Theorem. (The normalized diagonal gives a common model). Let be a finite nonempty family of models of . Each is integral. In over , let be the scheme-theoretic closure of the generic diagonal . Then is integral and proper flat of finite type over , with . Its normalization is finite, and is a normal integral proper flat finite-type model of . The maps are proper birational maps inducing the identity on . The normalization map is finite; the maps need not be finite.
The same construction provides a common normal refinement of any finite collection of normal models already mapping to a fixed model; the new maps commute with those maps to the fixed model.
Proof
Proof. On a nonempty affine open , flatness makes injective. Its target is the coordinate ring of a nonempty affine open of the integral variety . It is nonempty because would make into -torsion. Thus is a domain. Every nonempty open meets , so is dense and its irreducibility makes the entire model irreducible. The model is therefore integral, even though its special fibre need not be reduced.
The diagonal is closed in because is separated. Its scheme-theoretic closure is locally cut out by the kernel of the map to its generic function field on the affines which meet the closure. That kernel is prime. These kernels are coherent since is Noetherian, and they restrict to the diagonal ideal after inverting . Hence is integral with the stated generic fibre. It is a closed subscheme of the proper finite-type scheme , hence proper and finite type. Each of its affine rings contains and is a domain, so is torsion-free over and is flat by Stacks, Tag 0539.
The complete DVR is Noetherian and complete local. By the exact parts (2) and (5) of Stacks, Tag 0335, every finite-type -algebra is Nagata. Thus is Nagata, and Stacks, Tag 035S makes its normalization finite. Its affine rings are integral closures inside , so is integral and normal. It is proper and finite type, and is flat by the same torsion-free argument. Since is normal, normalization is unchanged on this open; hence . The projections are proper and are the identity on the dense open , which proves birationality.
For the refinement assertion apply the same construction to the models in question. Two resulting morphisms to the fixed separated model agree on the dense generic fibre. They agree everywhere: the inverse image of its diagonal is a closed subscheme containing that dense open, and an integral scheme has no nonzero ideal vanishing on a dense open. This proves commutation, not a least-model assertion. ◻