Progress · independent proof diagram
Arithmetic hard Lefschetz, positivity and finiteness
For products of pointed curves with a height satisfying the stated axioms, Chow projectors reduce arithmetic hard Lefschetz and positivity to specified middle-degree groups. Integral height finiteness further requires arithmetic control of the integral image and its fields of definition.
Conditional reductions · Source edition v0.5.1
Domain of the result
Products of pointed curves and the residual quotient groups defined in the arithmetic-reductions paper, with a supplied height system satisfying its four axioms.
Read the diagrams from top to bottom. Select a numbered connection for its exact hypotheses and deduction, or follow a node to its source. Analytic, model and comparison assumptions retain their stated scope.
How to read the logic
Read from top to bottom. Parallel premises meet at a numbered connection, then lead to a conclusion. Select a connection to read its hypotheses and deduction; select a node to read the linked statement.
The full scope of each occurrence is recorded below its diagram. A proved conditional implication and an open geometric premise keep their separate statuses.
LOGIC 01
Arithmetic hard Lefschetz, positivity and finiteness
The complete product package is equivalent to three still-open central assertions under H1–H4. The subsequent trees show both directions and isolate the additional arithmetic conditions.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01IFF · IFF the WHOLE three-part package holds on ALL subproducts
Premises and stated hypotheses
- OpenAll off-central subproduct cores vanish
For EVERY subproduct Y_S, EVERY finite E/F₀ and EVERY c with |S|≠2c−1, require U_Sᶜ(E)=0.
Scope & sources - OpenThe algebraic Abel–Jacobi map is rationally injective on every central A
For EVERY odd subproduct |S|=2c−1 and EVERY finite E/F₀.
Scope & sources - OpenEach central residual form has integral bounded-degree Northcott
Count projected images of actual integral cycles in the common geometric rational quotient, with both a height and a field-degree bound.
Scope & sources
Supporting results used in this deduction
- ConditionalAn equivalent package for products of curves
R2-L3The conditional equivalence, with both directions expanded in the package-proof tree. It does not establish the three open conditions.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Under H1–H4, the theorem proves both directions for this full conjunction. No single child is equivalent to the whole target.
Conclusion / target
The target is for the fixed pointed product and positive integral polarization, in every required degree and over every finite extension. The equivalence is proved conditionally; the three inputs remain open.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 8 nodes: scope, status and sources
OpenArithmetic hard Lefschetz AND primitive integral bounded-degree Northcott
The target is for the fixed pointed product and positive integral polarization, in every required degree and over every finite extension. The equivalence is proved conditionally; the three inputs remain open.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalAn equivalent package for products of curves
The conditional equivalence, with both directions expanded in the package-proof tree. It does not establish the three open conditions.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenAll off-central subproduct cores vanish
For EVERY subproduct Y_S, EVERY finite E/F₀ and EVERY c with |S|≠2c−1, require U_Sᶜ(E)=0.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenThe algebraic Abel–Jacobi map is rationally injective on every central A
For EVERY odd subproduct |S|=2c−1 and EVERY finite E/F₀.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenEach central residual form has integral bounded-degree Northcott
Count projected images of actual integral cycles in the common geometric rational quotient, with both a height and a field-degree bound.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalUnder H1–H4 the displayed equivalence itself is proved
The Chow Lefschetz reduction does not require the height axioms; the height, radical and Northcott steps do.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe three central assertions imply the product package
Use the exact central criterion and the primitive coefficient formula.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe product package recovers all three central assertions
Inflate a central core by fundamental classes; its primitive height is an explicit positive multiple.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 02
The actual Chow-block decomposition
Tensor the three curve projectors, identify each image by explicit inverse correspondences, and rescale the point factors so the polarization is square-zero raising.
Scope. X=∏ᵢ₌₁ⁿCᵢ with chosen rational points, Hᵢ their pullback point divisors and ℓ=ΣaᵢHᵢ with positive integers aᵢ. This decomposition and its integral denominator control do not require height axioms.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The orthogonal curve projectors AND their tensor products
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableπ₀,π₁,π₂ are actual orthogonal Chow projectors summing to Δ
Their transposes exchange π₀,π₂ and fix π₁.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableExplicit insertion and projection correspondences j_T,b_T
Intersections with degree-one point divisors recover the source class exactly.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Use π₀=o×C, π₂=C×o, π₁=Δ−π₀−π₂ and partition [n]=S⊔T⊔U.
Conclusion / target
j_T inserts points on T and fundamental classes on U; b_T projects z·∏ᵢ∈U Hᵢ to Y_S. These operations have integral coefficients.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Actual inverse projector correspondences AND the polarization calculation
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableb_Tj_T=Π_S and j_Tb_T=P_{S,T,U} in rational Chow
j_T inserts points on T and fundamental classes on U; b_T projects z·∏ᵢ∈U Hᵢ to Y_S. These operations have integral coefficients.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableHᵢπ₁,ᵢ=0 and the weighted coordinate map turns ℓ into Σxᵢ
This is an actual Chow-composition identity, not just a cohomological equality.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Orthogonal tensor projectors give the direct sum. Rescaling by a_T converts multiplication by the weighted polarization into E on B_I.
Conclusion / target
I=[n]∖S, B_I=ℚ[xᵢ]/(xᵢ²), and u⊗x_T maps to a_T j_Tu. The same identities hold on integral images.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 8 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableV*(X_E)=⊕_{S,c} U_Sᶜ(E)⊗B_I[c], with ℓ acting as E=Σᵢ∈I xᵢ
I=[n]∖S, B_I=ℚ[xᵢ]/(xᵢ²), and u⊗x_T maps to a_T j_Tu. The same identities hold on integral images.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableb_Tj_T=Π_S and j_Tb_T=P_{S,T,U} in rational Chow
j_T inserts points on T and fundamental classes on U; b_T projects z·∏ᵢ∈U Hᵢ to Y_S. These operations have integral coefficients.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableπ₀,π₁,π₂ are actual orthogonal Chow projectors summing to Δ
Their transposes exchange π₀,π₂ and fix π₁.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableExplicit insertion and projection correspondences j_T,b_T
Intersections with degree-one point divisors recover the source class exactly.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableHᵢπ₁,ᵢ=0 and the weighted coordinate map turns ℓ into Σxᵢ
This is an actual Chow-composition identity, not just a cohomological equality.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableOne fixed integer N_a=∏ᵢaᵢ clears every block-coordinate denominator
The bound works in every degree and every finite extension.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe inverse maps have integral coefficients
Thus the unweighted component class is an integral image.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availablea_T=∏ᵢ∈T aᵢ divides N_a
The weights aᵢ are fixed positive integers.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 03
Square-zero Lefschetz strings and the exact star constant
Raising and lowering form finite sl₂ strings; inclusion–exclusion determines the sign and factorial on their primitive part.
Scope. B_I has monomial basis x_T, |I|=m. Let E add one variable, F delete one variable, Hx_T=(m−2|T|)x_T and *x_T=x_{I∖T}. This is a rational algebra calculation.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The commutator identities AND positive adjointness
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof available[F,E]=H, [H,F]=2F, [H,E]=−2E
Check on the monomial basis by counting variables added or deleted.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableE and F are adjoint for orthonormal monomials
This positive scalar product proves the asserted nonzero string lengths.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
If Fv=0, then FEʲv=j(m−2t−j+1)Eʲ⁻¹v. Adjointness forces a nonzero string through Eᵐ⁻²ᵗv and then termination; successive orthogonal ker F and im E decompose B_I.
