Closed

Failures of weaker replacement statements

Proposition. (Failures of weaker replacement statements). The following limitations already occur in the present dimensional scope.

  1. Equal induced model metrics need not make the specified generic isomorphism extend on a nonnormal initial model, even when both underlying model lines are trivial.

  2. Abstractly equal model extensions, without their generic identifications, can induce different metrics and different values in (C.1.52).

  3. Normality of XX does not imply the generic power-presentation condition on its prescribed divisor support. The quadric example of Proposition C.1.99 fails it for every positive power.

Proof

Proof. For (1) take R=Q[[π]]R=\mathbf Q[[\pi]], K=Q((π))K=\mathbf Q((\pi)), u2=2u^2=2, B=Q(u)[[π]]B=\mathbf Q(u)[[\pi]] and A=R+πB=R⊕R(πu)≃R[z]/(z2−2π2)⊂B.A=R+\pi B=R\oplus R(\pi u) \simeq R[z]/(z^2-2\pi^2)\subset B. This is a finite free integral RR-algebra with A[1/π]=K(u)A[1/\pi]=K(u), and u∉Au\notin A is integral over AA. The model T=PAd\mathcal T=\mathbf P^d_A is proper flat of finite type over RR; its normal integral generic variety is PK(u)d\mathbf P^d_{K(u)}. The special fibre is allowed to be nonreduced: A/πA≃Q[z]/(z2)A/\pi A\simeq\mathbf Q[z]/(z^2).

Use two copies of OT\mathcal O_{\mathcal T} as extensions of OX\mathcal O_X, with generic identifications 1↦11\mapsto1 and 1↦u1\mapsto u. At every analytic point ∣u∣2=∣2∣=1|u|^2=|2|=1, so both induced norms of 11 are one. But the compatible generic isomorphism between these two model lines is multiplication by uu in one direction. It cannot extend on an affine chart with ring A[t1,…,td]A[t_1,\ldots,t_d], since uu does not belong to that ring. On the normal model PBd\mathbf P^d_B it is a unit and does extend. Normality of this model follows from normality of the DVR BB and Stacks, Tag 030A. Thus passing to a common normal model in Theorem C.1.106 is substantive.

For (2) work on PRd\mathbf P^d_R. Take L0=OXL_0=\mathcal O_X, s0=1s_0=1, e0=1e_0=1, and the two trivial extensions with identifications 1↦11\mapsto1 and 1↦π−11\mapsto\pi^{-1}. Their root norms of 11 are respectively 11 and ∣π∣|\pi|. For 1≤i≤d1\leq i\leq d take the standard extension of OX(1)\mathcal O_X(1) with section ZiZ_i. Set S0=∅S_0=\varnothing and Si={Zi=0}S_i=\{Z_i=0\}; the total generic intersection is empty. The first computation has model section σ0=1\sigma_0=1 and value zero. In the second σ0=π\sigma_0=\pi. Its first intersection is the full special fibre. Intersecting with Z1,…,ZdZ_1,\ldots,Z_d gives the kk-rational point [1:0:⋯:0][1:0:\cdots:0] with length one. The second value is therefore +λ+\lambda. This verifies the sign without using the pending logarithmic induction theorem.

For (3) use the proper normal quadric ad−bc=0ad-bc=0 in PK4\mathbf P^4_K and f=a/cf=a/c, with prescribed support P0∪P1P_0\cup P_1, P0={a=b=0}P_0=\{a=b=0\}, P1={c=d=0}P_1=\{c=d=0\}. The reviewed obstruction proof establishes that every effective Cartier divisor supported on this union near the vertex has zero coefficients at both planes: its pullback to the displayed small resolution restricts as OP1(m+n)\mathcal O_{\mathbf P^1}(m+n) on the exceptional curve, while a principal local divisor restricts trivially; m,n≥0m,n\geq0 force m=n=0m=n=0. A signed presentation of rdiv⁡(f)r\operatorname{div}(f) would thus have zero coefficients at both planes, contradicting r,−rr,-r for every r>0r>0. ◻

Citation

Non-Archimedean Geometry Foundations, Tag NAG-003133.

Proof in chapter · Fixed-edition record