Theorem 4.48.4. (Intrinsic correspondence over the original field). Suppose admits at least one semistable algebraic model over , and fix an unramified marking datum . The component vertex map induces a bijection between isomorphism classes of semistable algebraic models of carrying as a finite étale smooth marking and the finite nonempty vertex sets admissible for in Definition 4.48.3. For two such models there is a morphism inducing the identity on and respecting precisely when the target vertex set is contained in the source vertex set; that morphism is unique. Thus this bijection is an equivalence with the partially ordered set under reverse inclusion. Admissibility is independent of the chosen comparison field.
Proof
Proof. Let be such a marked model. Its vertices have certificates by Theorem 4.48.2. Proposition 4.45.2 identifies their entire inverse image with its geometric component vertices. After extension to , the pointed charts and Corollary 4.39.5 make this a finite semistable vertex set. Distinct marked sections have distinct smooth specializations, so its open-disc tubes contain at most one marked point and its nodal annular tubes contain none. This proves admissibility.
Conversely, let be admissible. By Theorem 4.48.2, choose an original-field semistable algebraic model whose vertex set contains . Refine it by Theorem 4.47.3 to make a disjoint smooth marking. Write for the resulting marked model and for its vertex set. It still has . Over , the entire inverse images satisfy by Proposition 4.45.2.
Consider a connected component of the geometric dual subgraph on the vertices outside . Since is semistable, Lemma 4.41.2 identifies with the part of the source skeleton in one component of . It is a finite tree, and each of its geometric component curves itself is a smooth , hence has no self-node. The number of its attaching branches is one if is an open disc and two if is an open annulus, with both branches counted even when they attach to the same protected component.
Every marking whose specialization is on a component of belongs to . Indeed, its smooth tube is connected, avoids , and has that component vertex in its closure. Since this vertex lies in open , the tube meets and therefore lies in that connected component of the complement. The marking condition for consequently bounds the number of marked legs on by one in the disc case and by zero in the annular case. Thus satisfies precisely the geometric marked forest condition of Definition 4.45.4.
Theorem 4.45.5 now gives an actual original-field marked model with component vertices exactly . Its generic identification is the original one and its marking is isomorphic to the prescribed . Corollary 4.46.3 proves uniqueness of the marked model, and Theorem 4.46.2, together with the marking assertion of that corollary, identifies all its morphisms. This proves the correspondence and its categorical assertion. Its characterization by original-field models also proves independence of the comparison field. ◻