Conclusion / target
For 0≤t≤m/2: Eᵐ⁻²ᵗ:B_Iᵗ→B_Iᵐ⁻ᵗ and ker Eᵐ⁻²ᵗ⁺¹=ker F.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 6 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableEᵐ⁻²ᵗ is an isomorphism and primitive degree-t vectors are exactly ker F
For 0≤t≤m/2: Eᵐ⁻²ᵗ:B_Iᵗ→B_Iᵐ⁻ᵗ and ker Eᵐ⁻²ᵗ⁺¹=ker F.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof available[F,E]=H, [H,F]=2F, [H,E]=−2E
Check on the monomial basis by counting variables added or deleted.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableE and F are adjoint for orthonormal monomials
This positive scalar product proves the asserted nonzero string lengths.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableFor z∈M⊗ker F, Eᵐ⁻²ᵗz=(−1)ᵗ(m−2t)! *z
The identity includes t=0 and coefficients in any rational vector space M.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableFz=0 gives all lower containment sums zero
The coefficient has the nonzero factor (t−|J|)!, which can be divided in ℚ.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableInclusion–exclusion leaves only the complementary coefficient
All proper subsets of I∖K vanish in the alternating containment sum.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 04
Both directions of the arithmetic Lefschetz reduction
Central blocks have precisely the square-zero string length; every noncentral block obstructs either injectivity or surjectivity.
Scope. Fix the pointed product, polarization and ONE finite field E. The statement is an unconditional rational Chow equivalence for this data and has no height assumption.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Central-only blocks AND the square-zero string theorem
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisEvery nonzero core has |S|=2c−1
Assumed for this direction, not established by the block decomposition.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableThe exact Chow blocks and square-zero strings
Use the coefficient identification of blocks-main.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Take the direct sum of the blockwise isomorphisms.
Conclusion / target
On a surviving block |S|=2c−1, m=n−|S| and t=r−c give n+1−2r=m−2t. If t<0 both block spaces vanish.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Exclude the positive-d case AND exclude the negative-d case
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availabled>0: r=c gives exponent m+d>m and kills U_Sᶜ⊗1
A nonzero source is sent to zero, contradicting injectivity.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availabled<0: r=k+1−c has polynomial source degree d<0 and a nonzero top target
The permitted r has zero source in this block and target U_Sᶜ⊗x_I, contradicting surjectivity.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Multiplication preserves each actual Chow block, so a failure in that block cannot be repaired by a different summand.
Conclusion / target
If U_Sᶜ≠0, put k=|S|, m=n−k and d=k+1−2c. Both d≠0 cases contradict an asserted isomorphism.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑03AND · Prove EACH direction of the stated equivalence
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableOff-central vanishing makes every block map a square-zero Lefschetz isomorphism
On a surviving block |S|=2c−1, m=n−|S| and t=r−c give n+1−2r=m−2t. If t<0 both block spaces vanish.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableAn isomorphism in every required degree rules out every noncentral block
If U_Sᶜ≠0, put k=|S|, m=n−k and d=k+1−2c. Both d≠0 cases contradict an asserted isomorphism.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The children are the two proof directions, not individually the hypotheses of an IFF gate.
Conclusion / target
The exponent and both domains are the ones of the product of n curves. The statement concerns ALL subproducts and all required degrees.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 03 in the diagram ↑All 7 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableAll off-central U_Sᶜ(E) vanish ⇔ every required ℓⁿ⁺¹⁻²ʳ map is an isomorphism
The exponent and both domains are the ones of the product of n curves. The statement concerns ALL subproducts and all required degrees.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableOff-central vanishing makes every block map a square-zero Lefschetz isomorphism
On a surviving block |S|=2c−1, m=n−|S| and t=r−c give n+1−2r=m−2t. If t<0 both block spaces vanish.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisEvery nonzero core has |S|=2c−1
Assumed for this direction, not established by the block decomposition.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe exact Chow blocks and square-zero strings
Use the coefficient identification of blocks-main.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableAn isomorphism in every required degree rules out every noncentral block
If U_Sᶜ≠0, put k=|S|, m=n−k and d=k+1−2c. Both d≠0 cases contradict an asserted isomorphism.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availabled>0: r=c gives exponent m+d>m and kills U_Sᶜ⊗1
A nonzero source is sent to zero, contradicting injectivity.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availabled<0: r=k+1−c has polynomial source degree d<0 and a nonzero top target
The permitted r has zero source in this block and target U_Sᶜ⊗x_I, contradicting surjectivity.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 05
The primitive sum of squares with its full constant
Complementary projector indices isolate identical coefficients; the primitive star identity supplies the sign and factorial.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. Fix a CENTRAL block |S|=2c−1, m=n−|S| and 0≤t=r−c≤m/2. This central-block identity does not assume off-central vanishing.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Actual transpose projector identities AND H3 correspondence adjunction
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableThe actual Chow projector and insertion identities
Transposition exchanges T and I∖T.
Scope & sources - HypothesisH3 holds on all required correspondence sources and products
The matching normalization and other standing H1–H4 assumptions remain in force.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
This is the height-theoretic step of the sum-of-squares proof; the prior square-zero algebra alone does not supply it.
Conclusion / target
Transpose swaps the point and fundamental-class indices. Its composition integrates one degree-one point in each omitted factor.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The primitive star identity AND complementary-index adjunction AND the weight/sign calculation
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Conditionalh_X(j_Tu,j_{I∖T}v)=h_YS(u,v), and all nonmatching blocks are orthogonal
Transpose swaps the point and fundamental-class indices. Its composition integrates one degree-one point in each omitted factor.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availablea_Ta_{I∖T}=a_I and r=c+t
These identities give the exact positive coefficient (m−2t)!a_I and the central sign.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Primitivity is Fz_S=0. Only each coefficient paired with its own complementary index survives. Their weights multiply to a_I and (−1)ʳ⁺ᵗ=(−1)ᶜ.
Conclusion / target
Here z_S=Σu_Tx_T is primitive, a_I=∏ᵢ∈I aᵢ and q_S,c(u)=(−1)ᶜh_YS(u,u).
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 6 nodes: scope, status and sources
Conditionalq_ℓ,r(z_S)=(m−2t)!·a_I·Σ|T|=t q_S,c(u_T)
Here z_S=Σu_Tx_T is primitive, a_I=∏ᵢ∈I aᵢ and q_S,c(u)=(−1)ᶜh_YS(u,u).
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableEᵐ⁻²ᵗz_S=(−1)ᵗ(m−2t)! *z_S
Conditionalh_X(j_Tu,j_{I∖T}v)=h_YS(u,v), and all nonmatching blocks are orthogonal
Transpose swaps the point and fundamental-class indices. Its composition integrates one degree-one point in each omitted factor.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe actual Chow projector and insertion identities
HypothesisH3 holds on all required correspondence sources and products
The matching normalization and other standing H1–H4 assumptions remain in force.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availablea_Ta_{I∖T}=a_I and r=c+t
These identities give the exact positive coefficient (m−2t)!a_I and the central sign.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 06
From central forms to primitive positivity and integral finiteness
The same sum-of-squares identity gives positivity from real central positivity, while finiteness additionally uses central integral Northcott and one common coordinate denominator.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · ALL off-central cores vanish AND every central form is REAL positive definite
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisAll off-central subproduct cores vanish over the fixed field
This is an additional hypothesis, not a consequence of the central primitive identity.
