Closed

Quasi-smoothness, flatness and geometric regularity

Theorem 2.35.14. (Quasi-smoothness, flatness and geometric regularity). For a morphism f:Y→Xf:Y\to X of analytic spaces, quasi-smoothness at yy is equivalent to analytic flatness at yy together with geometric regularity at yy of the H(f(y))\mathcal H(f(y))-analytic fibre. For good Y,XY,X, whenever these conditions hold one may choose the Jacobian presentation with its source an ordinary affinoid neighborhood of yy. More precisely, after fixing any relative affinoid presentation near yy, one can restrict it to an ordinary rational neighborhood of yy in its ambient polydisc so that the relation ideal is generated by n−rk⁡yΩY/Xn-\operatorname{rk}_y\Omega_{Y/X} elements with independent relative differentials.

Proof

Proof. A Jacobian chart is analytically flat. Start with a presentation W↪D⊂AXn,anW\hookrightarrow D\subset\mathbb A_X^{n,\mathrm{an}} whose ideal is generated by rr functions with independent relative differentials at yy. First treat the good chart itself, without assuming that WW is an ordinary neighborhood in any larger source. After any good analytic base change over any complete extension, the same equations and an invertible Jacobian minor give a presentation at each point over yy, by Proposition 2.41.4 and the actual domain base-change theorem. At such a point vv, extend the ground field to a nontrivially valued complete field Ω\Omega containing H(v)\mathcal H(v). Evaluation gives an Ω\Omega-rational lift ww. The base point is then Ω\Omega-rational as well. Proposition 2.35.13 proves naive flatness at ww. Both scalar-stalk maps are faithfully flat by Theorem 2.35.4, so Lemma 2.35.6 descends naive flatness to vv. All the tests in Definition 2.9.1 have now been verified.

Its fibres are geometrically regular. Let FF be any complete extension of H(f(y))\mathcal H(f(y)), and take any point vv of the extended fibre above yy. The pulled-back chart is still a Jacobian presentation over FF. Choose a nontrivially valued complete Ω⊃H(v)\Omega\supset\mathcal H(v) and its rational lift. The completed local ring at that lift is Ω[[T1,…,Tn−r]]\Omega[[T_1,\ldots,T_{n-r}]] by Proposition 2.35.13. Thus its local ring is regular. Its faithfully flat local map from the original fibre stalk has Noetherian source and target, by Theorem 2.35.11. Regularity descends by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00OF). This proves geometric regularity with every complete-extension test.

If the original quasi-smooth presentation uses only an affinoid domain W⊂YW\subset Y containing yy, analytic flatness descends from WW to the good source YY by Corollary 2.47.3. On each complete-extension fibre, the inverse image of WW is a domain containing every point over yy. Its ordinary local map from the ambient fibre is faithfully flat by Theorem 2.47.1. Applying [StacksAlg] (Tag 00OF) again descends regularity from this domain to that fibre. Thus the preceding conclusions hold for the original source, not only for the chosen presentation.

Recovering a Jacobian presentation. Now suppose Y,XY,X good, ff analytically flat at yy, and its analytic fibre geometrically regular at yy. Choose ordinary affinoid neighborhoods Y0=M(B)Y_0=\mathcal M(B), X0=M(A)X_0=\mathcal M(A) with f(Y0)⊂X0f(Y_0)\subset X_0. Lemma 2.33.7 gives B=P/IB=P/I, where P=A{s−1T1,…,sn−1Tn}P=A\{s^{-1}T_1,\ldots,s_n^{-1}T_n\}. Let rr be the rank at yy of the relative differentials of II, so that r=n−rk⁡yΩB/Ar=n-\operatorname{rk}_y\Omega_{B/A} by Proposition 2.41.6. Choose g1,…,gr∈Ig_1,\ldots,g_r\in I with independent such differentials, put J=(g1,…,gr)J=(g_1,\ldots,g_r), and let Z=M(P/J)Z=\mathcal M(P/J). The image point, still denoted yy, has the same completed residue field. An invertible Jacobian minor makes Z→X0Z\to X_0 quasi-smooth at yy, so the forward part already proved applies to it.

