B · Recovered native algebraization source

3 NAG Tags

B.1 Polarization and algebraization of a supplied formal curve

Let KK be a complete nontrivially valued field with a real-valued rank-one valuation vv. Put O=K∘O=K^\circ, m=K∘∘\mathfrak m=K^{\circ\circ}, and k=O/mk=O/\mathfrak m, and fix 0≠π∈m0\ne\pi\in\mathfrak m. The value group need not be discrete. All schemes and invertible sheaves below are ordinary algebraic schemes and sheaves until a formal completion is explicitly taken.

A proper flat finitely presented curve tower over O/πnO/\pi^n admits a compatible polarization, even when only its residue curve is initially polarized. The reason is topological: the residue curve and all levels of the tower have the same Noetherian underlying space of dimension at most one. We first record the precise lifting statement that uses this fact. The algebraization step will then be an application of the non-Noetherian theorem Stacks Tag 0D4T.

Lifting across a nil thickening

Lemma B.1.1. NAG-002909 (Picard lifting in topological dimension at most one). Let i:Z↪Yi:Z\hookrightarrow Y be a closed immersion of schemes inducing a homeomorphism of underlying spaces. Suppose that this common space is Noetherian and has dimension at most one. Then i∗:Pic⁡(Y)⟶Pic⁡(Z)i^*:\operatorname{Pic}(Y) \longrightarrow\operatorname{Pic}(Z) is surjective. If LZ\mathcal L_Z is ample, every invertible sheaf on YY whose restriction is isomorphic to LZ\mathcal L_Z is ample. No finite-generation or nilpotence bound on the ideal of ZZ is required.

Proof. Identify the two underlying spaces, and put J=ker⁡(OY→i∗OZ)\mathcal J=\ker(\mathcal O_Y\to i_*\mathcal O_Z). On an affine open of YY, every prime contains the ideal defining ZZ, so that ideal is nil. In particular its stalk ideals are nil. An element of a ring whose image is a unit modulo a nil ideal is a unit: a lift of its inverse has product 1+j1+j with jj nilpotent, and 1+j1+j has a finite geometric-series inverse. Applied to stalks, this gives an exact sequence of abelian sheaves on the common space, 1⟶1+J⟶OY×⟶i∗OZ×⟶1.1\longrightarrow 1+\mathcal J \longrightarrow\mathcal O_Y^\times \longrightarrow i_*\mathcal O_Z^\times \longrightarrow1. Here 1+J1+\mathcal J has its multiplicative group law. There is no identification with the additive sheaf J\mathcal J in this argument.

Grothendieck vanishing for a Noetherian topological space of dimension at most one, Stacks Tag 02UZ, applies to every abelian sheaf. Hence H2(Y,1+J)=0H^2(Y,1+\mathcal J)=0. The long exact cohomology sequence of Stacks Tag 01DZ and the identification of the Picard group with H1(O×)H^1(\mathcal O^\times), Stacks Tag 09NU, show that i∗i^* is surjective. Finally, Stacks Tag 09MW identifies ampleness of an invertible sheaf with ampleness of its restriction along any closed immersion inducing a homeomorphism. This proves the last assertion without requiring a nilpotence bound on J\mathcal J. ◻

A compatible ample bundle on the tower

Proposition B.1.2. NAG-002910 (Polarization of a supplied curve tower). For n≥1n\geq1, put Rn=O/πnOR_n=O/\pi^n O and Sn=Spec⁡RnS_n=\operatorname{Spec}R_n. Suppose given schemes Xn→SnX_n\to S_n, proper, flat, and of finite presentation, together with transition morphisms in:Xn↪Xn+1i_n:X_n\hookrightarrow X_{n+1} for which the squares over Sn↪Sn+1S_n\hookrightarrow S_{n+1} are cartesian. Suppose that C=X1×R1kC=X_1\times_{R_1}k has dimension at most one. Then CC has an ample invertible sheaf. For any prescribed ample invertible sheaf LC\mathcal L_C on CC, there exist ample invertible sheaves Ln\mathcal L_n on XnX_n, an isomorphism L1∣C≃LC\mathcal L_1|_C\simeq\mathcal L_C, and isomorphisms φn:in∗Ln+1→ ∼ Ln(n≥1).\varphi_n:i_n^*\mathcal L_{n+1} \xrightarrow{\ \sim\ }\mathcal L_n \qquad(n\geq1).

