Closed

Reduction loses a factor

Example. (Reduction loses a factor). Let k=Fpk=\mathbf F_p, K=k((t))K=k((t)) and L=k((u))L=k((u)) with up=tu^p=t. Keep ∣t∣=c|t|=c with 0<c<10<c<1, so ∣u∣=c1/p|u|=c^{1/p}. Take R=k[[t]]R=k[[t]], R′=k[[u]]R'=k[[u]], and regard X=Pk[[v]]d\mathcal X=\mathbf P^d_{k[[v]]} as an RR-model via t=vpt=v^p, where d≥2d\geq2. Grouping power-series exponents modulo pp identifies k[[v]]k[[v]] with the free RR-module on 1,v,…,vp−11,v,\ldots,v^{p-1}. Thus X\mathcal X is integral, proper and flat over RR, and its generic fibre is normal integral over KK.

Take exponent one throughout, (L0,σ0)=(O,v)(\mathcal L_0,\sigma_0)=(\mathcal O,v) with vertical support, and use dd coordinate hyperplane sections of O(1)\mathcal O(1) for the other factors. Their intersection with div⁡(v)\operatorname{div}(v) is one kk-point of length one, so JR(X)=λKJ_R(\mathcal X)=\lambda_K. The full base change is Y=PR′[v]/(vp−up)d≃PR′[ϵ]/(ϵp)d,v=u+ϵ.\mathcal Y=\mathbf P^d_{R'[v]/(v^p-u^p)} \simeq\mathbf P^d_{R'[\epsilon]/(\epsilon^p)},\qquad v=u+\epsilon . It has generic length pp along its one reduced component. After the hyperplane operations the quotient by vv is R′/(up)R'/(u^p), of length pp; multiplication by vv is injective because vp=upv^p=u^p and the algebra is R′R'-free. Equivalently, compute on the full fundamental cycle p[PR′d]p[\mathbf P^d_{R'}]. Thus deg⁡k′βY=p,JR′(Y)=(λK/p)p=λK.\deg_{k'}\beta_{\mathcal Y}=p,\qquad J_{R'}(\mathcal Y)=(\lambda_K/p)p=\lambda_K. Replacing Y\mathcal Y by its reduction before forming its fundamental cycle gives degree one and the incorrect value λK/p\lambda_K/p. Its reduction is a different scheme, not a permissible deletion of generic multiplicity.

Selected proof in the fixed edition

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003210.

Fixed-edition record