Closed

Transitivity of strict rational presentations

Theorem 2.25.4. (Transitivity of strict rational presentations). Let AA be a strict norm-admissible KK-affinoid algebra. Let BB be a rational presentation over AA, and let CC be a rational presentation over BB, with all radii in ∣K×∣|K^\times|. Then there is a rational presentation DD over AA and a unique bounded AA-algebra isomorphism D≃CD\simeq C with bounded inverse. Under the point homeomorphisms of Theorem 2.19.3, the image of M(C)\mathcal M(C) in M(A)\mathcal M(A) is precisely the rational subset represented by DD.

If the valuation of KK is nontrivial, DD can be chosen so that this isomorphism is isometric for the given actual presentation norms. For trivial valuation, the same holds after replacing the norm on AA by a defining strict quotient norm and using the induced quotient norms on the presentations; for the original norms the conclusion is a bounded isomorphism in both directions. The construction and conclusion allow zero quotients.

For every finite canonical AA-module MM, the resulting identifications D⊗AM ≃ C⊗AM ≃ C⊗B(B⊗AM)D\otimes_A M\ \simeq\ C\otimes_A M \ \simeq\ C\otimes_B(B\otimes_A M) are natural bounded isomorphisms with bounded inverses. The corresponding assertions hold with separated completed tensors. With norms from one fixed finite free presentation of MM, the module comparisons are isometric whenever the algebra comparison is isometric. This completed-tensor assertion concerns these finite modules.

Proof

Proof. By the weighted change of variables in Lemma 2.17.1, reduce every radius to one. This change is isometric. Write B=A⟨f/g⟩,C=B⟨h/k⟩,h=(h1,…,ht).B=A\langle f/g\rangle, \qquad C=B\langle h/k\rangle, \qquad h=(h_1,\ldots,h_t). If A=0A=0 or B=0B=0, then C=0C=0; the rational presentation A{V}/(0V−1)A\{V\}/(0V-1) is zero and gives the conclusion, including the module assertions. We may therefore assume A,B≠0A,B\ne 0. Choose certificates c0g+∑icifi=1,b0k+∑j=1tbjhj=1,c_0g+\sum_i c_if_i=1, \qquad b_0k+\sum_{j=1}^t b_jh_j=1, and define L=max⁡(1,∥ci∥)L=\max(1,\|c_i\|) and H=max⁡(1,∥bj∥)H=\max(1,\|b_j\|). Choose 0<η<H−10<\eta<H^{-1}. Lemma 2.25.2 supplies a common NN and p0,…,pt∈Ap_0,\ldots,p_t\in A such that a0′=g−Np0,aj′=g−Npj,∥k−a0′∥<η,∥hj−aj′∥<η.a'_0=g^{-N}p_0,\qquad a'_j=g^{-N}p_j, \qquad \|k-a'_0\|<\eta,\quad \|h_j-a'_j\|<\eta. Lemma 2.25.1 gives a unit-ideal certificate for (aj′)(a'_j) with coefficient norms at most HH, and an isometric BB-algebra identification C≃C′=B⟨a1′/a0′,…,at′/a0′⟩.C\simeq C'=B\langle a'_1/a'_0,\ldots,a'_t/a'_0\rangle. If KK is nontrivially valued, powers of a scalar of absolute value less than one give γ∈K×\gamma\in K^\times with ∣γ∣LN+1H≤1|\gamma|L^{N+1}H\leq 1. Lemma 2.25.3 then gives the required DD, with denominator gp0gp_0 and numerator list (p0fi)1≤i≤s,(gpj)1≤j≤t,γ.(p_0f_i)_{1\leq i\leq s},\qquad (gp_j)_{1\leq j\leq t},\qquad \gamma. Both comparisons are isometric, so D≃CD\simeq C is isometric. Notice that adding γ\gamma is indispensable to this construction: clearing denominators only proves a unit-ideal statement in BB, and does not establish (p0,…,pt)=A(p_0,\ldots,p_t)=A.

For trivial valuation, replace the norm on AA by a defining strict quotient norm. Uniformly equivalent coefficient norms give uniformly equivalent Tate and quotient norms, with the same underlying complete algebras: the coefficient convergence condition is unchanged, and taking infima over representatives preserves both norm comparisons. By Lemma 2.25.2, every nonzero element of AA and BB now has norm one. Hence L=H=1L=H=1, the approximations may be exact, and γ=1\gamma=1 meets the required inequality. The same two lemmas give an isometric comparison for these norms. Returning to the original uniformly equivalent norms gives the asserted bounded inverse maps.

The isomorphism is over AA. Applying Theorem 2.19.3 first to A→BA\to B and then to B→CB\to C identifies M(C)\mathcal M(C) homeomorphically with its image in M(A)\mathcal M(A). The same theorem for A→DA\to D, together with the constructed isomorphism, identifies this image with the rational subset of the displayed tuple. This proves the point assertion from the algebra comparison; no spectral-radius or maximum principle is needed in this proof. Any bounded AA-algebra endomorphism of CC restricts on BB to its unique bounded rational factorization and then has its values on the second-stage variables forced by their unit denominator. Thus it is the identity. The same argument after composing with the constructed inverse proves the asserted uniqueness. Different choices of approximations and of γ\gamma are consequently compared by unique bounded AA-algebra maps.

For the module assertion choose Av→FAw→M→0A^v\xrightarrow{F}A^w\to M\to 0. Ordinary tensor associativity, [StacksAlg] (Tag 00D2, Lemma 10.12.7), gives C⊗B(B⊗AM)≃C⊗AMC\otimes_B(B\otimes_A M)\simeq C\otimes_A M, sending c⊗(b⊗m)c\otimes(b\otimes m) to cb⊗mcb\otimes m. Theorem 2.17.2 identifies the successive relation-quotient module with Cw/FCCvC^w/F_CC^v, with its quotient norm. The algebra comparison gives a bounded inverse comparison with Dw/FDDvD^w/F_DD^v, and it is isometric if the coefficient comparison is isometric. All these maps agree on the images of the chosen generators and are therefore natural in MM. Finally, Theorem 2.17.2 and Proposition 1.11.6 identify each finite ordinary tensor here with its separated completion. No passage from algebraic flatness to an assertion about arbitrary completed tensors is involved. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001502, 2.25.4.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record