Proof. The scheme CC is proper and of finite type over kk, hence is separated and has a Noetherian underlying space. A separated finite-type scheme over a field of dimension at most one has an ample invertible sheaf, by Stacks Tag 0A25 and its proof.

For a∈ma\in\mathfrak m, the rank-one valuation gives an integer N≥1N\geq1 with Nv(a)≥v(π)Nv(a)\geq v(\pi), unless a=0a=0, when no choice is needed. Thus aN∈πOa^N\in\pi O, and m/πO\mathfrak m/\pi O is a nil ideal of R1R_1. Its extension to any R1R_1-algebra is still nil: each element is a finite sum of multiples of nilpotent elements in a commutative ring. Consequently the closed immersion C↪X1C\hookrightarrow X_1 induces a homeomorphism. This is the same radical comparison used in the established formal-fibre argument 3.17.2; it does not assert that the rings OX1\mathcal O_{X_1} are Noetherian.

The underlying space of X1X_1 is therefore Noetherian of dimension at most one. Lemma B.1.1 lifts the prescribed LC\mathcal L_C to an ample invertible sheaf L1\mathcal L_1. For each n≥1n\geq1, the kernel of Rn+1→RnR_{n+1}\to R_n is square-zero, since 2n≥n+12n\geq n+1. The cartesian square shows that ini_n is a square-zero closed immersion and a homeomorphism. All XnX_n thus have the same underlying space as CC.

Inductively apply Lemma B.1.1 to ini_n, choosing Ln+1\mathcal L_{n+1} and an isomorphism φn\varphi_n as stated. The lemma also gives ampleness at each step. Composites of the chosen φn\varphi_n supply the compatibilities between any two levels of the tower. The construction proves existence and makes no assertion of uniqueness of these choices. ◻

Algebraization and the nodal conclusion

Theorem B.1.3. NAG-002911 (Algebraization over the complete rank-one valuation ring). Under the hypotheses of Proposition B.1.2, there exist a projective, flat, finitely presented OO-scheme YY, an ample invertible sheaf L\mathcal L on YY, and compatible isomorphisms Y×ORn≃Xn,L∣Xn≃Ln(n≥1),Y\times_O R_n\simeq X_n,\qquad \mathcal L|_{X_n}\simeq\mathcal L_n\quad(n\geq1), where (Ln,φn)(\mathcal L_n,\varphi_n) can be any compatible system provided by that proposition. In particular L∣C\mathcal L|_C is the prescribed LC\mathcal L_C.

If C/kC/k is at-worst-nodal of pure dimension one, then Y/OY/O is at-worst-nodal of relative dimension one. No splitting condition on its nodes or branches is imposed.

If the tower is the system of quotients of a supplied π\pi-adic formal OO-scheme X\mathfrak X, and X\mathfrak X is recovered from these quotients with their transition maps, then the compatible isomorphisms give Y^π≃X.\widehat Y_\pi\simeq\mathfrak X. This formal scheme is admissible, and its generic fibre satisfies Xη≃(YK)an\mathfrak X_\eta\simeq(Y_K)^{\mathrm{an}}.

