OpenMath

Proof source

Scalar descent through quasi-étale uniformization

Complete proof text in the unsigned reading edition.

Download sourceBrowse research records

Reading edition of the complete source note. Original labels and explicit equation tags are retained; references use source titles where compiled numbering is unavailable. Current result status is recorded separately in the project register.

Contents of this source
  1. Scalar descent through quasi-étale uniformization

Scalar descent through quasi-étale uniformization

Status and authorship.

The scalar assertions proved below are DIRECT_COROLLARY of the specified primary results. They are not an arbitrary-current descent theorem and do not settle KC12. The independent-audit agent constructed this deduction after the root requested a source audit. The root independently proposed the same Galois-saturation repair after being informed of the relevant passage in Ducros. Neither participant is an author-independent reviewer of this deduction. A separate review is required before it is used as an accepted input.

Definitions and exact external interfaces

Let kk be a complete nontrivially valued non-Archimedean field. In its application to this project, kk is the original KK, or a finite extension used only in scalar analytic geometry, with the given absolute value extended and never renormalized. All spaces in the descent assertion are good, Hausdorff and strictly kk-analytic.

The notation PL⁡R(X)\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X) has the geometric meaning of Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff, Definition 5.1: on a covering by strictly analytic domains the function is a finite real linear combination of logarithms of absolute values of analytic units on those domains. This definition concerns functions on the full analytic domains. It is not a definition in terms of a selected skeleton or a chosen finite set of ordinary current tests. We use the following primary inputs, with their original hypotheses.

  1. Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff, arXiv:2111.05741v3, Definition 5.1, Remark 5.2 and Lemma 5.4: geometric real PL functions are G-local and are preserved by analytic pullback. Proposition 5.11, printed pp. 34–35, gives descent along finite, flat, surjective morphisms of good strictly analytic spaces. Corollary 5.12, printed p. 36, gives descent after extension to the completion of an algebraic extension.

  2. Ducros, Families of Berkovich spaces, Theorem 5.4.6 and the reduction in the proof of Proposition 9.1.1(c), printed pp. 118–120 and 177, give the following local form. A quasi-étale morphism can be covered G-locally on its source by strict affinoid domains DD admitting a factorization D↪E⟶Z↪X,(HU1)D\hookrightarrow E\longrightarrow Z \hookrightarrow X, \tag{HU1} where DD is an analytic domain of EE, ZZ is a connected strict affinoid domain of XX, and E→ZE\to Z is connected finite étale. One may use finitely many such pieces when the source is compact. The same proof explicitly passes to a connected finite Galois cover of ZZ dominating EE.

  3. Ducros, Proposition 9.1.1, printed pp. 177–178: if YY is quasi-compact and Γ\Gamma-strict, XX is separated, and a coherent sheaf on YY is XX-flat with quasi-finite support, its image is a compact Γ\Gamma-strict analytic domain of XX. We use only the case of the structure sheaf of a strict affinoid domain of a finite étale cover, with Γ={1}\Gamma=\{1\}. Such a domain maps quasi-étale, and hence flat, to the base.

  4. Temkin, arXiv:1503.05729v2, Theorem 3.3.1 and Corollary 3.3.2, printed p. 12, together with the rigid/Berkovich translation in §3.4: a compact quasi-smooth strictly kk-analytic space has, after a finite extension l/kl/k, a surjective quasi-étale affinoid cover possessing a strictly semistable formal l∘l^\circ-model. It is this statement, retaining the chosen strictly semistable model, that is used below. The separate wording of Theorem 3.4.1 says only that the maximal affine model is semistable; that wording alone is not silently strengthened.

  5. Gubler–Rabinoff, arXiv:2506.13548v2, Definition 7.1 and Proposition 7.2(6),(7), printed pp. 34–35: classically pluriharmonic scalars are preserved by base extension and analytic pullback. Proposition 7.8, printed p. 36: on a good, quasi-compact strictly analytic space having a strictly semistable formal model, every classically pluriharmonic scalar is geometric real PL.

