Closed

Two different saturation questions

Proposition. (Two different saturation questions). For chosen units u1,…,ur∈A×u_1,\ldots,u_r\in A^\times, the relation kernel Ru={a∈Zr:∏iuiai∈K×}R_u=\{a\in\mathbb Z^r: \textstyle\prod_i u_i^{a_i}\in K^\times\} is saturated in Zr\mathbb Z^r. Thus Zr/Ru\mathbb Z^r/R_u is the actual subgroup Hu⊂MAH_u\subset M_A generated by these units. The inclusion Hu⊂MAH_u\subset M_A need not be saturated, even when AA is normal and the chosen units and their inverses generate AA.

Proof

Proof. The relation kernel is the kernel of Zr→MA\mathbb Z^r\to M_A. Its quotient embeds in the torsion-free group MAM_A, proving saturation of the kernel. For the last assertion take, over an algebraically closed field of characteristic different from 22, A=K[t,t−1,(t−1)−1],u1=t2,u2=t−1.A=K[t,t^{-1},(t-1)^{-1}],\qquad u_1=t^2,\quad u_2=t-1. Factorization of polynomials over KK gives A×=K×tZ(t−1)ZA^\times=K^\times t^\mathbb Z(t-1)^\mathbb Z: a unit cannot have a zero or pole at any other finite point, and conversely these monomials are units. The ring is normal, as a fraction integral over this localization cannot have a pole at a non-inverted linear factor: a monic equation would have a unique term of lowest order there. In the basis [t],[t−1][t],[t-1] of MAM_A, the two chosen units generate 2Z⊕Z2\mathbb Z\oplus\mathbb Z, of index 22. Their relation kernel is zero. Nevertheless they generate the algebra with their inverses, since t=u2+1,t−1=(u2+1)u1−1.t=u_2+1,\qquad t^{-1}=(u_2+1)u_1^{-1}. The corresponding closed embedding in Gm2\mathbb G_m^2 has equation u1=(u2+1)2u_1=(u_2+1)^2. This proves the asserted distinction. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003020.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record