin is imposed on .
An ordinary scalar potential already suffices for action
Write for the canonical total-degree-one action of R6, Theorem r6-arbitrary-background-degree-one-delta. The following observation does not require its potential to define an actual delta-form.
Proposition (Continuous-potential action comparison). Let be symmetric. Suppose there is such that Then, for every allowed original of degree , , This is an equality on all original compact smooth complementary tests. It holds in every actual presentation and refinement. Consequently is separately closed and, whenever the degree is legal, . The same assertion is valid for germs: choose the representative and the potential once, before quantifying over backgrounds and tests. No equality on GK delta tests is asserted.
Proof. R6, Lemma r6-degree-one-hessian-presentation, gives locally a finite presentation where each is continuous piecewise smooth and each is a continuous local difference of continuous classical psh functions. On a compact test support use finitely many such ordinary neighborhoods and a subordinate original smooth partition. The actual embedding and continuous multiplication give on each neighborhood. Subtract (AP24.1). The resulting ordinary relation is All coefficients in this relation are continuous; the coefficient of the last curvature is the constant . Expand each local DC potential into its two original psh components. R6, Theorem r6-continuous-curvature-module, applies to this exact relation and gives By the definition and already proved independence of , the first sum is . This proves (AP24.2) locally and on every partitioned test, hence on the whole test.
Both first derivatives of vanish by the distributional identities and . This does not differentiate a nonsmooth coefficient informally: is a well-defined current by continuous multiplication with a coefficient-Radon current, and all derivatives here are distributional. The R6 statement is ordinary-local and already independent of all actual refinements, so no additional test or chart reduction is used. The germ assertion follows by choosing a representative for (AP24.1). ◻
Corollary (Automatic local DC regularity of a continuous potential). In the proposition it is enough that be finite continuous and satisfy (AP24.1). For every point , one may choose an ordinary neighborhood , before choosing , on which . The action identity (AP24.2) then holds on all of by ordinary locality. We do not assert a global DC decomposition on a previously prescribed .
Proof. Choose one finite presentation (AP24.3) about , and shrink once so that all have continuous psh components on that representative. Choose a relatively compact ordinary neighborhood inside it. The continuous coefficients are bounded there. With , take a finite such that on . Positivity of the individual curvatures and (AP24.1) give The functions and are finite continuous and have positive original curvature. The exact frozen R6 lemma r6-continuous-positive-classical makes them classical psh, locally and hence on . Therefore This construction depends on , but not on a background or test. Apply the proposition on each . The two sides of (AP24.2) are intrinsic ordinary currents on , since multiplication of by the given continuous is already defined. The local identities consequently glue, proving the last assertion. ◻
Corollary (A weaker sufficient target after the RV reduction). Let be the symmetric finitely piecewise-constant PS germ in RV12, with full , and use the accepted PH/QT preparation. Thus, on one ordinary representative, If for some , then for every allowed , in every legal degree. In particular the QA obstruction of vanishes for all . This conclusion does not require , a piecewise-linear potential for , or an actual delta-form structure on . By the preceding corollary it is enough to have a finite continuous satisfying the ordinary current equation, with local DC decompositions obtained after initial shrinking.
Proof. QT1–QT3 prove (AP24.6), including the full boundary term , and prove that the finite piecewise-quadratic is locally an original convex difference. It follows that . Apply the proposition to . Alternatively, the proposition for , the frozen identity , and linearity give the same equality. The chosen precede every subsequent choice of and compact test. ◻
Here is the exact quadratic application if the other RV gate has also been supplied. For a finite signed PL quadratic polynomial , let The frozen Leibniz identity gives . QA therefore gives . If the exact balanced lift RV4 has been provided, RV5–RV8 replace by a separately closed , changing it by full - and -exact degree-one forms whose QA action is zero. Under the additional potential hypothesis in (AP24.6), (AP24.7) now gives for every allowed . This implication is conditional on both existence steps. It supplies no carrier-CLN certificate: the unchanged IF action/full-polar distinction prevents that further inference. Common additional signed mixed tails may be absorbed into by finite positive-tail expansion in legal degrees. Unrelated termwise tails are not identified by this observation.
The first-derivative relation which is still missing
For a pure scalar codimension-one , the R6 module presentation can be chosen in the form (AP24.3) with continuous PS and finite continuous PL . Every is fully separately closed. Thus full says For each fixed allowed , the already proved Radon Leibniz rule gives the legal ordinary identity Indeed each is a finite signed expansion of allowed positive separately closed coefficient-Radon currents, to which R6’s continuous-PS Radon product rule applies. No boundary of has been discarded in (AP24.9), and no derivative of a moving approximation is used in (AP24.10).
The implication from (AP24.9) to vanishing of the right side of (AP24.10) has not been proved. R6’s scalar-coefficient theorem applies to , not to this covector-coefficient relation. We do not define an action on an arbitrary object by writing the right side and assuming presentation independence. The ambiguity RV10, where a normal one-form times a nonzero cap is zero, also prevents unrestricted coefficient extraction. If the implication were established for these particular , it would already imply their QA action vanishes, without proving RV15’s stronger zero assertion.