Scope & sources - HypothesisEvery central q_S,c is positive definite AFTER real scalar extension
Positivity only on nonzero rational vectors is insufficient.
Scope & sources - ConditionalThe exact primitive sum-of-squares and complementary pairings
All coefficients (m−2t)!a_I are strictly positive.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Complementary blocks then pair nondegenerately; distinct S are orthogonal. Positive coefficients in the primitive formula give primitive definiteness, and q(z+tw)≥0 gives Cauchy–Schwarz.
Conclusion / target
This conclusion is over a FIXED number field, including real scalar extension.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 9 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalReal primitive positivity and nondegenerate complementary pairings
This conclusion is over a FIXED number field, including real scalar extension.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisAll off-central subproduct cores vanish over the fixed field
This is an additional hypothesis, not a consequence of the central primitive identity.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisEvery central q_S,c is positive definite AFTER real scalar extension
Positivity only on nonzero rational vectors is insufficient.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe exact primitive sum-of-squares and complementary pairings
All coefficients (m−2t)!a_I are strictly positive.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalPrimitive integral bounded-degree Northcott on the full product
Count the intersection of the actual integral cycle image with the primitive subspace, over fields with bounded degree.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisEvery central projected integral image has bounded-degree Northcott
A rational nonpositive central vector would have infinitely many bounded-height integral multiples, so all terms are nonnegative.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisEvery off-central core vanishes over every required finite extension
The global field-degree bound is kept when selecting each coordinate.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableN_a clears ALL block-coordinate denominators uniformly
There is one fixed N_a, independent of the extension and cycle.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe primitive height bounds each coordinate separately
Use nonnegativity of every other central term.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 07
The actual maximal curve-visible Chow projector
A geometric positive semisimple endomorphism of a product of Jacobians has a polynomial pseudoinverse; faithful h¹ realization turns its identities into actual Chow identities.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀. The geometric construction of e,R and the abelian summand does not require the height axioms.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · A finite family spans the maximal geometric W AND geometric Hodge–Riemann with faithful h¹ realization
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisFinitely many projected curve correspondences span ALL W
Γⱼ=ΠΓⱼπ₁,ⱼ and J=∏Pic⁰(Cⱼ), all over one F₀.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe actual h¹ endomorphism realization is faithful and W is primitive
The actual Chow identity ℓ_YΠ=0 proves geometric primitiveness; Hodge–Riemann supplies the sign.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Transposition is Rosati adjunction; (−1)ᶜ⁻¹a is positive semidefinite. This is a geometric positivity theorem, distinct from conjectural height positivity.
Conclusion / target
The entries are divisor correspondences because 2c−dim Y=1. Geometric Hodge–Riemann applies to the primitive middle curve-visible space W.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · A faithful semisimple curve endomorphism AND its polynomial pseudoinverse
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availablea lies in End(⊕h¹Cⱼ)=End(J)ℚ, is semisimple, and ker a=ker Γ
The entries are divisor correspondences because 2c−dim Y=1. Geometric Hodge–Riemann applies to the primitive middle curve-visible space W.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableChoose f∈ℚ[t] equal to 1/t on nonzero spectrum and zero at zero
The fixed maps Γ and a⁺ᵗΓ identify B=pJ, up to isogeny, with eU_E on rational points.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Set a=ᵗΓΓ, a⁺=f(a), p=a⁺a and e=Γa⁺ᵗΓ. Faithfulness gives a⁺aa⁺=a⁺ and p²=p=ᵗp as actual Chow identities; hence e²=e=ᵗe and eΠ=Πe=e.
Conclusion / target
One fixed F₀ defines the finitely many spanning curve correspondences and source points; the same projectors and abelian variety work for EVERY finite E/F₀.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 8 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableActual self-transpose Chow projectors e and R=Π−e, with eU_E≅B(E)ℚ
One fixed F₀ defines the finitely many spanning curve correspondences and source points; the same projectors and abelian variety work for EVERY finite E/F₀.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availablea lies in End(⊕h¹Cⱼ)=End(J)ℚ, is semisimple, and ker a=ker Γ
The entries are divisor correspondences because 2c−dim Y=1. Geometric Hodge–Riemann applies to the primitive middle curve-visible space W.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisFinitely many projected curve correspondences span ALL W
Γⱼ=ΠΓⱼπ₁,ⱼ and J=∏Pic⁰(Cⱼ), all over one F₀.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe actual h¹ endomorphism realization is faithful and W is primitive
The actual Chow identity ℓ_YΠ=0 proves geometric primitiveness; Hodge–Riemann supplies the sign.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableChoose f∈ℚ[t] equal to 1/t on nonzero spectrum and zero at zero
The fixed maps Γ and a⁺ᵗΓ identify B=pJ, up to isogeny, with eU_E on rational points.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Conditionalq_e=(−1)ᶜh_Y on eU is a positive Néron–Tate form
This height conclusion uses H3 and H4 in addition to the geometric projector construction.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe actual projector and abelian summand
HypothesisH3 full correspondence adjunction and H4 the fixed curve sign
All standing H1–H4 hypotheses remain in force.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 08
Why curve-invisible algebraic cycles are in the radical
Zero cohomological action forces the transpose divisor’s Abel–Jacobi class to vanish, which is the divisor itself on a curve; height adjunction then gives radical membership.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Poincaré duality AND Abel–Jacobi functoriality AND the curve identification
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisΓ has zero geometric H¹ action
This condition concerns the projected curve correspondence.
Scope & sources - HypothesisAJ is correspondence-functorial and is Pic⁰ on a curve
Use the stated rationalized map and base-change descent.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Duality makes the transpose geometric map to H¹(C) zero. Its Abel–Jacobi value vanishes, and on a curve rationalized AJ identifies the class with Pic⁰.
Conclusion / target
Rational divisor vanishing after complex base change descends.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The transpose divisor vanishes AND correspondence adjunction
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableᵗΓ∗w=0 in Pic⁰(C)ℚ
Rational divisor vanishing after complex base change descends.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe supplied H3 identity holds for Γ and every complementary w
The resulting zero is in the full radical, not only the radical against algebraic tests.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
For every degree-zero divisor D, h_X(Γ∗D,w)=h_C(D,ᵗΓ∗w)=0.
