Closed

A punctured closed polydisc is not good

Theorem 3.23.2. (A punctured closed polydisc is not good). Let KK be any complete non-Archimedean field, possibly trivially valued, let n≥2n\ge 2, and let r1,…,rn>0r_1,\ldots,r_n>0. In X=M(K{r1−1T1,…,rn−1Tn})X=\mathcal M(K\{r_1^{-1}T_1,\ldots,r_n^{-1}T_n\}) consider the subset U=X∖{z:∣Ti(z)∣<ri for every i}=⋃i=1nUi,Ui={z∈X:∣Ti(z)∣=ri}.\begin{aligned} U&=X\setminus\{z:|T_i(z)|<r_i\text{ for every }i\} =\bigcup_{i=1}^n U_i,\\ U_i&=\{z\in X:|T_i(z)|=r_i\}. \end{aligned} Then UU is a compact Hausdorff analytic domain of XX. At the weighted Gauss point x(∑νaνTν)=max⁡ν∣aν∣rνx(\sum_\nu a_\nu T^\nu)=\max_\nu|a_\nu|r^\nu, the space UU has no affinoid neighbourhood.

Proof

Proof. Step 1: the domain structure. Each UiU_i is the Laurent domain ∣Ti∣≥ri|T_i|\ge r_i in XX; the opposite inequality already holds throughout XX. All finite intersections are Laurent affinoid domains. Their finite cover of UU is an analytic net: at a point z∈Uz\in U, remove the finitely many closed members which do not contain zz. The remaining relative open neighbourhood is covered by the members containing zz. The domain and net constructions in Proposition 2.39.3 and Proposition 2.40.5 therefore give the analytic-domain structure on UU. The displayed complement is open in XX, so UU is closed in the compact Hausdorff space XX, hence compact Hausdorff.

Step 2: unit radii. Assume first that every ri=1r_i=1, put k=K~k=\widetilde K, and let xx be the unit Gauss point. Polynomials are dense in the Tate algebra. Approximating the numerator and denominator of a fraction, with error smaller than the nonzero denominator, shows that H(x)\mathcal H(x) is the completion of K(T1,…,Tn)K(T_1,\ldots,T_n) for the Gauss absolute value. Every nonzero Gauss norm of a polynomial belongs to ∣K×∣|K^\times|. For a norm-one fraction, divide its numerator and denominator by coefficients of their maximal norms. Reduction then identifies the residue field with k(t1,…,tn)k(t_1,\ldots,t_n); completion has the same residue field by Lemma 3.22.2. The graded image of the Tate algebra in Fx=H(x)~ grF_x=\widetilde{\mathcal H(x)}^{\,\mathrm{gr}} is K~ gr[t1,…,tn]\widetilde K^{\,\mathrm{gr}}[t_1,\ldots,t_n]: only finitely many terms of a convergent series can have its maximal norm, and these give precisely its initial form.

All the UiU_i contain xx. Near xx, TiT_i is invertible; the additional active inequality defining UiU_i is ∣Ti−1∣≤1|T_i^{-1}|\le 1. By Lemma 3.19.5, its reduction adds ti−1t_i^{-1} to the graded image just computed. Gluing the domain germs by Theorem 3.19.9 and Theorem 3.19.10, the reduction of (U,x)(U,x) is therefore the union of the graded valuation subspaces containing K~ gr[t1,…,tn,ti−1],1≤i≤n.\widetilde K^{\,\mathrm{gr}} [t_1,\ldots,t_n,t_i^{-1}],\qquad 1\le i\le n. It is exactly the pullback, by restriction to degree one, of the ordinary birational space QQ in Lemma 3.23.1. That lemma says QQ is not affine. Lemma 3.19.20 shows that its graded pullback is not affine either, including when the valuation of KK is trivial. Theorem C.1.114 now shows that xx has no affinoid neighbourhood in UU.

Step 3: arbitrary radii. Equip the rational function field K(S1,…,Sn)K(S_1,\ldots,S_n) with the Gauss absolute value of polyradius rr and let LL be its completion. Multiplicativity and completion are the Gauss-field construction used in Lemma 3.18.2; no independence of the radii is required. The images cic_i of SiS_i satisfy ∣ci∣=ri|c_i|=r_i. Scalar extension identifies XL=M(L{r−1T})≃M(L{Z1,…,Zn}),Ti=ciZi.X_L=\mathcal M(L\{r^{-1}T\}) \simeq\mathcal M(L\{Z_1,\ldots,Z_n\}), \qquad T_i=c_iZ_i . The exact scalar presentation and domain base-change statements (2.33.5, 2.36.9, 2.40.12) identify (Ui)L(U_i)_L with ∣Ti∣=ri|T_i|=r_i, hence with ∣Zi∣=1|Z_i|=1. Since the finite domain cover and its intersections base change, UL=⋃i(Ui)LU_L=\bigcup_i(U_i)_L is exactly the unit-radius punctured polydisc. Equivalently its underlying set is the inverse image of UU: the projection preserves every number ∣Ti∣|T_i|, so it preserves the displayed complement condition as well.

Let yy be its unit Gauss point in the ZZ-coordinates. For a polynomial with coefficients in KK, evaluation at yy is max⁡ν∣aνcν∣=max⁡ν∣aν∣rν\max_\nu|a_\nu c^\nu| =\max_\nu|a_\nu|r^\nu; by continuity the same holds for every element of K{r−1T}K\{r^{-1}T\}. Thus yy lies over xx. If xx had an affinoid neighbourhood WW in UU, then WLW_L would be an affinoid domain of ULU_L. Moreover, an ordinary open neighbourhood of xx contained in WW has an open inverse image containing yy and contained in WLW_L. Hence WLW_L would be an affinoid neighbourhood of yy, contradicting Step 2 over LL. This proves the assertion for every positive polyradius. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001886, 3.23.2.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record