Here classically pluriharmonic means that both hh and −h-h are classically psh in the curve-test sense of the last reference. No identification with an arbitrary continuous ordinary-current harmonic witness is included in that definition.

Galois saturation and scalar PL descent

Proposition (compact quasi-étale scalar descent).

Let f:Y→Xf:Y\to X be a surjective quasi-étale morphism between compact good Hausdorff strictly kk-analytic spaces. For every real function hh on XX, h∘f∈PL⁡R(Y)⟺h∈PL⁡R(X).(HU2)h\circ f\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(Y) \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad h\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X). \tag{HU2} The assertion is about the given function on all analytic points. It does not assert that ff has an interior lift over each point of XX, nor that ff becomes finite on an ordinary neighborhood of every target point.

Proof.

Analytic pullback proves the reverse implication. Assume the left side. By HU1 and compactness, choose finitely many strict affinoid source domains DiD_i covering YY, with factorizations Di↪Ei→Zi↪XD_i\hookrightarrow E_i\to Z_i\hookrightarrow X as in HU1. The finite family can be obtained from finitely many source neighborhoods covered by the local affinoid pieces; thus it is an actual G-cover and not just a collection of selected points. It suffices to prove the assertion on the image of each DiD_i. Fix one piece and omit its index.

Choose a connected finite Galois cover q:E~→Zq:\widetilde E\to Z dominating E→ZE\to Z, and write G=Aut⁡Z(E~)G=\operatorname{Aut}_Z(\widetilde E). Let D~\widetilde D be the inverse image of DD. It is a compact strict affinoid domain of E~\widetilde E. The composite D~→Z\widetilde D\to Z is quasi-étale: analytic-domain embeddings and finite étale maps are quasi-étale, and this property is stable under composition. In particular it is flat and has zero-dimensional fibers. Ducros, Proposition 9.1.1, applied to OD~\mathcal O_{\widetilde D} therefore shows that C=q(D~)=f(D)is a compact strict analytic domain of Z.(HU3)C=q(\widetilde D)=f(D) \quad\hbox{is a compact strict analytic domain of }Z. \tag{HU3} It is consequently also an analytic domain of XX.

For every analytic point z∈Zz\in Z, the Galois group acts transitively on the points of q−1(z)q^{-1}(z). This is the usual finite-Galois-cover fiber property, and is also the property used in the Galois saturation in Ducros’s proof of Proposition 9.1.1(c). More explicitly, after tensoring the finite étale fiber algebra with H(z)\mathscr H(z), its geometric points form a GG-torsor. The absolute Galois group of H(z)\mathscr H(z) commutes with this action; therefore GG is transitive on its orbits, equivalently on the field factors of that finite étale algebra. Each finite extension of the complete valued field H(z)\mathscr H(z) has its unique extended absolute value, so these factors are exactly the analytic fiber points. Hence q−1(C)=⋃g∈Gg(D~).(HU4)q^{-1}(C)=\bigcup_{g\in G}g(\widetilde D). \tag{HU4} Indeed, any point on the right maps to the image of D~\widetilde D; conversely, a point above z∈Cz\in C is a conjugate of some chosen point of D~\widetilde D above zz. Both sides carry their induced analytic-domain structure in E~\widetilde E, and analytic-domain structures on a fixed subset are unique. The union in HU4 is finite. No points lying on domain boundaries have been removed.

Put h~=h∘q\widetilde h=h\circ q on E~\widetilde E, where hh is restricted to ZZ. Its restriction to D~\widetilde D is geometric real PL by pullback from DD. Since q∘g=qq\circ g=q, the function h~\widetilde h is GG-invariant. Transporting the presentation on D~\widetilde D by each gg proves that h~\widetilde h is geometric real PL on every g(D~)g(\widetilde D).

