Reading guide

Use a NAG Tag to find, read or cite a mathematical entry.

A Tag may identify a definition, a statement such as a theorem or lemma, or a specific proof question. The Tag links to the relevant passage and any available argument.

Proof statuses

Closed
The edition accepts a proof for the stated hypotheses and conclusion. The accepted result can be used within that scope.
Open
A step needed for the stated result is unresolved. The Tag identifies the step or records that a complete proof has yet to be verified.
Narrower scope proved
An accepted argument covers a narrower set of hypotheses or a weaker conclusion. The full statement remains open. Follow the selected scopes for the proved part.
Conditional
The displayed argument establishes its conclusion assuming the listed inputs. Check those inputs in the setting where you want to apply the result.
Comparison pending
The Tag records what must be checked to relate two constructions or categories, such as matching their test spaces or local presentations.
Review pending
The statement has a permanent Tag while its proof evidence is being checked. The Tag indicates whether an argument has been located.
Definition
The Tag records the meaning or conventions for an object. A proof status applies to claims made using that definition.

Problem types

These labels describe the work involved in a recorded gap. An entry can have several types. Read the status and the source note to see how much of the result is established.

Evidence, hypotheses and scope

Counterexample to the stated scope
An example contradicts the stated claim or a proposed extension. The admissible scope needs to be reduced or the statement revised.
External proof input
The argument uses a result supplied by an outside source. Its exact statement and applicability matter for the conclusion here.
Hypothesis transfer
An assumption must be verified after a change of field, model, test space or other setting.
Missing prerequisite
Another assertion is needed before the argument can proceed.
Scope extension
The available argument covers a narrower case. The missing step is to reach the rest of the stated scope.
Source and proof binding
The right statement, proof version or precise source location needs to be matched to the Tag.
Whole proof unverified
The record leaves a full proof unverified and gives too little evidence to name a more specific mathematical gap.
Proof awaiting review
A manuscript argument has been located. Its steps and applicability still need review.
Proof or proof location to verify
The argument’s location or its coverage of the stated claim still needs verification.

Constructions and comparisons

Algebraic criterion
An algebraic condition must be shown to characterize the stated property.
Chart presentation
Local coordinates or generators must represent the object, with the required compatibility of representations.
Closure under operations
Applying an operation has to keep the result in the specified class.
Cohomology and duality
The argument must identify cohomological constructions or check the claimed duality.
Comparison of constructions
Two constructions must agree on the specified objects, hypotheses and tests.
Construction
The object or operation still needs to be constructed in the stated setting.
Detection and faithfulness
The proposed tests must distinguish the objects or detect the property claimed.
Functoriality
The construction has to commute with the stated maps, such as pullback or pushforward.
Gluing
The local objects must agree on overlaps and assemble into a global object.
Lifting and descent
An object or map must lift to a larger setting or descend through the stated change of setting.
Uniqueness and independence
The result must be unique or independent of the choices made in its construction.
Well-definedness
The proposed formula must define an object and respect the equivalence of representatives.

Estimates, limits and geometric criteria

Balancing
The weighted directions or faces must satisfy the balancing equations.
Coefficient and value-group control
The coefficients or values must obey the required estimates or lie in the specified value group.
Continuity
The stated operation must be continuous in the required topology.
Density
The permitted test objects or approximants must be dense in the stated space and topology.
Dimension and purity
The required dimension, codimension or purity statement still needs justification.
Divisor and current identity
The divisor and current descriptions must agree with the stated sign, normalization and tests.
Equidistribution
The proof needs a distribution or measure limit for the specified points or nets.
Finiteness
The argument needs the stated finite fibres, finite morphism or other finiteness property.
Integration and calibration
Integration must use the correct weights, orientation or lattice normalization.
Intersection product
The specified product must exist and satisfy the claimed intersection properties.
Limit stability
A construction or identity must survive the stated passage to a limit.
Maximum principle
The required bound or extremum property must be established on the stated domain.
Norm estimate
The result needs a bound in the stated norm with control of the constants.
Numerical criterion
Numerical data such as degrees or intersection numbers must characterize the geometric condition.
Positivity
The asserted positivity or equivalence of positivity conditions must hold in the stated category.
Regularization
Approximants of the required class must exist with the specified convergence and constraints.
Support and boundary control
The proof must control the support or behavior at the boundary of the stated domain.
Vanishing
A specified form, current or obstruction must vanish under the stated conditions.
Volume and energy comparison
Volume and energy must agree in the stated setting with the specified normalization.