Closed

Two precise failures of weaker analytic premises

Proposition. (Two precise failures of weaker analytic premises). The following elementary examples are topology and convergence obstructions, not asserted native analytic spaces.

First, let C={0}∪{1/k:k≥1}C=\{0\}\cup\{1/k:k\geq1\} and let ENE_N be the functions on CC constant on {0}∪{1/k:k>N}\{0\}\cup\{1/k:k>N\}. Put E=⋃NENE=\bigcup_NE_N with its final locally convex topology from the finite-dimensional supremum-norm spaces ENE_N. Then F(f)=∑k≥1(f(1/k)−f(0))F(f)=\sum_{k\geq1}(f(1/k)-f(0)) is well-defined and has order-zero bound ∣F(f)∣≤2N∥f∥C|F(f)|\leq2N\|f\|_C on ENE_N, but it has no finite signed Radon representation on CC. Indeed there are fN∈ENf_N\in E_N with 0≤fN≤10\leq f_N\leq1 and F(fN)=NF(f_N)=N.

Second, on [0,1][0,1] the signed measures σm=m(δ1/m2−δ0)\sigma_m=m(\delta_{1/m^2}-\delta_0) satisfy ∣σm(h)∣≤∥h′∥∞/m(h∈C1([0,1])),∣σm∣([0,1])=2m,|\sigma_m(h)|\leq\|h'\|_\infty/m \quad(h\in C^1([0,1])),\qquad |\sigma_m|([0,1])=2m, while σm(x)=1\sigma_m(\sqrt{x})=1. Thus convergence to zero against all smooth tests does not imply convergence against a fixed continuous multiplier without a suitable variation bound.

Proof

Proof. Every f∈ENf\in E_N makes only its first NN summands nonzero, proving the first bound and continuity by finality. Let fNf_N be one on the first NN nonzero points and zero on the remaining points and on zero. This is a continuous member of ENE_N and gives F(fN)=NF(f_N)=N. A finite signed representing measure ν\nu would instead give ∣F(fN)∣≤∣ν∣(C)|F(f_N)|\leq|\nu|(C) for every NN, a contradiction. The space EE is uniformly dense in C(C)C(C), by uniform continuity at zero, so lack of smooth-density analogues is not the issue.

For the second assertion, the fundamental theorem gives ∣h(1/m2)−h(0)∣≤∥h′∥∞/m2|h(1/m^2)-h(0)|\leq\|h'\|_\infty/m^2. The two atoms are distinct with opposite masses of size mm, so their total variation is 2m2m. Finally m1/m2=1m\sqrt{1/m^2}=1. All claimed inequalities and failures follow directly. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003198.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record