Closed

A support-sensitive counterexample in every dimension

Proposition. (A support-sensitive counterexample in every dimension). Let X=PRd\mathcal X=\mathbf P^d_R, d≥2d\geq2, V=XkV=\mathcal X_k, and take (L,s)=(O(1),πZ0)(\mathcal L,s)=(\mathcal O(1),\pi Z_0). With prescribed support T=VT=V, G(L,s),V[V]=c1(OV(1))∩[V]≠0in CH⁡d−1(V).G_{(\mathcal L,s),V}[V]=c_1(\mathcal O_V(1))\cap[V]\ne0 \quad\text{in }\operatorname{CH}_{d-1}(V). After another d−1d-1 hyperplane operations its degree is one. Thus an operation that discards a component when its restricted section is zero fails the required vertical Chern compatibility.

More strongly, let D=Z(πZ0)D=Z(\pi Z_0), with closed support V∪H0V\cup H_0, where H0={Z0=0}H_0=\{Z_0=0\}. The same nonzero class maps to zero in CH⁡d−1(D)\operatorname{CH}_{d-1}(D). Knowing only its image in the ambient zero scheme therefore does not determine the operation on the original support VV.

Proof

Proof. The restricted section is identically zero on VV, so the definition gives the first Chern class. Its representative V∩H0V\cap H_0 followed by d−1d-1 other coordinate hyperplanes is one rational point with local quotient length one. Successive coordinate quotients compute its degree as one, proving nonvanishing on VV. Inside DD, the horizontal integral H0≃PRd−1H_0\simeq\mathbf P^{d-1}_R is an allowed scheme for rational equivalence. Its rational function π\pi has divisor V∩H0V\cap H_0 with coefficient one. The image of our class is consequently zero in CH⁡d−1(D)\operatorname{CH}_{d-1}(D). Inside VV that horizontal rational-equivalence relation is unavailable. This is why the operation must be constructed on each TT, not recovered from an ambient image after the first intersection. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003125.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record