Closed

The topology alone is insufficient

Example 1.9.2. (The topology alone is insufficient). Let KK be trivially valued. The two norms on K[T]K[T] given by ∥∑anTn∥1=max⁡n∣an∣,∥∑anTn∥w=max⁡n(n+1)∣an∣.\Big\|\sum a_nT^n\Big\|_1=\max_n|a_n|, \qquad \Big\|\sum a_nT^n\Big\|_w=\max_n(n+1)|a_n|. They make K[T]K[T] complete Banach algebras with the same discrete topology, but they are not uniformly equivalent. The identity from the second norm to the first is bounded and has no bounded inverse.

Proof

Proof. The coefficientwise ultrametric inequality gives the triangle rules and KK-homogeneity. Submultiplicativity of the second norm follows from i+j+1≤(i+1)(j+1)i+j+1\leq(i+1)(j+1); its unit has norm one. Every nonzero element has norm at least one for both norms, so both topologies are discrete and both spaces complete. But ∥Tn∥w=n+1\|T^n\|_w=n+1 and ∥Tn∥1=1\|T^n\|_1=1, which disproves a uniform reverse bound.

For r>1r>1, the generalized Tate algebra K{r−1S}K\{r^{-1}S\} is K[S]K[S]. The map S↦TS\mapsto T to the second normed algebra is bounded, because (n+1)/rn(n+1)/r^n is bounded, and is a topological quotient isomorphism. Its quotient norm, however, assigns rnr^n to TnT^n, and is not equivalent to n+1n+1. Thus the topology-only convention even admits presentations outside the intended affinoid category. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001387, 1.9.2.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record