For clarity, no goodness assumption is needed for the possibly non-affinoid union in HU4. Cover CC by strict affinoid domains VV. For each such VV, the space q−1(V)q^{-1}(V) is strict affinoid and q−1(V)→Vq^{-1}(V)\to V is finite étale and surjective. Its intersections with the finitely many domains g(D~)g(\widetilde D) form a finite analytic-domain cover. Restriction of the preceding PL presentations and G-locality show that h~∣q−1(V)\widetilde h|_{q^{-1}(V)} is real PL. Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff, Proposition 5.11, now gives h∣V∈PL⁡R(V)h|_V\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(V). G-locality gives h∣C∈PL⁡R(C)h|_C\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(C), understood through this affinoid cover if necessary.

Finally, the finitely many compact analytic domains f(Di)f(D_i) cover XX, because the DiD_i cover YY and ff is surjective. They form a finite G-cover of XX. Applying G-locality once more proves HU2. □\square

What the saturation accomplishes.

The finite étale map used for descent is q−1(V)→Vq^{-1}(V)\to V, after VV has been recognized as an actual target analytic domain. It need not map back into the single original source piece DD. The equality of the scalar pullback on all its Galois conjugates supplies PL presentations on the additional pieces. Thus this proof is not a domination of the original quasi-étale cover by an ordinary finite étale cover, and it makes no assertion of descent for an arbitrary current originally given only on DD.

The scalar consequence of altered uniformization

Corollary (classical pluriharmonic scalars are geometric real PL in the compact strict quasi-smooth case).

Let XX be a compact good Hausdorff quasi-smooth strictly kk-analytic space. Every classically pluriharmonic real function on XX belongs to PL⁡R(X)\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X): PH⁡cl(X)⊆PL⁡R(X).(HU5)\operatorname{PH}_{\mathrm{cl}}(X) \subseteq\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X). \tag{HU5} In particular this holds over the original KK. It also yields the corresponding local assertion at a point admitting a compact strict quasi-smooth analytic neighborhood on which the scalar is classically pluriharmonic.

Proof.

Use Temkin, Corollary 3.3.2 and §3.4, to choose a finite extension l/kl/k and a surjective quasi-étale morphism p:Y→Xlp:Y\to X_l with YY affinoid and possessing a strictly semistable formal model over l∘l^\circ. The original absolute value is merely extended to ll. The scalar hl∘ph_l\circ p is classically pluriharmonic by Gubler–Rabinoff, Proposition 7.2(6),(7). Their Proposition 7.8 shows that it is geometric real PL on YY. Apply HU2 over ll to obtain hl∈PL⁡R(Xl)h_l\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X_l). Finally, Gubler–Jell–Rabinoff, Corollary 5.12, descends this property along the finite algebraic extension l/kl/k and gives HU5. All steps concern scalars and their analytic pullbacks. No current over ll is constructed or imported. □\square

Boundary pressure test and the remaining KC interfaces

Let ϖ∈K\varpi\in K satisfy 0<∣ϖ∣<10<|\varpi|<1, and consider the compact annulus and its two closed subannuli B={∣ϖ∣≤∣T∣≤∣ϖ∣−1},B−={∣ϖ∣≤∣T∣≤1},B+={1≤∣T∣≤∣ϖ∣−1}.(HU6)\begin{split} B&=\{|\varpi|\leq |T|\leq |\varpi|^{-1}\},\\ B_-&=\{|\varpi|\leq |T|\leq1\},\qquad B_+=\{1\leq |T|\leq |\varpi|^{-1}\}. \end{split} \tag{HU6} The map B−⨿B+→BB_-\amalg B_+\to B is surjective and quasi-étale. The unit Gauss point is in the ordinary interior of BB and on the analytic boundary of both displayed source domains. Thus the shortcut asserting an ordinary interior lift for every point of a surjective quasi-étale compact cover is FALSE. This is the already frozen R19 UF5 example, not a new counterexample family. It does not contradict HU2: B−,B+B_-,B_+ themselves are a finite target G-cover, and scalar PL presentations glue on that cover. The associated R19 UF6–UF8 current example explains why discarding the boundary is nevertheless invalid for arbitrary-current action.

