Proposition. (A noncyclic obstruction surviving unramified base change). Give the valuation trivial on with and , defined on polynomials by the least monomial value, and let be its completion. Then and . For the field extension is tame Galois, of degree and value index four, with unchanged residue field, and The same assertions hold over any actual finite unramified extension after replacing by , with residue field and degree four over . Consequently no such base change converts this into one full-value-index cyclic Kummer step. Two exact quadratic steps suffice. This is a complete rank-one nondiscrete example.
Proof
Proof. Irrationality makes the values of distinct monomials distinct. A polynomial has a unique lowest term, whose product with the lowest term of another polynomial is again uniquely lowest. This proves multiplicativity and extends the valuation to fractions. Its group is . A value-zero fraction has numerator and denominator with the same leading exponents; its residue is their rational leading coefficient ratio. Hence its residue field is . Completion changes neither value group nor residue field: for a nonzero completed element choose an approximation whose difference has larger value; the two values and their leading residues agree. For value-zero elements this also identifies ordinary residues. The value group is nondiscrete. Indeed the positive numbers lie in and tend to zero. It is a nonzero ordered subgroup of , hence has rank one.
Take the two roots in a finite algebraic extension of , with its unique extending valuation. The four monomials have values in four distinct cosets modulo : their values are . They are linearly independent by the unique-minimum argument. Their span is closed under multiplication using (G.0.33), and the extension has degree at most four, so they are a basis and . Their values generate , of index four. The fundamental inequality Stacks 0ASH forces this to be the whole value group and forces residue degree one. Independent sign changes of are four automorphisms, giving (G.0.34); they are all inertia. Residue characteristic zero, equality of degree with value index, and unchanged residue verify all of (G.0.26).
The tower has value index and degree two at each step: the new value classes are represented by and , respectively. Their positive generators and the root , of residue order two, satisfy (G.0.27). For any actual unramified , its value group is still . Lemma G.0.18 proves , degree and value index four, and unchanged residue over . The four sign changes extend on this tensor product, giving the same noncyclic inertia and value quotient. A single (G.0.27) step of degree four has a cyclic value quotient of order four and a cyclic Galois group. Both conflict with (G.0.34). This proves the asserted obstruction, even if contains a primitive fourth root of unity. ◻