Closed

Quantitative comparison of a finite double complex

Lemma 2.21.2. (Quantitative comparison of a finite double complex). Let Dp,qD^{p,q} be a double complex of Banach KK-spaces in a finite rectangle 0≤p≤a0\leq p\leq a, 0≤q≤b0\leq q\leq b, with bounded commuting differentials dh,dvd_h,d_v. Use d=dh+(−1)pdvd=d_h+(-1)^p d_v on its total complex and maximum norms on finite sums. Let L∙L^\bullet be a complex of Banach KK-spaces with bounded differentials, concentrated in degrees 0,…,b0,\ldots,b, and let αq:Lq→D0,q\alpha^q:L^q\to D^{0,q} be a bounded compatible horizontal augmentation. Assume that every augmented horizontal row 0⟶Lq→αqD0,q→dhD1,q⟶⋯⟶Da,q⟶00\longrightarrow L^q\xrightarrow{\alpha^q}D^{0,q} \xrightarrow{d_h}D^{1,q}\longrightarrow\cdots \longrightarrow D^{a,q}\longrightarrow0 is strictly exact. Then α:L∙→Tot⁡(D)\alpha:L^\bullet\to\operatorname{Tot}(D) is a quasi-isomorphism of underlying algebraic complexes. Let PP be a Banach KK-space and let ϵ:P→L0\epsilon:P\to L^0 be a bounded augmentation with dLϵ=0d_L\epsilon=0, placing PP in degree −1-1. Its augmented complex is strictly acyclic if and only if P→Tot⁡(D)P\to\operatorname{Tot}(D) is strictly acyclic. All lifting and inverse bounds for either complex can be obtained from finitely many bounds for the rows, the differentials, α\alpha, and the other complex. If all these maps are contractive and every horizontal row has a contracting homotopy of norm at most one, a strict acyclicity bound Q≥1Q\geq 1 for P→L∙P\to L^\bullet also works for P→Tot⁡(D)P\to\operatorname{Tot}(D). The corresponding assertions with the two axes interchanged hold as well.

Proof

Proof. The algebraic assertion is the version with interchanged variables of [StacksAlg] (Tag 0133, Lemma 12.25.4), in the abelian category of KK-vector spaces, or of the retained algebraic modules. Its finite-diagonal hypothesis holds because the rectangle is finite. We prove the additional norm statement directly. Choose B,C≥1B,C\geq 1 so that BB bounds the differentials and α\alpha, and every horizontal cycle of positive horizontal degree has a preimage bounded by CC times its norm, while ∥u∥≤C∥αu∥\|u\|\leq C\|\alpha u\|. Such a common CC exists because there are finitely many strictly exact rows and terms. Lifts need not be linear or chosen compatibly.

Let z∈Tot⁡k(D)z\in\operatorname{Tot}^k(D) be a cocycle. Starting with the largest p>0p>0 for which its (p,k−p)(p,k-p) component is nonzero, that component is horizontally closed: the (p+1,k−p)(p+1,k-p) component of dz=0dz=0 says so, because the component one column farther to the right is zero. Lift it horizontally to y∈Dp−1,k−py\in D^{p-1,k-p} and replace zz by z−dyz-dy. This removes that component and introduces a possible new component only one column to the left. After at most aa repetitions, only z0,kz_{0,k} remains. It equals αu\alpha u for a unique u∈Lku\in L^k, and dLu=0d_Lu=0 follows from dvαu=0d_v\alpha u=0 and injectivity of α\alpha. Thus z=αu+dy,dLu=0.z=\alpha u+dy,\qquad d_Lu=0. At each elimination the current norm increases by at most BCBC. Consequently ∥u∥\|u\| and the norm of the sum of the chosen lifts are bounded by C(BC)a∥z∥C(BC)^a\|z\|. This bound is independent of kk. If u=dLvu=d_Lv, then y+αvy+\alpha v is a primitive of zz. In degree zero the same construction, followed by the inverse bound for the augmentation P→L0P\to L^0, controls the unique preimage in PP. Injectivity of that augmentation is also preserved. This proves one implication.

For the converse, let u∈Lku\in L^k be a positive-degree cocycle and suppose αu=dw\alpha u=dw. Apply the same elimination to ww. Although ww need not be a cocycle, every component of dwdw of positive horizontal degree is zero, which is precisely the condition used in each elimination. The result is w−dy=αvw-dy=\alpha v with ∥v∥≤C(BC)a∥w∥\|v\|\leq C(BC)^a\|w\|. Therefore αu=dαv=αdLv\alpha u=d\alpha v=\alpha d_Lv, and injectivity gives u=dLvu=d_Lv. A bounded primitive for αu\alpha u thus yields one for uu. In degree zero, a preimage of αu\alpha u in PP maps to uu by injectivity of α\alpha, with its norm bounded by BB times the corresponding total-complex bound. These estimates also prove the converse injectivity statement. For example, multiplying the bound for the other complex by (BC)a+2(BC)^{a+2} is sufficient in either direction.

If the row contractions and all maps have norm at most one, use the row contraction to choose each horizontal lift and its degree-zero preimage. No elimination increases the norm. Thus ∥y∥,∥u∥≤∥z∥\|y\|,\|u\|\leq\|z\|, and the asserted unchanged bound follows. Interchanging the two axes changes the total-complex convention by the isometric sign map xp,q↦(−1)pqxp,qx^{p,q}\mapsto(-1)^{pq}x^{p,q}; hence the same argument proves the symmetric version. Finally, exactness identifies each differential image with the kernel of the next bounded map. The images are therefore closed, and the primitive bounds are exactly the needed bounds for the inverse maps from image norms to quotient norms. This is norm-strictness, without an appeal to an open mapping theorem. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001460, 2.21.2.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record