Closed

Nonsaturation on an irreducible very affine nodal curve

Example. (Nonsaturation on an irreducible very affine nodal curve). Assume char⁡K≠2\operatorname{char}K\ne2. There is an integral, reduced, connected very affine curve U=Spec⁡AU=\operatorname{Spec}A and a nonempty principal open UhU_h such that MA→MAhM_A\to M_{A_h} has a quotient containing an element of exact order 22. Explicitly, take A=K[x±1,z±1]/((z−1)2−x(x−1)2),h=x−1.(6)A=K[x^{\pm1},z^{\pm1}]/\bigl((z-1)^2-x(x-1)^2\bigr), \qquad h=x-1. \tag{6}

Proof

Proof. Inside K(t)K(t) put x=t2x=t^2 and z=1+t(t2−1)z=1+t(t^2-1). Before inverting zz, division by the monic relation in y=z−1y=z-1 writes every element uniquely as a(x)+b(x)ya(x)+b(x)y with a,b∈K[x,x−1]a,b\in K[x,x^{-1}]. Its image is a(t2)+t(t2−1)b(t2)a(t^2)+t(t^2-1)b(t^2), whose even and odd powers of tt cannot cancel. This proves injectivity, and localization by the nonzero element zz preserves it. Hence ({6}) is an integral domain. Every nonzero prime contains a nonzero Laurent polynomial in xx: choose a nonzero element of the prime, take its algebraic equation over K(x)K(x) with nonzero constant term, and clear denominators. In the quotient, algebraic closedness then forces xx to be a scalar; the defining equation forces zz to be a scalar as well. Thus every nonzero prime is maximal. The nonzero prime (x−1,z−1)(x-1,z-1) exists, so the dimension is exactly one.

Its fraction field is K(t)K(t) because t=(z−1)/(x−1)t=(z-1)/(x-1) there. Its normalization is B=K[t,t−1,(1+t3−t)−1]=A[t].B=K[t,t^{-1},(1+t^3-t)^{-1}]=A[t]. Indeed t2=xt^2=x, so tt is integral over AA, and t−1=t/xt^{-1}=t/x shows the displayed ring equals A[t]A[t], hence is finite over AA. Factorization in K[t]K[t] shows that this localization is integrally closed, by the pole argument used in Proposition C.1.27. It follows that it is the normalization in the common fraction field.

The two evaluations at t=1t=1 and t=−1t=-1 are defined on BB and agree on AA: both give x=z=1x=z=1. They differ on tt, since the characteristic is not 22. Thus t∉At\notin A. After inverting hh the formula t=(z−1)/(x−1)t=(z-1)/(x-1) gives Ah=BhA_h=B_h. In particular t∈Ah×t\in A_h^\times, while its class modulo constants does not come from A×A^\times: an equality t=cut=cu would put tt in AA. But t2=x∈A×t^2=x\in A^\times. Its image in Ah×/A×A_h^\times/A^\times therefore has exact order 22.

The presentation gives a closed embedding of UU in Gm2\mathbb G_m^2, and AhA_h is generated by the units x,z,hx,z,h and their inverses, so UhU_h is also very affine. Both rings are integral and h≠0h\ne0, giving irreducibility, reducedness and connectedness. At x=z=1x=z=1, with local coordinates X=x−1X=x-1 and Y=z−1Y=z-1, the equation is Y2−X2−X3Y^2-X^2-X^3; its two distinct tangent lines are Y=±XY=\pm X. Thus this is an ordinary node. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003026.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record