Why the represented curvature interval does not create a potential
There is an available order bound, but not the necessary surjectivity theorem. On a relatively compact subdomain where (AP24.3) is fixed, expand into continuous psh functions and set . Choose larger than the absolute values of all coefficients there. Positivity of the individual curvatures gives For the RV/QT scalar boundary , symmetry and full separate closedness hold. Hence are positive separately closed ordinary currents. They have not thereby acquired continuous scalar potentials.
The exact compact set in R6’s curvature-interval theorem is where consists of already existing normalized continuous psh potentials with the specified ambient order bound. Its weak compactness and closedness show that a weak limit of members of this represented family remains represented. Neither its definition nor its proof identifies it with all positive closed currents between and . To use it here one must first construct a net of represented curvatures, on the same and in a common such interval, converging on every original test to the required current. No such net has been constructed. R6’s continuous-positive converse and HU/HL scalar harmonic recognition start with a continuous function; they do not supply the missing function from the current (AP24.11).
Intersecting cap branches do not form a rank-one coefficient space
The following elementary original pressure test limits a possible interpretation of the desired coefficient sheaf. It is not a counterexample to RV15 or to the continuous-potential existence target. Work on an ordinary two-torus polyannulus about the joint radius-one Gauss point , with These are genuine positive separately closed original currents, the ordinary currents of pure scalar codimension-one delta-forms. Their supports are the complete normal Gauss fibers, by the frozen CM1/R9 support theorem. In particular the points , for close to one, lie in and outside ; the points have the reverse property. Both actual Gauss-radius paths converge to .
If with , there is no finite continuous scalar on any ordinary representative of this germ such that To prove this, near the current is zero. Equality would give there. A continuous scalar multiplying a nonzero positive coefficient-Radon current can vanish only by being zero on its support: otherwise its nonzero fixed sign on a small neighborhood is detected by a positive compact test. Thus . Similarly . The two limits and continuity force , a contradiction.
Consequently closedness does not turn a multi-branch cap system into one continuous scalar coefficient relative to its sum, even before asking for a locally constant coefficient. Both weights in this diagnostic are constant and there is no centered homogeneous vanishing hypothesis. Also its currents already have the explicit continuous PL potential . The test only rules out this rank-one substitution for a branch-sensitive cycle module. It adds no KC or RV counterexample.
The geometric continuation step is not supplied by tameness alone
On a fixed full-rank calibrated refinement, a pure scalar codimension-one presentation of can be reduced to effective scalar coefficients on its cut-cells. Full makes each such coefficient constant along that cell. Artificial subdivision merely restricts this same coefficient. A different actual refinement can, however, change the calibrated branches and their weighted sums. Across genuine incidences the closed-cycle condition is a balancing condition; it is not an assertion that all branch coefficients are one scalar. The preceding pressure test explains that distinction on original analytic data.
The required additional theorem would give a refinement-compatible cycle-coefficient object for this fixed finite presentation, with enough ordinary-local specialization toward to force its closed section to vanish when its centered coefficients vanish there. We have constructed neither that specialization nor a finite detector for all later local refining domains. This is a precise remaining proof step, not a new defined theory. UR rules out replacing it by a tangent lift of the old Euler vector on every local cell. Its counterexample boundary is not closed and therefore does not decide this coupled continuation question.
The primary tameness results checked during this attempt have narrower typed conclusions. Hrushovski–Loeser’s Non-archimedean tame topology and stably dominated types, in the 166-page author version, Theorem 13.4.1, proves local contractibility of for a definable subset of an algebraic variety. This does not identify our absolute signed-cycle support or its effective coefficient module with that specified input. Arbitrary real facet slopes also cannot simply be inserted into its rational-linear value-group language.
Ducros, Espaces de Berkovich, polytopes, squelettes et théorie des modèles, Theorem 5.1 in the 53-page author version tropicbis.pdf, constructs skeleta from inverse images of the -torus skeleton under the hypothesis . A complete normal cap with positive-dimensional analytic fiber is not supplied with such a finite skeleton by that theorem. The associated local tropical-image theorem controls one finite moment image, not its entire original delta-relation kernel. The published erratum to the finite separation argument was also checked; it does not change these dimension or quotient scopes.
Remaining exact targets and review disclosure.
The scalar-potential target is: for every RV/QT boundary at an original ordinary germ, find one ordinary representative and one finite continuous with on all original smooth tests. It is OPEN; (AP24.5a)–(AP24.5b) would then give local DC regularity on an initially smaller representative. The covector transfer (AP24.9)–(AP24.10) is another OPEN sufficient action interface. Neither would by itself prove the full-polar seminorm conclusion. The stronger full-actual zero RV15 and the preceding balanced lift RV4 also remain OPEN.
The reconstruction researcher constructed this note, after root suggested pursuing an action target and then the branch-continuation route. The researcher previously constructed PH; PH, RV, QT, QA and the R6 action are frozen inputs, with their original review roles unchanged. This construction is not an independent review of itself. A separate exact-source review is required before acceptance.