Closed

Algebraic domination from vertex inclusion

Theorem 4.46.2. (Algebraic domination from vertex inclusion). For two semistable algebraic models X1,X2\mathcal X_1,\mathcal X_2 of CC, there is an OO-morphism f:X1⟶X2f:\mathcal X_1\longrightarrow\mathcal X_2 inducing the identity on CC if and only if V(X2)⊂V(X1)V(\mathcal X_2)\subset V(\mathcal X_1) in CanC^{\mathrm{an}}. When it exists, it is unique and proper, and f∗OX1=OX2f_*\mathcal O_{\mathcal X_1}=\mathcal O_{\mathcal X_2}.

Proof

Proof. A morphism of the indicated models is proper by its closed graph and the properness of the source over OO. Its completion induces the analytic identity, so Lemma 4.40.4 proves the necessary vertex inclusion.

Suppose conversely that the inclusion holds. Form G\mathcal G and its two projections as in Lemma 4.46.1. Both targets are normal and integral by Proposition 4.44.3. We show that p2p_2 is constant on every set-theoretic fibre of p1p_1.

Choose the isometric comparison field Ω\Omega of Lemma 4.45.1, with residue field k‾\overline k. The two base-changed target models are semistable algebraic models over Ω∘\Omega^\circ. Their nodes have the split rational pointed charts of Theorem 4.18.2, since Ω\Omega is algebraically closed. Completing these charts gives the pointedly semistable formal models of Definition 4.39.4. By Corollary 4.39.5, the fibres of their specialization maps are their singleton component vertices and the connected components of the complements of those vertex sets. Proposition 4.45.2 identifies their vertex sets with the entire inverse images of the original vertex sets, so V(X2,Ω∘)⊂V(X1,Ω∘).V(\mathcal X_{2,\Omega^\circ}) \subset V(\mathcal X_{1,\Omega^\circ}).

Consequently sp⁡2\operatorname{sp}_2 is constant on every fibre of sp⁡1\operatorname{sp}_1 on CΩanC_\Omega^{\mathrm{an}}. For a component generic point the latter fibre is a singleton. For a closed point it is a connected component of the complement of the larger vertex set. It avoids the smaller vertex set, and lies in one connected component of its complement, which is one fibre of sp⁡2\operatorname{sp}_2.

Let z1,z2∈Gk‾z_1,z_2\in\mathcal G_{\overline k} have the same (p1)k‾(p_1)_{\overline k}-image. The surjective specialization in Lemma 4.46.1 supplies x1,x2∈CΩanx_1,x_2\in C_\Omega^{\mathrm{an}} with sp⁡G(xj)=zj\operatorname{sp}_{\mathcal G}(x_j)=z_j. Functoriality gives sp⁡1(x1)=sp⁡1(x2)\operatorname{sp}_1(x_1)=\operatorname{sp}_1(x_2). The preceding constancy gives sp⁡2(x1)=sp⁡2(x2)\operatorname{sp}_2(x_1)=\operatorname{sp}_2(x_2), hence (p2)k‾(z1)=(p2)k‾(z2)(p_2)_{\overline k}(z_1)=(p_2)_{\overline k}(z_2).

Here is the descent of this actual fibre relation. A field extension is flat by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HD), since the only ideals of a field are zero and the whole field; its nonzero closed fibre makes it faithfully flat by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HP). If t1,t2∈Gst_1,t_2\in\mathcal G_s have the same p1p_1-image yy, the tensor product κ(t1)⊗κ(y)κ(t2)\kappa(t_1)\otimes_{\kappa(y)}\kappa(t_2) is therefore nonzero. A prime of it, supplied by [StacksAlg] (Tag 00E0(2)), gives a point of Gs×X1,sGs\mathcal G_s\times_{\mathcal X_{1,s}}\mathcal G_s with projections t1,t2t_1,t_2. Faithful flatness of k‾/k\overline k/k and surjectivity on spectra, [StacksAlg] (Tag 00HQ), lift this point to the base-changed fibre product. Its two projections have the same (p1)k‾(p_1)_{\overline k}-image, and thus the same (p2)k‾(p_2)_{\overline k}-image. Projection back shows p2(t1)=p2(t2)p_2(t_1)=p_2(t_2). On the generic fibre both projections are identities. The generic and special fibres exhaust the rank-one base, and their images cannot meet. This proves the required constancy on every fibre of p1p_1.

Lemma 4.44.4, applied to the proper birational map p1p_1 and its normal target, gives a unique algebraic factorization p2=f∘p1p_2=f\circ p_1. It induces the identity on CC. Any two morphisms X1→X2\mathcal X_1\to \mathcal X_2 inducing that identity are equal: their equalizer is closed because X2/O\mathcal X_2/O is separated, and contains the schematically dense generic fibre of the flat integral source. Finally the same proper-quotient lemma applied to ff gives f∗OX1=OX2f_*\mathcal O_{\mathcal X_1}=\mathcal O_{\mathcal X_2}. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-002311, 4.46.2.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record