The following conclusions are deliberately not part of HU5.

  1. A finite continuous scalar with ordinary D[h]=0D[h]=0 has not, by the definition alone, been identified with a classically pluriharmonic scalar. Any use of HU5 for KC harmonic witnesses must pin a valid comparison in exactly that scalar class. No general positivity-to-regularization implication is inferred from the abstracts of the cited papers.

  2. Geometric real PL on a G-cover is not yet a single global unit-log expression on a prescribed ordinary domain. A residue/Picard argument, when applicable, must retain its own exact hypotheses and ordinary-germ quantifiers.

  3. HU2 and HU5 construct neither pullback nor descent for arbitrary allowed positive currents along the quasi-étale map. They do not localize a previously chosen full carrier polar.

  4. No conclusion about mixed KC harmonic generators with arbitrary companion potentials, the full carrier-CLN seminorm, or the actual signed PL relation ideal follows just from scalar recognition. No ordinary-current equality is promoted to an arbitrary action on GK delta tests.

Accordingly the original same-germ KC12 implication and the variable-PS/CTO gates retain status OPEN. The precise topological obstruction to the naive three-result concatenation is repaired for geometric scalar PL descent by HU2; it is not repaired for arbitrary-current descent by the same argument.

Source text and edition identity

This reading copy omits personal attribution and places existing mathematical question marks over their relation symbols. The mathematical content and source status are retained.

Reading-copy SHA-256 f49135e231a62134696fff8f158072e7a8c68ec59284c27b1a45afbe4e31bb32

Frozen-original SHA-256 f49135e231a62134696fff8f158072e7a8c68ec59284c27b1a45afbe4e31bb32

\section{Scalar descent through quasi-\'etale uniformization}
\label{sec:r24-harmonic-uniformization}

\paragraph{Status and authorship.}
The scalar assertions proved below are \texttt{DIRECT\_COROLLARY} of the
specified primary results.  They are not an arbitrary-current descent
theorem and do not settle KC12.  The independent-audit agent constructed
this deduction after the root requested a source audit.  The root
independently proposed the same Galois-saturation repair after being
informed of the relevant passage in Ducros.  Neither participant is an
author-independent reviewer of this deduction.  A separate review is
required before it is used as an accepted input.

\subsection{Definitions and exact external interfaces}

Let $k$ be a complete nontrivially valued non-Archimedean field.  In its
application to this project, $k$ is the original $K$, or a finite
extension used only in scalar analytic geometry, with the given
absolute value extended and never renormalized.  All spaces in the
descent assertion are good, Hausdorff and strictly $k$-analytic.

The notation $\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X)$ has the geometric
meaning of Gubler--Jell--Rabinoff, Definition~5.1: on a covering by
strictly analytic domains the function is a finite real linear
combination of logarithms of absolute values of analytic units on
those domains.  This definition concerns functions on the full
analytic domains.  It is not a definition in terms of a selected
skeleton or a chosen finite set of ordinary current tests.  We use
the following primary inputs, with their original hypotheses.

