NAG-002445 · Accepted whole

A nonrational component cannot disappear

4 Analytic curves and skeleta

Open in the English reader · PDF page 825

Statement · exact TeX
\begin{proposition}[A nonrational component cannot disappear]
\label{v038:f5:essentialcomponentobstruction}
Let $C/K$ be a smooth projective geometrically connected curve.
Suppose $\mathcal Y/\Omega^\circ$ is a semistable algebraic
model of $C_\Omega$, and let $w$ be the component vertex of
a special component $E$ whose function field
$\overline k(E)$ is not rational.
Then every semistable algebraic model $\mathcal X/O$ of $C$
satisfies
\[
             w\in V(\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ}),
                  \qquad p(w)\in V(\mathcal X).
\]
Consequently, if $C$ has such an original-field model, the
point $v=p(w)$ must satisfy
\[
 \begin{aligned}
   |\mathcal H(v)^\times|&=|K^\times|,\\
   \widetilde{\mathcal H(v)}/k
       &\text{ is separably generated of transcendence degree one}.
 \end{aligned}
\]
Failure of either condition at $v$ rules out every original-field
semistable algebraic model, including every such marked model.
\end{proposition}
Full selected proof · exact TeX
\begin{proof}
Assume $\mathcal X$ exists. Its coefficient extension
$\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ}$ is a semistable algebraic model
of the same curve as $\mathcal Y$, by
Lemma~\ref{cand:algebraicmodelscalar} and preservation
of the nodal relative-curve condition under base change,
\cite[Tag 0C5B]{StacksAlg}.
Apply Theorem~\ref{v037:f5:commondomination} over the complete
field $\Omega$, with empty marking. It supplies an actual
semistable model $\mathcal T/\Omega^\circ$ and
generic-identity morphisms
\[
  \mathcal T\longrightarrow\mathcal Y,
             \qquad
  \mathcal T\longrightarrow\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ}.
\]
The first morphism and
Proposition~\ref{v036:f5:forestnecessity} show that
$w\in V(\mathcal T)$. Let $F$ be its special component
in $\mathcal T$. The actual residue-field identifications
of Proposition~\ref{v036:f5:vertexarithmetic}, applied
over $\Omega$, give
\[
       \overline k(F)=\widetilde{\mathcal H(w)}
                                  =\overline k(E).
\]
If $w$ were absent from $V(\mathcal X_{\Omega^\circ})$,
the necessity of the geometric forest condition for the
second morphism would make $F$ a smooth
$\mathbf P^1_{\overline k}$. Its function field would be
rational, contrary to the displayed equality. Hence $w$
is a vertex of the coefficient extension of $\mathcal X$.
The geometric vertex identification in
Proposition~\ref{v036:f5:vertexarithmetic} projects it to
the original vertex $v=p(w)$ and gives the two asserted
arithmetic conditions. Forgetting a marking retains a
semistable algebraic model, so the same obstruction applies
to every prescribed marking.
\end{proof}
Typeset reader excerpt
Typeset mathematical passage from PDF page 825
PDF page 825

Typed proof inputs

Reader cross-references

Proof map

Verified map inputs · NAG-002445

AND · joint registered proof inputs

  • NAG-002094 · Scalar extension of algebraic formal models · accepted whole Exact source window 44–68
    • Base change a hypothetical model to the same comparison field and obtain actual common domination with empty marking. Marked forest necessity gives vertex inclusion for the first map. The complete residual field identifies the actual function field at the same retained geometric vertex.
  • NAG-002271 · The arithmetic of a model vertex · accepted whole Exact source windows 44–68, 69–80
    • Base change a hypothetical model to the same comparison field and obtain actual common domination with empty marking. Marked forest necessity gives vertex inclusion for the first map. The complete residual field identifies the actual function field at the same retained geometric vertex.
    • If the vertex disappeared under the second map, the exact removed-tree condition would make that geometric component a smooth projective line. This contradicts its residual function field. Project the retained geometric vertex to the original component and use its two arithmetic invariants. Forgetting an actual marking preserves the underlying model.
  • NAG-002275 · Necessity of the geometric marked forest condition · accepted whole Exact source windows 44–68, 69–80
    • Base change a hypothetical model to the same comparison field and obtain actual common domination with empty marking. Marked forest necessity gives vertex inclusion for the first map. The complete residual field identifies the actual function field at the same retained geometric vertex.
    • If the vertex disappeared under the second map, the exact removed-tree condition would make that geometric component a smooth projective line. This contradicts its residual function field. Project the retained geometric vertex to the original component and use its two arithmetic invariants. Forgetting an actual marking preserves the underlying model.
  • NAG-002318 · Common original-field semistable models · accepted whole Exact source window 44–68
    • Base change a hypothetical model to the same comparison field and obtain actual common domination with empty marking. Marked forest necessity gives vertex inclusion for the first map. The complete residual field identifies the actual function field at the same retained geometric vertex.