Proposition. (The midpoint’s residual action is nontrivial). Let be the three-vertex projective model constructed in the audited midpoint proof by symmetric insertion in . The canonical action fixing and sending to extends to . On the new residual component it acts as Its two branch ends are fixed. For , the geometric residual-direction disc labelled is carried to that labelled . Thus the invariant midpoint and its fixed branch ends do not carry trivial residual-scheme or tube action. This gives a residual-action obstruction to effective descent of this given model with its fixed generic identification.
Proof
Proof. The audited symmetric insertion uses the ideal on the node chart. This ideal is invariant under the stated action, so its Rees algebra and blowup inherit the action; on the rest of the projective model the original coefficient action already exists. These actions agree on overlaps. The accepted symmetric blowup charts, used in the passing proof, give its middle chart as Here , . The two adjacent node charts add the missing ends of this residual , proving (14) on the whole component. Since , it is a nontrivial scheme automorphism.
The full tube description in F.1.3 identifies the smooth residual direction with Here one may use the constant lift . The action fixes this lift and changes to . It therefore carries this disc to the disc for , which is distinct because and the residue characteristic is zero.
Every actual base change from has identity inertia on its special fibre, because and the coefficient action on is the identity. An isomorphism giving descent with the prescribed generic identification would transport that action to the displayed action on . Indeed extensions of a fixed generic action to a flat separated model are unique: their equalizer is closed by separatedness, and its defining ideal vanishes after inverting the nonzero elements of , so vanishes by flatness. This contradicts (14). This argument diagnoses the residual mechanism of the already audited obstruction; it does not replace that earlier proof or assert a new model-existence theorem. ◻