Closed

Formal smooth and nodal tube closures

Proposition 4.39.3. (Formal smooth and nodal tube closures). Let Xs\mathfrak X_s be reduced and pure one-dimensional, and suppose X=XηX=\mathfrak X_\eta is Hausdorff. Let q∈Xs(k)q\in\mathfrak X_s(k) admit a pointed diagram (X,q) ⟵ (U,u) ⟶ (S,o)(\mathfrak X,q)\ \longleftarrow\ (\mathfrak U,u) \ \longrightarrow\ (\mathfrak S,o) of adic, topologically finitely presented, formally étale maps, with U\mathfrak U affine and uu rational over kk. Assume S\mathfrak S is either Spf⁡O⟨T⟩,o=(T‾),orSpf⁡O⟨S,T⟩/(ST−a),o=(S‾,T‾),0<∣a∣<1.\begin{aligned} &\operatorname{Spf}O\langle T\rangle, &&o=(\overline T),\\ \text{or}\quad &\operatorname{Spf}O\langle S,T\rangle/(ST-a), &&o=(\overline S,\overline T),\quad 0<|a|<1. \end{aligned} In the smooth case ]q[]q[ is an open unit disc. Its closure is the disc together with the component point above the unique residual component through qq, and is its one-point compactification. In the nodal case ]q[]q[ is the annulus ∣a∣<∣S∣<1|a|<|S|<1. Its two radial ends attach to the component points of the corresponding two branches through qq. Its closure is obtained by adjoining these ends; the two component points may coincide. Every neighbourhood of an attached endpoint in this closure contains the full corresponding radial tail.

Proof

Proof. Reduction of the displayed Jacobian presentations modulo m\mathfrak m gives ordinary étale maps on special fibres. Proposition 4.39.1, applied to both arrows, identifies their entire selected tubes. On the standard chart, Proposition 3.20.1 computes them as ∣T∣<1|T|<1 and ∣a∣<∣S∣<1|a|<|S|<1, respectively.

First work in the compact Hausdorff generic fibre of U\mathfrak U. Its special fibre is smooth or nodal near uu. Shrinking about uu preserves the tube and permits us to assume it is reduced and pure one-dimensional. In the smooth case exactly one component passes through uu: the completion of the local special-fibre ring is k[[T]]k[[T]] by [StacksAlg] (Tag 0AGX), and the ring injects into this domain by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00MC). In the nodal case Lemma 4.20.2 gives exactly two components through uu, corresponding to T=0T=0 and S=0S=0. Lemma 4.39.2 restricts the boundary to their component points.

The open unit disc is not compact, since ∣T∣|T| has supremum one and never takes that value. Thus its compact closure must add the unique possible boundary point. A compact Hausdorff space obtained from an open locally compact space by adding one point is its one-point compactification. Its endpoint neighbourhoods contain the complements of the closed discs ∣T∣≤r|T|\le r, r<1r<1: every compact subset of the open disc has max⁡∣T∣<1\max|T|<1.

For the nodal chart, write vTv_T for the component point of the branch T=0T=0, and vSv_S for that of S=0S=0. Their reductions give ∣S(vT)∣=1,∣T(vS)∣=1,∣S(vS)∣=∣a∣.|S(v_T)|=1,\qquad |T(v_S)|=1,\qquad |S(v_S)|=|a|. A net of points of the tube with ∣S∣→1|S|\to1 has a cluster point in its compact closure. Continuity of ∣S∣|S| and the boundary inclusion force every cluster point to be vTv_T. It therefore converges to vTv_T. The same argument treats ∣S∣→∣a∣|S|\to|a| and vSv_S. Applying this to Gauss points proves that both endpoints occur. If an open neighbourhood of vTv_T contained no full outer tail, its compact complement would contain a net with ∣S∣→1|S|\to1, a contradiction. The inner tail is treated in the same way. Equivalently, the complement has maximum ∣S∣<1|S|<1 or minimum ∣S∣>∣a∣|S|>|a|.

An étale map of special-fibre curves sends component generic points to component generic points, by the going-down argument in Lemma 4.20.2. All components through qq occur this way: the local map at uu over qq is faithfully flat, and going down, [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HS), lifts each minimal prime below the prime of uu. Functoriality of specialization and uniqueness of component points identify the analytic images of the endpoints. The image of the compact tube closure in Hausdorff XX is closed and contains ]q[]q[. Conversely every point in that image is in ]q[‾\overline{]q[}, by continuity and density of the tube in its closure. The map is an isomorphism on the open tube, and an endpoint cannot map into it because its specialization is generic. Thus the only possible identification is between the two nodal endpoints. The endpoint-tail assertions descend through this compact-to-Hausdorff quotient. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002222, 4.39.3.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record