Open

Inner flatness with nontrivially valued completed residue field

Theorem 2.62.2. (Inner flatness with nontrivially valued completed residue field). Let f:Y→Xf:Y\to X be a morphism of good analytic spaces over any complete field and let F\mathcal F be coherent on YGY_G. At an inner point yy, with H(f(y))\mathcal H(f(y)) nontrivially valued, naive XX-flatness of F\mathcal F is equivalent to analytic XX-flatness.

Argument in the manuscript

Proof. The identity base-change test proves the analytic-to-naive implication. Assume that Fy\mathcal F_y is naively flat, and put x=f(y)x=f(y) and F=H(x)F=\mathcal H(x). If the stalk is zero, a finite set of local generators vanishes on one ordinary neighborhood of yy. Every pullback then vanishes near every point above yy, giving the conclusion. We may assume the stalk is nonzero.

Step 1: a strict fibre-support induction. Choose an ordinary affinoid representative with strict FF-fibre, using Proposition 2.51.3. Replace its source by the closed support of F\mathcal F, defined by its annihilator. The sheaf is a finite module over this closed subspace, and its pushforward is the original sheaf. Theorem 2.35.17 identifies both naive and analytic flatness under this replacement. The closed immersion is finite and inner, so the new source is still inner over XX at yy. Its fibre is a strict affinoid quotient. Lemma 2.57.1 identifies its point set with the support of Fx\mathcal F_x. Induct on an upper bound nn for this strict fibre dimension, allowing every such representative with dimension at most nn. By Corollary 3.22.8, later restrictions to ordinary affinoid domains cannot increase this analytic support dimension. For a strict affinoid fibre it equals the Krull dimension.

Step 2: a finite projection to an integral fibre. Write the chosen closed support as ZZ and put d=dim⁡Zx≤nd=\dim Z_x\leq n. Theorem 2.51.4 gives a finite map from an ordinary neighborhood of yy in ZZ to an ordinary affinoid neighborhood TT of tt in AXd,an\mathbb A_X^{d,\mathrm{an}}. Finite branch separation retains the branch through yy and, after shrinking the target, makes yy its only point above tt. Since tt is in the ordinary interior of TT in relative affine space, it is inner over XX. Shrink by Proposition 2.51.3 to make TxT_x strict. This fibre is an affinoid domain of AFd\mathbb A_F^d; its ordinary rings are regular by Theorem 2.35.23. Lemma 2.52.2 decomposes its algebra into integral factors. Lemma 2.56.4 retains the factor containing tt by an actual ordinary domain over the original field. Pull the finite map back after each restriction. We obtain π:Z⟶T=M(B),C=B⊗^AF\pi:Z\longrightarrow T=\mathcal M(B), \qquad C=B\widehat\otimes_A F with singleton distinguished fibre, with CC integral and strict, and with dim⁡C≤d\dim C\leq d by Lemma 2.56.3. Here M(A)\mathcal M(A) is the chosen ordinary affinoid base neighborhood. The source and target ordinary germs at the distinguished points have not changed.

Step 3: an original generic basis and a smaller quotient. Put N=π∗FN=\pi_*\mathcal F and represent it by a finite BB-module. The singleton finite-pushforward formula makes NtN_t naively XX-flat. Fix any finite generating family of this BB-module. Its images span NC⊗CFrac⁡(C)N_C\otimes_C\operatorname{Frac}(C). Choose a subset which is a basis, allowing the empty subset when its rank is zero, and use the corresponding original generators to define u:Br→Nu:B^r\to N. Lemma 2.57.2 proves that uCu_C is injective, has ordinarily dense bijectivity locus, and that its cokernel QCQ_C has support of dimension at most dim⁡C−1\dim C-1 unless it is zero. Here injection follows because its kernel is a torsion submodule of the free module CrC^r over a domain. The dimension drop follows by annihilating the finite torsion cokernel by one nonzero element of CC and prepending the zero prime to each chain in its support. Thus the generators and the map uu are defined over the original affinoid algebra, not merely over the completed residue field.

Let L=OTrL=\mathcal O_T^r and Q=Coker⁡(u:L→N)Q=\operatorname{Coker}(u:L\to N). Lemma 2.62.1 gives injectivity of utu_t and naive XX-flatness of QtQ_t. By support compatibility under fibre base change, the closed support of QQ has strict fibre dimension at most dim⁡C−1≤n−1\dim C-1\leq n-1 whenever its fibre is nonempty. That closed support is inner at tt. If Qt≠0Q_t\ne 0, the induction hypothesis applied on this support makes QQ analytically XX-flat at tt; if Qt=0Q_t=0, local vanishing gives the same conclusion. When n=0n=0, the integral zero-dimensional fibre algebra CC is a field, so QC=0Q_C=0. Tensoring at the distinguished point gives Qt⊗OT,tH(t)=0Q_t\otimes_{\mathcal O_{T,t}}\mathcal H(t)=0, and Nakayama gives Qt=0Q_t=0. This supplies the induction start.

Step 4: all analytic tests. The target T→XT\to X is quasi-smooth, being an analytic-domain restriction of relative affine space. The map uxu_x is bijective on an ordinarily dense subset of its fibre and utu_t is injective. Corollary 2.52.6 therefore upgrades the analytic flatness of QQ to analytic flatness of NN. Explicitly, its universal-injectivity statement preserves L→NL\to N at every point above tt under every good-space base change over every complete extension. The pulled-back cokernel is the pullback of QQ by right exactness. Both that cokernel and the pullback of the free sheaf LL are flat over the new base, so their extension, the pullback of NN, is flat. This verifies all tests, not just those over the original field. The analytic version of Theorem 2.35.17 then gives analytic flatness of F\mathcal F at yy, because the distinguished finite fibre has one point; it includes all later fibre points after arbitrary tests. The induction is complete. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001823, 2.62.2.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record