Conclusion / target
Γ∈CHʳ(C×X)ℚ and the tested w lies in Vⁿ⁺¹⁻ʳ(X). The statement is about every such complementary test class.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 5 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalIf Γ∗H¹(C)=0, then Γ∗Pic⁰(C)ℚ lies in the full height radical
Γ∈CHʳ(C×X)ℚ and the tested w lies in Vⁿ⁺¹⁻ʳ(X). The statement is about every such complementary test class.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableᵗΓ∗w=0 in Pic⁰(C)ℚ
Rational divisor vanishing after complex base change descends.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisΓ has zero geometric H¹ action
This condition concerns the projected curve correspondence.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisAJ is correspondence-functorial and is Pic⁰ on a curve
Use the stated rationalized map and base-change descent.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe supplied H3 identity holds for Γ and every complementary w
The resulting zero is in the full radical, not only the radical against algebraic tests.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 09
The algebraic radical and the residual pairing
Maximality makes every residual curve correspondence invisible; the nondegenerate visible abelian part identifies all the relevant kernels, and self-transposition makes the quotient orthogonal.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Maximal W AND curve generation with trace descent AND the invisible-cycle lemma
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableThe maximal geometric projector
Its complement kills the geometric action of every curve correspondence.
Scope & sources - ConditionalCurve-invisible cycles lie in the FULL radical
The same zero geometric action kills their Abel–Jacobi classes.
Scope & sources - HypothesisGeometrically algebraic cycles are curve-generated after finite extension
Trace descends the finite data to E; rational coefficients allow the finite degree to be divided.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Every geometrically algebraically trivial cycle is generated from curves after finite extension and traced back. Apply the invisible lemma to RΔ.
Conclusion / target
Maximality of W includes all curves after finite extensions, not merely the finite family initially selected.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The residual algebraic classes are invisible AND the visible abelian part is detected AND self-transpose orthogonality
Premises and stated hypotheses
- ConditionalEvery later RΔ from a curve has zero geometric H¹ action
Maximality of W includes all curves after finite extensions, not merely the finite family initially selected.
Scope & sources - ConditionalAJ is rationally injective and q_e is nondegenerate on eU⊂A
The map from B to the intermediate Jacobian has injective rational H₁, hence finite kernel; visible-height supplies the positive Néron–Tate form.
Scope & sources - Conditionale=ᵗe gives orthogonality; two orthogonalized lifts differ in A∩A⊥
The identified radical makes their difference fully invisible to heights, so the quotient form and its value are independent of e.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Curve generation makes RA both AJ-zero and fully radical. On eU⊂A, AJ is rationally injective and the height nondegenerate. These facts identify the kernel and radicals; the residual form descends to RU/RA≅G.
Conclusion / target
U=eU⊕RU is orthogonal. The residual form is independent of the chosen maximal curve-visible projector.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 7 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalRA=ker(AJℚ|A)=A∩rad(U)=rad(A), and h_G on G=U/A is well-defined
U=eU⊕RU is orthogonal. The residual form is independent of the chosen maximal curve-visible projector.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalEvery later RΔ from a curve has zero geometric H¹ action
Maximality of W includes all curves after finite extensions, not merely the finite family initially selected.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe maximal geometric projector
Its complement kills the geometric action of every curve correspondence.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalCurve-invisible cycles lie in the FULL radical
The same zero geometric action kills their Abel–Jacobi classes.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisGeometrically algebraic cycles are curve-generated after finite extension
Trace descends the finite data to E; rational coefficients allow the finite degree to be divided.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalAJ is rationally injective and q_e is nondegenerate on eU⊂A
The map from B to the intermediate Jacobian has injective rational H₁, hence finite kernel; visible-height supplies the positive Néron–Tate form.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Conditionale=ᵗe gives orthogonality; two orthogonalized lifts differ in A∩A⊥
The identified radical makes their difference fully invisible to heights, so the quotient form and its value are independent of e.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 10
Integral control of the visible Néron–Tate summand
A fixed correspondence denominator converts the projected class into an actual point of a fixed Jacobian, where classical Northcott applies.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 1 connection
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · One fixed integral detecting correspondence AND polarization comparison AND classical Northcott
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisND is integral and D is injective on eU
N is independent of the cycle and the finite extension; any prescribed extra denominator bound is absorbed once.
Scope & sources - Conditionalq_e is a positive Néron–Tate form on the fixed B
Comparing its polarization with the ambient J polarization bounds the height of NDz.
Scope & sources - HypothesisClassical bounded-degree Northcott on the actual points of J
Keep the fixed height and degree bounds; rationalization removes torsion without changing these heights.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Let D=a⁺ᵗΓ with De=D. Choose N clearing its Chow denominators. For integral z, NDz is an actual point of J(E) detecting ez, and its Néron–Tate height is bounded by a fixed multiple of q_e(ez).
Conclusion / target
The projector is rational; the argument controls its denominators explicitly rather than treating ez as an integral abelian point.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 4 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalThe projected integral image in eU has bounded-degree Northcott with any fixed denominator bound
The projector is rational; the argument controls its denominators explicitly rather than treating ez as an integral abelian point.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisND is integral and D is injective on eU
N is independent of the cycle and the finite extension; any prescribed extra denominator bound is absorbed once.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Conditionalq_e is a positive Néron–Tate form on the fixed B
Comparing its polarization with the ambient J polarization bounds the height of NDz.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisClassical bounded-degree Northcott on the actual points of J
Keep the fixed height and degree bounds; rationalization removes torsion without changing these heights.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 11
The exact central Northcott equivalence
Central finiteness excludes an AJ kernel and bounds the residual image; conversely the residual ball and visible abelian ball determine the class when the AJ kernel vanishes.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01IFF · IFF the WHOLE bundle: algebraic AJ injectivity AND residual integral Northcott
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Hypothesisker(AJℚ|A_E)=0 for every field required by the chosen version
For the fixed-field version only that E is required.
Scope & sources - Hypothesisq_G has Northcott on the projected residual integral image with the SAME field quantifier
The residual quotient is viewed in the common geometric rational group and injects under field extension.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The equivalence uses the actual orthogonal projector, its fixed denominators and H1–H4. The two directions are expanded below.
Conclusion / target
The same equivalence holds either over one fixed E, or with bounded degree and the vanishing condition over EVERY finite E/F₀.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 11 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalCentral integral Northcott
The same equivalence holds either over one fixed E, or with bounded degree and the vanishing condition over EVERY finite E/F₀.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisker(AJℚ|A_E)=0 for every field required by the chosen version
For the fixed-field version only that E is required.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisq_G has Northcott on the projected residual integral image with the SAME field quantifier
The residual quotient is viewed in the common geometric rational group and injects under field extension.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalCentral Northcott implies AJ-kernel zero and residual Northcott
Choose one integer M making MR an integral correspondence.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisCentral integral Northcott with the stated field quantifier
Use the theorem’s premise for this direction.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe AJ kernel is RA and is in the full height radical
This supplies the zero-height conclusion for all integer multiples.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisOne M clears the fixed rational projector R
Multiplication by M is injective in the rational geometric quotient, and the field-degree bound is unchanged.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalAJ-kernel zero and residual Northcott imply central Northcott
Orthogonality gives q_U(z)=q_e(ez)+q_G([z]), with both terms nonnegative.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisResidual Northcott makes the allowed [z] finite and q_G nonnegative
This uses integral multiples in the specified residual image and the same field quantifier.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe fixed projected integral visible part satisfies classical Northcott
Use its fixed correspondence denominator.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe AJ kernel vanishes, so z↦(ez,[z]) is injective
The radical identification is essential; positivity alone would not prove this injectivity.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 12
Proof of the complete product/residual equivalence
The forward direction propagates central finiteness; the reverse direction inserts a central class into the whole product with an exact positive height factor.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The Lefschetz equivalence AND central Northcott AND primitive propagation
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableApply the exact Chow Lefschetz equivalence
Assume all off-central cores vanish over every finite extension.
