Closed

Exact generic criterion for acquiring presentations

Theorem. (Exact generic criterion for acquiring presentations). Let M\mathcal M be a normal model of XX, and let (Li,σi;Zi)(\mathcal L_i,\sigma_i;Z_i) be finitely many Cartier data on it. There exists a normal model M′\mathcal M' and a proper generic-identity map q:M′→Mq:\mathcal M'\to\mathcal M such that every pulled-back datum admits a signed presentation on q−1Ziq^{-1}Z_i if and only if every generic Cartier datum admits a signed presentation on Zi∩XZ_i\cap X. When these equivalent conditions hold, qq can be constructed by finitely many blowups of nonzero coherent ideals, followed by finite normalization. It is an isomorphism off ⋃iZi\bigcup_iZ_i. Each individual presentation retains its own prescribed inverse-image support.

In particular the condition holds if signed presentations are already supplied on another model and pulled back to M\mathcal M. It also holds for every collection of rational Cartier data when XX is locally factorial. No factoriality of M\mathcal M or M′\mathcal M' follows or is required.

Proof

Proof. Necessity follows by restriction to XX: the map is the identity there, and each effective Cartier factor remains effective Cartier because its nonzero section stays nonzero on the integral generic fibre.

For sufficiency first consider one datum, with divisor DD and a generic presentation D∣X=AK−BKD|_X=A_K-B_K on Z∩XZ\cap X. Let I+\mathcal I_+ and I−\mathcal I_- be the ideals of the scheme-theoretic closures of AKA_K and BKB_K in M\mathcal M. They are coherent nonzero ideals, are invertible on XX, and are the unit ideal off ZZ. For example, on Spec⁡A⊂M\operatorname{Spec}A\subset\mathcal M the closure ideal is the contraction of its ideal in A[1/π]A[1/\pi]; Noetherianity gives finite generation and localization gives gluing.

Blow up I+\mathcal I_+ and then the extended ideal I−\mathcal I_-. These blowups are projective and proper by Stacks, Tag 02NS and Stacks, Tag 01WC. Their affine charts for an ideal I=(a1,…,as)I=(a_1,\ldots,a_s) are A[I/aj]⊂Frac⁡(A)A[I/a_j]\subset\operatorname{Frac}(A), for nonzero aja_j. On such a chart the extended ideal is (aj)(a_j), an invertible ideal generated by a non-zero-divisor. Thus the blowups are integral, make the indicated ideals invertible, and are isomorphisms wherever those ideals were invertible. In particular they leave XX and M∖Z\mathcal M\setminus Z unchanged. Write u:Y→Mu:Y\to\mathcal M for the composite, and let A0,B0A_0,B_0 be the effective Cartier divisors of the two extended ideals. Their supports lie in u−1Zu^{-1}Z, and their generic restrictions are AK,BKA_K,B_K.

The Cartier divisor V=u∗D−(A0−B0)V=u^*D-(A_0-B_0) is zero on the generic fibre and off u−1Zu^{-1}Z. As subsheaves of the constant sheaf of rational functions on the integral YY, form the coherent nonzero ideal J=OY(−V)∩OY.\mathcal J=\mathcal O_Y(-V)\cap\mathcal O_Y. Coherence follows locally by clearing one denominator and intersecting two finitely generated modules over a Noetherian ring. It is the unit ideal on XX and off u−1Zu^{-1}Z. Blow up J\mathcal J, with map v:Y′→Yv:Y'\to Y, and write JOY′=OY′(−E)\mathcal J\mathcal O_{Y'}=\mathcal O_{Y'}(-E). The inclusion J⊂OY(−V)\mathcal J\subset\mathcal O_Y(-V) gives a nonzero map between invertible sheaves OY′(−E)⟶OY′(−v∗V).\mathcal O_{Y'}(-E)\longrightarrow\mathcal O_{Y'}(-v^*V). Its section has an effective Cartier divisor FF satisfying E−v∗V=FE-v^*V=F. This can also be checked in a local frame: if OY(−V)=fOY\mathcal O_Y(-V)=f\mathcal O_Y and JOY′=(h)\mathcal J\mathcal O_{Y'}=(h), then h/fh/f is regular and F=div⁡(h/f)F=\operatorname{div}(h/f). Both EE and FF vanish off (uv)−1Z(uv)^{-1}Z. Thus (uv)∗D=(v∗A0+E)−(v∗B0+F)(uv)^*D=(v^*A_0+E)-(v^*B_0+F) is the required signed presentation. This third blowup leaves the generic fibre unchanged because J∣X=OX\mathcal J|_X=\mathcal O_X.

For finitely many data repeat these steps, pulling earlier effective Cartier factors along subsequent dominant maps. Their sections remain nonzero, and their supports remain inside the respective inverse images of ZiZ_i. All stages are integral proper finite-type schemes over RR, with generic fibre XX, and are flat by Stacks, Tag 0539. Normalize the final stage. Its normalization is finite by Theorem C.1.96’s Nagata argument, is the identity over normal XX, and preserves all effective Cartier factors under its dominant pullback. Outside ⋃iZi\bigcup_iZ_i the previous stages were the original normal M\mathcal M, so normalization changes nothing there either. This gives qq and all the asserted support properties.

An existing presentation pulls back to any common integral model, with its actual line and section identities. No factoriality is needed for this step. Finally on a locally factorial integral Noetherian XX, decompose the finite Weil cycle of a Cartier divisor into its positive and negative parts. Local unique factorization makes both parts effective Cartier: their local equations differ by units on overlaps. Their difference is the original Cartier divisor, and their supports lie in its support. This proves the last sufficient condition, independently of any pending intersection claim. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003043.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record