\begin{enumerate}
\item Gubler--Jell--Rabinoff, arXiv:2111.05741v3, Definition~5.1,
Remark~5.2 and Lemma~5.4: geometric real PL functions are G-local and
are preserved by analytic pullback.  Proposition~5.11, printed
pp.~34--35, gives descent along finite, flat, surjective morphisms of
good strictly analytic spaces.  Corollary~5.12, printed p.~36, gives
descent after extension to the completion of an algebraic extension.
\item Ducros, \emph{Families of Berkovich spaces}, Theorem~5.4.6 and
the reduction in the proof of Proposition~9.1.1(c), printed
pp.~118--120 and~177, give the following local form.  A quasi-\'etale
morphism can be covered G-locally on its source by strict affinoid
domains $D$ admitting a factorization
\[
 D\lhook\joinrel\longrightarrow E\longrightarrow Z
 \lhook\joinrel\longrightarrow X,                         \tag{HU1}
\]
where $D$ is an analytic domain of $E$, $Z$ is a connected strict
affinoid domain of $X$, and $E\to Z$ is connected finite \'etale.
One may use finitely many such pieces when the source is compact.
The same proof explicitly passes to a connected finite Galois cover
of $Z$ dominating $E$.
\item Ducros, Proposition~9.1.1, printed pp.~177--178: if $Y$ is
quasi-compact and $\Gamma$-strict, $X$ is separated, and a coherent
sheaf on $Y$ is $X$-flat with quasi-finite support, its image is a
compact $\Gamma$-strict analytic domain of $X$.  We use only the case
of the structure sheaf of a strict affinoid domain of a finite
\'etale cover, with $\Gamma=\{1\}$.  Such a domain maps
quasi-\'etale, and hence flat, to the base.
\item Temkin, arXiv:1503.05729v2, Theorem~3.3.1 and
Corollary~3.3.2, printed p.~12, together with the rigid/Berkovich
translation in \S3.4: a compact quasi-smooth strictly $k$-analytic
space has, after a finite extension $l/k$, a surjective
quasi-\'etale affinoid cover possessing a \emph{strictly semistable}
formal $l^\circ$-model.  It is this statement, retaining the chosen
strictly semistable model, that is used below.  The separate wording
of Theorem~3.4.1 says only that the maximal affine model is
semistable; that wording alone is not silently strengthened.
\item Gubler--Rabinoff, arXiv:2506.13548v2,
Definition~7.1 and Proposition~7.2(6),(7), printed pp.~34--35:
classically pluriharmonic scalars are preserved by base extension and
analytic pullback.  Proposition~7.8, printed p.~36: on a good,
quasi-compact strictly analytic space having a strictly semistable
formal model, every classically pluriharmonic scalar is geometric
real PL.
\end{enumerate}

Here \emph{classically pluriharmonic} means that both $h$ and $-h$
are classically psh in the curve-test sense of the last reference.
No identification with an arbitrary continuous ordinary-current
harmonic witness is included in that definition.

\subsection{Galois saturation and scalar PL descent}

\paragraph{Proposition (compact quasi-\'etale scalar descent).}
Let $f:Y\to X$ be a surjective quasi-\'etale morphism between compact
good Hausdorff strictly $k$-analytic spaces.  For every real function
$h$ on $X$,
\[
 h\circ f\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(Y)
 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad
 h\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X).                   \tag{HU2}
\]
The assertion is about the given function on all analytic points.
It does not assert that $f$ has an interior lift over each point of
$X$, nor that $f$ becomes finite on an ordinary neighborhood of
every target point.

\paragraph{Proof.}
Analytic pullback proves the reverse implication.  Assume the left
side.  By HU1 and compactness, choose finitely many strict affinoid
source domains $D_i$ covering $Y$, with factorizations
$D_i\hookrightarrow E_i\to Z_i\hookrightarrow X$ as in HU1.
The finite family can be obtained from finitely many source
neighborhoods covered by the local affinoid pieces; thus it is an
actual G-cover and not just a collection of selected points.
It suffices to prove the assertion on the image of each $D_i$.
Fix one piece and omit its index.