Scope & sources - ConditionalApply the exact central Northcott criterion
Assume AJ injectivity and residual bounded-degree Northcott on every central subproduct.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableNorthcott forces positivity after real scalar extension
This implication does not assume finite rational rank.
Scope & sources - ConditionalApply positivity and integral coefficient propagation
The fixed N_a controls every block coefficient and field extension.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Off-central vanishing gives hard Lefschetz. AJ injectivity plus residual Northcott gives central Northcott; Northcott forces real central positivity, and the coefficient formula gives primitive finiteness, positivity and nondegeneracy.
Conclusion / target
They also imply real primitive positivity and nondegeneracy over every fixed number field.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 10 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalThe three central assertions imply the entire product package
They also imply real primitive positivity and nondegeneracy over every fixed number field.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableApply the exact Chow Lefschetz equivalence
Assume all off-central cores vanish over every finite extension.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalApply the exact central Northcott criterion
Assume AJ injectivity and residual bounded-degree Northcott on every central subproduct.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableNorthcott forces positivity after real scalar extension
This implication does not assume finite rational rank.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalApply positivity and integral coefficient propagation
The fixed N_a controls every block coefficient and field extension.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalThe product package implies all three central assertions
The primitive injection uses the same integral Chow projectors and the same polarization as the forward argument.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe reverse Chow Lefschetz implication
Use the assumed isomorphisms in every degree and finite extension.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Conditionalu↦j_∅u is an INTEGRAL primitive injection with the exact positive factor
Take degree r=c and t=0 in the central block; the omitted factors contribute m! times their fixed polarization weights.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisPrimitive integral bounded-degree Northcott on the whole product
Restrict it to the images of the central integral classes under this injection.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑ConditionalCentral Northcott forces the two central residual conditions
Apply separately to each odd subproduct with the original field quantifiers.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 13
The residual arithmetic regulator
An actual Chow projector leaves one Hochschild–Serre row; curve generation and maximal invisibility make the arithmetic cycle class factor through the residual quotient.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀. These cohomological constructions do not require a height or off-central vanishing. Fix p and V_p=R∗H²ᶜ⁻¹(Ȳ,ℚₚ(c)).
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Curve generation AND zero geometric H¹ action AND rational trace descent
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableMaximality kills every residual curve H¹ action
Only the geometric projector conclusion is used here.
Scope & sources - HypothesisAlgebraically trivial classes are curve-generated after finite extension
The finite data can be traced back to E.
Scope & sources - HypothesisCycle maps and spectral sequences respect correspondences and trace
All actions are the actual Chow-projector actions.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
A degree-zero curve divisor lives in its π₁ single row. RΔπ₁ has zero geometric action, so the image lies in F²=0. After finite L/E, cor∘res=[L:E] makes restriction injective over ℚₚ.
Conclusion / target
The filtration statement is essential: vanishing on the associated graded is converted into actual zero by F²=0.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The single-row identification AND annihilation of A_E AND functoriality
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableR H²ᶜ_cont(Y_E,ℚₚ(c))≅H¹(E,V_p), with F¹=H and F²=0
The actual R has geometric action only in degree k=2c−1, so only the q=k row survives in total degree k+1.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableThe projected arithmetic cycle class vanishes on A_E
The filtration statement is essential: vanishing on the associated graded is converted into actual zero by F²=0.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableAll maximal visible lifts have the same geometric action on the only graded term
The Π-part in total degree k+1 has just its first graded term. Equal geometric actions therefore give equal actions on the entire continuous-cohomology target.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Map z to cl_p(Rz), identify its target through the single row, and quotient by algebraically trivial classes only after proving their vanishing.
Conclusion / target
It respects restriction, corestriction and correspondences preserving the projectors, and is independent of the maximal curve-visible lift under the common cohomological identification.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 7 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableA canonical residual map a_p,E:G_E→H¹(E,V_p)
It respects restriction, corestriction and correspondences preserving the projectors, and is independent of the maximal curve-visible lift under the common cohomological identification.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableR H²ᶜ_cont(Y_E,ℚₚ(c))≅H¹(E,V_p), with F¹=H and F²=0
The actual R has geometric action only in degree k=2c−1, so only the q=k row survives in total degree k+1.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe projected arithmetic cycle class vanishes on A_E
The filtration statement is essential: vanishing on the associated graded is converted into actual zero by F²=0.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableMaximality kills every residual curve H¹ action
Only the geometric projector conclusion is used here.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisAlgebraically trivial classes are curve-generated after finite extension
HypothesisCycle maps and spectral sequences respect correspondences and trace
All actions are the actual Chow-projector actions.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableAll maximal visible lifts have the same geometric action on the only graded term
The Π-part in total degree k+1 has just its first graded term. Equal geometric actions therefore give equal actions on the entire continuous-cohomology target.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 14
Weight −1 gives finite arithmetic targets
The two local Frobenius weight exclusions kill rational local H¹; cocycles then factor through one finite-ramification Galois group, whose integral cohomology is finitely generated.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀. For every finite E/F₀ and every coefficient prime p, S_E includes the places over the fixed bad set S₀ and p, and all archimedean places. V_p has geometric weight −1.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 4 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Good unramified reduction AND the two Frobenius eigenvalue exclusions
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Hypothesisv∉S_E, so the representation is unramified and v∤p
Both restrictions are required for the stated tame-inertia calculation.
Scope & sources - HypothesisV has weight −1 and V(−1) has weight +1
Neither relevant eigenvalue can be one.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Smooth proper base change makes inertia trivial. Eigenvalue absolute values qᵥ^(−1/2) kill V/(Fr−1)V, and values qᵥ^(1/2) on V(−1) kill H¹(I,V)^Fr. The integral inertia invariants inject into the rational ones.
Conclusion / target
Integral local H¹ can equal the nonzero finite group T/(Fr−1)T; its inertia restriction is nevertheless zero.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · Finite cohomology with finite coefficients AND compact Nakayama
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisThe cited arithmetic cohomology finiteness theorem
Apply it to the fixed finite set of places over the chosen E.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableThe compact Nakayama argument and bounded continuous-cocycle image
Clearing denominators identifies rational H¹ with the tensor product of integral H¹ and ℚₚ.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The degree-zero inverse system is Mittag–Leffler. Thus H¹(G,T)=lim H¹(G,T/pᵃT); finite reduction and compact Nakayama imply finite generation. Continuous rational cocycles have bounded lattice denominators.
Conclusion / target
The finite-coefficient inverse limit is compact, and its mod-p quotient embeds in finite H¹(G,T/pT).
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑03AND · Inertia vanishing of every global cocycle AND integral finite generation
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableOutside S_E every local rational H¹ is zero, and integral cocycles restrict trivially to inertia
Integral local H¹ can equal the nonzero finite group T/(Fr−1)T; its inertia restriction is nevertheless zero.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableH¹(G_E,S_E,T) is a compact, finitely generated ℤₚ-module
The finite-coefficient inverse limit is compact, and its mod-p quotient embeds in finite H¹(G,T/pT).
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
The closed normal kernel is generated by inertia outside S_E. The cocycle identity shows that a cocycle zero on those inertia groups is zero on that kernel, so it descends. Rationalization of the integral cohomology proves finite dimension.
