Closed

Strict acyclic refinement and common refinement

Proposition 2.21.5. (Strict acyclic refinement and common refinement). Let NN be a finite intersection coefficient diagram, and let U=(Ui)i∈I\mathcal U=(U_i)_{i\in I} and V=(Vj)j∈J\mathcal V=(V_j)_{j\in J} be nonempty finite families. Suppose that for every nonempty tuple of U\mathcal U-indices, the augmented ordered complex of V\mathcal V restricted to Ui0∩⋯∩UipU_{i_0}\cap\cdots\cap U_{i_p} is strictly acyclic. No coefficient term is discarded on the basis of point-set emptiness.

  1. If V\mathcal V refines U\mathcal U, meaning that a map t:J→It:J\to I satisfies Vj≤Ut(j)V_j\leq U_{t(j)}, then the augmented complexes of U\mathcal U and V\mathcal V are strictly acyclic simultaneously. The usual refinement map is a quasi-isomorphism, compatible with augmentation; its cohomology map is independent of tt.

  2. Without a refinement assumption, put W=(Ui∩Vj)(i,j)∈I×J\mathcal W=(U_i\cap V_j)_{(i,j)\in I\times J}. Then the augmented complexes of U\mathcal U and W\mathcal W are strictly acyclic simultaneously. The hypotheses on every U\mathcal U-intersection remain necessary in this assertion.

All conclusions are valid for all-tuples complexes as well, with bounded comparison maps and degreewise bounded homotopies. Only finitely many of the stipulated local inverse and lifting bounds are needed.

Proof

Proof. For part (1), form the ordered double complex Dp,q=∏i0<⋯<ip∏j0<⋯<jqN(Ui0∩⋯∩Uip∩Vj0∩⋯∩Vjq).D^{p,q}=\prod_{i_0<\cdots<i_p}\prod_{j_0<\cdots<j_q} N(U_{i_0}\cap\cdots\cap U_{i_p}\cap V_{j_0}\cap\cdots\cap V_{j_q}). The assumed vertical augmented rows compare C∙(U,N)C^\bullet(\mathcal U,N) with Tot⁡(D)\operatorname{Tot}(D) by Lemma 2.21.2. In the other direction, fix a nonempty jj-tuple and choose any one of its indices j0j_0. Since Vj0∩⋯∩Vjq≤Ut(j0)V_{j_0}\cap\cdots\cap V_{j_q}\leq U_{t(j_0)}, the restricted U\mathcal U-family has a member equal to the entire intersection. Its augmented complex has the insertion contraction of [StacksAlg] (Tag 0G6T, Lemma 20.23.7). With the maximum norms, insertion has norm at most one; no local sheaf theorem is used. The same comparison lemma now compares C∙(V,N)C^\bullet(\mathcal V,N) with Tot⁡(D)\operatorname{Tot}(D). The two applications, preserving the common augmentation N(X)N(X), prove strict acyclicity in both directions.

We record the actual maps. In alternating notation the refinement map is (Ttc)j0…jk=ct(j0)…t(jk)∣Vj0∩⋯∩Vjk.(T_tc)_{j_0\ldots j_k} =c_{t(j_0)\ldots t(j_k)}\big|_{V_{j_0}\cap\cdots\cap V_{j_k}}. Repeated indices on the right give zero. Let aa and bb be the augmentations of the two complexes into the total double complex, placing them in bidegrees (k,0)(k,0) and (0,k)(0,k) respectively. The bounded homotopy (Hc)i0…ip;j0…jqp,q=(−1)pci0…ip t(j0)…t(jq)∣,p+q=k−1,(Hc)^{p,q}_{i_0\ldots i_p;j_0\ldots j_q} =(-1)^p c_{i_0\ldots i_p\,t(j_0)\ldots t(j_q)}\big|, \qquad p+q=k-1, satisfies dH+Hd=bTt−adH+Hd=bT_t-a. All restrictions are to the indicated mixed intersection. To check the sign, the terms obtained by deleting an ii-index cancel between dHdH and HdHd in positive horizontal degree; the terms obtained by deleting a t(j)t(j)-index cancel in positive vertical degree. The boundary terms are bTtbT_t at p=0p=0 and −a-a at q=0q=0. Thus the quasi-isomorphism supplied by the double complex is induced by the usual refinement map. The prism formula in [StacksAlg] (Tag 01FP, Section 20.25, paragraph “Refinements”, following (20.25.0.2)) gives a homotopy for two choices t,t′t,t'. It consists of finitely many signed restrictions and is bounded in each degree. In the finite-poset realization, one may restrict the first open family to the union of the refining family before applying that formula; pulling it back gives precisely the displayed coefficient maps. This verifies the presheaf scope without identifying N(X)N(X) with sections of an unproved sheaf.

For part (2), W\mathcal W refines U\mathcal U. Fix an intersection Y=Ui0∩⋯∩UipY=U_{i_0}\cap\cdots\cap U_{i_p} and choose i0i_0 among its indices. On YY, the family W∣Y\mathcal W|_Y refines V∣Y\mathcal V|_Y by (i,j)↦j(i,j)\mapsto j, while V∣Y\mathcal V|_Y refines W∣Y\mathcal W|_Y by j↦(i0,j)j\mapsto(i_0,j) because Y∩Vj=Y∩Ui0∩VjY\cap V_j=Y\cap U_{i_0}\cap V_j. The composites are homotopic to the identity by the same prism formula. These bounded homotopies preserve augmentation. For clarity, if f,gf,g are such maps with gf−1=dh+hdgf-1=dh+hd and fz=dyfz=dy, then gy−hzgy-hz is a primitive of zz; its norm is controlled by the norms of g,hg,h and the given primitive. The analogous degree-zero assertion follows from preservation of augmentation and injectivity. Hence strict acyclicity of V∣Y\mathcal V|_Y implies that of W∣Y\mathcal W|_Y. Apply part (1) to W→U\mathcal W\to\mathcal U. Finally apply Tag 01FM as in Theorem 2.21.3 to obtain the all-tuples versions. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001463, 2.21.5.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record