NAG-002357 · Accepted whole

Finite polyhedral upper bounds without an interior hypothesis

5 Tropicalization, multiplicities and balancing

Open in the English reader · PDF page 982

Statement · exact TeX
\begin{theorem}[Finite polyhedral upper bounds without an interior hypothesis]
\label{v037:globaltrop:upperbound}
Let $X=\mathcal M(A)$ be a nonempty generalized affinoid
space of analytic dimension $d$, and let analytic units
$f_1,\ldots,f_n$ define $t:X\to\mathbb R^n$.
For every $w\in t(X)$ there are a finite rational polyhedral
fan $C$ of dimension at most $d$ and a neighbourhood $V$ of
$w$ such that
\[
                         t(X)\cap V\subset(w+|C|)\cap V.
\]
Consequently $t(X)$ is contained in the support of a finite
integral affine polyhedral complex of dimension at most $d$.
\end{theorem}
Full selected proof · exact TeX
\begin{proof}
Choose a complete isometric extension $L/K$ containing
elements with sizes equal to every radius in a fixed
presentation of $A$, and elements $c_i$ with
$|c_i|=e^{-w_i}$; require also that $L$ be nontrivially valued.
Such a field is explicit: take the completion of a rational
function field with weighted Gauss norms assigning these
finitely many positive radii to its variables, and add a
variable of size strictly between zero and one.
The Gauss construction is
Proposition~\ref{fnd:gaussnorm}; its valued completion is
the one in Lemma~\ref{fnd:gaussvaluedfielddimension}.
The actual scalar presentation
\ref{fnd:generalscalarpresentation}, followed by rescaling
the finitely many presentation variables, makes $X_L$ strict.
Its dimension is $d$ by
Theorem~\ref{fnd:analyticdimensionindependence}.

Put $h_i=f_i/c_i$. Scalar spectral surjectivity
\ref{fnd:scalarextensionspectralsurjective} gives
\[
                         t_h(X_L)=t(X)-w.
\]
It suffices to prove the upper bound at zero for this
actual strict space. Its whole fibre $F=t_h^{-1}(0)$ is
a nonempty strict affinoid domain by
Theorem~\ref{fnd:generalizedrationaluniversal}.
Let $D$ be its algebra. It has an admissible integral model
$D_0$ by Proposition~\ref{fnd:affineformalpresentations}.
The elements $h_i^{\pm1}$ are power-bounded in $D$, since
their values on $F$ are one and
Theorem~\ref{fnd:generalizedpointwisepowerbound} applies.
Adjoin them to $D_0$ by
Theorem~\ref{fnd:powerboundedmodelblowup}. The resulting
algebra is still an actual admissible model of the same
$D$, and contains all these elements. Use this enlarged
model in what follows.

Write $k=\widetilde L$, $\mathfrak m=L^{\circ\circ}$, and
\[
 J=\ker\bigl(k[T_1^{\pm1},\ldots,T_n^{\pm1}]
                         \longrightarrow D_0/\mathfrak mD_0\bigr),
 \qquad R=k[T^{\pm1}]/J.
\]
Thus $R$ injects into the actual special-fibre algebra.
For every minimal prime $\mathfrak p$ of $R$, localization
preserves this injection, by \cite[Tag 00HT]{StacksAlg}.
The algebra
$(D_0/\mathfrak mD_0)\otimes_RR_{\mathfrak p}$ is nonzero,
so it has a prime by \cite[Tag 00E0(1)]{StacksAlg}.
Its contraction is the unique prime of $R_{\mathfrak p}$.
It therefore gives a prime $\mathfrak q$ of the special
fibre lying above $\mathfrak p$; no finiteness of the
injection $R\to D_0/\mathfrak mD_0$ is required here.
Actual specialization surjectivity,
Theorem~\ref{fnd:affineformalspecializationsurjective}, supplies
$x\in F$ specializing to $\mathfrak q$. The induced
injections give
\[
                    \operatorname{Frac}(R/\mathfrak p)
                         \hookrightarrow\widetilde{\mathcal H(x)}.
\]
By \cite[Tag 00P0]{StacksAlg} and
Theorem~\ref{fnd:affinoidabhyankarmaximum},
\[
 \dim(R/\mathfrak p)
   =\operatorname{trdeg}_k\operatorname{Frac}(R/\mathfrak p)
   \leq d_L(x)\leq d.
\]
The residue field here is the same as for $x\in X_L$, by
Corollary~\ref{fnd:domainresiduefields}.

