Closed

Two ways that forgetting support loses information

Proposition. (Two ways that forgetting support loses information). In every dimension d≥2d\geq2 the following hold.

  1. On PRd\mathbf P^d_R, a closed rational special-fibre point has class zero in the ordinary Chow group CH0(PRd)CH_0(\mathbf P^d_R), but has vertical degree one. Thus a degree homomorphism on that ordinary Chow group cannot recover the required vertical intersection degree. The support must be retained.

  2. On the blowup of Section 3, p∗[F]=0p_*[F]=0 as a dd-cycle, but deg⁡A∣F,…,A∣F,k(F)=1.\deg_{A|_F,\ldots,A|_F,k}(F)=1. The two semipositive model metrics hH,hAh_H,h_A on the same generic O(1)\mathcal O(1) agree outside the tube of PP. On the standard unit polydisc around PP their difference of weights is u=log⁡(hA/hH)=−log⁡max⁡{∣π∣,∣z1∣,…,∣zd∣}.\begin{equation} u=\log(h_A/h_H) =-\log\max\{|\pi|,|z_1|,\ldots,|z_d|\}. \end{equation} It satisfies u(ξ0)=0u(\xi_0)=0 and u(ξF)=λu(\xi_F)=\lambda. With the semipositive model measure μA=δξF\mu_A=\delta_{\xi_F} one therefore has ∫u dμA=λ>0\int u\,d\mu_A=\lambda>0. Agreement outside that tube and equality of generic line-bundle classes do not imply zero metric correction. If the supported model values of the preceding proposition are available, changing the first model line from AA to H=A(F)H=A(F), with the other dd lines equal to AA, changes that value by +λ+\lambda.

Proof

Proof. For (1), choose the horizontal closed section C={Z1=⋯=Zd=0}≃Spec⁡RC=\{Z_1=\cdots=Z_d=0\}\simeq\operatorname{Spec}R. The divisor of π\pi on this integral one-dimensional scheme is its closed point with coefficient length⁡R(R/πR)=1\operatorname{length}_R(R/\pi R)=1. Its pushforward is a principal-divisor relation in CH0(PRd)CH_0(\mathbf P^d_R), so that point has ordinary class zero. Its degree as a zero-cycle on the special fibre is [k:k]=1[k:k]=1. Rational equivalence inside the vertical support cannot use the horizontal curve CC; this is exactly the information lost by forgetting support.

For (2), the image of FF is the point PP, so cycle pushforward in dimension dd is zero. But A∣F=OPkd(1)A|_F=\mathcal O_{\mathbf P^d_k}(1) by Proposition I.2.8, whose top mixed degree is one. This does not contradict projection: the factors AA are not the pulled-back line HH. On the unit polydisc, a generator of the pulled-back centre ideal has absolute value max⁡{∣π∣,∣z1∣,…,∣zd∣}\max\{|\pi|,|z_1|,\ldots,|z_d|\}. The canonical generic section of O(F)\mathcal O(F) has that norm. Since H=A⊗O(F)H=A\otimes\mathcal O(F), the ratio of the metrics gives (I.2.21). Away from the tube {red⁡X(x)=P}\{\operatorname{red}_{\mathcal X}(x)=P\} the centre ideal is generated by a unit of norm one, so the metrics agree there. At ξ0\xi_0 one of the displayed coordinate norms is one; at ξF\xi_F they all equal ∣π∣|\pi|. This proves the two values and the integral. Finally, compatible generic sections of HH and AA have model divisors differing by FF. Additivity of the stated supported interface gives λdeg⁡(c1(A∣F)d[F])=λ\lambda\deg(c_1(A|_F)^d[F])=\lambda, with the asserted positive sign. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003058.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record