Conclusion / target
For a stable free ℤₚ-lattice T, the corresponding integral inflation is also an isomorphism and H¹(E,T) is finitely generated. The local integral H¹ need not be zero.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 03 in the diagram ↑All 10 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableH¹(E,V_p)=H¹(G_E,S_E,V_p) is finite-dimensional over ℚₚ
For a stable free ℤₚ-lattice T, the corresponding integral inflation is also an isomorphism and H¹(E,T) is finitely generated. The local integral H¹ need not be zero.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableOutside S_E every local rational H¹ is zero, and integral cocycles restrict trivially to inertia
Integral local H¹ can equal the nonzero finite group T/(Fr−1)T; its inertia restriction is nevertheless zero.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisv∉S_E, so the representation is unramified and v∤p
Both restrictions are required for the stated tame-inertia calculation.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisV has weight −1 and V(−1) has weight +1
Internal proof availableH¹(G_E,S_E,T) is a compact, finitely generated ℤₚ-module
The finite-coefficient inverse limit is compact, and its mod-p quotient embeds in finite H¹(G,T/pT).
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe cited arithmetic cohomology finiteness theorem
Apply it to the fixed finite set of places over the chosen E.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe compact Nakayama argument and bounded continuous-cocycle image
Clearing denominators identifies rational H¹ with the tensor product of integral H¹ and ℚₚ.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe cycle-class image factors through the SAME fixed arithmetic model outside S₀ and p
This is the original image-specific argument; the weight theorem above strengthens it to the whole target.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisOne finite S₀ supports smooth Y and the actual identity R²=R
Spread the finitely many cycle representatives AND their rational-equivalence witnesses.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableEvery generic cycle extends to the regular model by closure
Cycle-map compatibility gives the factorization, and arithmetic cohomology finiteness gives its finite-dimensional target.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 15
Scalar detection and local integral modules
A fixed projector denominator places integral cycles in a finite ℤₚ-module; scalar-extended injectivity then controls the source rank and its p-adic integral image.
Scope. Fix a pointed product of curves, its positive integral product polarization and the projected integral images in the geometric rational Chow group. Every height assertion assumes H1–H4 on the required products, correspondence sources and finite extensions; no proof status is promoted. For a fixed odd subproduct |S|=2c−1, U=Π∗CHᶜ_hom,ℚ, A=U∩CHᶜ_alg,ℚ and G=U/A. Define all curve-visible projectors over ONE fixed F₀, then work over every required finite E/F₀.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · One integral projector multiple AND integral cycle-class finiteness AND the single-row identification
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisOne M clears the Chow coefficients of R
For an actual integral representative Z, (MR)Z is an integral cycle.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe cited integral continuous cycle-class image is a finitely generated ℤₚ-module
Intersect its rational image with the R-subspace; a submodule of a finite ℤₚ-module is finite.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableThe residual regulator uses the single-row isomorphism
This turns the bounded cycle-class module into the stated H¹ module.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Choose M with MR integral. The integral cycle map contains Mcl_p(RZ); intersect its finite module with the R-subspace, apply the single-row identity and divide by the fixed M.
Conclusion / target
This is a separate conclusion at EACH coefficient prime. It does not supply a common rational lattice as p varies.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 10 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableFor every fixed E,p, a_p,E(Λ_G(E)) lies in a finitely generated ℤₚ-module
This is a separate conclusion at EACH coefficient prime. It does not supply a common rational lattice as p varies.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisOne M clears the Chow coefficients of R
For an actual integral representative Z, (MR)Z is an integral cycle.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe cited integral continuous cycle-class image is a finitely generated ℤₚ-module
Intersect its rational image with the R-subspace; a submodule of a finite ℤₚ-module is finite.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe residual regulator uses the single-row isomorphism
This turns the bounded cycle-class module into the stated H¹ module.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableScalar-extended injectivity at ONE p implies dimℚ G_E<∞
Injectivity merely as a ℚ-linear map into a finite-dimensional ℚₚ-space would be insufficient.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisG_E⊗ℚℚₚ→H¹(E,V_p) is injective
This rational-detection conjecture is an additional hypothesis.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe complete H¹ target is finite-dimensional over ℚₚ
Internal proof availableUnder scalar injectivity, Λ_G(E)⊗ℤℤₚ is finite and Λ_G(E)/pΛ_G(E) is finite
“Finite” for the tensor module means finitely generated over ℤₚ, not a finite set.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe integral regulator image lies in a finite ℤₚ-module
This is the local bound proved without injectivity.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe same scalar-extended regulator is injective
Retain injectivity after extension of scalars, not only on rational points.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 16
Northcott forces real positive definiteness
A negative direction gives integral multiples of negative height; a real null direction gives infinitely many bounded-height integer roundings.
Scope. Λ is a subgroup spanning a rational space V and q is a real-valued quadratic form. No finite-rank hypothesis is used: work in each finite-dimensional rational subspace.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 1 connection
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Exclude every negative real direction AND every nonzero real null direction
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableA negative real direction gives a nonzero integral vector of negative height
Use rational approximation and clear denominators; all its positive integer multiples lie in a fixed upper height ball.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableA nonzero real null vector gives infinitely many distinct bounded-height roundings
After excluding negative directions Q is semidefinite. Round tu to integer z_t with bounded error; q(z_t)=(z_t−tu)ᵗQ(z_t−tu) is bounded while z_t is unbounded.
Scope & sources - HypothesisThe upper q-balls in Λ are finite
Integral basis vectors in each finite rational subspace are available because Λ spans V.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Choose a rational basis in Λ on any finite-dimensional subspace. Both failures of definiteness contradict finite upper height balls.
Conclusion / target
This is stronger than positivity on nonzero rational vectors, and it has no converse without arithmetic control of Λ.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 4 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableIntegral Northcott implies positive definiteness on V⊗ℚℝ
This is stronger than positivity on nonzero rational vectors, and it has no converse without arithmetic control of Λ.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableA negative real direction gives a nonzero integral vector of negative height
Use rational approximation and clear denominators; all its positive integer multiples lie in a fixed upper height ball.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableA nonzero real null vector gives infinitely many distinct bounded-height roundings
After excluding negative directions Q is semidefinite. Round tu to integer z_t with bounded error; q(z_t)=(z_t−tu)ᵗQ(z_t−tu) is bounded while z_t is unbounded.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe upper q-balls in Λ are finite
Integral basis vectors in each finite rational subspace are available because Λ spans V.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 17
The five finite-rank lattice criteria
A positive gap makes the integral image uniformly discrete; a bounded fundamental parallelepiped then gives a single denominator. That same denominator is equivalent to finite-adelic relative compactness.
Scope. Λ is torsion-free of FINITE rank, V=Λ⊗ℚ, and q is positive definite on V⊗ℝ. The zero group is included, with the gap condition interpreted vacuously.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 3 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · A uniform positive gap AND a rational basis in Λ
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisA positive lower bound q(λ)≥ε for every nonzero λ
Northcott gives this under the standing positive definite finite-rank scope.
