NAG-002446 · Accepted whole

A potential smooth model with an original-field obstruction

4 Analytic curves and skeleta

Open in the English reader · PDF page 826

Statement · exact TeX
\begin{theorem}[A potential smooth model with an original-field obstruction]
\label{v038:f5:cubicramificationobstruction}
Assume $\operatorname{char}k\notin\{2,3\}$, and choose
$a\in K$ with $0<|a|<1$. Let $C_a$ be the projective curve
\[
                       y^2z=x^3+a z^3.
\]
It is smooth and geometrically connected. If
\[
          |a|^{1/2}\notin|K^\times|
                 \quad\text{or}\quad
          |a|^{1/3}\notin|K^\times|,
\]
then $C_a$ has no semistable algebraic model over the
original valuation ring $O$.

Nevertheless, if $b\in\Omega$ satisfies $b^6=a$ and
$L=K(b)$, the curve has the smooth projective model
\[
                \mathcal E/L^\circ:\quad Y^2Z=X^3+Z^3,
                \qquad
                [x:y:z]=[b^2X:b^3Y:Z].
\]
The unique component vertex of
$\mathcal E_{\Omega^\circ}$ is fixed by every isometric
$K$-automorphism of $\Omega$.
In particular, for $K=\mathbf Q_p$, $p\geq5$, with the
specified absolute value $|p|=p^{-1}$, the choice $a=p$
gives the stated nonexistence over $\mathbf Z_p$.
\end{theorem}
Full selected proof · exact TeX
\begin{proof}
We first verify the actual model and its special curve.
The integers $2$ and $3$ are units in $O$, and hence in
$L^\circ$. The two affine charts $Z\ne0$ and $Y\ne0$
cover $\mathcal E$: the equation rules out a projective
point with $Y=Z=0$. Their coordinate rings are
\[
 \begin{gathered}
 L^\circ[X,Y]/(Y^2-X^3-1),\\
 L^\circ[u,v]/(v-u^3-v^3).
 \end{gathered}
\]
Each is free over the polynomial algebra in the first
variable, since its equation is monic, up to a unit, in
the second. They are therefore flat over $L^\circ$.
They have finite algebra presentations; the projective
closed embedding makes the resulting morphism separated
and quasi-compact, so it is finitely presented.

On the first chart, $Y^2-X^3=1$ makes $D(X)$ and $D(Y)$
a cover; the corresponding partial derivatives
$-3X^2$ and $2Y$ are units. On the second chart, a point
with $v\ne0$ belongs to the first chart, whereas a point
with $v=0$ has $1-3v^2$ invertible. These are actual
standard smooth presentations by
\cite[Tag 01V9(6)]{StacksAlg}. Thus $\mathcal E/L^\circ$
is smooth of relative dimension one.

Over any extension field of $\widetilde L$, the polynomial
$X^3+1$ is not a square in the rational function field
in $X$: its order at infinity is $-3$, whereas the order
of a square is even. Therefore $Y^2-X^3-1$ is irreducible.
Its quotient ring injects into the corresponding quadratic
field over that rational function field, by its monic
degree-two basis, so the affine chart is integral.
The only point of its projective complement is
$[0:1:0]$. Every fibre is smooth of relative dimension
one; in particular this point is on a one-dimensional
component and cannot be an additional component by itself.
The affine chart is consequently dense, and the fibre
is connected. It is geometrically reduced and regular
by \cite[Tag 056T]{StacksAlg}. This verifies the exact
semistable-model conditions, including geometric
connectedness, over $L^\circ$.

The same calculation with $a\ne0$ over any extension of
$K$ proves that $C_a$ is smooth and geometrically
connected: the affine chart has equation
$y^2=x^3+a$, with partial derivatives $2y$ and $-3x^2$,
which cannot both vanish on it; the unique point at
infinity has a unit partial derivative in the chart
$y\ne0$. Its affine polynomial is irreducible by the
same odd-order calculation.
The root $b$ exists in the chosen algebraically closed
$\Omega$. The extension $L/K$ has its actual degree
$[K(b):K]\leq6$ and is complete with the extending
absolute value by Lemma~\ref{fnd:finiteextensionnorms}.
The displayed coordinate change identifies the generic
fibre of $\mathcal E$ with $C_{a,L}$, and
$|b|=|a|^{1/6}$ for this unchanged extending value.

Write $E$ for the special curve after extension to
$\overline k$. Its function field is not rational.
Here is a direct verification. On the affine chart
the differential
\[
                              \omega=\frac{dX}{2Y}
\]
extends across a zero of $Y$ as $dY/(3X^2)$, since
$2Y\,dY=3X^2\,dX$ and $X\ne0$ there. Near infinity
put $u=X/Y$ and $v=Z/Y$, so $v=u^3+v^3$.
The affine coordinates are $u/v$ and $1/v$; differentiating
the equation gives
\[
 (1-3v^2)\,dv=3u^2\,du,\qquad
 \omega=\frac{v\,du-u\,dv}{2v}
                          =-\frac{du}{1-3v^2}.
\]
This is regular at infinity. The differential is nonzero:
on the affine function field the derivation
$\delta(X)=2Y$, $\delta(Y)=3X^2$ respects the equation
and evaluates $\omega$ to $1$.