Choose a connected finite Galois cover $q:\widetilde E\to Z$
dominating $E\to Z$, and write $G=\operatorname{Aut}_Z(\widetilde E)$.
Let $\widetilde D$ be the inverse image of $D$.  It is a compact
strict affinoid domain of $\widetilde E$.  The composite
$\widetilde D\to Z$ is quasi-\'etale: analytic-domain embeddings and
finite \'etale maps are quasi-\'etale, and this property is stable
under composition.  In particular it is flat and has
zero-dimensional fibers.  Ducros, Proposition~9.1.1, applied to
$\mathcal O_{\widetilde D}$ therefore shows that
\[
 C=q(\widetilde D)=f(D)
 \quad\hbox{is a compact strict analytic domain of }Z.    \tag{HU3}
\]
It is consequently also an analytic domain of $X$.

For every analytic point $z\in Z$, the Galois group acts transitively
on the points of $q^{-1}(z)$.  This is the usual finite-Galois-cover
fiber property, and is also the property used in the Galois
saturation in Ducros's proof of Proposition~9.1.1(c).  More
explicitly, after tensoring the finite \'etale fiber algebra with
$\mathscr H(z)$, its geometric points form a $G$-torsor.  The
absolute Galois group of $\mathscr H(z)$ commutes with this action;
therefore $G$ is transitive on its orbits, equivalently on the field
factors of that finite \'etale algebra.  Each finite extension of the
complete valued field $\mathscr H(z)$ has its unique extended
absolute value, so these factors are exactly the analytic fiber
points.  Hence
\[
 q^{-1}(C)=\bigcup_{g\in G}g(\widetilde D).              \tag{HU4}
\]
Indeed, any point on the right maps to the image of $\widetilde D$;
conversely, a point above $z\in C$ is a conjugate of some chosen
point of $\widetilde D$ above $z$.  Both sides carry their induced
analytic-domain structure in $\widetilde E$, and analytic-domain
structures on a fixed subset are unique.  The union in HU4 is
finite.  No points lying on domain boundaries have been removed.

Put $\widetilde h=h\circ q$ on $\widetilde E$, where $h$ is restricted
to $Z$.  Its restriction to $\widetilde D$ is geometric real PL by
pullback from $D$.  Since $q\circ g=q$, the function $\widetilde h$
is $G$-invariant.  Transporting the presentation on $\widetilde D$
by each $g$ proves that $\widetilde h$ is geometric real PL on every
$g(\widetilde D)$.

For clarity, no goodness assumption is needed for the possibly
non-affinoid union in HU4.  Cover $C$ by strict affinoid domains $V$.
For each such $V$, the space $q^{-1}(V)$ is strict affinoid and
$q^{-1}(V)\to V$ is finite \'etale and surjective.  Its intersections
with the finitely many domains $g(\widetilde D)$ form a finite
analytic-domain cover.  Restriction of the preceding PL
presentations and G-locality show that
$\widetilde h|_{q^{-1}(V)}$ is real PL.  Gubler--Jell--Rabinoff,
Proposition~5.11, now gives $h|_V\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(V)$.
G-locality gives $h|_C\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(C)$, understood
through this affinoid cover if necessary.

Finally, the finitely many compact analytic domains $f(D_i)$ cover
$X$, because the $D_i$ cover $Y$ and $f$ is surjective.  They form a
finite G-cover of $X$.  Applying G-locality once more proves HU2.
\hfill$\square$

\paragraph{What the saturation accomplishes.}
The finite \'etale map used for descent is
$q^{-1}(V)\to V$, after $V$ has been recognized as an actual target
analytic domain.  It need not map back into the \emph{single}
original source piece $D$.  The equality of the scalar pullback on
all its Galois conjugates supplies PL presentations on the additional
pieces.  Thus this proof is not a domination of the original
quasi-\'etale cover by an ordinary finite \'etale cover, and it makes
no assertion of descent for an arbitrary current originally given
only on $D$.

