Closed

The interchange defect

Lemma. (The interchange defect). Let i≠ji\ne j, let JJ index the other r−1r-1 entries, and put Ri=HHiZ(j,J)+VZ(i;j,J),Rj=HHjZ(i,J)+VZ(j;i,J).R_i=H_{\mathcal H_iZ}(j,J)+\mathcal V_Z(i;j,J),\qquad R_j=H_{\mathcal H_jZ}(i,J)+\mathcal V_Z(j;i,J). Under the preceding explicit operation and lower-dimensional recursion hypotheses, their difference is exactly Ri−Rj=HHjHiZ−HiHjZ(J)+VHiZ(j;J)−VHjZ(i;J)+VZ(i;j,J)−VZ(j;i,J).\begin{align} R_i-R_j={}&H_{\mathcal H_j\mathcal H_iZ-\mathcal H_i\mathcal H_jZ}(J)\\ &+\mathcal V_{\mathcal H_iZ}(j;J)-\mathcal V_{\mathcal H_jZ}(i;J)\\ &+\mathcal V_Z(i;j,J)-\mathcal V_Z(j;i,J). \end{align} Consequently equality of the horizontal codimension-two cycles and the vertical interchange identity VHiZ(j;J)+VZ(i;j,J)=VHjZ(i;J)+VZ(j;i,J)\begin{equation} \mathcal V_{\mathcal H_iZ}(j;J)+\mathcal V_Z(i;j,J) =\mathcal V_{\mathcal H_jZ}(i;J)+\mathcal V_Z(j;i,J) \end{equation} are sufficient for equality of the two first choices. Without that horizontal-cycle equality, vanishing of the full right side of (I.0.8) is the exact necessary and sufficient condition. If the appropriate identities hold at every node, and the curve/point base cases are compatible, the recursion is independent of its order.

Proof

Proof. Apply the lower-dimensional recursion to HHiZ(j,J)H_{\mathcal H_iZ}(j,J) and to HHjZ(i,J)H_{\mathcal H_jZ}(i,J). Their horizontal terms are respectively HHjHiZ(J)H_{\mathcal H_j\mathcal H_iZ}(J) and HHiHjZ(J)H_{\mathcal H_i\mathcal H_jZ}(J), and their vertical terms are the first two vertical expressions in (I.0.8). Subtract, use cycle linearity, and retain the two original vertical terms. This proves the exact formula and both stated criteria. Induct on dimension for every possible first choice, using the criteria to compare any two first choices and the induction hypothesis for later choices. The separately assumed curve and point cases start this induction. No equality of Chow classes is substituted for a required cycle or functional identity. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002940.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record