Closed

The full analytic unit group is not a finite lattice

Proposition. (The full analytic unit group is not a finite lattice). The group B×/K×\mathcal B^\times/K^\times is not finitely generated. In fact, for any prime ℓ\ell with ∣ℓ∣=1|\ell|=1, it contains a subgroup isomorphic to Z[1/ℓ]\mathbb Z[1/\ell], represented by units whose absolute value is identically 11 on M(B)\mathcal M(\mathcal B).

Proof

Proof. Choose c∈Kc\in K with 0<r=∣c∣<10<r=|c|<1. Such a prime ℓ\ell exists by taking one different from the residue characteristic when that characteristic is positive. For m≥0m\geq0 set n=ℓmn=\ell^m. On the closed ball ∥v∥≤r\|v\|\leq r consider Φn(v)=n−1(cT−∑j=2n(nj)vj).\Phi_n(v)=n^{-1}\left(cT-\sum_{j=2}^n\binom nj v^j\right). The sum is empty when n=1n=1. Since ∣n∣=1|n|=1 and integer coefficients have norm at most 11, this map preserves the ball. Moreover ∥Φn(v)−Φn(w)∥≤r∥v−w∥,\|\Phi_n(v)-\Phi_n(w)\|\leq r\|v-w\|, using vj−wj=(v−w)∑a=0j−1vj−1−awav^j-w^j=(v-w)\sum_{a=0}^{j-1}v^{j-1-a}w^a. Iteration from zero is Cauchy, because the successive differences are bounded by a geometric sequence with ratio r<1r<1; completeness gives a unique fixed point vmv_m in the ball. Set um=1+vmu_m=1+v_m. The fixed-point equation says umℓm=1+cT.(8)u_m^{\ell^m}=1+cT. \tag{8} The geometric series in −vm-v_m proves that umu_m is a unit. Also um+1ℓu_{m+1}^{\ell} lies within distance rr of 11 and satisfies the same equation as umu_m, so uniqueness yields um+1ℓ=umu_{m+1}^{\ell}=u_m.

Consequently a/ℓm↦[uma]a/\ell^m\mapsto[u_m^a] defines a homomorphism Z[1/ℓ]→B×/K×\mathbb Z[1/\ell]\to\mathcal B^\times/K^\times. If its value is zero for a≠0a\ne0, raising to the ℓm\ell^mth power would make (1+cT)a(1+cT)^a constant. This is impossible: for positive aa its top coefficient cac^a is nonzero, and negative aa reduces to the positive case by inversion. Uniqueness of Laurent coefficients justifies this test inside B\mathcal B. Thus the homomorphism is injective.

Every subgroup of a finitely generated abelian group is finitely generated: lift it to a subgroup of a finite-rank free group and apply Lemma C.1.26. But a finite collection of elements of Z[1/ℓ]\mathbb Z[1/\ell] has bounded denominator and cannot generate this group. This proves non-finite-generation. Finally frozen NAG-000655 gives ∣vm(x)∣≤∥vm∥<1|v_m(x)|\leq\|v_m\|<1 at every analytic point xx, so ∣um(x)∣=1|u_m(x)|=1. All represented tropical logarithms therefore vanish. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003030.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record