Closed

Serre comparison for finite modules; F8ST-S

Lemma C.1.15. (Serre comparison for finite modules; F8ST-S). Let R→SR\to S be a regular map of Noetherian rings and MM a finite RR-module. If MM is S1S_1, then M⊗RSM\otimes_RS is S1S_1. If the map is also faithfully flat, the converse holds. The converse in fact needs only faithful flatness, not regular fibres.

Proof

Proof. For ascent, fix q∈Supp⁡(M⊗RS)\mathfrak q\in\operatorname{Supp}(M\otimes_RS), put p=q∩R\mathfrak p=\mathfrak q\cap R, and work with the flat local map Rp→SqR_{\mathfrak p}\to S_{\mathfrak q}. Write M0=MpM_0=M_{\mathfrak p} and N=M0⊗SqN=M_0\otimes S_{\mathfrak q}. We need a non-zero-divisor on NN in its maximal ideal only when dim⁡Supp⁡N>0\dim\operatorname{Supp}N>0. If dim⁡Supp⁡M0>0\dim\operatorname{Supp}M_0>0, the S1S_1 condition supplies such an element a∈pRpa\in\mathfrak pR_{\mathfrak p} on M0M_0; flatness preserves its injectivity on NN.

Otherwise M0M_0 is nonzero of finite length. Its composition series tensors to a filtration of NN by copies of F=Sq/pSqF=S_{\mathfrak q}/\mathfrak pS_{\mathfrak q}. Hence Supp⁡N=Spec⁡F\operatorname{Supp}N=\operatorname{Spec}F. The ring FF is regular local. If its dimension is positive, its maximal ideal contains a nonzero element that is regular on FF, because FF is a domain (STACKS-00NP). Lift that element to qSq\mathfrak qS_{\mathfrak q}. It is injective on each filtration quotient, and therefore on NN. This proves ascent.

For descent, suppose MM is not S1S_1. Choose a prime p\mathfrak p for which MpM_{\mathfrak p} has positive support dimension and depth zero. There is an injection κ(p)↪Mp\kappa(\mathfrak p)\hookrightarrow M_{\mathfrak p}: equivalently, the maximal ideal is associated to this finite local module. In (R∖p)−1S(R\setminus\mathfrak p)^{-1}S, choose a prime minimal over the extension of p\mathfrak p. Such a prime exists by faithful flatness; let q\mathfrak q be its preimage in SS. Its contraction is p\mathfrak p, and F=Sq/pSqF=S_{\mathfrak q}/\mathfrak pS_{\mathfrak q} is a nonzero Artinian local ring. Tensoring the injection gives F↪NF\hookrightarrow N. The socle of FF is nonzero, so depth⁡N=0\operatorname{depth}N=0.

Choose p0⊊p\mathfrak p_0\subsetneq\mathfrak p in Supp⁡M\operatorname{Supp}M. Flat going down (STACKS-00HS) gives q0⊊q\mathfrak q_0\subsetneq\mathfrak q over p0\mathfrak p_0. The localized map is faithfully flat, so (M⊗RS)q0≠0(M\otimes_RS)_{\mathfrak q_0}\ne0. Consequently dim⁡Supp⁡N>0\dim\operatorname{Supp}N>0, contradicting S1S_1 upstairs. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002763, C.1.15.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record