Scope & sources - HypothesisA finite rational basis chosen inside Λ
The bounded fundamental parallelepiped is finite-dimensional.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
For the Euclidean norm √q, the gap makes Λ uniformly discrete. Reducing modulo the ℤ-span of the basis into a bounded fundamental parallelepiped leaves finitely many representatives; hence that lattice has finite index.
Conclusion / target
Take a positive minimum on the finite unit ball, or use one if it contains no nonzero point.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The gap-to-lattice chain AND lattice-to-finiteness AND the finite-adelic comparison
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableNorthcott gives a gap, which gives a finite-index basis lattice
Take a positive minimum on the finite unit ball, or use one if it contains no nonzero point.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableFinite generation clears to Λ⊂N⁻¹Λ₀, and bounded lattice balls are finite
Clear the finitely many rational generator coordinates. Positive real definiteness makes each height ball bounded in the Euclidean lattice.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableRelative compactness in V(𝔸_f) is equivalent to one such denominator
A compact set lies in N⁻¹Λ₀⊗ℤ̂ by a finite subcover of these open compact sets. Conversely these sets are compact; intersect with V(ℚ).
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
These proof directions establish the full chain of equivalent conditions in the theorem.
Conclusion / target
Finite rank and REAL definiteness are standing hypotheses of this equivalence.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 9 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableNorthcott ⇔ positive gap ⇔ finite generation ⇔ one denominator ⇔ finite-adelic relative compactness
Finite rank and REAL definiteness are standing hypotheses of this equivalence.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableNorthcott gives a gap, which gives a finite-index basis lattice
Take a positive minimum on the finite unit ball, or use one if it contains no nonzero point.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisA positive lower bound q(λ)≥ε for every nonzero λ
Northcott gives this under the standing positive definite finite-rank scope.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisA finite rational basis chosen inside Λ
The bounded fundamental parallelepiped is finite-dimensional.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableFinite generation clears to Λ⊂N⁻¹Λ₀, and bounded lattice balls are finite
Clear the finitely many rational generator coordinates. Positive real definiteness makes each height ball bounded in the Euclidean lattice.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableRelative compactness in V(𝔸_f) is equivalent to one such denominator
A compact set lies in N⁻¹Λ₀⊗ℤ̂ by a finite subcover of these open compact sets. Conversely these sets are compact; intersect with V(ℚ).
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableA height-B ball has at most (1+2⌊N√(B/μ)⌋)ˢ points
s=dim V and μ>0 is the least eigenvalue of the Gram matrix in a basis of Λ₀.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisΛ⊂N⁻¹Λ₀
Use the same fixed rational basis and denominator.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe real Gram matrix has least eigenvalue μ>0
LOGIC 18
All-prime saturation produces one denominator
All local inverse lattices are bounded; almost-everywhere equality with ONE rational lattice leaves only finitely many denominator factors to clear.
Scope. V is finite-dimensional over ℚ, Λ⊂V and Λ₀ is a full rational lattice. For EVERY prime p, D_p:V⊗ℚₚ↪W_p is injective and M_p is a full ℤₚ-lattice in the finite-dimensional target.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 1 connection
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · Open compact inverse lattices AND almost-everywhere equality AND global coordinate integrality
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableInjectivity makes L_p=D_p⁻¹(M_p) an open compact ℤₚ-lattice
The target is finite-dimensional and the map is injective AFTER extending scalars.
Scope & sources - HypothesisL_p=Λ₀⊗ℤₚ for all but finitely many p
This comparison across primes is an additional hypothesis beyond separate finite generation at each p.
Scope & sources - HypothesisD_p(Λ)⊂M_p for EVERY prime p
A finite list of detectors cannot clear a denominator at an untested prime.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableA fixed denominator plus real positive definiteness gives finite height balls
Use the lattice theorem only after the denominator is established.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
At finitely many exceptional p choose b_p with D_p⁻¹(M_p)⊂p⁻ᵇᵖΛ₀⊗ℤₚ. Put N=∏pᵇᵖ; every coordinate of Nλ lies in ℤₚ for every p, hence in ℚ∩∏ₚℤₚ=ℤ.
Conclusion / target
For every p require D_p(Λ)⊂M_p; for almost every p require D_p⁻¹(M_p)=Λ₀⊗ℤₚ with the SAME Λ₀.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 5 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableΛ⊂N⁻¹Λ₀ for one integer N; every real positive definite q then has Northcott
For every p require D_p(Λ)⊂M_p; for almost every p require D_p⁻¹(M_p)=Λ₀⊗ℤₚ with the SAME Λ₀.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableInjectivity makes L_p=D_p⁻¹(M_p) an open compact ℤₚ-lattice
The target is finite-dimensional and the map is injective AFTER extending scalars.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisL_p=Λ₀⊗ℤₚ for all but finitely many p
This comparison across primes is an additional hypothesis beyond separate finite generation at each p.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisD_p(Λ)⊂M_p for EVERY prime p
A finite list of detectors cannot clear a denominator at an untested prime.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableA fixed denominator plus real positive definiteness gives finite height balls
Use the lattice theorem only after the denominator is established.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 19
A finite Kummer quotient and a genuine height gap
Sufficiently deep reduction modulo m separates a bounded height ball; then repeated division by m with bounded representatives produces finite generation.
Scope. Λ is torsion-free, √q is a REAL positive quadratic norm on Λ⊗ℝ, m≥2, s=|Λ/mΛ|<∞ and q(λ)≥ε>0 for every nonzero λ. No finite-rank assumption is needed.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 2 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · A genuine uniform gap AND finite quotient layers AND the norm triangle inequality
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Hypothesisq(λ)≥ε>0 for all nonzero integral λ
Rational or real positivity alone does not give this uniform gap.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Torsion-freeness identifies every mⁱΛ/mⁱ⁺¹Λ with Λ/mΛ. The real positive norm makes the height separation estimate valid.
Conclusion / target
If x−y=mʲz and q(x),q(y)≤B, then ∥z∥≤2√B/mʲ<√ε, so z=0.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑02AND · The finite bounded-ball count AND the height descent on quotient representatives
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Internal proof availableThe height-B ball injects into Λ/mʲΛ, of size sʲ
If x−y=mʲz and q(x),q(y)≤B, then ∥z∥≤2√B/mʲ<√ε, so z=0.
Scope & sources - Internal proof availableWriting x=my+t gives ∥y∥≤(∥x∥+C)/m
With C=max∥t∥ for t∈T, repeat until entering any ball of radius >C/(m−1). That finite ball together with T generates Λ.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
First prove finite balls by a modulo-mʲ injection. Then use a finite set T of representatives modulo mΛ to descend every vector to one fixed finite ball.
Conclusion / target
If m²ʲε>4B, the height-B ball has at most sʲ elements.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 02 in the diagram ↑All 5 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableΛ is finitely generated and q has Northcott
If m²ʲε>4B, the height-B ball has at most sʲ elements.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThe height-B ball injects into Λ/mʲΛ, of size sʲ
If x−y=mʲz and q(x),q(y)≤B, then ∥z∥≤2√B/mʲ<√ε, so z=0.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisq(λ)≥ε>0 for all nonzero integral λ
Rational or real positivity alone does not give this uniform gap.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesis|Λ/mΛ|=s<∞ and Λ is torsion-free
Internal proof availableWriting x=my+t gives ∥y∥≤(∥x∥+C)/m
With C=max∥t∥ for t∈T, repeat until entering any ball of radius >C/(m−1). That finite ball together with T generates Λ.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 20
Trace to the field of a class
The stabilizer defines the class field, and trace supplies an integral representative there after a bounded multiplier, even when the chosen cycle itself does not descend.
