Closed

Weak convergence does not control the logarithm

Proposition. (Weak convergence does not control the logarithm). For every d≥2d\geq2 and KK as in the standing finite-model data there are genuine semipositive product-model measures μj\mu_j of mixed mass one on X=(PK1)dX=(\mathbf P^1_K)^d and a fixed model-metrized line (M,h)(M,h) with a nonzero regular section ss such that μj⟹δo,∫−log⁡∥s∥h dμj=jλ⟶+∞,o∈Z(s).\mu_j\Longrightarrow\delta_o,\qquad \int-\log\|s\|_h\,d\mu_j=j\lambda\longrightarrow+\infty, \qquad o\in Z(s). Thus finite-model integrability and weak measure convergence, even with an unchanged metric on MM, do not imply logarithmic integrability of the limit. This does not contradict convergence theorems that also require uniform convergence of the semipositive metrics defining the measures.

Proof

Proof. For each j≥1j\geq1 use the model (PR1)d(\mathbf P^1_R)^d with generic-fibre identification Ti=πjSiT_i=\pi^jS_i, and the model lines pr⁡i∗O(1)\operatorname{pr}_i^*\mathcal O(1). They are semipositive: on any special-fibre curve their degrees are nonnegative, since they are generated by global sections. The special fibre has one reduced component, b=1b=1, and its mixed degree is one, by intersecting the dd coordinate divisors at one kk-rational product point. Its model measure is therefore μj=δξj\mu_j=\delta_{\xi_j}, where ∣∑m∈NdamTm∣(ξj)=max⁡m∣am∣ ∣π∣j(m1+⋯+md).\left|\sum_{m\in\mathbf N^d}a_mT^m\right|(\xi_j) =\max_m|a_m|\,|\pi|^{j(m_1+\cdots+m_d)}. Gauss multiplicativity gives the point, and its polynomial evaluations converge to ∣a0∣|a_0|, the evaluations at the origin oo. The evaluation topology in NAG-001707 gives ξj→o\xi_j\to o in the common affine chart and thus in XanX^\mathrm{an}. Consequently the Dirac masses converge against every continuous analytic test, not just radial tests.

Use M=pr⁡1∗O(∞)M=\operatorname{pr}_1^*\mathcal O(\infty) with its standard model metric and its global section s=T1s=T_1 relative to the frame 11 on the finite chart. On that chart ∥s(x)∥h=∣T1(x)∣max⁡(1,∣T1(x)∣).\|s(x)\|_h=\frac{|T_1(x)|}{\max(1,|T_1(x)|)}. This extends as a regular section nonzero at infinity, with zero divisor {T1=0}\{T_1=0\}. At ξj\xi_j the norm is ∣π∣j|\pi|^j, so the integral is jλj\lambda. At oo it is zero and its negative logarithm is infinite. For fixed RR, the tails are (jλ−R)+(j\lambda-R)_+ and are unbounded in jj. The curvature metrics defining μj\mu_j are moving; their uniform convergence is not claimed. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002851.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record