Proof. We first check the base ring in the algebraization theorem. Since v(π)>0v(\pi)>0, the sequence nv(π)nv(\pi) tends to infinity. The ideals πnO\pi^nO therefore define the valuation topology on OO. The ring OO is closed in the complete field KK, so it is complete for this topology. More explicitly, representatives of a compatible system of classes modulo πn\pi^n form a Cauchy sequence in OO. Its limit has the prescribed residues, since every πnO\pi^nO is closed. Also ⋂nπnO=0\bigcap_n\pi^nO=0. Hence O≃lim←⁡nRn.O\simeq\varprojlim_n R_n. Each transition Rn+1→RnR_{n+1}\to R_n is surjective with square-zero kernel. The cartesian tower, its proper flat finitely presented structure morphisms, and the compatible invertible sheaves with L1\mathcal L_1 ample now satisfy every hypothesis of Stacks Tag 0D4T. That theorem supplies YY, L\mathcal L, and all the displayed compatible isomorphisms, with Y/OY/O proper, flat, and finitely presented and L\mathcal L ample on YY. The affine base Spec⁡O\operatorname{Spec}O has an ample invertible sheaf. Therefore properness together with the ample sheaf L\mathcal L implies projectivity by Stacks Tag 0B45, the equivalence of conditions (5) and (1).

Suppose next that C/kC/k is at-worst-nodal of pure dimension one. For the flat finitely presented morphism Y→Spec⁡OY\to\operatorname{Spec}O, Stacks Tag 0DSC gives a maximal open U⊆YU\subseteq Y on which it is at-worst-nodal of relative dimension one; this open commutes with arbitrary base change. Since Yk≃CY_k\simeq C, it follows that Yk⊆UY_k\subseteq U. If the closed complement Y∖UY\setminus U were nonempty, its image in Spec⁡O\operatorname{Spec}O would be nonempty and closed, by properness. Every nonempty closed subset of the spectrum of a local ring contains its closed point. This would force Y∖UY\setminus U to meet YkY_k, a contradiction. Thus U=YU=Y.

Finally, the compatible isomorphisms at every level identify both the common underlying spaces and their inverse systems of structure sheaves. Taking the inverse limit gives the stated isomorphism of π\pi-adic formal schemes. The established projective-completion result 4.13.2 applies to the projective, flat, finitely presented scheme YY. It says that Y^π\widehat Y_\pi is admissible and that its generic fibre is (YK)an(Y_K)^{\mathrm{an}}. Transporting this identification through the formal isomorphism, using the functoriality in 3.17.2, gives the assertion for X\mathfrak X. ◻

The formal interface and the nondiscrete boundary

The input is the supplied cartesian tower, including properness, flatness, and finite presentation at every level. For a formal model, these hypotheses must be checked for its actual quotients by πn\pi^n. For example, on a flat formal affine chart with a finite restricted-power-series presentation B=O⟨T1,…,Tr⟩/(f1,…,fs),B=O\langle T_1,\ldots,T_r\rangle/(f_1,\ldots,f_s), reduction modulo πn\pi^n has the finite presentation Rn[T1,…,Tr]/(fˉ1,…,fˉs)R_n[T_1,\ldots,T_r]/(\bar f_1,\ldots,\bar f_s); restricted series become polynomials at this level. Flatness descends by base change. Properness of the reductions is the separate global input. Reconstruction from the quotient sheaves is the stated completeness condition on the formal model.

The distinction between kk and O/πOO/\pi O cannot be dropped. If the value group is nondiscrete, then m2=m\mathfrak m^2=\mathfrak m: for a∈m∖{0}a\in\mathfrak m\setminus\{0\} choose b∈Kb\in K with 0<v(b)<v(a)0<v(b)<v(a) and write a=b(a/b)a=b(a/b). Both factors lie in m\mathfrak m. It follows that lim←⁡nO/mn=k,\varprojlim_n O/\mathfrak m^n=k, which does not recover OO. Moreover m/πO\mathfrak m/\pi O is nonzero, nil, and idempotent, hence is not nilpotent. Its nonzero elements exist because one can choose a positive value less than v(π)v(\pi). Lemma B.1.1 handles this first thickening without replacing it by finitely many square-zero steps.

The theorem algebraizes the specified tower and preserves its residue nodes. It does not construct a tower from an arbitrary analytic curve, choose a polarization canonically, or algebraize a supplied formal group action. Those are separate assertions.