Choose a nontrivially valued complete Ω⊃H(y)\Omega\supset\mathcal H(y), with rational lifts u∈Y0,Ω⊂ZΩu\in Y_{0,\Omega}\subset Z_\Omega and v∈X0,Ωv\in X_{0,\Omega}. Put R=OX0,Ω,v,S=OZΩ,u,T=OY0,Ω,u,N=ker⁡(S⟶T).R=\mathcal O_{X_{0,\Omega},v},\quad S=\mathcal O_{Z_\Omega,u},\quad T=\mathcal O_{Y_{0,\Omega},u},\quad N=\ker(S\longrightarrow T). These rings are Noetherian, and NN is a finite SS-module. The RR-module TT is flat, by the assumed analytic flatness. The two fibre local rings S/mRS,T/mRTS/\mathfrak m_R S,\qquad T/\mathfrak m_R T are regular. For the first this follows from Proposition 2.35.13; for the second it is the assumed geometric regularity, using the identification of this fibre with the scalar extension of Yf(y)Y_{f(y)} by associativity of completed base change. Both have embedding dimension n−rn-r, by Lemma 2.35.12 and invariance of the Jacobian rank under the field embedding. Their dimensions therefore both equal n−rn-r. The surjection between them has zero kernel by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00NR): an ideal with regular quotient of the same dimension is generated by zero members of a regular parameter system.

Let RR be a commutative ring and let 0→A→B→C→00\to A\to B\to C\to 0 be an exact sequence of RR-modules with CC flat. For every RR-module XX, tensoring the sequence with XX is exact. To check injectivity on the left, choose a free module FF mapping onto XX, with kernel GG. Lift an element of X⊗RAX\otimes_R A that dies in X⊗RBX\otimes_R B to v∈F⊗RAv\in F\otimes_R A. Its image in F⊗RBF\otimes_R B comes from some w∈G⊗RBw\in G\otimes_R B. The image of ww in G⊗RCG\otimes_R C is zero because it is zero in F⊗RCF\otimes_R C and CC is flat. Right exactness lifts ww to G⊗RAG\otimes_R A. Subtract the image of this lift from vv. The difference vanishes in F⊗RBF\otimes_R B, hence in F⊗RAF\otimes_R A since FF is free. Thus vv comes from G⊗RAG\otimes_R A, and the original element of X⊗RAX\otimes_R A is zero.

If AA is also flat, then BB is flat. Given an injection X↪YX\hookrightarrow Y, tensor the short exact sequence with XX and with YY, using the first assertion for the left injections. An element of X⊗RBX\otimes_R B that dies in Y⊗RBY\otimes_R B maps to zero in X⊗RCX\otimes_R C, by flatness of CC. It comes from X⊗RAX\otimes_R A. The image of this preimage in Y⊗RAY\otimes_R A is zero by the left injection in the row for YY; flatness of AA kills the preimage. Hence the induced map on tensoring with BB is injective for every injection, which is flatness of BB.

Apply the first assertion to 0→N→S→T→00\to N\to S\to T\to 0 and X=R/mRX=R/\mathfrak m_R. The quotient TT is flat over RR, so N/mRNN/\mathfrak m_RN injects into the zero fibre kernel just computed. Hence N=mRNN=\mathfrak m_RN. Because mRS⊂mS\mathfrak m_RS\subset\mathfrak m_S and NN is finite, N=0N=0. Explicitly, writing finite generators in terms of themselves with coefficients in mRS\mathfrak m_RS gives a matrix CC with entries in mS\mathfrak m_S; the adjugate identity for 1−C1-C and the unit det⁡(1−C)\det(1-C) annihilate every generator.

The coherent ideal I/JI/J on ZZ thus has zero scalar-pullback stalk at uu. Theorem 2.35.4 identifies that stalk with its tensor product over OZ,y\mathcal O_{Z,y} with the faithfully flat OZΩ,u\mathcal O_{Z_\Omega,u}. Consequently (I/J)y=0(I/J)_y=0. Its finite generators vanish on an ordinary neighborhood NyN_y in ZZ. Since ZZ is closed in the ambient polydisc, choose an ordinary open neighborhood of yy in that polydisc whose intersection with ZZ is contained in NyN_y, and then a rational affinoid neighborhood D′D' inside it. On D′D', the two closed subspaces Y0Y_0 and ZZ coincide, with ideal generated by g1,…,grg_1,\ldots,g_r. Their intersection with D′D' is an ordinary affinoid neighborhood of yy in YY, and the minor stays nonzero at yy. This is the asserted strengthened Jacobian presentation.

For general analytic spaces, choose affinoid domains in source and target and use the GG-local definition of analytic flatness. Quasi-smoothness is invariant under these restrictions by Theorem 2.41.8. Completed residue fields on domains agree, so the local analytic fibres are precisely analytic domains in the original fibre. In the forward direction the chart argument above proves regularity on all such domains after all complete extensions. In the reverse direction geometric regularity of the fibre supplies regularity on its affinoid charts, while analytic flatness supplies the good-space tests there. The good case therefore applies on every required chart and proves the general equivalence. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001751, 2.35.14.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record