Closed

An invariant midpoint over a dense value group

Proposition. (An invariant midpoint over a dense value group). There is a complete nontrivially real-valued field KK, with algebraically closed residue field of characteristic zero and dense value group Γ=Z[1/3]\Gamma=\mathbb Z[1/3], and a split projective semistable model X\mathcal X of PK1\mathbb P^1_K, for which the following holds. Its geometric skeleton is an interval of length 11. Adding its midpoint gives a semistable geometric vertex set fixed by every isometric KK-automorphism of Ω=K‾^\Omega=\widehat{\overline K}, but no semistable original-OO model has that geometric vertex set. The midpoint is realized after the ramified quadratic extension K(t)/KK(\sqrt t)/K.

Proof

Proof. Fix an algebraically closed field kk of characteristic zero. Take compatible Laurent-series fields Fn=k((t1/3n)),Fn↪Fn+1,v(t1/3n)=3−n,F_n=k((t^{1/3^n})),\qquad F_n\hookrightarrow F_{n+1},\qquad v(t^{1/3^n})=3^{-n}, and let KK be the completion of F=⋃n≥0FnF=\bigcup_{n\geq0}F_n. For nonzero a∈Ka\in K, choose f∈Ff\in F with ∣a−f∣<∣a∣|a-f|<|a|; then ∣a∣=∣f∣|a|=|f|. Thus completion introduces no new nonzero values and v(K×)=Z[1/3]v(K^\times)=\mathbb Z[1/3], which is dense in R\mathbb R. For a∈K∘a\in K^\circ, approximation with error less than 11 identifies its residue with a residue from some Fn∘F_n^\circ. Hence the residue field is kk.

On PO1\mathbb P^1_O, with affine coordinate TT, blow up the ideal (T,t)(T,t), extended as the unit ideal outside its support. The two affine charts over the TT-line are Spec⁡O[T,u]/(Tu−t),Spec⁡O[z],T=tz.\operatorname{Spec}O[T,u]/(Tu-t), \qquad \operatorname{Spec}O[z],\quad T=tz. Their standard monomial bases make these rings free over OO, hence flat; the displayed presentations are finite. The first is a nodal chart and the second is smooth. Together with the unchanged infinity chart they give a projective semistable model X\mathcal X, by Stacks Tag 02NS and Stacks Tag 0C4P, with special fibre two copies of Pk1\mathbb P^1_k meeting at one split node. Its geometric vertices have v(T)=0,1v(T)=0,1, and the node tube is ∣t∣<∣T∣<1|t|<|T|<1, of length 11.

Choose b∈Ωb\in\Omega with b2=tb^2=t, and put L=K(b)L=K(b). Since 1/2∉Γ1/2\notin\Gamma, b∉Kb\notin K and [L:K]=2[L:K]=2. The two terms in a+cba+cb, for a,c∈Ka,c\in K, have distinct valuations when nonzero, since Γ∩(Γ+1/2)=∅\Gamma\cap(\Gamma+1/2)=\varnothing. Thus ∣a+cb∣=max⁡(∣a∣,∣c∣∣b∣)|a+cb|=\max(|a|,|c||b|); completeness follows coefficientwise from completeness of KK. Since v(b)=1/2v(b)=1/2, the extension is ramified. Lemma C.1.84, using the accepted charts

Proof input. cand:symmetricnodeblowup

, at δ=1/2\delta=1/2 on XL∘\mathcal X_{L^\circ} inserts exactly the midpoint. Consequently its base change to Ω∘\Omega^\circ realizes the three-element semistable geometric vertex set {ζ(1), ζ(∣t∣1/2), ζ(∣t∣)}.\{\zeta(1),\ \zeta(|t|^{1/2}),\ \zeta(|t|)\}. Each of these Gauss seminorms is fixed by every isometric KK-automorphism of Ω\Omega: its radius is fixed and its formula on Ω[T]\Omega[T] uses only the absolute values of the coefficients.

If an original semistable model realized this set, then

Proof input. v036:f5:vertexarithmetic

would make the image ww of the midpoint a component vertex satisfying v(H(w)×)=Γv(\mathcal H(w)^\times)=\Gamma. But TT is a nonzero element of H(w)\mathcal H(w) with v(T(w))=1/2v(T(w))=1/2, a contradiction. Thus invariance, even with already split branches and residue field, is insufficient. The use of L∘L^\circ above is a ramified construction, not an etale descent step. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002604.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record