Closed

Domain base change can destroy naive flatness

Corollary 2.60.5. (Domain base change can destroy naive flatness). Choose π∈K\pi\in K with 0<∣π∣<10<|\pi|<1 and set f(T)=∑n≥0π⌊n⌋Tn,ϕ:D⟶AK2,an,t⟼(t,f(t)).f(T)=\sum_{n\geq0}\pi^{\lfloor\sqrt n\rfloor}T^n, \qquad\phi:D\longrightarrow\mathbb A_K^{2,\mathrm{an}}, \qquad t\longmapsto(t,f(t)). The morphism ϕ\phi is naively flat at the unit Gauss point η\eta. Its base change by the analytic domain X={∣T1∣≤1}X=\{|T_1|\leq 1\} is not naively flat at that point.

Proof

Proof. The coefficients tend to zero, whereas their nnth-root absolute values tend to one. Thus f∈K⟨T⟩f\in K\langle T\rangle has convergence radius exactly one. Theorem 2.60.4 makes the ordinary target local ring at x=ϕ(η)x=\phi(\eta) a field. Every module over a field is flat, so ϕ\phi is naively flat at η\eta.

Because ϕ\phi factors through the domain XX, its base change to XX is its closed graph immersion, with equation g=T2−f(T1)g=T_2-f(T_1). The ordinary local ring R=OX,xR=\mathcal O_{X,x} is a domain by Theorem 2.35.23 and [StacksAlg] (Tag 00NP), using an affinoid neighborhood of xx in XX. The germ gg is nonzero: differentiation in the second coordinate gives ∂g/∂T2=1\partial g/\partial T_2=1. This derivation on convergent series restricts to the germ by Theorem 2.41.3 and Theorem 2.41.5. It vanishes at xx, so R/(g)R/(g) is nonzero. Tensoring the injective multiplication map R→gRR\xrightarrow{g}R with R/(g)R/(g) gives the zero map on the nonzero module R/(g)R/(g). This quotient is therefore not RR-flat. The graph local ring is exactly R/(g)R/(g) by the coherent closed-subspace restriction formula, proving the assertion. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001883, 2.60.5.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record