Lemma 4.47.4. (Three marked branches force a vertex). Assume the ground field is algebraically closed. Let be a semistable algebraic model of a smooth projective curve, and let be a finite set of rational points of its generic fibre whose sections have pairwise distinct smooth specializations. Suppose admits three pairwise disjoint connected open subsets with such that Then is a component vertex of .
Proof
Proof. Suppose is not a vertex, and let be its connected component in the complement of the model vertices. The split pointed charts of Theorem 4.18.2 complete to the pointed formal charts of Definition 4.39.4. Corollary 4.39.5 and Proposition 4.39.3 identify with an actual open-disc or open-annulus tube. Its boundary has one point in the disc case and at most two in the annulus case. Every meets , since and is open.
If is not contained in , it meets . Indeed, otherwise would be a nonempty proper subset both open and closed in the connected space . The disjoint meet distinct boundary points when they meet . Thus at most one of them is not contained in a disc tube, and at most two are not contained in an annular tube. In the first case contains at least two members of , contradicting their distinct specializations. In the second it contains at least one member of , contradicting smoothness of its marked specialization. These contradictions prove the assertion. ◻