Closed

A principal divisor with no presentation on its support

Proposition. (A principal divisor with no presentation on its support). Over any field KK, let X={ad−bc=0}⊂PK4,[a:b:c:d:t],o=[0:0:0:0:1].X=\{ad-bc=0\}\subset\mathbf P^4_K, \qquad [a:b:c:d:t],\qquad o=[0:0:0:0:1]. This is a normal integral proper threefold. Put P0={a=b=0},P1={c=d=0},Z=P0∪P1.P_0=\{a=b=0\},\qquad P_1=\{c=d=0\},\qquad Z=P_0\cup P_1. The rational section f=a/cf=a/c of OX\mathcal O_X has Cartier divisor with Weil cycle P0−P1P_0-P_1 and is a regular unit off ZZ. It has no signed presentation on ZZ, even in a neighbourhood of oo. Hence no proper generic-identity modification of any normal DVR model carrying this datum can acquire such a presentation on the inverse image of the prescribed support. In particular this obstruction applies to the constant equation ad−bc=0ad-bc=0 over a complete DVR.

Proof

Proof. On the chart t=1t=1 the coordinate algebra is A=K[a,b,c,d]/(ad−bc)A=K[a,b,c,d]/(ad-bc). It identifies with the weight-zero subring of B=K[u0,u1,v0,v1]B=K[u_0,u_1,v_0,v_1], where u0,u1u_0,u_1 have weight 11, v0,v1v_0,v_1 have weight −1-1, and a=u0v0,b=u0v1,c=u1v0,d=u1v1.a=u_0v_0,\quad b=u_0v_1,\quad c=u_1v_0,\quad d=u_1v_1. Every weight-zero monomial is a product of these four generators. Their only relation is the displayed determinant: after inverting aa one solves d=bc/ad=bc/a, and a,b,ca,b,c are algebraically independent under this substitution. The determinant polynomial is prime by its primitive linear form in dd and unique factorization, so this localization is injective.

The polynomial ring BB is normal by Stacks, Tag 0BC1 and Stacks, Tag 0AFV. If z∈Frac⁡(A)z\in\operatorname{Frac}(A) is integral over AA, it is integral over BB, so belongs to BB. Under the weight substitution with an independent Laurent variable, zz is fixed because it is a fraction of weight-zero elements. Comparing Laurent powers shows that its polynomial expression has weight zero, hence lies in AA. Thus AA is normal. Its localizations are normal by Stacks, Tag 00GY. The remaining projective charts, where one of a,b,c,da,b,c,d is nonzero, solve for a variable and are polynomial three-dimensional charts. This proves normality and integrality of XX; projectivity gives properness.

The hyperplane sections satisfy div⁡(a)=P0+Q\operatorname{div}(a)=P_0+Q and div⁡(c)=P1+Q\operatorname{div}(c)=P_1+Q, where Q={a=c=0}Q=\{a=c=0\}. Each coefficient is one, as is seen by solving the determinant equation at the corresponding generic point. Their difference is P0−P1P_0-P_1. Off ZZ, the two rows are nonzero; where a/ca/c is not directly a unit, it equals b/db/d, which is a unit there. Thus the support is exactly as claimed. The presentation using the two hyperplane sections adds QQ, which is not contained in ZZ, and is not an allowed presentation.

We prove the obstruction without a class-group computation. Over the affine chart t=1t=1, consider the incidence variety Y={((a,b,c,d),[u0:u1]):au1=cu0, bu1=du0}⟶Spec⁡A.Y=\{((a,b,c,d),[u_0:u_1]): au_1=cu_0,\ bu_1=du_0\} \longrightarrow\operatorname{Spec}A. It is closed in Spec⁡A×P1\operatorname{Spec}A\times\mathbf P^1 and hence proper over Spec⁡A\operatorname{Spec}A. Its two charts are (a,b,z),c=za, d=zb;(c,d,w),a=wc, b=wd.(a,b,z),\quad c=za,\ d=zb; \qquad (c,d,w),\quad a=wc,\ b=wd. They are affine three-spaces. The map is an isomorphism off the origin, since a nonzero rank-one matrix determines its column line. Its exceptional fibre is the zero section C≃P1C\simeq\mathbf P^1, which has codimension two. In particular there is no exceptional prime divisor. The strict transforms F0,F1F_0,F_1 of P0,P1P_0,P_1 are fibres of Y→P1Y\to\mathbf P^1, over [0:1][0:1] and [1:0][1:0].

Suppose an effective Cartier divisor HH near oo is supported in P0∪P1P_0\cup P_1, with multiplicities m,n≥0m,n\geq0. Shrink to an affine neighbourhood of oo on which HH is principal. Its pullback to YY over that neighbourhood has divisor mF0+nF1mF_0+nF_1: off CC this follows from the isomorphism, and no prime divisor is contained in CC. Equality of these Cartier divisors follows on the local UFD charts. The associated line bundle restricts to the trivial line on CC, because it was pulled back from a principal divisor. But the restriction of OY(mF0+nF1)\mathcal O_Y(mF_0+nF_1) is OP1(m+n)\mathcal O_{\mathbf P^1}(m+n). In the standard two affine trivializations its transition function is zm+nz^{m+n}. A trivialization of the line on each affine chart can change this only by invertible polynomials, which are constants. Thus triviality forces m+n=0m+n=0, and hence m=n=0m=n=0. Both effective factors of a hypothetical signed presentation would therefore have zero coefficients at P0,P1P_0,P_1 near oo, contradicting the coefficients 1,−11,-1 of div⁡(f)\operatorname{div}(f).

The same weight-zero argument over the UFD RR shows that the constant affine cone is normal over RR; the other charts are polynomial rings over RR. This gives a normal proper model, flat by torsion-freeness. The ratio a/ca/c is a unit outside the two corresponding closed row planes, so defines the prescribed model datum. Any proposed generic-identity presentation would restrict to the impossible presentation on XX, by Theorem C.1.98. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003044.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record