Closed

A minimal finite boundary is the smallest closed boundary

Lemma 3.12.4. (A minimal finite boundary is the smallest closed boundary). Suppose that a compact space XX of multiplicative seminorms on an algebra has continuous evaluation functions and has a finite boundary. Every inclusion-minimal finite boundary is contained in every closed boundary. In particular it is unique.

Proof

Proof. Choose an inclusion-minimal finite boundary SS and a point ξ∈S\xi\in S. Minimality supplies aa with m=∣a(ξ)∣>max⁡s∈S∖{ξ}∣a(s)∣=q,m>0,m=|a(\xi)|>\max_{s\in S\setminus\{\xi\}}|a(s)|=q, \qquad m>0, where the maximum over the empty set is zero. Let CC be any closed boundary and put C0={y∈C:∣a(y)∣=m}C_0=\{y\in C:|a(y)|=m\}, a nonempty compact set. For bb in the algebra and y∈C0y\in C_0, the boundary property of SS gives ∣b(y)∣≤max⁡s∈S(∣a(s)∣/m)n∣b(s)∣→n→∞∣b(ξ)∣.|b(y)|\leq \max_{s\in S}\bigl(|a(s)|/m\bigr)^n|b(s)| \xrightarrow[n\to\infty]{}|b(\xi)|. If ∣b(ξ)∣>0|b(\xi)|>0, choose for each sufficiently large nn a point yn∈Cy_n\in C attaining the maximum of ∣anb∣|a^n b|. The maximum equals mn∣b(ξ)∣m^n|b(\xi)| for large nn. Since ∣a∣≤m|a|\leq m and ∣b∣|b| is bounded, we obtain ∣a(yn)∣→m|a(y_n)|\to m and ∣b(yn)∣≥∣b(ξ)∣|b(y_n)|\geq|b(\xi)|. A convergent subnet has limit in C0C_0 and attains ∣b(ξ)∣|b(\xi)| there. For finitely many b1,…,btb_1,\ldots,b_t with nonzero values at ξ\xi, apply this conclusion to their product. The preceding upper bound for each factor forces all their values to equal the respective values at ξ\xi at one common point of C0C_0. Factors vanishing at ξ\xi vanish throughout C0C_0 by that same upper bound.

Thus the closed sets {y∈C0:∣b(y)∣=∣b(ξ)∣}\{y\in C_0:|b(y)|=|b(\xi)|\}, indexed by all bb, have the finite intersection property. Compactness produces a point with all evaluations equal to those of ξ\xi. Points are the seminorms themselves, so this point is ξ\xi. Hence ξ∈C\xi\in C. This holds for every ξ∈S\xi\in S and every closed boundary CC, proving the assertion. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-001904, 3.12.4.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record