Theorem 20.11.2 · First variation and the difference formula
Theorem 20.11.2. (First variation and the difference formula). For admitted u,v put h=u−v and ut=v+th, 0≤t≤1. Then dtdEθ(ut)Eθ(u)−Eθ(v)=∫Xhθutn,=n+11j=0∑n∫Xhθuj∧θvn−j.
Argument in the manuscript
Proof. All expressions along this segment are polynomials in t, by multilinearity of the continuous mixed products. Differentiation is therefore algebraic. Put Θ=θut. Differentiating the jth summand of the energy gives ∫XhΘjθn−j+j∫Xutd′d′′h∧Θj−1θn−j. By Proposition 20.10.2, the second integral equals j∫Xh(Θ−θ)Θj−1θn−j. Thus the summand becomes (j+1)∫XhΘjθn−j−j∫XhΘj−1θn−j+1. Summing over j cancels consecutive terms and leaves (n+1)∫XhΘn. This proves the derivative formula. Integrate from zero to one and expand θut=(1−t)θv+tθu. The coefficient of each mixed term is (jn)∫01tj(1−t)n−jdt=n+11. The integral identity follows by j integrations by parts, or by the factorial formula j!(n−j)!/(n+1)!. This proves the difference formula. ◻