Scope. The common geometric rational Chow quotient has a discrete Galois action, compatible integral images Λ(E), and restriction and trace preserving those images. Every class is defined over a finite extension.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 1 connection
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01AND · The open stabilizer inclusion AND integral trace with projector compatibility
Premises and stated hypotheses
- HypothesisK is the fixed field of the stabilizer of the QUOTIENT CLASS
It need not be a field of definition of the chosen integral cycle representative.
Scope & sources - HypothesisTrace preserves integral images, fixed Chow projectors and algebraic equivalence
These are the standing assumptions for the geometric quotient.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Gal(F̄/E) is contained in the stabilizer, so K⊂E. Push an integral cycle representative from E to K; geometrically it is a sum over K-embeddings, each having class ξ, hence equals [E:K]ξ.
Conclusion / target
If [E:F₀]≤D, the multiplier m=[E:K] lies between one and D.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 3 nodes: scope, status and sources
Internal proof availableFor ξ∈Λ(E), K=F₀(ξ)⊂E and [E:K]ξ∈Λ(K)
If [E:F₀]≤D, the multiplier m=[E:K] lies between one and D.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisK is the fixed field of the stabilizer of the QUOTIENT CLASS
It need not be a field of definition of the chosen integral cycle representative.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisTrace preserves integral images, fixed Chow projectors and algebraic equivalence
These are the standing assumptions for the geometric quotient.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 21
The separate condition on fields of definition
Fixed-field Northcott handles a finite list of class fields; uniform ramification is exactly what produces that finite list at bounded degree.
Scope. Use the geometric quotient, integral images and trace assumptions of class-trace. q is invariant under Galois and field extension; bounded-degree balls are counted in the ONE geometric rational group.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 4 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01IFF · IFF fixed-field Northcott for EVERY finite K AND uniform class-field ramification on each bounded ball
Premises and stated hypotheses
- Hypothesisq has fixed-field Northcott on Λ(K) for EVERY finite K/F₀
A theorem over a single E is not enough for this prerequisite.
Scope & sources - HypothesisFor every B,D, all minimal class fields in the ball are unramified outside ONE finite S(B,D)
This controls the fields F₀(ξ), not merely the Galois cohomology over a separately chosen E.
Scope & sources
How the deduction works
Bounded-degree Northcott trivially includes each fixed-field assertion. Under those assertions, the theorem makes the ramification condition exactly equivalent to the bounded-degree conclusion.
Conclusion / target
For every height bound B and degree bound D. The theorem is a proved equivalence under the displayed compatibility; its geometric residual hypotheses remain open.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 13 nodes: scope, status and sources
ConditionalBounded-degree integral Northcott
For every height bound B and degree bound D. The theorem is a proved equivalence under the displayed compatibility; its geometric residual hypotheses remain open.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisq has fixed-field Northcott on Λ(K) for EVERY finite K/F₀
A theorem over a single E is not enough for this prerequisite.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisFor every B,D, all minimal class fields in the ball are unramified outside ONE finite S(B,D)
This controls the fields F₀(ξ), not merely the Galois cohomology over a separately chosen E.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableThese two hypotheses make each bounded-degree height ball finite
The trace multiplier and the height bound are kept explicitly.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisHermite–Minkowski bounds the fields of degree ≤D outside S(B,D)
The fixed-degree local discriminant exponents can be bounded; then apply discriminant finiteness.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availablemξ descends integrally with m≤D
This avoids assuming that ξ itself has an integral representative over its minimal class field.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisFixed-field Northcott bounds mξ at height D²B
There are only finitely many K and multipliers m; the group is rational, so m has no kernel.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableA finite bounded-degree ball has one finite class-field ramification set
The finite set can depend on B,D; no linear estimate in height is asserted.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisThe given bounded-degree height ball is finite
This is the premise for the reverse direction.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Internal proof availableEach finite extension ramifies at only finitely many finite places
The stabilizer class fields are finite by the discrete Galois assumption.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenA quantitative discriminant route to bounded-degree Northcott
The estimate log N disc(F₀(ξ)/F₀)≤A_D q(ξ)+B_D is a proposed sufficient bound, not equivalent to qualitative uniform ramification.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenThe displayed discriminant inequality for all integral classes of degree ≤D
Constants depend on D and the fixed geometric data; the estimate is not proved in this paper.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenFixed-field Northcott for every finite class field
The field bound does not provide this arithmetic condition.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑LOGIC 22
Why the omitted arithmetic hypotheses cannot be skipped
The paper’s abstract counterexamples separate rational positivity, real positivity, integral denominators, finite rank and the fields of definition.
Scope. These are abstract groups and quadratic forms used to identify missing implications. They are not geometric counterexamples to the conjectures.
Scroll inside the frame to follow a large branch. “Fit width” shows the whole layout; “Readable size” restores the text to 100%.
Read the 5 connections
Each numbered card gives the exact inputs, the deduction and its sources.
01BLOCKED · Separate finite generation at EVERY prime is insufficient
Inputs to the rejected shortcut
- HypothesisReal positive q and a finite local integral module for each coefficient prime
There is no assumed almost-everywhere saturation relative to ONE rational lattice.
Scope & sources
Why the shortcut fails
Λ=Σₚ ℤ·(1/p)⊂ℚ and q(x)=x² have Λ⊗ℤₚ=p⁻¹ℤₚ finite free for every p, but q(1/p)→0. The inverse lattices differ from one fixed lattice at infinitely many primes.
Target not obtained from these inputs
The target still requires arithmetic discreteness or another valid finiteness criterion.
Scope & sourcesEvidence and further reading
Back to connection 01 in the diagram ↑All 10 nodes: scope, status and sources
OpenFixed-field integral Northcott from real positivity and local integral bounds
The target still requires arithmetic discreteness or another valid finiteness criterion.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisReal positive q and a finite local integral module for each coefficient prime
There is no assumed almost-everywhere saturation relative to ONE rational lattice.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenReal positive definiteness from positivity only on nonzero rational vectors
The stronger real condition is the one used in Euclidean height descent.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑Hypothesisq(v)>0 for every nonzero rational v
This does not exclude a nonzero real null vector.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenFinite rational rank from Northcott alone
Scalar detection is a separate route to finite rank; the rank conclusion cannot be added to the general Northcott lemma.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisOnly Northcott on the integral image
No scalar-extended rational detector or finite Kummer quotient is supplied.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenBounded-degree Northcott from uniform fixed-field estimates alone
A separate restriction on minimal class fields is still needed.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisFixed-field Northcott with uniform degree-dependent rank, gap and Kummer bounds
The compatible trace and restriction images in the example still satisfy these properties.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑OpenA common denominator from detectors at finitely many primes
The all-prime theorem really requires every coefficient prime.
Back to this node in the diagram ↑HypothesisIntegral detector bounds only at a finite list of primes
Remaining problem
The remaining assertions concern the residual height, its real positivity and integral discreteness, and the fields of definition of bounded-height classes. Positivity on a rational vector space alone does not give the Northcott property.