The finite-type $k$-algebra $R$ is Noetherian by
\cite[Tag 00FO]{StacksAlg}, and has finitely many minimal primes, by
\cite[Tag 00FR]{StacksAlg}. Its tropical support is the
union of the supports of the corresponding integral
quotients: every analytic prime kernel contains a minimal
prime by \cite[Tag 00E0(4)]{StacksAlg}.
Theorem~\ref{cand:tropicalpuredimension} bounds the dimension
of each of these algebraic tropicalizations by $d$.
Lemma~\ref{v037:analytic:finitetropicalbasis} gives a finite
rational fan $C$ with support $\operatorname{Trop}(\operatorname{Spec}R)$
and finitely many nonzero $p_j\in J$ cutting out that
support tropically. Its dimension is therefore at most $d$.

Lift every nonzero coefficient of each $p_j$ to an element
of $L^\circ$ of absolute value one, obtaining a Laurent
polynomial $P_j$. Since $p_j\in J$,
$P_j(h)\in\mathfrak mD_0$. Express this membership as a
finite sum $\sum_\ell b_{j\ell}d_{j\ell}$ with
$|b_{j\ell}|<1$ and $d_{j\ell}\in D_0$.
Every $d_{j\ell}$ has absolute value at most one on $F$,
by the actual model presentation. Hence there is a real
$c_j<1$ with $|P_j(h)|<c_j$ throughout $F$.
The compact subset of $X_L$ where $|P_j(h)|\geq c_j$ has
compact moment image missing zero. Avoiding these finitely
many images gives a neighbourhood $V_0$ of zero where
all these strict inequalities hold on the entire inverse
image. This uses the compact spectrum of
Proposition~\ref{fnd:boundedspectrumcompact}.

Shrink $V_0$ further so that, for every monomial of every
$P_j$, its norm at a weight $v\in V_0$ is greater than
$c_j$. At zero all these finitely many norms equal one,
so continuity permits the simultaneous choice. If an
actual moment value $v\in V_0$ lay outside $|C|$, some
$p_j$ would have a unique least-weight term there.
The same term of $P_j(h)$ would have strictly largest
absolute value at any point over $v$, and that value
would exceed $c_j$. The non-Archimedean triangle equality
would give $|P_j(h)|>c_j$, a contradiction.
Thus $t_h(X_L)\cap V_0\subset |C|$. Translating back proves
the local assertion over the original field and norm.

Finally, at every $w\in t(X)$ choose a closed rectangular
box centred at $w$ inside its upper-bound neighbourhood.
Finitely many box interiors cover the compact set $t(X)$.
The union of the intersections of these boxes with the
corresponding translated finite fans contains $t(X)$.
It is a finite union of integral affine polytopes, all
of dimension at most $d$. Cutting by their finitely many
defining hyperplanes gives a finite common complex, as
in Lemma~\ref{cand:polyhedralrefinementproduct}.
This proves the final assertion.
\end{proof}
Typeset reader excerpt
Typeset mathematical passage from PDF page 982
PDF page 982 · excerpt continues in the reader

Typed proof inputs

Selected scopes

minimal level residual prime lift

The ledger retains this scope. Its exact text or reader anchor is unavailable in this edition.

Reader cross-references

Proof map

Verified map inputs · NAG-002357

AND · joint registered proof inputs

Unlinked source pointers

These pointers have no operative linked edge in this map.

  • STACKS-00E0
  • STACKS-00FO
  • STACKS-00FR
  • STACKS-00HT
  • STACKS-00P0
  • SUPPORT:NAG-001932:finite_admissible_model_enlargement