Closed

Separable rigid points in smooth spaces

Lemma 2.55.3. (Separable rigid points in smooth spaces). Over a nontrivially valued complete field FF, every nonempty ordinary open subset of a good smooth FF-analytic space contains a point whose completed residue field is finite separable over FF.

Proof

Proof. First consider a nonempty ordinary open set in AFn,an\mathbb A_F^{n,\mathrm{an}}. Finite polynomial-value inequalities describe a smaller nonempty open neighborhood of any chosen point. The group ∣F×∣\sqrt{|F^\times|} is dense in R>0\mathbb R_{>0}: powers with rational exponents of any fixed value different from one already are dense. Choose all upper and lower bounds for these inequalities, and the ambient polydisc radii, in this group, strictly outside the values at the point. This produces a nonempty affinoid domain inside the open set. After a finite extension realizing the finitely many radii as absolute values, its presentation is strict. A maximal ideal of this strict algebra gives, by Theorem 1.12.3, a point whose coordinates are algebraic over FF. Surjectivity of complete scalar extension ensures that the chosen domain remains nonempty.

Separable algebraic elements are dense among algebraic elements over FF. To see the only nontrivial case, let aa have inseparable monic minimal polynomial PP of degree dd. Then P′=0P'=0. For arbitrarily small ε∈F×\varepsilon\in F^\times, the polynomial P(T)+εTP(T)+\varepsilon T is separable, as its derivative is the nonzero constant ε\varepsilon. In a finite splitting extension write its roots as b1,…,bdb_1,\ldots,b_d. Evaluation at aa gives ∏i∣a−bi∣=∣εa∣\prod_i|a-b_i|=|\varepsilon a|, so one root approaches aa as ε→0\varepsilon\to 0; the case a=0a=0 is already separable. Lemma 1.12.1 supplies compatible absolute values in the finite splitting extensions. Approximating the finitely many coordinates simultaneously preserves the finitely many strict polynomial inequalities. Their joint field is finite separable over FF. This proves the assertion for affine space.

Now take an étale coordinate chart of the given smooth open set. An étale map is ordinary-open. Indeed, near any point it is finite flat; separate the finite fibre into branches over a small ordinary target neighborhood. A source ordinary neighborhood contains the relevant branch after a further target shrinking, by compactness and the closed-map property. The finite flat branch has open-and-closed image by Lemma 2.44.2, so the image contains a neighborhood of the image point. Apply the affine-space assertion to this nonempty open image. Over the resulting finite separable point the étale fibre is a nonempty finite union of finite separable fields. Any point of it gives a finite separable extension of FF, as required. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002001, 2.55.3.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record