If $\overline k(E)$ were $\overline k(t)$,
\cite[Tag 0BY1]{StacksAlg}, applied to the smooth
projective curve $E$ and $\mathbf P^1_{\overline k}$,
would identify these curves. But a regular differential
on $\mathbf P^1$ has the form $f(t)\,dt$ on its affine
line, with $f\in\overline k[t]$; at $s=t^{-1}$ it is
$-f(s^{-1})s^{-2}\,ds$, which is regular at $s=0$
only when $f=0$. The nonzero $\omega$ is a contradiction.

Complete $\mathcal E_{\Omega^\circ}$ along any fixed
$0\ne\pi\in K^{\circ\circ}$.
Theorem~\ref{cand:projectiveformalcompletion} identifies
its actual analytic generic fibre with $C_{a,\Omega}^{\an}$.
Proposition~\ref{cand:reducedmodelcomponentpoints} supplies
the unique component vertex $w$ over the generic point
of $E$. Put $v=p(w)$.
The reduction identification in
Proposition~\ref{cand:componentvaluedresiduefield}
shows that the affine functions $X$ and $Y$ have
norm one at $w$, since both have nonzero residues at
the generic point of $E$. Hence the original rational
functions $x/z$ and $y/z$ satisfy
\[
             |(x/z)(v)|=|a|^{1/3},\qquad
             |(y/z)(v)|=|a|^{1/2}.
\]
They are nonzero elements of $\mathcal H(v)$, so either
failure in the hypothesis makes its value group strictly
larger than $|K^\times|$.
Proposition~\ref{v038:f5:essentialcomponentobstruction}
now rules out every original-field semistable model.

Finally, let $\sigma$ be an isometric $K$-automorphism
of $\Omega$. Then $\sigma(b)=\zeta b$ with
$\zeta^6=1$, and $|\zeta|=1$.
The canonical semilinear action on $C_{a,\Omega}$
transforms the displayed integral coordinates by
\[
                    X\longmapsto\zeta^{-2}X,
                    \qquad Y\longmapsto\zeta^{-3}Y,
                    \qquad Z\longmapsto Z.
\]
These substitutions and their inverses preserve the
equation over $\Omega^\circ$, so give an actual
semilinear automorphism of the smooth model. Its unique
special component, and thus its component vertex $w$,
is preserved. For $K=\mathbf Q_p$ and $a=p$, the two
displayed values are $p^{-1/3}$ and $p^{-1/2}$, neither
of which lies in $|\mathbf Q_p^\times|=p^{\mathbf Z}$.
Throughout, the absolute value was extended and never
rescaled.
\end{proof}
Typeset reader excerpt
Typeset mathematical passage from PDF page 826
PDF page 826 · excerpt continues in the reader

Typed proof inputs

Reader cross-references

Proof map

Verified map inputs · NAG-002446

AND · joint registered proof inputs

  • NAG-001450 · Finite-dimensional norms and finite field extensions · accepted whole Exact source windows 158–172, 228–246
    • The same two-chart argument with a nonzero parameter gives the original smooth geometrically connected curve. Its finite sixth-root extension has the specified unique complete norm, and the displayed coordinate substitution gives the potential good model.
    • The sixth-root twist acts by the displayed unit coordinate substitutions on the actual model and fixes its sole geometric component and its vertex. The Qp example uses the original cyclic value group.
  • NAG-002036 · The analytic point of a residual component · accepted whole Exact source windows 205–226, 228–246
    • Complete the actual projective model to obtain its generic analytic fibre and unique component vertex. Its integral coordinates have unit norm by their actual nonzero residual values. The original coordinates then give the two exact powers of the extended absolute value. Apply the nonrational-component obstruction to the original-field value group.
    • The sixth-root twist acts by the displayed unit coordinate substitutions on the actual model and fixes its sole geometric component and its vertex. The Qp example uses the original cyclic value group.
  • NAG-002038 · Completion of a projective model · accepted whole Exact source window 205–226
    • Complete the actual projective model to obtain its generic analytic fibre and unique component vertex. Its integral coordinates have unit norm by their actual nonzero residual values. The original coordinates then give the two exact powers of the extended absolute value. Apply the nonrational-component obstruction to the original-field value group.
  • NAG-002070 · The valued field of a component point · accepted whole Exact source window 205–226
    • Complete the actual projective model to obtain its generic analytic fibre and unique component vertex. Its integral coordinates have unit norm by their actual nonzero residual values. The original coordinates then give the two exact powers of the extended absolute value. Apply the nonrational-component obstruction to the original-field value group.
  • NAG-002445 · A nonrational component cannot disappear · accepted whole Exact source window 205–226
    • Complete the actual projective model to obtain its generic analytic fibre and unique component vertex. Its integral coordinates have unit norm by their actual nonzero residual values. The original coordinates then give the two exact powers of the extended absolute value. Apply the nonrational-component obstruction to the original-field value group.