\subsection{The scalar consequence of altered uniformization}

\paragraph{Corollary (classical pluriharmonic scalars are geometric
real PL in the compact strict quasi-smooth case).}
Let $X$ be a compact good Hausdorff quasi-smooth strictly
$k$-analytic space.  Every classically pluriharmonic real function
on $X$ belongs to $\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X)$:
\[
 \operatorname{PH}_{\mathrm{cl}}(X)
       \subseteq\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X).       \tag{HU5}
\]
In particular this holds over the original $K$.  It also yields the
corresponding local assertion at a point admitting a compact strict
quasi-smooth analytic neighborhood on which the scalar is
classically pluriharmonic.

\paragraph{Proof.}
Use Temkin, Corollary~3.3.2 and \S3.4, to choose a finite extension
$l/k$ and a surjective quasi-\'etale morphism
$p:Y\to X_l$ with $Y$ affinoid and possessing a strictly semistable
formal model over $l^\circ$.  The original absolute value is merely
extended to $l$.  The scalar
$h_l\circ p$ is classically pluriharmonic by
Gubler--Rabinoff, Proposition~7.2(6),(7).  Their Proposition~7.8
shows that it is geometric real PL on $Y$.  Apply HU2 over $l$ to
obtain $h_l\in\operatorname{PL}_{\mathbf R}(X_l)$.  Finally,
Gubler--Jell--Rabinoff, Corollary~5.12, descends this property along
the finite algebraic extension $l/k$ and gives HU5.
All steps concern scalars and their analytic pullbacks.  No current
over $l$ is constructed or imported. \hfill$\square$

\subsection{Boundary pressure test and the remaining KC interfaces}

Let $\varpi\in K$ satisfy $0<|\varpi|<1$, and consider the compact
annulus and its two closed subannuli
\[
 \begin{split}
 B&=\{|\varpi|\leq |T|\leq |\varpi|^{-1}\},\\
 B_-&=\{|\varpi|\leq |T|\leq1\},\qquad
 B_+=\{1\leq |T|\leq |\varpi|^{-1}\}.
 \end{split}                                                    \tag{HU6}
\]
The map $B_-\amalg B_+\to B$ is surjective and quasi-\'etale.
The unit Gauss point is in the ordinary interior of $B$ and on the
analytic boundary of both displayed source domains.  Thus the
shortcut asserting an ordinary interior lift for every point of a
surjective quasi-\'etale compact cover is \texttt{FALSE}.  This is
the already frozen R19 UF5 example, not a new counterexample family.
It does not contradict HU2: $B_-,B_+$ themselves are a finite
target G-cover, and scalar PL presentations glue on that cover.
The associated R19 UF6--UF8 current example explains why discarding
the boundary is nevertheless invalid for arbitrary-current action.

The following conclusions are deliberately \emph{not} part of HU5.
\begin{enumerate}
\item A finite continuous scalar with ordinary $D[h]=0$ has not,
by the definition alone, been identified with a classically
pluriharmonic scalar.  Any use of HU5 for KC harmonic witnesses must
pin a valid comparison in exactly that scalar class.  No general
positivity-to-regularization implication is inferred from the
abstracts of the cited papers.
\item Geometric real PL on a G-cover is not yet a single global
unit-log expression on a prescribed ordinary domain.  A
residue/Picard argument, when applicable, must retain its own exact
hypotheses and ordinary-germ quantifiers.
\item HU2 and HU5 construct neither pullback nor descent for
arbitrary allowed positive currents along the quasi-\'etale map.
They do not localize a previously chosen full carrier polar.
\item No conclusion about mixed KC harmonic generators with
arbitrary companion potentials, the full carrier-CLN seminorm, or
the actual signed PL relation ideal follows just from scalar
recognition.  No ordinary-current equality is promoted to an
arbitrary action on GK delta tests.
\end{enumerate}

Accordingly the original same-germ KC12 implication and the
variable-PS/CTO gates retain status \texttt{OPEN}.  The precise
topological obstruction to the naive three-result concatenation is
repaired for geometric scalar PL descent by HU2; it is not repaired
for arbitrary-current descent by the same argument.