Proposition 4.36.3. (The Legendre model when two is a unit). Let be complete of characteristic zero with nontrivial absolute value and residue characteristic different from two. Every pointed smooth projective genus-one curve over has, after a finite extension, a projective nodal model over the resulting valuation ring. Its special fibre is either smooth or an irreducible cubic with one ordinary double point.
Proof
Proof. Use Lemma 4.36.1 and split its cubic as after a finite extension. The roots are distinct. Choose the pair labelled to have maximal pairwise distance. After scaling by and adjoining a square root for the corresponding -scaling, the equation becomes At least one of the last two norms is one. If both are one, the three residual roots are distinct. Since two is a unit, the affine partial derivatives then have no common zero on the cubic. The point at infinity is smooth as in Lemma 4.36.2.
If , the residual equation is , with its sole singular point at the origin. There the derivative ideal is . The local hypersurface ring has depth one: is a nonzerodivisor since the equation is not divisible by , and its dimension is one. Its first differential Fitting ideal is the derivative ideal just computed. Its residue field is the base field, so [StacksAlg] (Tag 0C4D(5)) proves that this point is a node. If , translate ; the same computation uses and derivative . The quadratic terms have two distinct linear factors over a separable extension, because the characteristic is not two. The residual cubic is irreducible over the algebraic closure: in the first case is not a square in , so is irreducible, and the second case is identical with . The integral-family lemma now supplies the required model. ◻