Lemma C.1.15. (Serre comparison for finite modules; F8ST-S). Let be a regular map of Noetherian rings and a finite -module. If is , then is . If the map is also faithfully flat, the converse holds. The converse in fact needs only faithful flatness, not regular fibres.
Proof
Proof. For ascent, fix , put , and work with the flat local map . Write and . We need a non-zero-divisor on in its maximal ideal only when . If , the condition supplies such an element on ; flatness preserves its injectivity on .
Otherwise is nonzero of finite length. Its composition series tensors to a filtration of by copies of . Hence . The ring is regular local. If its dimension is positive, its maximal ideal contains a nonzero element that is regular on , because is a domain (STACKS-00NP). Lift that element to . It is injective on each filtration quotient, and therefore on . This proves ascent.
For descent, suppose is not . Choose a prime for which has positive support dimension and depth zero. There is an injection : equivalently, the maximal ideal is associated to this finite local module. In , choose a prime minimal over the extension of . Such a prime exists by faithful flatness; let be its preimage in . Its contraction is , and is a nonzero Artinian local ring. Tensoring the injection gives . The socle of is nonzero, so .
Choose in . Flat going down (STACKS-00HS) gives over . The localized map is faithfully flat, so . Consequently , contradicting upstairs. ◻